Why Do You Need to Use a Caries Risk Assessment Protocol to Provide an Effective Caries Preventive Regime?

Abstract

Background

Clinical guidelines recommend an individual is given a caries risk status based on analysis of defined clinical and social criteria before implementing a tailored preventive plan.

Aims

Improve documentation of caries risk assessment (CRA) in a general dental practice setting, using a systems-based approach to quality improvement methods. Investigate the impact of quality improvement efforts on subsequent design and delivery of preventive care. Identify barriers to delivery of CRA and provision of preventive care.

Design

Data for patients aged 0–16 years was collected over two cycles using standard audit methodology. The first cycle was a retrospective analysis (n=400) using random sampling. The second cycle a prospective analysis (n=513) using consecutive sampling over a 15-week period. Five staff meetings with feedback occurred between cycles.

Results

In cycle one, no specific CRA system was identified. CRA status was not stated widely, risk factors were not analysed and there was variation with respect to the prescription and delivery of preventive strategies. These discrepancies were demonstrable for all four participating dentists and at all ages. In cycle two, 100% recorded CRA. All risk factors were analysed and individual caries risk was correctly annotated. There was 100% compliance with the protocol for preventive plans.

Conclusions

The use of CRA improved documentation of caries risk status. This has improved subsequent prescription of age specific evidence-based preventive care appropriate to the risk status of that individual. Barriers were identified to the delivery of CRA and the provision of comprehensive preventive care by the dentists and other healthcare professionals.

Keywords

Caries risk assessment Caries risk assessment protocol Caries risk assessment tool

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Research and Development: West of Scotland Research Ethics Service. Available at: www.nhsggc.org.uk/content/default.asp?page=s1379_4. Accessed Jan 2015.

Childsmile. Available at: www.childsmile.org.uk. Accessed Jan 2015.

Macpherson

, Ball

, Brewster

, Duane

, Hodges

, Wright

, Gnich

, Rodgers

, McCall

, Turner

, Conway

. Childsmile: the national child oral health improvement programme in Scotland. Part 1: Establishment and development. Br Dent J 2010;209(2):73–8.

Turner

, Brewster

, Kidd

, Gnich

, Ball

, Milburn

, Pitts

, Goold

, Conway

, Macpherson

. Childsmile: the national child oral health improvement programme in Scotland. Part 2: Monitoring and delivery. Br Dent J 2010;209(2):79–83.

SIGN 47. Preventing Dental Caries in Children at High Caries Risk. Targeted Prevention of Dental Caries in the Permanent Teeth of 6–16 Year Olds Presenting for Dental Care. Edinburgh: Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network; 2000. Available at: www.sign.ac.uk/guidelines/fulltext/47. Accessed Aug 2013.

SIGN 83. Prevention and Management of Dental Decay in the Pre-school Child. Edinburgh: Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network; 2005. Available at: http://sign.ac.uk/guidelines/fulltext/83/index.html. Accessed Jan 2015.

EAPD. Guidelines on the use of fluoride in children. Eur Arch Paed Dent 2009;10(3):129–135.

DH/BASCD Oral Health Toolkit 2007. Available at: www.gov.dh.gov.uk. Accessed Jan 2015.

SDCEP. Oral Health Assessment and Review. Available at: www.sdcep.org.uk. Accessed Jan 2015.

10.

SDCEP. The Prevention and Management of Dental Caries in Children: Dental Clinical Guidance. Scottish Dental Clinical Effectiveness Programme. 2010. Available at: www.scottishdental.org/cep. Accessed Jan 2015.

11.

Nutrition and Dental Heath - Guidelines for Professionals. Belfast: Health Promotion Agency for Northern Ireland; 2008. Available at: www.healthpromotionagency.org.uk/Resources/nutrition/pdfs/Nutrition_and_Dental_Health.pdf. Accessed Jan 2015.

12.

NICE. Clinical Guideline 19. Dental recall – Recall interval between routine dental examinations. London: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence; 2004. Available at: www.nice.org.uk/guidance/index.jsp?action=byID&r=true&o=10952 Accessed Jan 2015.

13.

Faculty of General Dental Practice. Selection Criteria for Dental Radiography. London: Faculty of General Dental Practice (UK) of The Royal College of Surgeons; 2004.

14.

Faculty of General Dental Practice. Clinical Examination and Record Keeping. Good Practice Guidelines (2nd Ed). London: Faculty of General Dental Practice (UK) of The Royal College of Surgeons; 2009.

15.

The American Association of Paediatric Dentists: Guideline on caries risk assessment and management for infants, children and adolescents. Available at: www.aapd.org/media/Policies_Guidelines/G_CariesRiskAssessment.pdf. Accessed Jan 2015.

16.

American Dental Association. Caries risk assessment. Available at: www.ada.org. Accessed Jan 2015.

17.

American Dental Association. Councils on Scientific Affairs and Dental Practice. Caries Risk Assessment Form (Ages 0–6). Chicago: American Dental Association; 2008. Available at: www.ada.org/sections/professionalResources/docs/topics_caries_under6.doc. Accessed Jan 2015.

18.

American Dental Association. Councils on Scientific Affairs and Dental Practice. Caries Risk Assessment Form (Age >6). Chicago: American Dental Association; 2008. Available at: www.ada.org/sections/professionalResources. Accessed Aug 2014.

19.

BSPD. British Society for Paediatric Dentistry (BSPD). Available at: www.bspd.co.uk. Accessed Jan 2015.

20.

SIGN 138. Dental interventions to prevent caries in children. 2014. Available at: www.sign.ac.uk/pdf/SIGN138.pdf. Accessed Jan 2015.

21.

Tellez

, Gomez

, Pretty

, Ellwood

, Ismail

Evidence on existing caries risk assesssment systems: Are they predictive of future caries? Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2013;41:67–68.

22.

Mejare

, Axelson

, Dahlen

, Espelid

, Norlund

, Traneus

, Twetman

Caries risk assessment. A systematic review: Acta Odontol Scand 2013; Early online 1–11.

23.

Harris

, Nicoll

, Pine

. Risk factors for dental caries in young children: A systematic review of the literature. Community Dent Health 2004;21:(supplement)71–85.

24.

Zero

, Fontana

, Lennon

. Clinical applications and outcomes of using indicators of risk in caries management. J Dent Educ 2001;65(10):1126–32.

25.

Reich

, Lussi

, Newbrun

Caries Risk Assessment. Int Dent J 1999;49:15–26.

26.

Featherstone

. The caries balance: Contributing factors and early detection. J Calif Dent Assoc 2003;31(2):129–33.

27.

Featherstone

. The caries balance: The basis for caries management by risk assessment. Oral Health Prev Dent 2004;2(Suppl 1):259–64.

28.

Marinho

, Higgins

, Sheiham

, Logan

Fluoride toothpastes for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2003a;1:CD002278. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

29.

Marinho

, Higgins

, Logan

, Sheiham

Topical fluoride (toothpastes, mouthrinses, gels or varnishes) for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2003c;4:CD002782. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

30.

Marinho

, Higgins

, Sheiham

, Logan

One topical fluoride (toothpastes, or mouthrinses, or gels, or varnishes) versus another for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2004a;1:CD002780. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

31.

Marinho

, Higgins

, Sheiham

, Logan

Combinations of topical fluoride (toothpastes, mouthrinses, gels, varnishes) versus single topical fluoride for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2004b;1:CD002781. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

32.

Marinho

, Higgins

, Logan

, Sheiham

Fluoride mouthrinses for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2003b;3:CD002284. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

33.

Marinho

, Higgins

, Logan

, Sheiham

Fluoride gels for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2002a;2:CD002280. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

34.

Marinho

, Higgins

, Logan

, Sheiham

Fluoride varnishes for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2002b;3:CD002279. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

35.

Marinho

VCC

. Cochrane reviews of randomized trials of fluoride therapies for preventing dental caries an update. Eur Arch Paed Dent 2009;10(3):183–91.

36.

Ahovuo-Saloranta

, Hiiri

, Nordblad

, Mäkelä

, Worthington

. Pit and fissure sealants for preventing dental decay in the permanent teeth of children and adolescents. 2009. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

37.

Hiiri

, Ahovuo-Saloranta

, Nordblad

, Mäkelä

Pit and fissure sealants versus fluoride varnishes for preventing dental decay in children and adolescents 2010. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

38.

NHS Education for Scotland. Audit steps. Available at: http://www.nes.scot.nhs.uk/education-and-training/by-discipline/dentistry/areas-of-education/professional-development/clinical-audit-and-sea/audit-steps.aspx. Accessed Jan 2015.

39.

Clarkson

, Ramsay

, Eccles

, Eldridge

, Grimshaw

, Johnston

, Michie

, Treweek

, Walker

, Young

, Black

, Bonetti

, Cassie

, Francis

, Mackenzie

, Macpherson

, McKee

, Pitts

, Rennie

, Stirling

, Tilley

, Torgerson

, Vale

Translation of research in a dental setting (TRiaDS) Implement Sci 2010;20;5:57. DOI:10.1186/1748-5908-5-57.

40.

Ivers

, Jamtvedt

, Flottorp

, Young

, Odgaard-Jensen

, French

, O'Brien

, Johansen

, Grimshaw

, Oxman

. Audit and feedback: effects on professional practice and healthcare outcomes. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2012, Issue 6. Art. No.: CD000259. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD000259. pub3. Available at: www.thecochranelibrary.com. Accessed Jan 2015.

41.

Michie

, Johnston

, Abraham

, Lawton

, Parker

, Walker

Making psychological theory useful for implementing evidence based practice: a consensus approach. Qual Saf Health Care 2005;14:26–33.

42.

Michie

, Johnston

, Francis

, Hardeman

, Eccles

From Theory to Intervention: Mapping Theoretically Derived Behavioural Determinants to Behaviour Change Techniques. Appl Pscy 2008;57(4):660–80.

43.

Michie

, van Stralen

, West

The behaviour change wheel: A new method for characterising and designing behaviour change interventions. Implement Sci 2011;6:42.

44.

Firmstone

, Elley

, Skrybant

, Fry-Smith

, Bayliss

, Torgerson

. Systematic review of the effectiveness of continuing dental professional development on learning, behavior, or patient outcomes. J Dent Educ 2013;77:300–15.

45.

Dominic

Multifaceted and mixed didactic-interactive methods are more effective ways to learn and change behaviour. Evid-Based Dent 2013;14:67–8.

46.

Grimshaw

, Thomas

, MacLennan

, . Effectiveness and efficiency of guideline dissemination and implementation strategies. Health Technol Assess 2004;8:1–72.

47.

Clarkson

, Turner

, Grimshaw

, . Changing clinicians’ behaviour: A randomized controlled trial of fees and education. J Dent Res 2008;87:640–4.

48.

Richards

Guidelines and the killer Bs. Evid Based Dent 2006;7:1–2.

49.

Richards

Caries prevention guidelines. Evid Based Dent 2008;9:66.

50.

National Dental Inspection Programme of Scotland. Report of the NDIP on the detailed inspection of P1 Children and the basic inspections of P1 and P7 in Scotland. Available at: www.scottishdental.org/index.aspx?o=2153. Accessed Jan 2015.

51.

Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation. Scottish Government. Available at: www.scotland.gov.uk/Topics/Statistics/SIMD/Overview. Accessed Jan 2015.

52.

Statement of Dental Remuneration. Available at: www.psd.scot.nhs.uk/professionals/dental/Amendment-no-122-to-the-SDR_000.pdf. Accessed Jan 2015.

53.

General Dental Council (GDC). Standards for Dental Professionals. Principles of Patient Consent. 2006. Available at: www.gdc-uk.org/News+publications+and+events/Publications/Guidance+documents. Accessed Jan 2015.

54.

Sheiham

, Alexander

, Cohen

, Marinho

, Moyses

, Petersen

, Spencer

, Watt

, Weyant

Global oral health inequalities: task group - implementation and delivery of oral health strategies. Adv Dent Res 2011;23(2):259–67.

55.

Pitts

, Amaechi

, Niederman

, Acevedo

, Vianna

, Ganss

, Ismail

, Honkala

Global oral health inequalities: dental caries task group - research agenda. Adv Dent Res 2011;23(2):211–20.

56.

Beck

. Risk revisited. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1998;26:220–5.

57.

Keyes

. The infectious and transmissible nature of experimental dental caries. Arch Oral Biol 1960;1:304–320.

58.

National Institutes of Health (NIH). Diagnosis and management of dental caries throughout life. Bethesuda Md; National Institute of Health Consensus Conference statement 2001. J Dent Educ 2001;65:1162–8.

59.

Yip

, Smales

Oral diagnosis and treatment planning: part 2. Dental caries and assessment of risk. Br Dent J 2012;213:59–66.

60.

Yip

, Smales

Oral diagnosis and treatment planning:part 5. Preventive and treatment planning for dental caries. Br Dent J 2012;2213:211–220.

61.

Fontana

, Gonzalez-Cabezas

Minimal intervention dentistry: part 2. Caries risk assessment in adults. Br Dent J 2012;213:447–51.

62.

Bader

, Shugars

. What do we know about how dentists make caries related treatment decisions? Comm Dent Oral Epidemiol 1997;25(1):97–103.

63.

Pitts

, Melo

, Martignon

, Ekstrand

, Ismail

Caries risk assessment, diagnosis and synthesis in the context of a European Core Curriculum in Cariology. Eu J Den Ed 2011;15:23–31.

64.

Yoon

, Smaldone

, Edelstein

. Early Childhood Screening Tools: A Comparison of four approaches. J Am Dent Assoc 2012;143(7):756–63.

65.

Keightley

, Lucey

, Leitch

, Lloyd

, Campbell

A pilot improvement project in hospital-based oral health care: Improving caries risk assessment documentation. Brit Dent J 2012;(2):E3.

66.

Macritchie

, Longbottom

, Robertson

, Nugent

, Chan

, Radford

, Pitts

. Development of the Dundee Caries Risk Assesssment Model (DCRAM) - risk model development using a novel application of CHAID analysis. Comm Dent Oral Epidemiol 2012;40(1):37–45.

67.

Jenson

, Budenz

, Featherstone

. Clinical protocols for caries management by risk assessment. CDA Journal 2007;35:714–23.

68.

Ramos-Gomez

, Crystal

, Ng

. Pediatric dental care: prevention and management protocols based on caries risk assessment. CDA Journal 2010;38:746–61.

69.

Ramos-Gomez

, Crall

, Gansky

, Slayton

, Featherstone

. Caries risk assessment appropriate for the age 1 visit (infants and toddlers). CDA Journal 2007;35:687–702.

70.

Young

, Lyon

, Azevedo

The role of dental hygiene in caries management: a new paradigm. J Dent Hyg 2010;84:121–9.

71.

Young

, Featherstone

. Implementing caries risk assessment and clinical interventions. Dent Clin N Am 2010;54:495–505.

72.

Domejean

, White

, Featherstone

Validation of the CDA CAMBRA caries risk assessment – a 6 year retrospective study. CDA Journal 2011;39:709–15.

73.

Hansel

Petersson G

, Isberg

P-E

, Twetman

Caries risk assessment in school children using a reduced Cariogram model without saliva tests. BMC Oral Health 2010;10:5.

74.

Hansel

Petersson G

, Twetman

, Bratthall

Evaluation of a computer based program for caries risk assessment in schoolchildren. Caries Res 2002;36:327–40.

75.

Hansel

Petersson G

, Isberg

P-E

, Twetman

Caries risk profiles in schoolchildren over 2 years assessed by Cariogram. Int J Paediatr Dent 2010;20:341–6.

76.

Hansel

Petersson G

, Fure

, Bratthall

Evaluation of a computer based caries risk assessment program in an elderly group of individuals. Acta Odontol Scand 2003;61:164–71.

77.

Holgerson

, Twetman

, Stecksen-Blicks

Validation of an age-modified caries risk assessment program (Cariogram) in preschool children. Acta Odont Scand 2009;67:106–12.

78.

Gao

, Hsu

, Xu

, Hwarng

, Loh

, Koh

Building caries risk assessment models for children. J Dent Res 2010;89:637–43.

79.

Fontana

, Zero

Assessing patients caries risk. JADA 2006;137(9):1231–9.

80.

Disney

, Graves

, Stamm

, Bohannan

, Abernathy

, Zack

. The University of North Carolina Caries Risk Assessment study: further developments in caries risk prediction. Comm Dent Oral Epidemiol 1992;20:64–75.

81.

Tickle

, Milson

The whole population approach to caries prevention in general dental practice. Br Dent J 2008;205:521.

82.

Milsom

, Blinkhorn

, Tickle

The incidence of dental caries in the primary molar teeth of young children receiving national health funded dental care in the North West of England. Br Dent J 2008;205:E14.

83.

Enhanced Capitation Survey. Available at: www.shsc.scot.nhs.uk/upload/file/national_committee_services/sdpbenhanced_capitation_survey_050506.pdf. Accessed Jan 2015.