Assessing the Economic Life of Rail Using a Stochastic Analysis of Failures

Abstract

In this article, a model is developed to evaluate the economic life of rail using a stochastic analysis of rail failures. The occurrence of rail defects and failures is analysed and issues related to rail maintenance are addressed. The hazard rate of alumino-thermic weld failures is predicted for continuously welded rail, where the expected number of welds is increasing in tonnage as a result of replacement. Imperfect inspections are modelled for predicting the expected number of failures by employing a filtered non-homogeneous Poisson process. The impact of maintenance on failure occurrence and whole life-cycle cost (LCC) is analysed and integrated within the model. The application and capability of the proposed model and sensitivity of parameters are illustrated through the use of a practical example. It is shown that an optimal economic life of rail can always be found, as the repair cost and the risk cost of accident are increasing with tonnage that passed through it. In addition, the inspection frequency has a significant impact on rail LCC. The results also suggest that the proposed model is also valid for optimizing the interval between rail inspections.

Keywords

rail economic life failure life-cycle cost stochastic

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Zarembski

A. M.

Forecasting of track component lives and its use in track maintenance planning. International Heavy Haul Workshop on Maintenance of Way and Train Operations, Balancing the Conflicts. Vancouver, Canada, 1991, pp. 38–44.

Staplin

D. E.

Wells

T. R.

Branchline rail replacement strategies

J. Transport. Res. Board Transport. Res. Rec., 1988, 1174, 1–12.

Wiseman

P. W.

A numerate criterion for rail replacement on mainline BR track. Report TM TM 047, British Rail Research, 1990.

Lamson

S. T.

Hastings

N. A.J.

Willis

R. J.

Minimum cost maintenance in heavy haul rail track

J. Opl. Res. Soc., 1983, 34 (3), 211–223.

Hope

Marpas relates track costs to traffic

Railway Gazette Int., 1992, 148 (3), 147–150.

Grimes

Kay

Developments towards integrated track management. International Conference on

Railway engineering, London, 2002, CD-ROM.

Rhodes

Harrison

Temple

New decision support tool for track asset management. Maintenance & Renewal of Permanent Way Power & Signalling Structures & Earthworks, London, UK, 2004, CD-ROM.

Jovanovic

Esveld

ECOTRACK: an objective condition-based decision support system for long-term track M&R planning directed towards reduction of life cycle costs. IHHA Conference, Australia, 2001, pp. 199–207.

Martland

C. D.

McNeil

Acharya

Mishakani

Eshelby

Applications of expert systems in railroad maintenance: Scheduling rail relays

Trans. Res., 1990, 24A (1), 39–52.

10.

Simon

S. A.

Ferreira

Murray

M. H.

Rail track maintenance planning - an assessment model. Transport Research Record 1713, 2000, pp. 29–35.

11.

Railtrack. Track inspection requirements. Railtrack line specification. RT/CE/S/103, issue 2, UK, 1997.

12.

Kalousek

Analysis of rail grinding tests and implications for corrective and preventive grinding. The Fourth International Heavy Haul Railway Conference, Brisbane, Australia, 1989, pp. 193–204.

13.

Chiang

C. L.

Introduction to stochastic processes and their applications, 1980 (R. E. Krieger Pub. Co, Huntington, New York).

14.

Nashida

S. I.

Sugino

I. K.

Urashima

Masumoto

Study on contact rolling fatigue of rails

Bull. JSME, 1985, 28 (243), 1819–1824.

15.

Grassie

S. L.

Rolling contact fatigue on the British railway system: Treatment

Wear, 2005, 258, 1310–1318.

16.

Burstow

M. C.

Watson

A. S.

Beagles

Application of the whole life rail model to control rolling contact fatigue. International Conference on

Railway engineering, London, UK, 2002, CD-ROM.

17.

Shyr

Ben-Akiva

Modeling rail fatigue behaviour with multiple hazards

J. Infrastruct. Syst., 1996, 2 (2), 73–81.

18.

Beichelt

A unifying treatment of replacement policies with minimal repair

Naval Res. Logist., 1993, 40, 51–67.

19.

Wang

Christer

A. H.

Solution algorithm for a non-homogeneous multi-component inspection model

Comput. Oper. Res., 2003, 30 (1), 19–34.

20.

Moubrary

Reliability centred maintenance, 1992 (Industrial Press INC., New York).

21.

Parzen

Stochastic processes, 1962 (Holden-Day, San Francisco).

22.

American Railway Engineering and Maintenance of Way Associations. Manual for Railway Engineering, Chapter 4, 2002.

23.

Stirling

Roberts

Chan

A. H.C.

Madelin

K. B.

Prototype expert system for the maintenance and renewal of railway track. Freight Vehicle Design Workshop, Manchester, UK, 2000.

24.

Jeong

D. Y.

Tang

Y. H.

Orringer

Damage tolerance analysis of detail fractures in rail

Theor. Appl. Mech., 1997, 28, 109–115.

25.

Vatn

Podfillini

Z. E.

Svee

A risk based approach to determine type of ultrasonic inspection and frequencies in railway applications. Proceedings of the World Congress on Railway Research, Edinburgh, UK, 2003, pp. 689–698.