Based on an experiment among more than 2000 students in nine culturally diverse countries, this article investigates how the cultural characteristic of uncertainty avoidance moderates the impact of valence and intensity on the effectiveness of antismoking messages. The results show that adolescents with high uncertainty avoidance respond more favorably to loss-framed advertisements than to benefit-framed advertisements, whereas the opposite holds for those with low uncertainty avoidance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AakerJennifer L., and WilliamsPatti (1998), “Empathy Versus Pride: The Influence of Emotional Appeals Across Cultures,”Journal of Consumer Research, 25 (December), 241–61.
2.
Albers-MillerNancy D., and BetsyD. Gelb (1996), “Business Advertising Appeals as a Mirror of Cultural Dimensions: A Study of Eleven Countries,”Journal of Advertising, 25 (4), 57–70.
3.
AndrewsJ. Craig, RichardG. Netemeyer, BurtonScot, MobergD. Paul, and ChristiansenAnn (2004), “Understanding Adolescent Intentions to Smoke: An Examination of Relationships Among Social Influence, Prior Trial Behavior, and Antitobacco Campaign Advertising,”Journal of Marketing, 68 (July), 110–23.
4.
BagozziRichard (1981), “Evaluating Structural Equation Models with Unobservable Variables and Measurement Error: A Comment,”Journal of Marketing Research, 18 (August), 375–81.
5.
BanksS.M., SaloveyP., GreenerS., RothmanA.J., MoyerA., BauvaisJ., and EppelE. (1995), “The Effects of Message Framing on Mammography Utilization,”Health Psychology, 14 (2), 178–84.
6.
BarnumHoward (1994), “The Economic Burden of the Global Trade in Tobacco,”Tobacco Control, 3 (December), 358–61.
7.
BaumgartnerHans, and Jan-BenedictE.M. Steenkamp (2001), “Response Styles in Marketing Research: A Cross-National Investigation,”Journal of Marketing Research, 38 (May), 143–56.
8.
BienerLois, JiMing, ElizabethA. Gilpin, and AlisonB. Albers (2004), “The Impact of Emotional Tone, Message, and Broadcast Parameters in Youth Anti-Smoking Advertisements,”Journal of Health Communication, 9 (3), 259–74.
9.
BoddewynJean (1993), “Where Should Articles on the Link Between Tobacco Advertising and Consumption Be Published?”Journal of Advertising, 22 (4), 105–107.
10.
BosterFranklin J., and MongeauPaul (1984), “Fear-Arousing Persuasive Messages,” in Communications Yearbook, Vol. 8, RobertN. Bostrom, ed. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications, 330–75.
11.
BrowneMichael, and CudeckRobert (1993), “Alternative Ways in Assessing Model Fit,” in Testing Structural Equation Models, BollenKenneth, and LongScott, eds. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications, 136–62.
12.
CaillatZahna, and MuellerBarbara (1996), “The Influence of Culture on American and British Advertising: An Exploratory Comparison of Beer Advertising,”Journal of Advertising Research, 36 (3), 79–88.
13.
ChengHong, and JohnC. Schweitzer (1996), “Cultural Values Reflected in Chinese and U.S. Television Commercials,”Journal of Advertising Research, 36 (3), 27–45.
14.
ChoeMinja Kim, ThapaShyam, PodhisitaChai, RaymundoCorazon, LinHui-Sheng, and AchmadSulistina (2004), “The Teen Tobacco Epidemic in Asia: Indonesia, Nepal, Philippines, Taiwan, and Thailand,”Journal of Youth Studies, 7 (1), 73–87.
15.
CraigC.S., and DouglasS.P. (1999), International Marketing Research.New York: John Wiley & Sons.
16.
De MooijMarieke K. (1998), Global Marketing and Advertising: Understanding Cultural Paradoxes.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
17.
De MooijMarieke K., and HofstedeGeert (2002), “Convergence and Divergence in Consumer Behavior: Implications for International Retailing,”Journal of Retailing, 78 (1), 61–69.
18.
DetweilerJerusha B., BrianT. Bedell, Peter SaloveyE. Pronin, and AlexanderJ. Rothman (1999), “Message Framing and Sunscreen Use: Gain-Framed Messages Motivate Beach Goers,”Health Psychology, 18 (2), 189–96.
19.
DouglasS.P., and NijssenE.J. (2003), “On the Use of ‘Borrowed’ Scales in Cross-National Research,”International Marketing Review, 20 (6), 621–42.
20.
European Commission (2004), “EU Fight Against Tobacco Continues with Graphic Picture Warnings and 72 Million Media Campaigns,” (accessed November 15, 2005), [available at http://www.europa.eu.int/comm/health/index_en.htm].
21.
FarrellyMatthew C., CherylG. Healton, KevinC. Davis, MesseriPeter, JamesC. Hersey, and Lyndon HavilandM. (2002), “Getting to the Truth: Evaluating National Tobacco Countermarketing Campaigns,”American Journal of Public Health, 92 (6), 901–907.
22.
FriedK., and LevyD.T. (2002), “Reductions in Smoking Prevalence and Cigarette Consumption Associated with Mass-Media Campaigns,”Health Education Research, 17 (1), 85–98.
23.
GerbingDavid, and AndersonJames (1988), “An Updated Paradigm for Scale Development Incorporating Unidimensionality and Its Assessment,”Journal of Marketing Research, 25 (May), 186–92.
24.
GoldmanLisa K., and StantonA. Glantz (1998), “Evaluation of Antismoking Advertising Campaigns,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 279 (10), 772–77.
25.
HaleJerold L., and DillardJames Price (1995), “Fear Appeals in Health Promotion Campaigns,” in Designing Health Messages, MaibachE., and ParrottR.L., eds. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 65–80.
26.
HanSang-Pil, and ShavittSharon (1994), “Persuasion and Culture: Advertising Appeals in Individualistic and Collectivistic Countries,”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 30 (4), 326–50.
27.
HastingsGerard B., and PhilipP. Aitken (1995), “Tobacco Advertising and Children Smoking: A Review of the Evidence,”European Journal of Marketing, 29 (11), 6–17.
28.
HoekenHans, van den BrandtCorine, CrijnsRogier, DominguezNúria, HendriksBerna, PlankenBrigitte, and StarrenMarianne (2003), “International Advertising in Western Europe: Should Differences in Uncertainty Avoidance Be Considered When Advertising in Belgium, France, the Netherlands and Spain?”Journal of Business Communication, 40 (3), 195–218.
29.
HofstedeGeert (2001), Culture's Consequences: Comparing Values, Behaviors, Institutions, and Organizations Across Nations, 2d ed.New York: McGraw-Hill.
30.
HornJohn (1991), “Comments on ‘Issues in Factorial Invariance,'” in Best Methods for the Analysis of Change, CollinsLinda, and HornJohn, eds. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 114–25.
31.
HornJohn, McArdleJack, and MasonRalph (1983), “When Is Invariance Not Invariant: A Practical Scientist's Look at the Ethereal Concept of Factor Invariance,”The Southern Psychologist, 1 (Summer-Fall), 179–88.
32.
JöreskogKarl, and SörbomDag (1993), LISREL 8: Structural Equation Modeling with the SIMPLIS Command Language.Chicago: Scientific Software.
33.
JöreskogKarl, SörbomDag, duToitStephen, and duToitMathilda (2001), LISREL 8: New Statistical Features.Chicago: Scientific Software.
34.
KangH.Y., KimH.J., ParkT.K., JeeS.H., NamC.M., and ParkH.W. (2003), “Economic Burden of Smoking in Korea,”Tobacco Control, 12 (March), 37–44.
35.
KingKaren Whitehill, and ReidLeonard (1989), “Fear Arousing Anti-Drinking and Driving PSAs: Do Physical Injury Threats Influence Young Adults?”Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 12 (1), 155–76.
36.
LarocheMichel, ToffoliRoy, ZhangQuihong, and PonsFrank (2001), “A Cross-Cultural Study of the Persuasive Effect of Fear Appeal Messages in Cigarette Advertising: China and Canada,”International Journal of Advertising, 20 (3), 297–317.
37.
LarocheMichel, UeltschyLinda, AbeShuzo, ClevelandMark, and YannopoulosPeter (2004), “Service Quality Perceptions and Customer Satisfaction: Evaluating the Role of Culture,”Journal of International Marketing, 12 (3), 58–85.
38.
LevinIrwin P., and GaryJ. Gaeth (1988), “Framing of Attribute Information Before and After Consuming the Product,”Journal of Consumer Research, 15 (December), 374–78.
39.
LevittTheodore (1983), “The Globalization of Markets,”Harvard Business Review, 61 (May-June), 92–102.
40.
LichtensteinDonald, RidgwayNancy, and NetemeyerRichard (1992), “Price Perceptions and Consumer Shopping Behavior: A Field Study,”Journal of Marketing Research, 30 (May), 234–45.
41.
MaheswaranDurairaj, and Meyers-LevyJoan (1990), “The Influence of Message Framing and Issue Involvement,”Journal of Marketing Research, 27 (August), 361–67.
42.
MavondoFelix, GabbottMark, and TsarenkoYelena (2003), “Measurement Invariance of Marketing Instruments: An Implication Across Countries,”Journal of Marketing Management, 19 (5-6), 523–40.
43.
MeyerowitzBeth E., and ChaikenShelly (1987), “The Effects of Message Framing on Breast Self-Examination Attitudes, Intentions, and Behavior,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52 (March), 500–510.
44.
MitchellAndrew, and OlsonJerry (1981), “Are Product Attribute Beliefs the Only Mediator of Advertising Effects on Brand Attitude?”Journal of Marketing Research, 13 (August), 318–32.
45.
NeuwirthKurt, DunwoodySharon, and GriffinRobert (2000), “Protection Motivation and Risk Communication,”Risk Analysis, 20 (5), 721–34.
46.
PechmannCornelia, and SusanJ. Knight (2002), “An Experimental Investigation of the Joint Effects of Advertising and Peers on Adolescents’ Beliefs and Intentions About Cigarette Consumption,”Journal of Consumer Research, 29 (June), 5–19.
47.
PechmannCornelia, and RatneshwarS. (1994), “The Effects of Antismoking and Cigarette Advertising on Young Adolescents’ Perceptions of Peers Who Smoke,”Journal of Consumer Research, 21 (September), 236–51.
48.
PechmannCornelia, and ShihChuan-Fong (1999), “Smoking Scenes in Movies and Antismoking Advertisements Before Movies: Effects on Youth,”Journal of Marketing, 63 (July), 1–13.
49.
PechmannCornelia, ZhaoGuangzhi, MarvinE. Goldberg, and ReiblingEllen Thomas (2003), “What to Convey in Antismoking Advertisements for Adolescents: The Use of Protection Motivation Theory to Identify Effective Message Themes,”Journal of Marketing, 67 (April), 1–18.
50.
PierceJohn P., WonS. Choi, ElizabethA. Gilpin, ArthurJ. Farkas, and RobertK. Merritt (1996), “Validation of Susceptibility as a Predictor of Which Adolescents Take Up Smoking in the United States,”Health Psychology, 15 (5), 355–61.
51.
PollayRichard W. (1995), “Targeting Tactics in Selling Smoke: Youthful Aspects of 20th Century Cigarette Advertising,”Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, 3 (1), 1–22.
52.
PollayRichard W., SiddarthS., SiegelMichael, HaddixAnne, RobertK. Merritt, GaryA. Giovino, and MichaelP. Eriksen (1996), “The Last Straw? Cigarette Advertising and Realized Market Shares Among Youths and Adults,”Journal of Marketing, 60 (April), 1–16.
53.
RobbersonMargaret R., and RonaldW. Rogers (1988), “Beyond Fear Appeals: Negative and Positive Persuasive Appeals to Health and Self-Esteem,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 18 (3), 277–87.
54.
RogersRonald W. (1983), “Cognitive and Physiological Process in Fear Appeals and Attitude Change: A Revised Theory of Protection Motivation,” in Social Psychophysiology: A Source Book, CacioppoJohn, and PettyRichard, eds. New York: Guilford Press, 153–76.
55.
RotfeldHerbert J. (1988), “Fear Appeals and Persuasion: Assumptions and Errors in Advertising Research,”Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 11 (1), 21–40.
56.
RothmanAlexander J., StevenC. Martino, BrianT. Bedell, JerushaB. Detweiler, and SaloveyPeter (1999), “The Systematic Influence of Gain- and Loss-Framed Messages on Interest in and Use of Different Types of Health Behavior,”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 25 (11), 1355–69.
57.
RothmanAlexander J., and SaloveyPeter (1997), “Shaping Perceptions to Motivate Healthy Behavior: The Role of Message Framing,”Psychological Bulletin, 121 (1), 3–19.
58.
SchoenbachlerDenise, and WhittlerTommy (1996), “Adolescent Processing of Social and Physical Threat Communications,”Journal of Advertising, 25 (4), 37–54.
59.
ShivBaba, JulieA. Edell, and JohnW. Payne (1997), “Factors Affecting the Impact of Negatively and Positively Framed Ad Messages,”Journal of Consumer Research, 24 (December), 285–94.
60.
ShivBaba, JulieA. Edell, and JohnW. Payne (2004), “Does Elaboration Increase or Decrease the Effectiveness of Negatively Versus Positively Framed Messages?”Journal of Consumer Research, 31 (June), 199–208.
61.
SmithKaren, and StuttsMary Ann (2003), “Effects of Short-Term Cosmetic Versus Long-Term Health Fear Appeals in Anti-Smoking Advertisements on the Smoking Behaviour of Adolescents,”Journal of Consumer Behaviour, 3 (2), 157–77.
62.
SteenkampJan-Benedict E.M., and BaumgartnerHans (1998), “Assessing Measurement Invariance in Cross-National Consumer Research,”Journal of Consumer Research, 25 (June), 78–90.
63.
TannerJohn F.Jr., JamesB. Hunt, and DavidR. Eppright (1991), “The Protection Motivation Model: A Normative Model of Fear Appeals,”Journal of Marketing, 55 (July), 36–45.
64.
TverskyAmos, and KahnemanDaniel (1981), “The Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of Choice,”Science, 211 (January), 453–58.
65.
WakefieldM., DurrantR., Terry-McElrathY., RuelE., BalchG., AndersonS., SzczypkaG., EmeryS., and FlayB. (2003a), “Appraisal of Anti-Smoking Advertising by Youth at Risk for Regular Smoking: A Comparative Study in the United States, Australia and Britain,”Tobacco Control, 12 (September, Supplement 2), 82–86.
66.
WakefieldM., FlayBrian, NichterMark, and GiovinoGary (2003b), “Effects of Anti-Smoking Advertising on Youth Smoking: A Review,”Journal of Health Communication, 8 (3), 229–47.
67.
World Bank (2003), “World Development Indicators,” (July), (accessed May 26, 2005), [available at http://www.worldbank.org].
68.
World Health Organization (2003), “An International Treaty for Tobacco Control,” (August 12), (accessed May 5, 2006), [available at http://www.who.int/features/2003/08/en/].
69.
World Health Organization (2005a), “Why Is Tobacco a Public Health Priority?” (accessed May 5, 2006), [available at http://www.who.int/tobacco/].
ZandpourFred, CamposVeronica, CatalanoJoelle, ChangCypress, ChoYoung Dae, HoobyarRenee, JiangShu-Fang, LinMan-Chi, MadridStan, ScheidelerHolly, and OsbornSusan Titus (1994), “Global Reach and Local Touch: Achieving Cultural Fitness in TV Advertising,”Journal of Advertising Research, 34 (September-October), 35–63.
72.
ZhangYong, and BudaRichard (1999), “Moderating Effects of Need for Cognition on Responses to Positively Versus Negatively Framed Advertising Messages,”Journal of Advertising, 28 (2), 1–15.
