The Make or Buy Decision in the Context of Manufacturing Strategy Development

Abstract

This paper describes an approach to structuring the make or buy decision process, basing it firmly in the context of an overall manufacturing strategy. The work has been carried out jointly by the University of Cambridge Manufacturing Engineering Group and Lucas Industries. A review of the current state of ideas surrounding the linked issues of vertical integration and make or buy decisions is presented. Important features of the approach include identification of core manufacturing capabilities, assessment of the role of technology in manufacturing, the development of a cost model to support make or buy decisions and a review of the strategic implications of varying degrees of vertical integration.

Further, the approach has been embodied in a practical methodology that has been applied within Lucas Aerospace. A brief review of this practical application is included.

References

Williamson

O. E.

Markets and hierarchies: analysis and antitrust implications, 1975 (Free Press, New York).

Porter

M. E.

Competitive strategy: techniques for analyzing industries and competitors, 1980 (Free Press, New York).

Harrigan

K. R.

Strategies for vertical integration, 1983 (Lexington Books, Massachusetts).

Skinner

Manufacturing: Missing link in corporate strategy. Harvard Business Review, May-June 1974 (Harvard Business School, Boston).

Hayes

R. H.

Wheelwright

S. C.

Restoring our competitive edge: competing through manufacturing, 1984 (Wiley, New York).

Hayes

R. H.

Wheelwright

S. C.

Clark

Dynamic manufacturing: creating the learning organisation, 1988 (Free Press, New York).

Platts

K. W.

Gregory

M. J.

Competitive manufacturing: a practical approach to the development of a manufacturing strategy, 1989 (IFS, Bedford).

Ellram

L. M.

Supply chain management: The industrial organisation perspective. Int. J. Physical Distribution and Logistics, 1991, 21 (1).

Jones

Supply chain management—the key issues. BPICS Control, 1989 (British Production and Inventory Control Society, Coventry).

10.

Macbeth

D. K.

Baxter

L. F.

Ferguson

Neil

G. C.

Customer supplier relationship audit, 1990 (IFS, Bedford).

11.

Buffa

E. S.

Meeting the competitive challenge, manufacturing strategy for US companies, 1984 (Dow Jones-Irwin, Homewood, Illinois).

12.

Dobler

D. W.

Burt

D. N.

Lee

Purchasing and materials management: text and cases, 1990 (McGraw-Hill, New York).

13.

Brigham

E. F.

Financial management: theory and practice, 1982 (Dryden, New York).

14.

Gambino

A. J.

The make or buy decision, 1980 (National Association of Accountants, New York).

15.

Porter

M. E.

Competitive advantage—creating and sustaining superior performance, 1985 (Free Press, New York).

16.

Harrigan

K. R.

Strategies for joint ventures, 1985 (Lexington Books, Massachusetts).

17.

Coase

R. H.

The nature of the firm. In Economica, 1937 (Blackwell, Oxford).

18.

Monteverde

Teece

D. J.

Supplier switching costs and vertical integration in the automotive industry. Bell J. Economics, 1992, 13 (Rand, Santa Monica, California).

19.

Teece

D. J.

Contributions and impediments of economic analysis to the study of strategic management. In Perspectives on strategic management (Ed. Frederickson

J. W.

), 1990 (Harper and Row, New York).

20.

Prahalad

C. K.

Hamel

The core competence of the corporation. Harvard Business Review, May-June 1990 (Harvard Business School, Boston).

21.

Abetti

P. A.

Linking technology and business strategy, 1989 (The President's Association, American Management Association, New York).

22.

Culliton

J. W.

Make or buy, 1942, Business Research Study 27 (Harvard University Graduate School of Business).

23.

Venkatesan

To make or not to make. Harvard Business Review, November-December 1992 (Harvard Business School, Boston).