An Investigation into the Reproducibility Values of the European Inter-Laboratory Test for Lightweight Walls

Abstract

In an inter-laboratory test programme (ILT) for the measurement of airborne sound insulation of lightweight walls, reproducibility values of up to 12dB were obtained from the sound reduction index measured in 21 participating laboratories. These high reproducibility values were for a test structure composed of lightweight plasterboard panels, forming a double wall, mounted on separate metal ‘C’ channels.

This paper presents possible reasons for the large reproducibility values for the double wall using experimental investigations and theoretical models using Statistical Energy Analysis (SEA). Whilst the sound reduction index(SRI) does take into account the different test wall areas and reverberation times of the respective laboratories involved, some factors which may influence the measured SRI values are not.

It is suggested that the principle factor which may have effected the SRI values of this test programme for the double wall was the lining material of the test aperture in the various laboratories which can provide a flanking transmission path between both sides of the double wall. Other factors are discussed which may also play a contributory role in causing differences in the measured SRI values such as sill/reveal size, aspect ratio, panel-channel connections and workmanship.

References

Fausti

Pompoli

Smith

R.S.

(1999). An inter-comparison of laboratory measurements of airborne sound insulation of lightweight plasterboard partitions. Journal of Building Acoustics Vol.6 No. 2.

ISO 140/2 (1991) “Measurement of sound insulation in buildings and of building elements – Part 2: Determination, verification and application of precision data”, UNI EN 20140–2 (1994).

Pompoli

(1997) Inter-comparison of laboratory measurements of airborne sound insulation of walls. Final Report. EC Measurements and Testing Programme 1990–1994. Contract No. MAT1-CT-940054.

Leppington

F.G.

Broadbent

E.G.

Heron

K.H.

(1982). The acoustic radiation efficiency of rectangular panels. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. A382, 241–271.

Leppington

F.G.

Broadbent

E.G.

Heron

K.H.

(1984). The acoustic radiation from rectangular panels with constrained edges. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. A393, 67–84.

Leppington

F.G.

Broadbent

E.G.

Heron

K.H.

Mead

S.M.

(1986). Resonant and non-resonant acoustic properties of elastic panels. I The radiation problem. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. A406, 139–171.

Leppington

F.G.

Broadbent

E.G.

Heron

K.H.

Mead

S.M.

(1987). Resonant and non-resonant acoustic properties of elastic panels. II The transmission problem. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. A412, 309–337.

Leppington

F.G.

(1996). Acoustic radiation from plates into a wedge-shaped fluid region: Application to the free plate problem. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. A452, 1745–1764.

Craik

R.J.M.

(1992). The influence of the laboratory on measurements of wall performance. Applied Acoustics, 35, p25–46.

10.

Craik

R.J.M.

(1996). Sound transmission through buildings using statistical energy analysis. Gower. UK.

11.

Smith

R.S.

(1997). Sound transmission through lightweight parallel plates. PhD Thesis. Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK.

12.

Lyon

R.H.

(1975). Statistical energy analysis of dynamical systems. Theory and applications. MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. USA.

13.

London

(1950). Transmission of reverberant sound through double walls. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 22, 270–279.

14.

Price

A.J.

Crocker

M.J.

(1970). Sound transmission through double walls using statistical energy analysis. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 47, 683–693.

15.

Osipov

Mees

Vermeir

(1996). Low frequency airborne sound transmission in buildings: Single plane walls. Proceedings of Inter-noise 96, Liverpool, UK. 1791–1794.

16.

Osipov

Mees

Vermeir

(1997). Low frequency airborne sound transmission through single partitions in buildings. Applied Acoustics, 52, 278–288.

17.

Fahy

F.J.

Mohammed

A.D.

(1992). A study of uncertainty in applications of SEA to coupled beam and plate systems, Part I: Computational experiments. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 158, 45–67.

18.

Guy

R.W.

Sauer

(1984). The influence of sills and reveals on sound transmission loss. Applied Acoustics, 17, 453–476.

19.

Lewis

P.T.

(1972). The noise generated by road traffic and its penetration into buildings. PhD Thesis. University of Newcastle, Newcastle, UK.

20.

Craik

R.J.M.

Steel

J.A.

(1989). The effect of workmanship on sound transmission through buildings: Part 1- Airborne sound. Applied Acoustics, 27, 57–63.