An Investigation of Short Pitch Wheel and Rail Corrugations on the Vancouver Mass Transit System

Abstract

Shortly after opening, the Vancouver mass transit system experienced severe rail and wheel corrugation problems. Poor alignment of wheelsets in trucks, generation of ‘roll-slip’ oscillations between wheel and rail and the development of close conformity between the wheel tread and the rail were judged to be associated with the development of corrugations. Remedies included reducing the tolerance on wheelset misalignment to ±10 minutes of arc, applying a friction modifier to wheels to change the friction characteristic between wheel tread and rail from negative to positive, regauging the track and grinding the rail to different profiles in each of the four equal sections of tangent track. These remedies have virtually eliminated corrugation from the system.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Grassie

S. L.

Gregory

R. W.

Johnson

K. L.

The dynamic loading of rails at corrugation frequencies. In Proceedings of International Symposium on contact mechanics and wear of rail/wheel systems (Eds Kalousek

Dukkipati

R. V.

Gladwell

G. M. L.

), Vancouver, July 1982, 1983 (University of Waterloo Press).

Grassie

S. L.

Johnson

K. L.

Periodic microslip between a rolling wheel and a corrugated rail. Wear, 1985, 101, 291–309.

Clark

R. A.

Foster

IMechE Seminar on Rail corrugation, London, 27 September 1983 (Mechanical Engineering Publications, London).

Grassie

S. L.

Johnson

K. L.

IMechE Seminar on Rail corrugation, London, 27 September 1983 (Mechanical Engineering Publications, London).

Newland

D. E.

On the time-dependent spin creep of a railway wheel. J. Mech. Engng Sci., 1982, 24, 55–64.

Grassie

S. L.

An investigation into the generation of corrugation by transient spin creep. Wear, 1985, 101, 161–174.

Frederick

C. O.

A rail corrugation theory. In Contact mechanics and wear of rail/wheel systems (Eds Gladwell

G. M. L.

Ghonem

Kalousek

), Vol. II, Rhode Island, 1986, 1987 (University of Waterloo Press).

Clark

R. A.

Scott

G. A.

Poole

Short wave corrugations—an explanation based on slip stick vibrations. Symposium on Applied mechanics rail transportation, AMD Vol. 96, RTD Vol. 2, ASME 988, pp. 141–148.

Hempelmann

Hiss

Knothe

Ripke

The formation of wear patterns on rail tread. Wear, 1991, 144, 179–195; also in Mechanics and fatigue in wheel/rail contact (Ed. Grassie

S. L.

), 1991 (Elsevier, Amsterdam).

10.

Milne

A. A.

MacDonald

S. D.

IMechE Conference on Lubrication and wear, London, 1957, pp. 740 (Institution of Mechanical Engineers, London).

11.

Kalker

J. J.

Simplified theory of rolling contact. Delft program report, Series C; Mech. Aeronaut. Engng and Shipbdg, 1973, 1, 1–10.

12.

Logston

C. F.

Jr Itami

G. S.

Locomotive friction—creep studies. Paper 80-RT-1, ASME, 1980.

13.

Holdcroft

Townsend

The development of tribological solutions to alleviate problems associated with wear, corrugation formation, and noise generation on railway system track. In Lubrication on the rail/wheel interface, November 1991, pp. 136–144. (Canfield Campus Monash University, Australia).

14.

Smith

R. E.

Kalousek

A design methodology for wheel and rail profiles for use on steered railway vehicles. Wear, 1991, 144, 329–342.