Jar-opening challenges. Part 2: Estimating the force-generating capacity of thumb muscles in healthy young adults during jar-opening tasks

Abstract

This study discusses the force-generating capacity of thumb muscles during jar-opening tasks using two grip patterns: the power grip and the precision grip. This study develops a three-dimensional biomechanical model of the thumb to predict muscle forces in jar-opening activities based on external forces measured by a custom-designed jar device. Ten healthy subjects participated in the study. Each participant turned a jar lid of 66 mm diameter counterclockwise with maximal effort and preferred speed using both grip patterns. The average normal and tangential forces applied by the thumb to the jar lid show that the normal force is the primary contributive force for opening a jar. This normal force is approximately three times the tangential force. Muscular force-generating capacity measurements show that the major active muscles during a jar-opening activity for both grips include the flexor pollicis longus, flexor pollicis brevis, abductor pollicis brevis, adductor pollicis, and opponens pollicis. The total muscle force ratios for the precision grip and power grip with respect to externally applied forces are 5.6 and 4.7 respectively. These ratios indicate that the power grip pattern produces less muscle force per unit of external applied load. The technique proposed in this study provides a proper apparatus and model for measuring three-dimensional loads and estimating the force-generating capacity of each muscle and tendon of the thumb during jar-opening tasks.

Keywords

biomechanical model muscle force thumb jar opening hand twisting

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Rayan

G. M.

Young

B. T.

‘Ligament reconstruction arthroplasty for trapeziometacarpal arthrosis.’

J. Hand Surg. Am. 22 (6) (1997): 1067–1076

Sandqvist

Eklund

Akesson

Nordenskiold

‘Daily activities and hand function in women with scleroderma.’

Scand. J. Rheumatology 33 (2) (2004): 102–107

Voorbij

A. I. M.

Steenbekkers

L. P. A.

‘The twisting force of aged consumers when opening a jar.’

Appl. Ergonomics 33 (1) (2002): 105–109

Winder

Ridgway

Nelson

Baldwin

‘Food and drink packaging: Who is complaining and who should be complaining.’

Appl. Ergonomics 33 (5) (2002): 433–438

Young

B. T.

Rayan

G. M.

‘Outcome following nonoperative treatment of displaced distal radius fractures in low-demand patients older than 60 years.’

J. Hand Surg. Am. 25 (1) (2000): 19–28

Yoxall

Janson

Bradbury

S. R.

Langley

Wearn

Hayes

‘Openability: Producing design limits for consumer packaging.’

Packag. Technol. Sci. 19 (2006): 219–225

Peebles

Norris

‘Filling ‘gaps’ in strength data for design.’

Appl. Ergonomics 34 (1) (2003): 73–88

Fowler

N. K.

Nicol

A. C.

‘Measurement of external three-dimensional interphalangeal loads applied during activities of daily living.’

Clin. Biomechanics (Bristol, Avon) 14 (9) (1999): 646–652

Fowler

N. K.

Nicol

A. C.

‘A force transducer to measure individual finger loads during activities of daily living.’

J. Biomechanics 32 (7) (1999): 721–725

10.

Purves

W. K.

Berme

‘Resultant finger joint loads in selected activities.’

J. Biomed. Engng 2 (4) (1980): 285–289

11.

Berme

Paul

J. P.

Purves

W. K.

‘A biomechanical analysis of the metacarpophalangeal joint.’

J. Biomechanics 10 (7) (1977): 409–412

12.

Chao

E. Y.

K. N.

Cooney

W. P.

III Linscheid

R. L.

‘Muscle and joint forces in the hand.’ In Biomechanics of the hand, a basic research study (Eds Chao

E. Y.

K. N.

Cooney

W. P.

Linscheid

R. L.

), 1989, pp. 53–72 (World Scientific Singapore).

13.

Chao

E. Y.

K. N.

Cooney

W. P.

III Linscheid

R. L.

‘Quantitative analysis of the intrinsic and extrinsic musculature of the hand.’ In Biomechanics of the hand, a basic research study (Eds Chao

E. Y.

K. N.

Cooney

W. P.

Linscheid

R. L.

), 1989, pp. 31–51 (World Scientific Singapore).

14.

Chao

E. Y.

Opgrande

J. D.

Axmear

F. E.

‘Three-dimensional force analysis of finger joints in selected isometric hand functions.’

J. Biomechanics 9 (6) (1976): 387–396

15.

Cooney

W. P.

III Chao

E. Y.

‘Biomechanical analysis of static forces in the thumb during hand function.’

J. Bone Jt Surg. Am. 59 (1) (1977): 27–36

16.

Fowler

N. K.

Nicol

A. C.

‘Interphalangeal joint and tendon forces: Normal model and biomechanical consequences of surgical reconstruction.’

J. Biomechanics 33 (9) (2000): 1055–1062

17.

Giurintano

D. J.

Hollister

A. M.

Buford

W. L.

Thompson

D. E.

Myers

L. M.

‘A virtual five-link model of the thumb.’

Med. Engng Physics 17 (4) (1995): 297–303

18.

Harding

D. C.

Brandt

K. D.

Hillberry

B. M.

‘Finger joint force minimization in pianists using optimization techniques.’

J. Biomechanics 26 (12) (1993): 1403–1412

19.

Weightman

Amis

A. A.

‘Finger joint force predictions related to design of joint replacements.’

J. Biomed. Engng 4 (3) (1982): 197–205

20.

F.-C.

Chiu

H.-Y.

Chang

J.-H.

Lin

C.-F.

Hong

R.-F.

Kuo

L.-C.

‘Jar-opening challenges. Part 1: An apparatus for assessing hand and finger torques and forces in a jar-opening activity.’

Proc. IMechE, Part H: J. Engineering in Medicine 223 (1) (2009): 121–130 DOI: 10.1243/09544119JEIM422.

21.

Chang

J. H.

K. Y.

F. C.

‘Kinetic analysis of the thumb in jar-opening activity among female adults.’

Ergonomics 51 (6) (2008): 843–857

22.

Smutz

W. P.

Kongsayreepong

Hughes

R. E.

Niebur

Cooney

W. P.

K. N.

‘Mechanical advantage of the thumb muscles.’

J. Biomechanics 31 (6) (1998): 565–570

23.

Barbenel

J. C.

‘The biomechanics of the temporomandibular joint: A theoretical study.’

J. Biomechanics 5 (3) (1972): 251–256

24.

Seireg

Arvikar

R. J.

‘A mathematical model for evaluation of forces in lower extremeties of the musculo-skeletal system.’

J. Biomechanics 6 (3) (1973): 313–326

25.

Brand

P. W.

Beach

R. B.

Thompson

D. E.

‘Relative tension and potential excursion of muscles in the forearm and hand.’

J. Hand. Surg. Am. 6 (3) (1981): 209–219

26.

Crawford

J. O.

Wanibe

Nayak

‘The interaction between lid diameter, height and shape on wrist torque exertion in younger and older adults.’

Ergonomics 45 (13) (2002): 922–933

27.

Jung

M.-C.

Hallbeck

M. S.

‘The effect of wrist position, angular velocity, and exertion direction on simultaneous maximal grip force and wrist torque under the isokinetic conditions.’

Int. J. Ind. Ergonomics 29 (2002): 133–143

28.

Morse

J. L.

Jung

M.-C.

Bashford

G. R.

Hallbeck

M. S.

‘Maximal dynamic grip force and wrist torque: The effects of gender, exertion direction, angular velocity, and wrist angle.’

Appl. Ergonomics 37 (6) (2006): 737–742

29.

K. N.

Cooney

W. P.

Chao

E. Y.

Askew

L. J.

Daube

J. R.

‘Determination of forces in extensor pollicis longus and flexor pollicis longus of the thumb.’

J. Appl. Physiology 54 (3) (1983): 714–719

30.

Johanson

M. E.

Valero-Cuevas

F. J.

Hentz

V. R.

‘Activation patterns of the thumb muscles during stable and unstable pinch tasks.’

J. Hand Surg. Am. 26 (4) (2001): 698–705

31.

Valero-Cuevas

F. J.

Johanson

M. E.

Towles

J. D.

‘Towards a realistic biomechanical model of the thumb: The choice of kinematic description may be more critical than the solution method or the variability/uncertainty of musculoskeletal parameters.’

J. Biomechanics 36 (7) (2003): 1019–1030

32.

Kaufman

K. R.

K. N.

Litchy

W. J.

Cooney

W. P.

Chao

E. Y. S.

‘In-vivo function of the thumb muscles.’

Clin. Biomechanics (Bristol, Avon) 14 (2) (1999): 141–150

33.

Pearlman

Roach

Valero-Cuevas

‘The fundamental thumb-tip force vectors produced by the muscles of the thumb.’

J. Orthop. Res. 22 (2) (2004): 306–312