Softening of Normal Strength and High-Strength Concrete Frames

Abstract

In the 21st century, computing facilities will make it possible to opt on a regular basis for more accurate rigorous methods of analysis. A rigorous collapse load analysis requires a knowledge of the behaviour of plastic hinges up to advanced curvatures. Concrete sections characteristically soften, that is the bending moment capacity decreases with increasing curvatures after the end of the plastic plateau while steel sections undergo a hardening phase. Consideration of softening is essential in a rational analysis. In this paper, the important aspects of softening of concrete frame structures are reviewed.

High-strength concrete (f'c>50 MPa) is a more brittle construction material than normal strength concrete. High-strength concrete sections show a steeper softening slope when compared with similar normal strength concrete sections. An example is presented to demonstrate that a HSC frame structure with steeper softening slopes will have a lower collapse load.

Keywords

inforced concrete high-strength concrete softening rotation capacity hinges

References

ACI-ASCE Committee 428 (1968). Progress Report on Code Clauses for Limit Design, J. ACI, 65, No.9, 1968, 713–715.

Attard

M.M.

and Mendis

P.A.

(1993), “Ductility of high-strength concrete columns”, Civil Eng. Trans., I.E.Aust., 35(4), 295–306.

Barnard

P.R.

(1964), “The collapse of Reinforced Concrete Beams”, Proceedings, International Symposium on The Flexural Mechanics of Reinforced Concrete, Miami, ACI SP-12, 501–520.

Bazant

Z.P.

(1976), “Instability, Ductility and Size Effect in Strain Softening Concrete”, Journal of the Engineering mechanics Division, ASCE, 102(2), 331–334.

Bertero

V.V.

and Felippa

(1964), “Discussion of Ductility of Concrete”, by Roy

H.E.H.

and Sozen

M.A.

, Proceedings, Internal Symposium on the Flexural Mechanics of Reinforced Concrete, Miami, ACI SP-12, 227–234.

Bonacci

J.F.

(1996), “Analysis requirements for performance-based design of beam-column joints”, Worldwide Advances in Structural Concrete and Masonary, Proceedings of the CCMS Symposium, ASCE, Chicago, 257–265.

Cranston

W.B.

(1965), “Tests on Reinforced Concrete Frames; 1: Pinned Portal Frames”, Technical Report TRA/932, Cement and Concrete Association, London.

Cranston

W.B.

and Chatterji

A.K.

(1970), “Computer Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Portal Frames with Fixed Feet”, Technical Report TRA/444, Cement and Concrete Association, London.

Cranston

W.B.

and Cracknell

J.A.

(1969), “Tests on Reinforced Concrete Frames; 2 Portal Frames with Fixed Feet”, Technical Report TRA/240, Cement and Concrete Association, London.

10.

Darvall

P.LeP.

(1983), “Critical Softening of Hinges in Indeterminate Beams and Portal Frames”, Civil Engineering Transactions, Institute of Engineers Australia, CE25(3), 199–210

11.

Darvall

P.LeP.

and Mendis

P.A.

(1985), “Elastic-Plastic-Softening Analysis of Plane Frames”, Journal of the Structural Division, ASCE, 111(4), 871–888.

12.

Ghosh

S.K.

(1986), “Seismic Resistance of Reinforced Concrete Structural Systems of Limited Ductility”, Proceedings, the third US national conference on earthquake engineering, Charleston, South Carolina.

13.

Ghosh

S.K.

and Cohn

M.Z.

(1972), “Non-Linear Analysis of Strain-Softening Structures”, Proceedings, Symposium on Inelastic and Non-Linearity in Structural Concrete, Paper No. 12, Study No. 8, University of Waterloo, 315–332.

14.

Kovacic

(1995), “Design of high-strength concrete columns”, M.Eng. Thesis, The University of Melbourne.

15.

Maier

Zavelani

and Dotreppe

J.C.

(1978), “Equilibrium Branching due to Flexural Softening”, Journal of the Engineering Mechanics Division, ASCE, 99(4), 897–901.

16.

Mander

J.B.

Priestly

M.J.N.

and Park

(1988), “Theoretical Stress-Strain Model for Confined Concrete”, Journal of Structural Engineering, 114(8) Aug., 1804–1826.

17.

Mendis

P.A.

(1986), “Softening of reinforced concrete structures”, Ph.D. Thesis, Monash University.

18.

Mendis

P. A.

Pendyala

and Setunge

(1999), “Stress-strain model to predict the full-range moment curvature behaviour of high-strength concrete sections”, to be published in Magazine of Concrete Research Journal, UK, Vol. 52, No. 3.

19.

Park

and Paulay

(1975), “Reinforced Concrete Structures”, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA.

20.

Pendyala

Mendis

and Patnaikuni

(1996), “Full-range behavior of high-strength concrete flexural members: Comparison of ductility parameters of high and normal-strength concrete members”, Struct. J. ACI, 93(1), 30–35.

21.

Pendyala

R.S.

(1997), “The behaviour of high-strength concrete flexural members”, Ph.D Thesis, The University of Melbourne.

22.

Rosenblueth

and de Cossio

Diaz R.

(1964), “Instability Considerations in Limit Design of Concrete Frames”, Proceedings, International Symposium on the Flexural Mechanics of Reinforced Concrete, Miami, ACI SP-12, 439–463.

23.

Sanjayan

(1988), “Dynamic response of reinforced concrete structures with softening behavior”, Ph.D. Thesis, Monash University.

24.

Scott

B.D.

Park

and Priestly

M.J.N.

(1982), “Stress-Strain Behaviour of Concrete Confined by Overlapping Hoops at Low and High Strain Rates”, ACI Journal, 79(1), 13–27.

25.

Setunge

and Mendis

P.A.

(1996), Stress-strain relationship of concrete: How important is it?, Radical Concrete Technology Conf., Dundee, Dhir

R K

and Hewlett

P.C.

, eds., E&FN Spon, 91–98.

26.

Setunge

(1993), “Structural properties of very high strength concrete”, Ph.D thesis, Monash University, Australia.

27.

Taylor

H.P.J.

(1974), “The Behaviour of In-Situ Beam-Column Joints”, Technical Report 42/492, Cement and Concrete Association, London.

28.

Tse

and Darvall

P.LeP.

(1988), “Softening Hinges in Reinforced Concrete Beams”, Proceedings, First National Structural Engineering Conference, The Institute of Engineers, Melbourne, Australia, 483–488.