The Beat is Getting Stronger: The Effect of Atmospheric Stability on Low Frequency Modulated Sound of Wind Turbines

Abstract

Sound from wind turbines involves a number of sound production mechanisms related to different interactions between the turbine blades and the air. An important contribution to the low frequency part of the sound spectrum is due to the sudden variation in air flow which the blade encounters when it passes the tower: the angle of attack of the incoming air suddenly deviates from the angle that is optimized for the mean flow. Hitherto, low-frequency sound from wind turbines has not been shown to be a major factor contributing to annoyance. This seems reasonable as the blade passing frequency is of the order of one hertz where the human auditory system is relatively insensitive. This argument, however, obscures a very relevant effect: the blade passing frequency modulates well audible, higher-frequency sounds and thus creates periodic sound: blade swish. This effect is stronger at night because in a stable atmosphere there is a greater difference between rotor averaged and near-tower wind speed. Measurements have shown that additional turbines can interact to further amplify this effect. Theoretically the resulting fluctuations in sound level will be clearly perceptible to human hearing. This is confirmed by residents near wind turbines with the same common observation: often late in the afternoon or in the evening the turbine sound acquires a distinct ‘beating’ character, the rhythm of which is in agreement with the blade passing frequency. It is clear from the observations that this is associated to a change toward a higher atmospheric stability. The effect of stronger fluctuations on annoyance has not been investigated as such, although it is highly relevant because a) the effect is stronger for modern (that is: tall) wind turbines, and b) more people in Europe will be living close to these wind turbines as a result of the growth of wind energy projects.

References

European Wind Energy Association (EWEA), European Commission's Directorate General for Transport and Energy (DG TREN): “Wind Energy -The Facts: An Analysis of Wind Energy in the EU-25” (2004).

van den Berg

.: “Effects of the Wind Profile at Night on Wind Turbine Sound”, J. Sound Vib. 277 (4–5), 955–970 (2004).

Lowson

M.V.

: “A New Prediction Model for Wind Turbine Noise”, Wind Engineering 18 (2), 51–62 (1995).

Grosveld

F.W.

: “Prediction of Broadband Noise from Horizontal Axis Wind Turbines”, J. Propulsion 1 (4), 292–299 (1985).

Hubbard

H.H.

and Shepherd

K.P.

: “Aeroacoustics of Large Wind Turbines”, J. Acoust. Soc. Am 89 (6), 2495–2508 (2004).

Wagner

Bareiss

and Guidati

: “Wind Turbine Noise”, Springer, Berlin, 1996.

Petersen

E.L.

Mortensen

N.G.

Landberg

Hùjstrup

and Frank

.: “Wind Power Meteorology: Part I: Climate and Turbulence”, Wind Energy 1 2–22 (1998).

The Working Group on Noise from Wind Turbines: “The Assessment & Rating of Noise from Wind Farms” (ETSU-R-97), Department of Trade and Industry, United Kingdom (1996).

Garrat

J.R.

: “The Atmospheric Boundary Layer”, Cambridge University Press, 1992.

10.

Archer

C.L.

and Jacobson

M.Z.

: “Spatial and Temporal Distributions of U.S. Winds and Wind Power at 80 m Dervoide from Measurements”, J. Geophys. Res. 108 (D9), (2003).

11.

Roy

Baidya S.

Pacala

S.W.

and Walko

R.L.

: “Can Large Wind Farms Affect Local Meteorology?”, Journal of Geophysical Research, Vol. 109, D19101 (2004).

12.

Smedman

Högström

and Bergström

: “Low Level Jets – A Decisive Factor for Off-Shore Wind Energy Siting in the Baltic Sea”, Wind Engineering 20 (3), 137–147 (1996).

13.

Smith

Randall

Malcolm

Kelly

and Smith

: “Evaluation of Wind Shear Patterns at Midwest Wind Energy Facilities” (preprint), National Renewable Energy Laboratory NREL/CP-500-32492, USA (2002).

14.

Pérez

I.A.

García

Sánchez

. and de Torre

: “Analysis and parameterisation of wind profiles in the low atmosphere”, Solar Energy, in press (2004).

15.

Holtslag

A.A.M.

: “Estimates of Diabatic Wind Speed Profiles from Near-Surface weather observations”, Boundary-Layer Meteorology 29, 225–250 (1984).

16.

IEC International Standard 61400–11, Wind Turbine Generator Systems—Part 11: Acoustic Noise Measurement Techniques, IEC 61400–11:1998(E).

17.

Hutcheson

F.V.

and Brooks

T.F.

: “Effects of Angle of Attack and Velocity on Trailing Edge Noise”, pros. 42^nd Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Reno, January 2004.

18.

Nanahara

Asara

Sato

Yamaguchi

Shibata

and Maejima

: “Smoothing Effects of Distributed Wind Turbines, Part 1”, Wind Energy 2004 (7), pp. 61–74.

19.

Nanahara

: personal communication, June 14, 2004.

20.

B&K: “Microphone Handbook”, Brüel & Kjaer, Denmark, 1995.

21.

Pedersen

: “Noise annoyance from wind turbines – a review”, Swedish Environmental Protection Agency (2003).

22.

Pedersen

and Waye

Persson K.

: “Perception and Annoyance due to Wind Turbine Noise – a Dose-Response Relationship”, J. Acoust. Soc. Am 116 (6), 3460–3470 (2004).

23.

WHO: “Guidelines for Community Noise”, World Health Organization (Geneva) and Institute of Environmental Epidemiology (Singapore), 2000.

24.

Waye

Persson K.

and Öhström

: Psycho-acoustic characters of relevance for annoyance of wind turbine noise – J. Sound Vib. 250(1), 65–73 (2002).

25.

Pedersen

Waye

Persson K.

and Hallberg

L.R.M.

: “Living Close to Wind Turbines-A Qualitative Approach to a Deeper Understanding”, proc. Internoise2004, Prague (2004).

26.

Zwicker

and Fastl

: “Psycho-Acoustics, Facts and Models”, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1999).

27.

van Ulden

A.P.

van der Vliet

J.G.

en Wieringa

: “Temperature and Wind Observations at Heights from 2m to 200m at Cabauw in 1973”, 1976, De Bilt.

28.

Jakobsen

: “Low Frequency Sound from Wind Turbines”, proc. Low Frequency Noise and Vibration, Maastricht (2004).

29.

Brooks

T.F.

Pope

D.S.

and Marcolini

M.A.

: “Airfoil Self-Noise and Prediction”, NASA reference publication 1218, USA (1989).

30.

ISO: “Acoustics — Frequency-Weighting Characteristic for Infrasound Measurements” (ISO 7196), International Organization of Standardization (1995).

31.

: Wind Report 2004”, E.ON Netz GmbH, Bayreuth, Germany (2004).

32.

ESB: “Impact of Wind Power Generation in Ireland on the Operation of Conventional Plant and the Economic Implications”, ESB National Grid, Ireland (2004).

33.

Health Council of the Netherlands: “Effects of Noise on Sleep and Health”, Health Council of the Netherlands, publication no. 2004/14, The Hague (2004).

34.

van den Berg

G.P.

: “Wind Turbines at Night: Acoustical Practice and Sound Research”, Proc. Euronoise 2003, Naples (2003).