Controlling the Madrinas: The Police Informer Management and Control System in Mexico

Abstract

One of the most relevant issues concerning snitching in the criminal information system of any police organisation is its control. This article analyses the different ways in which the Mexican Judicial Police exert control over their informants. Utilising a mixed qualitative methodology of research, in-depth interviews and ethnographic work, this article elaborates a taxonomy of police informant control constructed from a diverse array of particular tools, both informal (personal and impersonal) and formal (impersonal), that are determined by three variables: type of contact, personal characteristics of the informant and criminal environment.

Keywords

police informant criminal information system control

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akerström

(1989) ‘Snitches on snitching’ Society 26, 2: 22–6.

Anderson

(1999) Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner City. New York: Norton.

Asbury

(2011) ‘Anti-Snitching Norms and Community Loyalty’ Oregon Law Review 89: 1257.

Bean

Billingsley

(2001) ‘Drugs, Crime and Informers’ in Billingsley

Nemitz

Bean

(eds), Informers: Policing, Policy, Practice. Cullompton:Willan, 25–37.

Bennet

Hess

(1994) Criminal Investigation. St Paul: West Publishing.

Bernstein

S.K.

(1990) ‘Fourth Amendment: Using the Drug Courier Profile to Fight the War on Drugs’ Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 80: 996–1017.

Billingsley

(2001) ‘Informers' Careers: Motivations and Change’ in Billingsley

Nemitz

Bean

(eds), Informers: Policing, Policy, Practice. Cullompton:Willan, 81–97.

Billingsley

(2004) ‘Process Deviance and the Use of Informers: The Solution’ Police Research and Management 6(2): 67–88.

Bloom

(2002) Ratting: The Use and Abuse of Informers in the American Justice System. Westport: Praeger.

10.

Boisvert

A-M.

(2005) La protection des collaborateurs de la justice: Éléments de mise à jour de la politique québécoise. Québec: Ministère de la Sécurité Publique du Québec.

11.

Brewer

(2000) Ethnography. Buckingham: Open University Press.

12.

Brown

(1994) ‘Notes on the Culture of Prison Informing’ Current Issues in Criminal Justice 54: 5.

13.

Choo

A. L-T.

Mellors

(1995) ‘Undercover Police Operations and What the Suspect Said (Or Didn't Say)’ 2 Web JCLI. [Online] <http://webjcli.ncl.ac.uk/articles2/choo2.html> (10 August 2012).

14.

Clark

(2001) ‘Informers and Corruption’ in Billingsley

Nemitz

Bean

(eds), Informers: Policing, Policy, Practice. Cullompton:Willan, 39–49.

15.

Constitución política de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos (2009) [Political Constitution of the Mexican United States]. [Online] <http://www.ordenjuridico.gob.mx/Constitucion/cn16.pdf> (21 May 2012).

16.

Curriden

(1995) ‘The Informer Trap: Secret Threat to Justice’ National Law Journal 17: 1–4.

17.

Den Boer

(1997) Undercover Policing and Accountability from an International Perspective. Maastricht: EIPA.

18.

Dix

(1975) ‘Undercover Investigations and Police Rulemaking’ Texas Law Review 53: 203–94.

19.

Donnelly

Richard

(1951) ‘Judicial Control of Informants, Spies, Stool Pigeons, and Agent Provocateurs’ Yale LJ 60: 1091–3.

20.

Dorn

Murji

South

(1992) Traffickers: Drug Markets and Law Enforcement. London: Routledge.

21.

Duneier

(1999) Sidewalk. New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux.

22.

Dunnighan

Norris

(1996) ‘A Risky Business: The Recruitment and Running of Informers by English Police Officers’ Police Studies 19, 2: 1–25.

23.

Dunnighan

Norris

(1998) ‘Some Ethical Dilemmas in the Handling of Police Informers’ Public Money and Management 18, 1: 21–5.

24.

Ericson

(1993) Making Crime: A Study of Detective Work. Toronto: Butterworths.

25.

Ferziger

Currell

(1999) ‘Snitching for Dollars: The Economics and Public Policy of Federal Civil Bounty Programs’ University of Illinois Law Review 1141.

26.

Fijnaut

Marx

(eds) (1995) Undercover Police Surveillance in Comparative Perspective. The Hague: Kluwer.

27.

Fitzgerald

(2007) Informants and Undercover Investigations. Boca Raton: CRC Press.

28.

Frey

L.R.

Botan

C.H.

Kreps

G.L.

(2000) Investigating Communication: An Introduction to Research Methods. Needham Heights, MA: Ally & Bacon.

29.

Girodo

(1991) ‘Drug Corruption in Undercover Agents: Measuring the Risk’ Behavioral Sciences and the Law 9: 361–70.

30.

Grabosky

P.N.

(1991) Prosecutors, Informants, and the Integrity of the Criminal Justice System. Unpublished Report, Australian Institute of Criminology.

31.

Greer

(1995) Supergrasses: A Study in Anti-terrorist Law Enforcement in Northern Ireland. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

32.

Greer

(1995) ‘Towards a Sociological Model of the Police Informer’ The British Journal of Sociology 46, 3: 509–27.

33.

Grosman

(1969) The Prosecutor. Toronto: Toronto University Press.

34.

Haglund

(1990) ‘Impeaching the Underworld Informant’ Southern California Law Review 63: 1407–47.

35.

Hall

(1986) Disorganized Crime. University of Queensland Press, Brisbane.

36.

Hammersley

Atkinson

(1995) Ethnography: Principles in Practice. London: Routledge.

37.

Harney

M.L.

Cross

J.C.

(1968) The Informer in Law Enforcement. Springfield, Illinois: Thomas.

38.

Harris

(2000) ‘Testimony for Sale: The Law and Ethics of Snitches and Experts’ Pepperdine Law Review 28: 1–72.

39.

Hoffman

Riley

(1995) Domestic Terrorism: A National Assessment of State and Local Preparedness. Santa Monica: RAND.

40.

Hogg

(1987) ‘The Politics of Criminal Investigation’ in Wickham

G.'

(ed.) Social Theory and Legal Politics. Sydney:Legal Consumption Publications, 120–40.

41.

Honneth

(1994) Kampf um Anerkennung. Zur moralischen Grammatik sozialer Konflikte, Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.

42.

Hughes

(1992) ‘Agreements for Cooperation in Criminal Cases’ Vanderbilt Law Review 45: 1.

43.

Independent Commission Against Corruption (1992) Police Informants. Sidney: ICAC.

44.

Innes

Sheptycki

(2004) ‘From Detection to Disruption: Intelligence and the Changing Logic of Police Crime Control in the United Kingdom’ International Criminal Justice Review 14: 1–24.

45.

Jackson

J.A.

Fulk

(2005) ‘A Law Gone Rogue: Time to Return Fairness to the False Claims Act’ Washington Legal Foundation 20(64), December 16.

46.

Jacobs

(1993) ‘Undercover Deception Clues’ Criminology 31: 281–99.

47.

Jacobs

(1997) ‘Contingent Ties: Undercover Drugs Officer's Use of Informers’ British Journal of Sociology 48(35): 43–4.

48.

Joh

(2009) ‘Breaking the Law to Enforce It: Undercover Police Participation in Crime’ Stanford Law Review 62(155): 190–1.

49.

Karchmer

C.L.

(1977) ‘Productivity Problems in Organized Crime Enforcement’ The Police Chief 44: 28–30.

50.

Katz

(1981) ‘The Paradoxical Role of Informers within the Criminal Justice System: A Unique Perspective’ University of Dayton Law Review 7: 51–71.

51.

Katz

(1978) ‘Narcotics Investigations: Developing and Using Informers’ Police Law Quarterly 5: 5–12.

52.

Katz

(1980) Developing and Using Underworld Police Informers. National Institute of Justice, 1–37. [Online] <http://www.ncjrs.gov/App/Publications/abstract.aspx?ID=72371> (11 August 2012).

53.

Koletar

(2006) The FBI Career Guide. New York: Amacom.

54.

Lacko

(2004) La protection des témoins. Groupe de la coopération internationale, Ottawa: Ministère de la Justice du Canada.

55.

Lawler

(1986) ‘Police Informer Privilege: A Study for the Law Reform Commission of Canada’ Criminal Law Quarterly 28: 91–128.

56.

Lee

G.D.

(1993) ‘Drug Informants: Motives, Methods and Management’ FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, September: 10–15.

57.

Levinson

(1982) ‘The Hidden Costs of Infiltration’ The Hastings Center Report 12(4) (August): 29–37.

58.

Maguire

John

(1995) Intelligence, Surveillance and Informants: Integrated Approaches . Crime Detection and Prevention Series, 64. London: HOPRG.

59.

Mallory

(2000) Informants: Development and Management. Incline Village, NV: Copperhouse.

60.

Manning

P.K.

Redlinger

L.J.

(1977) ‘Invitational Edges of Corruption: Some Consequences of Narcotic Law Enforcement’, in Rock

(ed.) Drugs and Politics. London:Transaction Books, 279–310.

61.

Marx

(1974) ‘Thoughts on a Neglected Category of Social Movement Participant: The Agent Provocateur and the Informer’ American Journal of Sociology 80(2): 402–42.

62.

Marx

(1988) Undercover Police Surveillance in America. Berkeley: University of California Press.

63.

Marx

(1992) ‘When the Guards Guard Themselves: Undercover Tactics Turned Inward’ Policing and Society 2: 151–72.

64.

McAdams

(1995) ‘The Political Economy of Entrapment’ The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 96, 1: 107–85.

65.

McCabe

R.J.

(1989) Procedures to be Adopted for Management, Control and Evaluation of Sources of Information. Unpublished report, October.

66.

Meares

Kahan

(1998) ‘Law and (Norms of) Order in the Inner City’ Law and Society Review 32: 805.

67.

Miles

M.B.

Huberman

A.M.

(1994) Qualitative Data Analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

68.

Miller

G.I.

(1987) ‘Observations on Police Undercover Work’ Criminology 25: 27–46.

69.

Mount

H.A.

(1990) ‘Criminal Informants: An Administrator's Dream or Nightmare’ FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, December, 12–16.

70.

Natapoff

(2004) ‘Snitching: The Institutional and Communal Consequences’ University of Cincinnati Law Review 73: 644–703.

71.

National Crime Authority (1992) Policy and Procedures Manual, Volume 2. Chapter 14. Informant Management. Unpublished.

72.

Newman

(1999) No Shame in my Game: The Working Poor in the Inner City. New York: Knopf & Sage Foundation.

73.

Nugent

Leahy

Connors

(1991) Managing Confidential Informants. Monograph, Bureau of Justice Assistance.

74.

Oscapella

(1980) ‘A Study of Informers in England’ Criminal Law Review, 136–46.

75.

Parker

(1986) ‘Confidential Informers and the Truth Finding Functions’ Cooley Law Review 4: 565–73.

76.

Pfuhl

Jr. (1992) ‘Crimestoppers: The Legitimation of Snitching’ Justice Quarterly 9(3): 505–28.

77.

Progrebin

Poole

(1993) ‘Vice Isn't Nice: A Look at the Effects of Working Undercover’ Journal of Criminal Justice 21: 383–94.

78.

Reuter

(1983) ‘Licensing Criminals: Police and Informants’ in Caplan

G.M.

(ed.) ABSCAM Ethics: Moral Issues and Deception in Law Enforcement. Cambridge, MA:Ballinger, 100–17.

79.

Rich

(2010) ‘Coerced Informants and Thirteenth Amendment Limitations on the Police-Informant Relationship’ Santa Clara Law Review 50(681): 689–90.

80.

Rich

(2012) ‘Brass Rings and Red-Headed Stepchildren: Protecting Active Criminal Informants’ ExpressO. [Online] <http://works.bepress.com/michael_rich/2> (1 December 2012).

81.

Rich

(2012) ‘Lessons of Disloyalty in the World of Criminal Informants’ American Criminal Law Review 49 (forthcoming 2012). [Online] <http://ssrn.com/abstract=1722597> (1 December 2012).

82.

Rosenfeld

Jacobs

B.A.

Wright

(2003) ‘Snitching and the Code of the Street’ The British Journal of Criminology 43: 291–309.

83.

Ross

(2004) ‘Impediments to Transnational Cooperation in Undercover Policing: A Comparative Study of the United States and Italy’ The American Journal of Comparative Law 52(3): 569–623.

84.

Salvador

Bell

Anderson

(1999) ‘Design Ethnography’ Design Management Journal 10(4): 35–41.

85.

Schliefman

(1988) Undercover Agents in the Russian Revolutionary Movement: The SR Party, 1902–1914. London: Macmillan.

86.

Schuberg

(1992) Maintaining Integrity in Police Informant Management . Policy paper presented at Australian Police Staff College, 16th Senior Police Executive Officers Course, 17 August–25 September.

87.

Settle

(1995) Police Informers: Negotiation and Power. Leichhardt: The Federation Press.

88.

Simons

(2003) ‘Retribution for Rats: Cooperation, Punishment and Atonement’ Vanderbilt Law Review 1(56): 28–9.

89.

Skolnick

J.H.

(1975) Justice Without trial: Law Enforcement in a Democratic Society. New York: Wiley.

90.

Stone

(1976) ‘The Scope of the Fourth Amendment: Privacy and the Police Use of Spies, Secret Agents, and Informers’ American Bar Foundation Research Journal 4: 1193–271.

91.

Temby

(1991) Of Dogs and Do-gooders; Informants and Their Protection , Paper presented at the Electoral and Administrative Review Commission Public Seminar in Brisbane.

92.

The Attorney General's Guidelines Regarding the Use of Confidential Informers (2002) U.S. Department of Justice. [Online] <http://www.ignet.gov/pande/standards/prgexhibith.pdf> (11 August 2012).

93.

The Attorney General's Guidelines on Federal Bureau of Investigations undercover operations (2002). U.S. Department of Justice. [Online] <http://www.usdoj.gov/olp/fbiundercover.pdf> (10 August 2012).

94.

United States Sentencing Guidelines Manual. 5K 1.1 (2002) [Online] <http://www.ussc.gov/guidelin.htm> (10 August 2012).

95.

Walsh

(2000) Doing Ethnography. Seale: Clive. Weinstein, I. (1999) ‘Regulating the Market for Snitches’ Buffalo Law Review 47: 563–632.

96.

Weyrauch

(1986) ‘Gestapo Informants: Facts and Theory of Undercover Operations’ Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 24: 553–96.

97.

Williams

Guess

(1981) ‘The Informer: A Narcotics Enforcement Dilemma’ Journal of Psychoactive Drugs 13: 235–45.

98.

Williamson

Bagshaw

(2001) ‘The Ethics of Informer Handling’ in Billingsley

Nemitz

Bean

(eds), Informers: Policing, Policy, Practice. Cullompton:Willan, 50–66.

99.

Wool

(1985) ‘Police Informants in Canada: The Law and Reality’ Saskatchewan Law Review 50: 249–70.

100.

Zimmerman

(1994) ‘Toward a New Vision of Informers: A History of Abuses and Suggestions for Reform’ Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly 22(81): 93–7.