Optimum Matching of Non-Electrical Loads to Wind Turbines

Abstract

Improvements in technology have reduced the unit cost of wind–electric power systems by almost an order of magnitude since 1981, and installed wind power capacity is growing rapidly world-wide. Paradoxically, the use of wind-powered pumping systems, formerly the major application of wind power, is declining and little progress has been made towards the direct application of wind power to drive other mechanical loads such as aerators and compressors for heat pumps, despite huge potential markets in areas remote from electricity grids. A major reason for this failure to apply improved wind turbine technology to non-electrical loads is low system efficiency resulting from poor torque matching between the wind turbine rotor and the load. Methods of improving system efficiency are reviewed, including load-disengaging devices to permit easy starting and a simple mechanical control system for a variable ratio drive which would ensure that any wind turbine driving any load will operate near peak efficiency over the full operating range from cut-in to governing. The latter system could improve average system efficiency by a factor of 3 to 8 and has the further advantage that it can provide starting torque and can actuate overspeed control for Darrieus vertical axis wind turbines and low-solidity horizontal axis wind turbines.

Keywords

wind power costs mechanical loads load matching system efficiency control system

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Davidson

Finding the path forward. Windpower Monthly, September 1989, 20–23.

Hagen

Kaneff

Solar reduction of greenhouse emissions and external costs. Proceedings of ANZ Solar Energy Society Conference Solar 91, Adelaide, South Australia, 5–7 December 1991, 494–507.

Braun

G. W.

Smith

D. R.

Commercial wind power: Recent experiences in the United States. In Annual review of energy and the environment (Ed. Hollander

J. M.

), 1992 (Annual Reviews, Inc., Palo Alto, California).

Mackenzie

West funds reactors to replace Chernobyl. New Scientist, 16 July 1994, 4.

Harrison

Maturing with confidence. Windpower Monthly, October 1992, 8(10), 22–25.

Harrison

Knight

Changing gear: Wind moves into the fast lane at EWEC 1993. Windpower Monthly, April 1993, 9(4), 15–19.

Spruce

A Review of the EWEC ‘Potential of Wind Farms’ Conference. Windirections (Newsletter of the British and European Wind Energy Associations), 1992, XII(2), 8.

Ashley

Flywheels put a new spin on electric vehicles. In Mechanical engineering, October 1993, pp. 44–51 (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).

O'Connor

Electric vehicles move closer to market. In Mechanical engineering, March 1995, pp. 82–87 (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).

10.

Headifen

R. N.

Flywheel energy storage for wind turbines. Proceedings of Twenty-ninth Intersociety Conference on Energy conversion, Monterey, California, 7–11 August 1994, pp. 1374–1379.

11.

Bhattacharyya

Dasgupta

Remote area power system development—RAPSYD. Proceedings of European Conference on Wind energy, Herning, Denmark, 6–10 June 1988, pp. 203–208.

12.

Vadot

Water pumping by windmills. La Houille Blanche, September 1957, 4, 524–535.

13.

Fraenkel

P. L.

The ITDG international windpump programme. Proc. Ind. Acad. Sci., March 1979, C2(1).

14.

Pinilla

A. E.

Burton

J. D.

Dunn

P. D.

Wind energy to water pumped: conversion efficiency limits using single-acting lift pumps. In Proceedings of BWEA Conference, 1984, pp. 334–345 (Cambridge University Press).

15.

Smulders

Burton

Pinilla

Stacey

The 3-S pump project: piston pump innovation for wind pumps. Proceedings of EWEC 1994: Fifth European Wind Energy Association Conference, Thessaloniki, Greece, 1994, pp. 1145–1148.

16.

Nagái

Shinoda

Ushiyama

Agricultural applications of wind power in Japan. Proceedings of European Wind Energy Association Conference, Rome, 7–9 October 1986, pp. 463–468.

17.

Feron

The use of windpower in autonomous reverse osmosis seawater desalination. Wind Engng, 1985, 9(3), 180–186.

18.

Draper

The Draper Ingersoll Rand wind powered integrated desalination system: a world first. Product information. Draper Development Corporation, Camberwell, Victoria, Australia, 1983.

19.

Robinson

Mathew

Wind energy for reverse osmosis desalination. UNESCO Regional Seminar on Technology for Community Development in Australia, South-East Asia and the Pacific, Alice Springs, Australia, 9–11 July 1990.

20.

Lake Aid, Inc. Clean Water. Promotion Literature. Lake Aid, Inc., Bismarck, North Dakota, 1992.

21.

Kirke

B. K.

Wind-powered aeration for wastewater treatment, aquaculture and lake destratification. Wind Engng, 1995, 19(1), 1–12.

22.

Backhurst

J. R.

Marker

J. H.

Kaul

S. N.

The performance of pilot and full-scale vertical shaft aerators. Water Res., 1988, 22(10), 1239–1243.

23.

Elgammal

A. H.

Integrated wind-refrigeration systems. Proceedings of European Conference on Wind energy, Herning, Denmark, 6–10 June 1988.

24.

Fraenkel

P. L.

Why windpower? A consideration of factors that may determine the success or failure of small wind turbines in the market place. Proceedings of Conference on Wind energy for rural areas, Bergen, Netherlands, 10–14 October 1991, pp. 223–232.

25.

Fraenkel

P. L.

The development of a novel type of mechanical wind-pump for economic low volume commercial production, 1992, pp. 1656–1662 (Pergamon Press, Oxford).

26.

Beurskens

H. J. M.

Hageman

A. J. F. K.

Hospers

G. D.

Kragten

Lysen

E. H.

Low speed water pumping windmills: rotor tests and overall performance. Proceedings of Third International Symposium on Wind energy systems, Lyngby, Denmark, 26–29 August 1980, pp. 501–520.

27.

Banas

J. F.

Sullivan

W. N.

Engineering of wind energy systems. Sandia Laboratories, Albuquerque, New Mexico, report SAND-75–0530, January 1976.

28.

Burton

Ghorap

Seals and sealing for wind driven lift pumps. Wind Engng, 1995, 19(2), 67–80.

29.

Pinilla

A. E.

Wind-powered pumping systems for Colombia. PhD thesis, Reading University, April 1985.

30.

Baird

J. P.

Design characteristics of the Mono wind turbine. J. Wind Engng Ind. Aerodyn., 1983, 15, 305–315.

31.

Kentfield

J. A. C.

Vardi

A hydromechanical variable-stroke mechanism for water-pumping wind turbines. Proceedings of Intersol Conference, 1985, pp. 2112–2116.

32.

Vinayagalingam

Sivasegaram

A variable-stroke, wind-operated water-pumping system. Wind Engng, 1979, 3(2), 127–131.

33.

Chidzey

W. J.

Controlling wind motors. Australian Pat. 43622/85, December 1985.

34.

Jones

C. N.

Berrill

T. D.

Fries

P. O.

Pilot wind energy survey in Southern Queensland. Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Queensland, October 1987.