Pill Count,Self-Report,and Pharmacy Claims Data to Measure Medication Adherence in the Elderly

Abstract

OBJECTIVE:

To compare medication adherence calculated from four different data sources including a pill count and self-report obtained during a home medication history, as well as calculations based on refill frequency derived from a provincial prescription claims database (manual and electronic).

DESIGN:

Baseline medication adherence was collected as part of a prospective, randomized, controlled study. Mean medication adherence results obtained from the four data sources were compared using repeated-measures ANOVA followed by a Tukey's multiple range test.

SETTING:

A pharmacy consultation service located at an interdisciplinary wellness center for noninstitutionalized elderly.

PATIENTS:

65 years or older, noninstitutionalized, taking one or more prescribed or nonprescribed medications. Clients would either present to the wellness center or be referred by the Provincial Home Care program.

RESULTS:

When calculated from self-report or manual or electronic prescription claims data, mean percent adherence by drug was high and not statistically different (95.8% ± 17.1%, 107.6% ± 40.3%, and 94.6% ± 24.0%, respectively), whereas the pill count adherence was significantly lower at 74.0% ± 41.5% (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS:

An unexpected finding was that the pill count technique used in this study of elderly clients using chronic, repeat medications appeared to underestimate medication adherence. Numerous other limitations of pill count, self-report, and a province-wide prescription claims database in estimating medication adherence are presented. When using medication adherence as a process measure, the researcher and practitioner should be aware of the limitations unique to the data source they choose, and interpret data cautiously.

Keywords

geriatrics compliance adherence

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Coambs

Jensen

Hao Her

Ferguson

Jarry

Wong

JSW

Review of the scientific literature on the prevalence, consequences, and health costs of noncompliance and inappropriate use of prescription medication in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1995.

Mullins

Baldin

Perfetto

. What are outcomes? J Am Pharm Assoc 1996;NS36:39–49.

Rudd

. Helping patients follow the treatments you prescribed. In: Sackett

Haynes

Guyatt

Tugwell

, eds. Clinical epidemiology. A basic science for clinical medicine. 2nd ed. Toronto: Little, Brown and Company, 1991:249–61.

O'Hanrahan

O'Malley

. Compliance with drug treatment. Br Med J 1981;283:298–300.

Eraker

Kirscht

Becker

. Understanding and improving patient compliance. Ann Intern Med 1984;100:258–68.

Evans

Spelman

. The problem of non-compliance with drug therapy. Drugs 1983;25:63–76.

Stewart

. The validity of an interview to assess a patient's drug taking. Am J Prev Med 1987;3:95–100.

Fletcher

Pappius

Harper

. Measurement of medication compliance in a clinical setting: Comparison of three methods in patients prescribed digoxin. Arch Intern Med 1979;139:635–8.

Landry

Smyer

Tubman

Lago

Roberts

Simonson

. Validation of two methods of data collection of self-reported medicine use among the elderly. Gerontologist 1988;28:672–6.

10.

Pullar

Kumar

Tindall

Feely

. Time to stop counting tablets? Clin Pharmacol Ther 1989;46:163–8.

11.

Rudd

Byyny

Zachary

LoVerde

Titus

Mitchell

The natural history of medication compliance in a drug trial: Limitations of pill counts. Clin Pharmacol Ther 1989;46:169–76.

12.

Spilker

. Methods of assessing and improving patient compliance in clinical trials. In: Cramer

Spilker

, eds. Patient compliance in medical practice and clinical trials. New York: Raven Press, 1991:37–56.

13.

Cramer

Mattson

Prevey

Scheyer

Ouellette

. How often is medication taken as prescribed? A novel assessment technique. JAMA 1989;261:3273–7.

14.

Kruse

Koch-Gwinner

Nikolaus

Oster

Schlierf

Weber

. Measurement of drug compliance by continuous electronic monitoring: A pilot study in elderly patients discharged from hospital. J Am Geriatr Soc 1992;40:1151–5.

15.

Matsuyama

Mason

Jue

. Pharmacists' interventions using an electronic medication-event monitoring device's adherence data versus pill counts. Ann Pharmacother 1993;27:851–5.

16.

Steiner

Koepsell

Fihn

Inui

. A general method of compliance assessment using centralized pharmacy records: Description and validation. Med Care 1988;26:814–23.

17.

Farris

Kaplan

Kirking

. Examination of days supply in computerized prescription claims. J Pharmacoepidemiol 1994;3:63–76.

18.

Strom

Carson

. Use of automated databases for pharmacoepidemiology research. Epidemiol Rev 1990;12:87–107.

19.

Williamson

Grymonpre

. A comprehensive pharmaceutical care model: the Pharmacy Resource Centre for Noninstitutionalized Elderly. Communication 1994;July/August:26–9.

20.

Shimp

Glazer

Reinke

Ascione

Pegs

Reinhardt

. A systematic approach to identifying and reducing medication-related problems in family practice patients. Fam Pract Res J 1986;5:247–54.

21.

Drug Programs Information Network Pharmacy Manual. Winnipeg: Manitoba Health Services, May 31, 1994.

22.

Statistics Analysis System. Cary, NC: SAS Institute Inc., 1988.

23.

Rudd

. In search of the gold standard for compliance measurement (editorial). Arch Intern Med 1979;139:627–8.

24.

Stephenson

Rowe

Haynes

Macharia

Leon

. Is this patient taking the treatment as prescribed? JAMA 1993;269:2779–81.

25.

Gordis

. Conceptual and methodologic problems in measuring patient compliance. In: Haynes

Taylor

Sackett

, eds. Compliance in health care. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1979:23–45.

26.

Christensen

. Drug-taking compliance: A review and synthesis. Health Serv Res 1978;Summer:171–87.

27.

Westfall

. Methods for assessing compliance. Top Clin Nurs 1986;7 (4):23–30.

28.

Stewart

Caranasos

. Medication compliance in the elderly. Med Clin North Am 1989;73:1551–63.

29.

Inui

Carter

Pecoraro

. Screening for noncompliance among patients with hypertension: Is self-report the best available measure? Med Care 1981;19:1061–4.

30.

Bradshaw

. Treating yourself. Nurs Times 1987;11:40–1.

31.

Rich

Gray

Beckham

Wittenberg

Luther

. Effect of a multidisciplinary intervention on medication compliance in elderly patients with congestive heart failure. Am J Med 1996;101:270–6.

32.

MacDonald

Phoenix

. Improving drug compliance after hospital discharge. Br Med J 1977;2:618–21.

33.

Joyner

Fikrat

Catania

. Evaluation of a medication-monitoring service for geriatric patients in a congregate housing facility. Am J Hosp Pharm 1983;40:1509–12.

34.

Sweeney

Dixon

Sutcliffe

. The impact of the clinical pharmacist on compliance in a geriatric population. Pharm J 1989;18(February):R4–6.

35.

Wong

Norman

. Evaluation of a novel medication aid, the Calendar Blister-Pak, and its effect on drug compliance in a geriatric outpatient clinic. J Am Geriatr Soc 1987;35:21–6.

36.

Ware

Holford

Davison

Harris

. Unit dose calendar packaging and elderly patient compliance. N Z Med J 1991;104:495–7.

37.

Raynor

Booth

Blenkinsopp

. Effects of computer generated reminder charts on patients' compliance with drug regimens. BMJ 1993;306:1158–61.

38.

Murray

Birt

Manatunga

Darnell

. Medication compliance in elderly outpatients using twice-daily dosing and unit-of-use packaging. Ann Pharmacother 1993;27:616–21.

39.

Pereles

Romonko

Murzyn

Hogan

Silvius

Stokes

Evaluation of a self-medication program. J Am Geriatr Soc 1996;44: 161–5.

40.

Lowe

Raynor

Courtney

Purvis

Teale

. Effects of self medication programme on knowledge of drugs and compliance with treatment in elderly patients. BMJ 1995;310:1229–31.

41.

Botelho

Dudrak

. Home assessment of adherence to long-term medication in the elderly. J Fam Pract 1992;35:61–5.

42.

Kendrick

Bayne

JRD

. Compliance with prescribed medication by elderly patients. Can Med Assoc J 1982;127:961–2.

43.

Cargill

. Medication compliance in elderly people: Influencing variables and interventions. J Adv Nurs 1992;17:422–6.

44.

Gabriel

Gagnon

Bryan

. Improved patient compliance through use of a daily drug reminder chart. Am J Public Health 1977;67:968–9.

45.

Esposito

. The effects of medication education on adherence to medication regimens in an elderly population. J Adv Nurs 1995;21:935–43.

46.

Friedman

Kazis

Jette

Smith

Stollerman

Torgerson

A telecommunications system for monitoring and counseling patients with hypertension: Impact on medication adherence and blood pressure control. Am J Hypertens 1996;9:285–92.

47.

Grymonpre

Williamson

Huynh

Desilets

. A community-based pharmaceutical care model for the elderly: Report on a pilot project. Int J Pharm Pract 1994;2:229–34.

48.

Spagnoli

Ostino

Borga

D'Ambrosio

Maggiovotti

Todisco

Drug compliance and unreported drugs in the elderly. J Am Geriatr Soc 1989;37:619–24.

49.

Murray

Darnell

Weinberger

Martz

. Factors contributing to medication noncompliance in elderly public housing tenants. Drug Intell Clin Pharm 1986;20:146–52.