Gang Rape in Sydney: Crime,the Media,Politics,Race and Sentencing

Abstract

In 2001 and 2002, print, radio and television gave extensive coverage to a series of gang rapes in Bankstown and other suburbs of south-west Sydney. The coverage attacked the laxity and inefficiency of the criminal justice system and immigration policy. It fuelled public fears about increases in crime in particular areas and fear of “ethnic gangs” and racially-motivated crime. The sentences imposed on three youths of Lebanese background in the first of these cases to be dealt with attracted widespread criticism from politicians, the media and the public because of their leniency. These events occurred at a time when issues of race were in the news as a result of the arrival of “boat people”, followed by a heightened fear of terrorism because of the events of September 11, 2001. The issue of gang rape by ethnic-minority youth resurfaced in August 2002 when a second group of offenders, again Lebanese-Australian youth, were sentenced, this time with gaol terms which for the most part were applauded for their severity. In parliament, legislation was introduced to increase penalties and political parties engaged in a pre-election law-and-order auction. These events are portrayed as an example of how a localised story about crime can become “racialised” and linked with debates about asylum-seekers and terrorism. This article attempts to draw out some of the criminal-justice issues from this story. In particular it explores some of the flaws in the sentencing process that assisted in inflaming the debate. A pedagogical role for judges is suggested in relation to the public understanding of crime and guideline judgements are recommended.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albrechtsen

Janet

. (2002, July 17). Talking race not racism. The Australian. Retrieved July 19, 2004, from http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au

Ashworth

(2000). Victims' rights, defendants' rights and criminal procedure. In Crawford

Goodey

(Eds.), Integrating a victim perspective within criminal justice. (pp. 185–204). Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.

Bloustein

Israel

(2003). Crime and the media. In Goldsmith

Israel

Daly

(Eds.), Crime and justice: An Australian textbook in criminology (2nd ed.) (pp. 39–60). Sydney, Australia: Lawbook.

Chulov

Videnieks

McIlveen

(2001, August 24). Gangrape terms “too lenient”. The Australian, p. 3.

Cohen

(1980). Folk devils and moral panics: The creation of the mods and rockers. Oxford, UK: Martin Robertson.

Collins

Noble

Poynting

Tabar

(2000). Kebabs, kids, cops & crime. Sydney, Australia: Pluto Press.

Crichton

(2002, March 14). Court slaps longer jail terms on rape gang. The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved May 26, 2003, from http://www.old.smh.com.au/news

Crichton

Kennedy

Wainwright

(2001, September 7). Ridiculously lenient jail terms for gang rapists spark appeal. The Sydney Morning Herald, p. 4.

Crichton

Stevenson

(2002, September 14). Crime and prejudice. The Sydney Morning Herald, p. 30.

10.

Cunneen

White

(2002). Juvenile justice: Youth and crime in Australia. Melbourne, Australia: Oxford University Press.

11.

Findlay

(2002, August 19). Law-and-order bandwagon leaves justice bleeding. The Australian, 2002, p. 11.

12.

Fraser

Melham

Yacoub (1997). Violence against Arab Australians. In Cuneen

Fraser

Tomsen

(Eds.), Faces of hate. (pp. 75–96). Sydney, Australia: Hawkins Press.

13.

Freiberg

(2002, August 16). Sentencing: How much is enough. The Sunday Age. Retrieved July 19, 2004, from http://theage.com.

14.

Hall

Crichter

Jefferson

Clarke

Roberts

(1978). Policing the crisis: Mugging, the state and law and order. London: Macmillan.

15.

Haslem

(2002, October 12). Gang rapes worse than murder: Judge. The Weekend Australian, p. 3.

16.

Haslem

Gerard

(2002, August 19). PM backs rape sentence. The Australian, p. 3.

17.

Hogg

Brown

(1998). Rethinking law & order. Sydney, Australia: Pluto Press.

18.

Jabbour

(2001, October). Policing partnership in a multicultural Australia: Achievements and challenges—An Australian-Arabic Perspective. Paper presented at Policing Partnerships in a Multicultural Australia: Achievements and Challenges Conference, Brisbane, Australia.

19.

Leaky boat lands 348. (2001, August 17). Daily Telegraph, p. 8.

20.

New South Wales Anti-discrimination Board. (2003). Race for the headlines. Sydney, Australia: Author.

21.

O'Malley

(2001, August 17). Military past may keep out migrants. The Sydney Morning Herald, p. 3.

22.

Manne

(2002, September 16). Open season on Muslims in the newest phobia. The Sydney Morning Herald, p. 13.

23.

O'Regan

(Executive producer). (2001, September 27). The Media Report [radio broadcast]. Radio National, ABC.

24.

Our community demands justice. (2001, August 26). The Sunday Telegraph, p. 87.

25.

Morris

(2001, August 17). Migrants to declare military experience. Daily Telegraph, p. 8.

26.

Mukherjee

(1999). Ethnicity and crime. Trends and Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice, 117.

27.

Pearson

(1983). Hooligan: A history of respectable fears. London: Macmillan Press.

28.

Penberthy

(2003, March 14). Don't hide the facts: Gang rape victims. Daily Telegraph, p. 2.

29.

Poynting

(2002a). Racism and community safety. Current Issues in Criminal Justice, 13, 328–330.

30.

Poynting

(2002b). Bin Laden in the suburbs: Attacks on Arab and Muslim Australians before and after 11 September. Current Issues in Criminal Justice, 14, 43–64.

31.

Samuels

(2002). Review of the New South Wales Director of Public Prosecutions' Policy and Guidelines for Charge Bargaining and Tendering of Agreed Facts. Retrieved July 19, 2004, from http://www.lawlink.nsw.gov.au

32.

Senate Select Committee on a Certain Maritime Incident. (2002). Report of the Committee. Retrieved July 18, 2004, from http://www.aph.gov.au/senate/committee/maritime_incident_ctte/martime/report/index.htm

33.

Sentencing Advisory Panel. (2000). Racially aggravated offences: Advice to the Court of Appeal. Retrieved July 18, 2004, from http://www.sentencing-guidelines.gov.uk

34.

Sheehan

(2001, August 29). Tolerant, multicultural Sydney can face this difficult truth. The Sydney Morning Herald, p. 20.

35.

Timeline: Asylum in Australia. (2001, 28 August). CNN.com. Retrieved June 2, 2003, from http://cnn.worldnews

36.

Toy

Knowles

(2001, August 24). Exclusive: Victim tell how rapist taunted her. The Daily Telegraph, p. 1.

37.

Thompson

(1998). Moral panics. London: Routledge.

38.

Waddington

(1986). Mugging as a moral panic: A question of proportion. British Journal of Criminology, 37, 249–259.

39.

Wakim

(1999, September). Guilty Until Proven Innocent. Paper presented at the Restoration for Victims of Crime Conference, Australian Institute of Criminology, Melbourne, Australia.

40.

Warner

(2003). The role of guideline judgments in the law and order debate in Australia. Criminal Law Journal, 27, 8–22.

41.

Warner

(2002). Sentencing review 2001–2002. Criminal Law Journal, 26, 349–352.

42.

Weatherburn

(2001). The facts on sexual assault in Bankstown. [Media release, August 22]. Sydney, Australia: New South Wales Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research.

43.

Weber

(2002, September 17). Police study race to spot criminal link. The Daily Telegraph, p. 5.

44.

Wockner

(2001, August 25). How the allegations were watered down: Clinical exercise in plea-bargaining. The Daily Telegraph, p. 4.

45.

Wockner

(2002a, March 14). Gang rape sentences are doubled. The Daily Telegraph, p. 3.

46.

Wockner

(2002b, August 16). Liar, bully, coward, callous and mean. The Daily Telegraph, p 4.