Mathematical modelling of supermarket refrigeration systems for design,energy prediction and control

Abstract

This paper describes a mathematical model developed to simulate the performance of supermarket refrigeration systems. Such a model can be used for the comparison of different systems and control strategies in terms of their energy and total equivalent warming impact. The model is based on a large number of component models which have been linked together within the TRNSYS environment. Major component models include the compressor, air-cooled condenser, thermostatic expansion valve, display cabinet and control. The overall system model has been validated against monitored data obtained from both a laboratory-based system and a full-scale system in a supermarket in Scotland. The value of the model is illustrated by determining and comparing the effectiveness of head pressure and variable-speed control against fixed head pressure and constant speed control. It is shown that even at summer ambient conditions the system can be operated without problems at much lower head pressures than is done in practice under fixed-pressure control strategies. The use of variable-speed control on one of the compressors can also provide better control of the suction pressure and a substantial (up to 23 per cent) energy savings compared to on-off control.

Keywords

modelling refrigeration systems compressors supermarket energy consumption design

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Tocano

W. M.

Oven

M. J.

Walker

D. H.

Vinneyard

E. A.

Cooper

W. L.

Design and laboratory testing of an unequal parallel multi-compressor supermarket refrigeration system. ASHRAE Trans., 1982, 4, 1084–1100.

Zubair

S. M.

Bahel

Compressor capacity modulation scheme. Heating, Piping, Air Conditioning, 1989, 61(1), 135–144.

TRNSYS, a transient simulation program. Solar Energy Laboratory, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1996.

Fischer

S. K.

Rice

C. K.

A steady-state computer design model for air-to-air heat pump. Report ORNL/CON-80, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, 1981, 35 pp.

Domanski

Didion

Computer Modeling of the Vapor Compression Cycle With Constant Flow Area Expansion Device, NBS Building Science Series 155, 1983 (National Bureau of Standards, Washington, DC).

Energy Efficiency Office Guidance Notes for Reducing Energy Consumption Costs of Electric Motor and Drive Systems, Best Practice Programme, Good Practice Guide 2, 1989 (Department of Energy, London).

Tassou

S. A.

Green

R. K.

A mathematical model of the heat transfer process in a shell and tube condenser for use in refrigeration applications. J. Appl. Mathl Modelling, 1981, 9(1), 29–33.

Tassou

S. A.

Green

R. K.

Wilson

D. R.

A mathematical model for predicting the performance characteristics of direct expansion evaporator evaporator coils. Indian J. Technol., 1982, 20(10), 377–385.

Incoprera

F. P.

De Witt

D. P.

Fundamentals of Heat and Mass Transfer, 1990, p. 496 (John Wiley, New York).

10.

Travis

D. P.

Baron

A. B.

Rohsenow

W. M.

Forced convection condensation inside tubes: A heat transfer equation for condenser design. ASHRAE Trans., 1973, 79(1), 157–165.

11.

Chaddock

J. B.

Noerager

J. A.

Evaporation of refrigerant 12 in a horizontal tube with a constant wall heat flux. ASHRAE Trans., 1966, 79(1), 90–103.

12.

McQuiston

F. C.

Correlation of heat, mass and momentum transfer coefficients for plate-fin-tube heat transfer surface with staggered tubes. ASHRAE Trans., 1978, 84(1), 294–301.

13.

McQuiston

F. C.

Finned tube heat exchangers: State of the art for the air side. ASHRAE Trans., 1981, 87(1), 1077–1085.

14.

Oskarsson

S. P.

Krakow

K. I.

Lin

Evaporator model for operation with dry, wet, and frosted finned surface. Part I: Heat transfer and fluid flow theory. ASHRAE Trans., 1990, 96(1), 373–380.

15.

Oskarsson

S. P.

Krakow

K. I.

Lin

Evaporator model for operation with dry, wet, and frosted finned surface. Part II: Evaporator models and verification. ASHRAE Trans., 1990, 96(1), 381–392.

16.

Krakow

K. I.

Lin

Oskarsson

S. P.

A method for determining the effects of coil geometry and fan type on evaporator frosting. ASHRAE Trans., 1990, 96(1), 393–399.

17.

Rajendran

Pate

A computer model of the start up transients in a vapour-compression refrigeration system. In Proceedings of the International Institute of Refrigeration Conference on Progress in the Design and Construction of Refrigeration Systems, Purdue University, Lafayette, Indiana, 1986, Vol. 1, pp. 201–211.

18.

Howell

H. R.

Adams

Effects of indoor space conditions on refrigerated display case performance. Final report for ASHRAE Project 596RP, University of South Florida, 1991, 130 pp.

19.

Condenser and Pack Controller (PAM) User Guide; Setup Unit and Installation Guide, January 1995, (Elm Limited, Glasgow, Scotland).

20.

Thermodynamic Properties of Refrigerants and Refrigerant Mixtures, Version 5.1, 1996. (National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, Maryland).