The study of the design process, design theory and methodology has been a preoccupation of engineers, designers and researchers over the last four to five decades. As the end of this millenium is approached and with the renewed interest around the world in engineering design, it is fitting to examine the state of the art and current status of issues relating to design philosophies, theory and methodology. Over the last 40 years, many approaches to design have been put forward by various researchers, designers and engineers, both in academia and industry, on how design ought to and might be carried out. These proposals on design have tended towards what has come to be regarded as design philosophies, design models and design methods. The thesis of this paper is to discuss various aspects of generic research in design, within the above classifications in the light of the work that has been done in the last four decades. Discussions will focus on various definitions of design, design theory and methodology, the nature and variety of design problems, design classifications, philosophies, models, methods and systems.
BroadbentG. H.WardA.Design methods in architecture, 1969 (Lund Humphries, London).
4.
Design: Science: Method, Proceedings of the 1980 Design Research Society Conference (Eds JacquesR.PowellJ. A.), 1981 (Westbury House, Guildford, Surrey).
5.
Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 89, Harrogate, 1989, WDK 18, Vols 1 and 2 (Mechanical Engineering Publications, London).
6.
Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 81, Rome, 1981, WDK 5.
7.
Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 83, Kobenhavn, 1983, WDK 10.
8.
Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 85, Hamburg, 1985, WDK 12.
9.
Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 91, Zurich, 1991, WDK 20.
10.
Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 93, The Hague, 17–19 August 1993, WDK 22 (Ed. RoozenburgN. F. M.), Vols 1, 2 and 3.
11.
Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 87, Boston, 1987, WDK 13 (Ed. EderE. W.), Vols 1 and 2.
12.
Proceedings of the 1988 NSF Grantee Workshop on Design theory and methodology, Design Theory '88 (Eds NewsomeS. L.SpillersW. R.FingerS.), 1989 (Springer-Verlag, New York).
13.
Proceedings of First International Conference on Design theory and methodology, Montreal, Canada, September 1989, DE Vol. 17 (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
14.
Proceedings of Second International Conference on Design theory and methodology, Chicago, Illinois, 16–19 September 1990, DE Vol. 27 (Ed. RinderleJ.) (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
15.
Proceedings of Third International Conference on Design, theory and methodology, Miami, Florida, 22–25 September 1991, DE Vol. 31 (Ed. StaufferL. A.) (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
16.
Proceedings of Fourth International Conference on Design, theory and methodology, Scottsdale, Arizona, 13–16 September 1992, DE Vol. 42 (Eds TaylorD. L.StaufferL. A.) (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
17.
Proceedings of Fifth International Conference on Design, theory and methodology, Albuquerque, New Mexico, 19–22 September 1993, DE Vol. 53 (Ed. StaufferL. A.) (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
18.
Proceedings of Sixth International Conference on Design, theory and methodology, Minneapolis, Minnesota, 11–14 September 1994 (Ed. StaufferL. A.) (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
FinkelsteinL.FinkelsteinA. C. W.Review of design methodology. IEE Proc., June 1983, 130 (Part A, No. 4).
21.
LuckmanJ.An approach to the management of design. In Developments in design methodology (Ed. CrossN.), 1984, pp. 83–97 (John Wiley, London).
22.
ArcherL. B.Systematic method for designers. In Developments in design methodology (Ed. CrossN.), 1984, pp. 57–82 (John Wiley, London).
23.
CaldecoteV.The design team in relation to the individual designer. The practice of and education for engineering design. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, 1963–4, 178(3B), 16–19.
24.
Goals and priorities for research in engineering design, 1986 (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
25.
RabinsMDesign theory and methodology–a new discipline. Mech. Engng, August 1986, 23–27.
26.
RzevskiG.On the design of a design methodology. In Design: Science: Method, Proceedings of the 1980 Design Research Society Conference (Eds JacquesR.PowellJ. A.), 1981, pp. 6–17 (Westbury House, Guildford, Surrey).
27.
Banares-AlcantaraR.Representing the engineering design process: Two hypotheses. In Artificial intelligence in design conference (Ed. GeroJ. S.), 1991, pp. 3–22 (Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford).
28.
GeroJ. S.A system for computer-aided design in architecture. In Computer aided design (Eds ViletstraJ.WielingaR. F.), 1973 (North Holland, Amsterdam).
29.
SmithersT.AI-based design versus geometry-based design, or why design cannot be supported by geometry alone. Computer Aided Des., 1989, 21(3), 141–150.
30.
JusterN. P.The design process and design methodologies. Technical report, University of Leeds, May 1985.
31.
CaganJ.AgoginoA. M.Dimensional variable expansion–a formal approach to innovative design. Res. in Engng Des., 1991, 3, 75–85.
32.
SriramD.Knowledge-based system applications in engineering design: Research at MIT. AI Mag., Fall 1989, 10(3), 79–96.
33.
PahlG.BeitzW.Engineering design, Original German Edition, 1st edition, 1971; English Edition (Ed. WallaceK.), 1984 (The Design Council, London).
34.
ClausingD. P.Total quality development–the development of competitive new products, March 1994 (American Society of Mechanical Engineers Press, New York).
35.
MedlandA. J.The computer based design process, 1986 (Kogan Page, London).
36.
MostowJ.Toward better models of the design process. AI Mag., Spring 1985, 44–57.
37.
BroadbentG. H.Design methods–13 years after–a review. In Design: science: method (Eds JacquesR.PowellJ. A.), 1980, pp. 3–5 (Westbury House, Guildford, Surrey).
38.
FingerS.DixonJ. R.A review of research in mechanical engineering design. Part 1: Descriptive, prescriptive, and computer-based models of design processes. Res. in Engng Des., 1989, 1, 51–67.
WallaceK. M.Better by design. Mfg Engr, May 1989, 35–36.
45.
OsbornA. F.Applied imagination, 1963 (Scribener's & Sons, New York).
46.
GordonW. J. J.Synectics: the development of creative capacity, 1961 (Harper and Row, New York).
47.
AsimowM.Introduction to design, 1962 (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey).
48.
WattsR. D.The elements of design. In The design method (Ed. GregoryS. A.), 1966, pp. 85–95 (Butterworth, London).
49.
MarplesD. L.The decisions of engineering design, 1960, pp. 1–16 (The Institution of Engineering Designers, London).
50.
EderW. E.Definitions and methodologies. In The design method (Ed. GregoryS. A.), 1966, pp. 19–31 (Butterworth, London).
51.
EvbuomwanN. F. O.Quality function deployment–past, present and future. 10th ISPE/IFAC International Conference on CAD/CAM, robotics and factories of the future, CARS & FOF 94, Ottawa, Canada, 21–24 August 1994, pp. 596–601.
52.
KrickE. V.Engineering and engineering design, 2nd edition, 1969 (John Wiley, New York).
53.
HubkaV.Design for quality and design methodology. J. Engng Des., 1992, 3(1), 5–15.
54.
FrenchM. J.Conceptual design for engineers, 1st edition, 1971 (The Design Council, London).
55.
HarrisA. J.Can design be taught. Proc. Instn Civ. Engrs, August 1980, Part 1, No. 68, 409–416.
BS 7000, Management of design, January 1990 (British Standards Institution, London).
58.
SubN.The principles of design, 1988 (Oxford University Press, New York).
59.
TagnchiG.Introduction to quality engineering: designing quality into products and processes, 1986 (Asian Productivity Organisation, Tokyo, Japan).
60.
SanchezS. M.Quality by design. In Concurrent engineering: automation, tools and techniques (Ed. KusiakA.), 1993, Ch. 10, pp. 235–286 (John Wiley, New York).
61.
ErtasA.JonesJ. C.The engineering design process, 1993 (John Wiley, New York).
62.
UllmanD. G.DiettrichT. A.Mechanical design methodology–computers in engineering, 1986, pp. 173–180 (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
63.
UllmanD. G.StaufferL. A.DiettrichT. A.Preliminary results of an experimental study of the mechanical design process. In Proceedings from the NSF Workshop on the design process (Ed. WaldronM. B.), 1987, pp. 145–188 (Ohio State University, Oakland, California).
64.
MarchL.The logic of design. In Developments in design methodology (Ed. CrossN.), 1984, pp. 265–276 (John Wiley, London).
65.
MatchettE.BriggsA. H.Practical design based on method (fundamental design method). In The design method (Ed. GregoryS. A.), 1966, pp. 183–199 (Butterworth, London).
66.
JonesJ. C.Design methods–seeds of human futures, 1970 (John Wiley, London).
67.
HybsI.GeroJ. S.An evolutionary process model of design. Des. Stud., July 1992, 13(3), 273–290.
68.
NevilleG. E.Computational models of design processes. In Proceedings of the 1988 NSF Grantee Workshop on design theory and methodology, Design Theory '88 (Eds NewsomeS. L.SpillersW. R.FingerS.), 1989, pp. 82–96 (Springer-Verlag, New York).
69.
AgoginoA. M.AI/OR computational model for integrating qualitative and quantitative design methods. Proceedings of NSF Engineering in Design Conference, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts, 11–14 June 1989, pp. 97–112.
70.
MostowJ.A domain-independent model of knowledge-based design. In Proceedings of the 1988 NSF Grantee Workshop on design theory and methodology, Design Theory '88 (Eds NewsomeS. L.SpillersW. R.FingerS.), 1989, pp. 97–99 (Springer-Verlag, New York).
71.
DixonJ. R.Iterative redesign and respeciflcation: research on computational models of design processes. In Proceedings of the 1988 NSF Grantee Workshop on design theory and methodology, Design Theory '88 (Eds NewsomeS. L.SpillersW. R.FingerS.), 1989, pp. 104–107 (Springer-Verlag, New York).
72.
GeroJ. S.AI and new computational models of design. International Association for Bridge and Structural Engineering (IABSE) Colloquium on Knowledge-based systems in civil engineering, Beijing, China, 1993, pp. 25–32.
73.
FitzhornP. A.Engineering design is a computable function. Artif. Intell. for Engng Des., Analysis and Mfg, 1994, 8, 35–44.
74.
HubkaV.Design tactics = methods + working principles for design engineers. International Conference on Engineering design, ICED, Kobenhavn, 15–18 August 1983, pp. 16–34.
75.
ChawdhryP. K.Integration and management of concurrent design activities. Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 93, The Hague, 17–19 August 1993, WDK 22 (Ed. RoozenburgN. F. M.), Vol. 3, pp. 1481–1485.
76.
BauertF.BallN. R.The integrated design framework: blackboards as a communication medium between designers and software medium. Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 93, The Hague, 17–19 August 1993, WDK 22 (Ed. RoozenburgN. F. M.), Vol. 3, pp. 1351–1358.
77.
BracewellR. H.Schemebuilder, a design aid for the conceptual stages of product design. Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design ICED 93, The Hague, 17–19 August 1993, WDK 22 (Ed. RoozenburgN. F. M.), Vol. 3, pp. 1311–1318.
78.
OhV. K.SharpeJ. E. E.Integrated computer support for interdisciplinary system design. In Methodologies, techniques, and tools for design development (Eds TanikM. M.), Vol. 5, PD-Vol. 64–5, Proceedings of Second Biennial European Joint Conference on Engineering systems design and analysis, London, 4–7 July 1994, pp. 107–114 (American Society of Mechanical Engineers, New York).
79.
GillamA.Vehicle knowledge-based design environment. J. Spacecraft and Rockets, May-June 1993, 30(3), 342–347.
80.
BeitzW.FeldhasenJ.Management systems and program concepts for an integrated CAD process. Res. in Engng Des., 1991, 3, 61–74.
81.
MeerkammH.Design system MFK–an important step towards an engineering workbench. Proc. Instn Mech. Engrs, Part B, 1993, 207(B2), 105–116.
82.
AkmanV.A fundamental and theoretical framework for an intelligent CAD system. Computer Aided Des., July-August 1990, 22(6), 352–367.
83.
FingerS.Design support systems for concurrent engineering: a case study in large power transformer design. Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering design, ICED 93, The Hague, 17–19 August 1993, WDK 22 (Ed. RoozenburgN. F. M.), Vol. 3, pp. 1433–1440.
FingerS.DixonJ. R.A review of research in mechanical engineering design. Part 2: Representations, analysis, and design for the life cycle. Res. in Engng Des., 1989, 1, 121–137.
