This study investigates the relationships between penality (or official approaches to punishment) and welfare thinking that emerged in Queensland in the interwar years. Penality came to focus upon concerns about gender ordering and, in particular, those conceptions of “familied” masculinity and femininity which (supposedly) enhanced human wellbeing and social stability during a time of economic and social distress. Yet while state punishment selectively sanctioned and worked towards reinforcing particular masculine and feminine constructs, the “correctional” outcomes for various categories of male and female offenders in terms of their lived experiences were very different: determined not only by gender but also along lines of age and family arrangements. Three major strands of penal philosophy — the domestic, work ethic and medical approaches — coexisted between the wars and their overlap, seen perhaps more clearly in the case of women, compounded the gendered nature of ‘penality as welfare’. Attention to specific regimes in the social history of punishment reminds us of the need to appreciate the often complex interplay between systems of punishment and welfare.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenJ. (1990). Sex and secrets: Crimes involving Australian women since 1880. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
2.
BosworthM. (1999). Engendering resistance: Agency and power in women's prisons. Aldershot: Ashgate
3.
CarrabineE.LonghurstB. (1998). Gender and prison organisation: Some comments on masculinities and prison management. Howard Journal, 37(2), 161–176.
4.
ConnellR.W. (1996). New directions in gender theory: Masculinity research, and gender politics. Ethnos, 6(4), 157–176.
5.
CostarB. (1989). Controlling the victims: The authorities and the unemployed in Queensland in the Great Depression. Labour History, 56, 1–14.
6.
DalyK. (1989). Rethinking judicial paternalism: Gender, work-family relations, and sentencing. Gender and Society, 3(1), 9–36.
7.
DanielsK. (1998). Convict women. St. Leonards, Vic: Allen & Unwin.
8.
DobashR.P.DobashR.E.GutteridgeS. (1986). The imprisonment of women. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
9.
FinnaneM. (1997). Punishment in Australian society. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
10.
FinnaneM. (1991). After the convicts: Towards a history of imprisonment in Australia. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 24(2), 105–118.
11.
FinnaneM.McGuireJ. (2001) The uses of punishment and exile: Aborigines in colonial Australia. Punishment and Society, 3(2), 279–298.
12.
ForsytheW.J. (1995). The Garland thesis and the origins of modern English prison discipline: 1835–1939. Howard Journal, 34(3), 259–273.
13.
FoucaultM. (1977). Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison. New York: Pantheon Books.
14.
FreedmanE. (1981). Their sisters' keepers: Women's prison reform in America 1830–1930. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
15.
GarlandD. (1985). Punishment and welfare: A history of penal strategies. Aldershot, UK: Gower.
16.
GarlandD. (1990). Punishment and modern society: A study in social theory. Oxford: Clarendon.
17.
GarlandD. (1995). Penal modernism and postmodernism. In BlombergT.G.CohenS.(Eds.), Punishment and control: Essays in honor of Sheldon L. Messinger (pp. 181–210). New York: Aldine De Gruyter.
18.
GartonS. (1996). The convict taint: Australia and New Zealand. In EmsleyC.KnaflaL.(Eds.), Crime history and histories of crime: Studies in the historiography of crime and criminal justice in modern history (pp. 271–290). Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press.
19.
GartonS. (1994). Sound minds and healthy bodies: Re-considering eugenics in Australia, 1914–1940. Australian Historical Studies, 26(103), 163–181.
20.
GartonS. (1986). The rise of the therapeutic state: Psychiatry and the system of criminal jurisdiction in New South Wales, 1890–1940. Australian Journal of Politics and History, 32(3), 378–388.
21.
GoodnowJ.BurnsA.RussellG. (1989). Australian families: Pictures and interpretations. In HancockK.(Ed.), Australian Society (pp. 23–43). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
22.
HudsonB. (1996). Understanding justice: An introduction to ideas, perspectives and controversies in modern penal theory. Buckingham: Open University Press.
23.
IgnatieffM. (1985). State, civil society and total institutions: A critique of recent social histories of punishment. In CohenS.ScullA.(Eds.), Social control and the state: Historical and comparative essays (pp. 75–105). Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
24.
JonesR.L. (1999). The master potter and the rejected pots: Eugenic legislation in Victoria, 1918–1939. Australian Historical Studies, 31(113), 319–342.
25.
LakeM. (1986). The politics of respectability: Identifying the masculinist context. Historical Studies, 22(86), 116–131.
26.
LynnP.ArmstrongG. (1996). From Pentonville to Pentridge: A history of prisons in Victoria. Melbourne: State Library of Victoria.
27.
MacintyreS. (1986). The Oxford history of Australia (Volume 4, 1901–41). Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
28.
McConvilleS. (1995). The Victorian Prison: England, 1865–1965. In N. Morris & D. Rothman (Eds.), The Oxford history of the prison: The practice of punishment in western society (pp. 131-167). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
29.
MukherjeeS.K. (1981). Crime trends in 20th-century Australia. Sydney: Australian Institute of Criminology, George Allen & Unwin.
30.
MukherjeeS.K.FitzgeraldR.W. (1981). The myth of rising female crime. In MukherjeeS.KScuttJ.(Eds.), Women and crime (pp. 127–166). Sydney: Australian Institute of Criminology, George Allen & Unwin.
31.
O'ConnorI. (1992). Youth, crime and justice in Queensland. Brisbane: Criminal Justice Commission.
32.
PrattJ. (1992). Punishment in a perfect society: The New Zealand penal system, 1840–1939. Wellington: Victoria University Press.
33.
PrattJ. (1997). Governing the dangerous: Dangerousness, law and social change. Sydney: Federation Press
34.
RamslandJ. (1996). With just and relentless discipline: A social history of corrective services in New South Wales. Kenthurst, NSW: Kangaroo Press.
35.
ReigerK. (1985). The disenchantment of the home: Modernizing the Australian family, 1880–1940. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
36.
ScottJ. (1993). A place in normal society: Unemployed protest in Queensland in the 1930s. Labour History, 65, 136–149.
37.
ThomasJ.StewartA. (1978). Imprisonment in Western Australia: Evolution, theory and practice. Perth: University of Western Australia Press.
38.
TochH. (1998). Hypermasculinity and prison violence. In BowkerL.(Ed.), Masculinities and violence (pp. 168–178). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
39.
WattsR. (1994). Beyond nature and nurture: Eugenics in 20th century Australian history. Australian Journal of Politics and History, 40(3), 318–334.
40.
ZednerL. (1991). Women, crime and custody in Victorian England. Oxford: Clarendon.
