This article is the first to empirically examine the effect of customer loyalty in retail price negotiations. Across three field studies and one negotiation experiment, the authors establish what they call the “loyalty–discount cycle”: in price negotiations with salespeople, loyal customers receive deeper discounts that, in turn, increase customer loyalty, resulting in a downward spiral of a company's price enforcement. The reason for the positive effect of customer loyalty on discount is twofold: (1) loyal customers demand a reward for their loyalty and invoke their elevated perceived negotiation power, and (2) to retain loyal customers, salespeople grant discounts more willingly. Furthermore, the mechanisms are moderated by the basis of a customer's loyalty (price vs. quality) and the length of the relationship between the salesperson and the customer. To escape the loyalty–discount cycle, salespeople can use functional and relational customer-oriented behaviors. The study helps managers and salespeople optimize their price enforcement and servicing of loyal customers.
AcquistiAlessandro and VarianHal R.(2005), “Conditioning Prices on Purchase History,”Marketing Science27(3), 367–81.
2.
AgrawalDeepak(1996), “Effect of Brand Loyalty on Advertising and Trade Promotions: A Game Theoretic Analysis with Empirical Evidence,”Marketing Science15(1), 86–108.
3.
AikenLeona S. and WestStephen G.(1991), Multiple Regression: Testing and Interpreting Interactions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
4.
AllenderWilliam J. and RichardsTimothy J.(2012), “Brand Loyalty and Price Promotion Strategies: An Empirical Analysis,”Journal of Retailing88(3), 323–42.
5.
AmanatullahEmily T., MorrisMichael W., and CurhanJared R.(2008), “Negotiators Who Give Too Much: Unmitigated Communion, Relational Anxieties, and Economic Costs in Distributive and Integrative Bargaining,”Journal of Personality & Social Psychology95(3), 723–38.
6.
AndersonErin and JapSandy D.(2005), “The Dark Side of Close Relationships,”MIT Sloan Management Review46(3), 76–83.
7.
AndersonEugene W. and MittalVikas(2000), “Strengthening the Satisfaction–Profit Chain,”Journal of Service Research3(2), 107–120.
8.
BagozziRichard P.(1977), “Structural Equation Models in Experimental Research,”Journal of Marketing Research14(May), 209–226.
9.
BanasiewiczAndrew D.(2013), Marketing Database Analytics: Transforming Data for Competitive Advantage. New York: Routledge.
10.
BawaKapil and ShoemakerRobert W.(1987), “The Coupon-Prone Consumer: Some Findings Based on Purchase Behavior Across Product Classes,”Journal of Marketing51(October), 99–110.
11.
Ben-YoavOrly and PruittDean G.(1984), “Resistance to Yielding and the Expectation of Cooperative Future Interaction in Negotiation,”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology20(4), 323–35.
12.
BlauPeter M.(1964), Exchange and Power in Social Life. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
13.
BolesTerry L., CrosonRachel T.A., and MurnighanJ.K.(2000), “Deception and Retribution in Repeated Ultimatum Bargaining,”Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes83(2), 235–59.
14.
BrownRobert G.(1974), “Sales Response to Promotions and Advertising,”Journal of Advertising Research14(4), 33–39.
15.
BucklinRandolph E., GuptaSunil, and SiddarthS.(1998), “Determining Segmentation in Sales Response Across Consumer Purchase Behaviors,”Journal of Marketing Research35(May), 189–97.
16.
BulkleyGeorge(1992), “The Role of Loyalty Discounts When Consumers Are Uncertain of the Value of Repeat Purchases,”International Journal of Industrial Organization10(1), 91–101.
17.
CaminalRamon and ClaiciAdina(2007), “Are Loyalty-Rewarding Pricing Schemes Anti-Competitive?”International Journal of Industrial Organization25(4), 657–74.
18.
CarmanJames M.(1970), “Correlates of Brand Loyalty: Some Positive Results,”Journal of Marketing Research7(February), 67–76.
19.
ChaudhuriArjun(1999), “The Relationship of Brand Attitudes and Brand Performance: The Role of Brand Loyalty,”Journal of Marketing Management9(3), 1–9.
20.
ChaudhuriArjun and HolbrookMorris B.(2001), “The Chain of Effects from Brand Trust and Brand Affect to Brand Performance: The Role of Brand Loyalty,”Journal of Marketing65(April), 81–93.
21.
ChenYa-Rue, MannixElizabeth A., and OkumuraTetsushi(2003), “The Importance of Who You Meet: Effects of Self-Versus Other-Concerns Among Negotiators in the United States, the People's Republic of China, and Japan,”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology39(1), 1–15.
22.
ChenYongmin and PearcyJason(2010), “Dynamic Pricing: When to Entice Brand Switching and When to Reward Consumer Loyalty,”RAND Journal of Economics41(4), 674–85.
CookKaren S. and EmersonRichard M.(1978), “Power, Equity and Commitment in Exchange Networks,”American Sociological Review43(5), 721–39.
25.
CropanzanoRussell and MitchellMarie S.(2005), “Social Exchange Theory: An Interdisciplinary Review,”Journal of Management31(6), 874–900.
26.
De WulfKristof, Odekerken-SchröderGaby, and IacobucciDawn(2001), “Investments in Consumer Relationships: A Cross-Country and Cross-Industry Exploration,”Journal of Marketing65(October), 33–50.
27.
DeneckereRaymond, KovenockDan, and LeeRobert(1992), “A Model of Price Leadership Based on Consumer Loyalty,”Journal of Industrial Economics40(2), 147–56.
28.
DickAlan S. and BasuKunal(1994), “Customer Loyalty: Toward an Integrated Conceptual Framework,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science22(2), 99–113.
29.
DowlingGrahame R. and UnclesMark(1997), “Do Customer Loyalty Programs Really Work?”MIT Sloan Management Review38(4), 71–82.
30.
DubéJean-Pierre, HitschGünter J., RossiPeter E., and VitorinoMaria A.(2008), “Category Pricing with State-Dependent Utility,”Marketing Science27(3), 417–29.
31.
EmersonRichard M.(1972), “Exchange Theory, Part I: Exchange Relations and Network Structures,”inSociological Theories in ProgressZelditchMorris and AndersonBo eds. Boston: Houghton Mifflin58–87.
32.
EmersonRichard M.(1976), “Social Exchange Theory,”Annual Review of Sociology2335–62.
33.
EmersonRichard M.(1981), “Social Exchange Theory,”inSocial Psychology: Sociological PerspectivesRosenbergMonis and TurnerRalph eds. New York: Basic Books30–65.
34.
EvanschitzkyHeiner and WunderlichMaren(2006), “An Examination of Moderator Effects in the Four-Stage Loyalty Model,”Journal of Service Research8(4), 330–45.
35.
FoaUriel G. and FoaEdna B.(1975), Resource Theory of Social Exchange. Morriston, NJ: General Learning Press.
36.
FryWilliam R., FirestoneIra J., and WilliamsDavid L.(1983), “Negotiation Process and Outcome of Stranger Dyads and Dating Couples: Do Lovers Lose?”Basic and Applied Social Psychology4(1), 1–16.
37.
GalinatWithold H. and MüllerGunther F.(1988), “Verbal Responses to Different Bargaining Strategies: A Content Analysis of Real-Life Buyer–Seller Interaction,”Journal of Applied Psychology18(2), 160–78.
38.
GelfandMichele J., BrettJeanne, GuniaBrian C., ImaiLynn, HuangTsai-Jung, and HsuBi-Fen(2013), “Toward a Culture-by-Context Perspective on Negotiation: Negotiating Teams in the United States and Taiwan,”Journal of Applied Psychology98(3), 504–513.
39.
GouldnerAlvin W.(1960), “The Norm of Reciprocity: A Preliminary Statement,”American Sociological Review25(2), 161–78.
40.
GraysonKeny and AmblerTim(1999), “The Dark Side of Long-Term Relationships in Marketing Services,”Journal of Marketing Research36(February), 132–41.
41.
GreenhalghLeonard and ChapmanDeborah I.(1998), “Negotiator Relationships: Construct Measurement, and Demonstration of Their Impact on the Process and Outcomes of Negotiation,”Group Decision and Negotiation7(6), 465–89.
42.
GreenhalghLeonard and GilkeyRoderick W.(1993), “The Effect of Relationship Orientation on Negotiators' Cognitions and Tactics,”Group Decision and Negotiation2(2), 167–86.
43.
GreenhalghLeonard, NeslinScott A., and GilkeyRoderick W.(1985), “The Effects of Negotiator Preferences, Situational Power, and Negotiator Personality on Outcomes of Business Negotiations,”Academy of Management Journal28(1), 9–33.
44.
GuadagniPeter M. and LittleJohn D.C.(2008), “A Logit Model of Brand Choice Calibrated on Scanner Data,”Marketing Science27(1), 29–48.
45.
GundlachGregory T., AchrolRavi S., and MentzerJohn T.(1995), “The Structure of Commitment in Exchange,”Journal of Marketing59(January), 78–92.
46.
GustafssonAnders, JohnsonMichael D., and RoosInger(2005), “The Effects of Customer Satisfaction, Relationship Commitment Dimensions, and Triggers on Customer Retention,”Journal of Marketing69(October), 210–18.
47.
HofstedeGeert(1991), Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind. New York: McGraw-Hill.
48.
HomansGeorge C.(1974), Social Behavior: Its Elementary Forms. New York: Taylor & Francis.
49.
HomburgChristian, MüllerMichael, and KlarmannMartin(2011), “When Does Salespeople's Customer Orientation Lead to Customer Loyalty? The Differential Effects of Relational and Functional Customer Orientation,”Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science39(6), 795–812.
50.
HüffmeierJoachim, FreundPhilipp A., ZerresAlfred, BackhausKlaus, and HertelGuido(2014), “Being Tough or Being Nice? A Meta-Analysis on the Impact of Hard- and Softline Strategies in Distributive Negotiations,”Journal of Management40(3), 866–92.
51.
HuppertzJohn W. and ArensonSidney J.(1978), “An Application of Equity Theory to Buyer–Seller Exchange Situations,”Journal of Marketing Research15(May), 250–60.
JohnsonMichael D., HerrmannAndreas, and HuberFrank(2006), “The Evolution of Loyalty Intentions,”Journal of Marketing70(April), 122–32.
54.
KalwaniManohar U. and NarayandasNarakesari(1995), “Long-Term Manufacturer–Supplier Relationships: Do They Pay Off for Supplier Firms?”Journal of Marketing59(January), 1–16.
55.
KalyanaramGurumurthy and LittleJohn D.C.(1994), “An Empirical Analysis of Latitude of Price Acceptance in Consumer Package Goods,”Journal of Consumer Research21(3), 408–418.
56.
KamakuraWagner A., MittalVikas, de RosaFernando, and MazzonJosé A.(2002), “Assessing the Service-Profit Chain,”Marketing Science21(3), 294–317.
57.
KehHean T. and PangJun(2010), “Customer Reactions to Service Separation,”Journal of Marketing74(March), 55–70.
58.
KimPeter H., PinkleyRobin L., and FragaleAlison R.(2005), “Power Dynamics in Negotiation,”Academy of Management Review30(4), 799–822.
59.
KingWesley C. and HinsonThomas D.(1994), “The Influence of Sex and Equity Sensitivity on Relationship Preferences, Assessment of Opponent, and Outcomes in a Negotiation Experiment,”Journal of Management Accounting Research20(3), 605–624.
60.
KoçaşCenk and BohlmannJonathan D.(2008), “Segmented Switchers and Retailer Pricing Strategies,”Journal of Marketing72(May), 124–42.
61.
KrishnamurthiLakshman and PapatlaPurushottam(2003), “Accounting for Heterogeneity and Dynamics in the Loyalty–Price Sensitivity Relationship,”Journal of Retailing79(2), 121–35.
62.
KrishnamurthiLakshman and RajS.P.(1991), “An Empirical Analysis of the Relationship Between Brand Loyalty and Consumer Price Elasticity,”Marketing Science10(2), 172–83.
63.
KumarPiyush(1999), “The Impact of Long-Term Client Relationships on the Performance of Business Service Firms,”Journal of Service Research2(1), 4–18.
64.
LawlerEdward J. and YoonJeongkoo(1993), “Power and the Emergence of Commitment Behavior in Negotiated Exchange,”American Sociological Review58(4), 465–81.
65.
LeeDon Y.(2000), “Retail Bargaining Behaviour of American and Chinese Customers,”European Journal of Marketing34(1), 190–206.
66.
LiMin, TostLeigh P., and Wade-BenzoniKimberly(2007), “The Dynamic Interaction of Context and Negotiator Effects: A Review and Commentary on Current and Emerging Areas in Negotiation,”International Journal of Conflict Management18(3), 222–59.
67.
McCannJohn M.(1974), “Market Segment Response to the Marketing Decision Variables,”Journal of Marketing Research11(November), 399–412.
68.
MelaCarl F., GuptaSunil, and LehmannDonald R.(1997), “The Long-Term Impact of Promotion and Advertising on Consumer Brand Choice,”Journal of Marketing Research34(May), 248–61.
69.
MittalVikas and KamakuraWagner A.(2001), “Satisfaction, Repurchase Intent, and Repurchase Behavior: Investigating the Moderating Effect of Customer Characteristics,”Journal of Marketing Research38(February), 131–42.
70.
MorganNeil A. and RegoLopo L.(2006), “The Value of Different Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty Metrics in Predicting Business Performance,”Marketing Science25(5), 426–39.
71.
MuthénLinda K. and MuthénBengt O.(2010), Mplus User's Guide: Statistical Analysis with Latent Variables. Los Angeles: Muthén & Muthén.
72.
O'ConnorKathleen M., ArnoldJosh A., and BurrisEthan R.(2005), “Negotiators' Bargaining Histories and Their Effects on Future Negotiation Performance,”Journal of Applied Psychology90(2), 350–62.
73.
OliverRichard L.(1999), “Whence Consumer Loyalty?”Journal of Marketing63(October), 33–44.
74.
OliverRichard L., BalakrishnanP.V., and BarryBruce(1994), “Outcome Satisfaction in Negotiation: A Test of Expectancy Disconfirmation,”Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes60(2), 252–75.
75.
PalmatierRobert W., ScheerLisa K., and SteenkampJan-Benedict E.(2007), “Customer Loyalty to Whom? Managing the Benefits and Risks of Salesperson-Owned Loyalty,”Journal of Marketing Research44(May), 185–99.
76.
PattonCharles and BalakrishnanP.V.(2010), “The Impact of Expectation of Future Negotiation Interaction on Bargaining Processes and Outcomes,”Journal of Business Research63(8), 809–816.
77.
PodsakoffPhilip M., MacKenzieScott B., LeeJeong-Yeon, and PodsakoffNathan P.(2003), “Common Method Biases in Behavioral Research: A Critical Review of the Literature and Recommended Remedies,”Journal of Applied Psychology88(5), 879–903.
78.
PolzerJeffrey T., NealeMargaret A., and GlennPatrick O.(1993), “The Effects of Relationships and Justification in an Interdependent Allocation Task,”Group Decision and Negotiation2(2), 135–48.
79.
RajuJagmohan S., SrinivasanV., and LalRajiv(1990), “The Effects of Brand Loyalty on Competitive Price Promotional Strategies,”Management Science36(3), 276–304.
80.
RavenscroftSue P., HakaSusan F., and ChalosPeter(1993), “Bargaining Behavior in a Transfer Pricing Experiment,”Organizational Behavior & Human Decision Processes55(3), 414–43.
81.
ReichheldFrederick F.(2001), The Loyalty Effect: The Hidden Force Behind Growth, Profits, and Lasting Value. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
82.
ReichheldFrederick F. and SasserW.E.(1990), “Zero Defections: Quality Comes to Services,”Harvard Business Review68(5), 105–111.
83.
ReinartzWerner J. and KumarV.(2000), “On the Profitability of Long-Life Customers in a Noncontractual Setting: An Empirical Investigation and Implications for Marketing,”Journal of Marketing64(October), 17–35.
84.
SawyerAlan G.(1975), “Demand Artifacts in Laboratory Experiments in Consumer Research,”Journal of Consumer Research1(4), 20–30.
85.
SchneiderKenneth C., RodgersWilliam C., and BristowDennis N.(1999), “Bargaining over the Price of a Product: Delightful Anticipation or Abject Dread?”Journal of Product & Brand Management8(3), 232–43.
86.
SchroederJuliana, RisenJane, GinoFrancesca, and NortonMichael I.(2014), “Handshaking Promotes Cooperative Dealmaking,”Working Paper No. 14-117, Harvard Business School.
87.
ShafferGreg and ZhangZ.J.(2000), “Pay to Switch or Pay to Stay: Preference-Based Price Discrimination in Markets with Switching Costs,”Journal of Economics & Management Strategy9(3), 397–424.
88.
SondakHarris and MooreMarian C.(1993), “Relationship Frames and Cooperation,”Group Decision and Negotiation2(2), 103–118.
89.
SrinivasanSrini S., AndersonRolph, and PonnavoluKishore(2002), “Customer Loyalty in E-Commerce: An Exploration of Its Antecedents and Consequences,”Journal of Retailing78(1), 41–50.
90.
TellisGerard J. and ZufrydenFred S.(1995), “Tackling the Retailer Decision Maze: Which Brands to Discount, How Much, When and Why?”Marketing Science14(3), 271–99.
91.
ThompsonLeigh and DeHarpportTerri(1998), “Relationships, Goal Incompatibility, and Communal Orientation in Negotiations,”Basic and Applied Social Psychology20(1), 33–44.
92.
Van KleefGerben A., De DreuCarsten K.W., PietroniDavide, and MansteadAntony S.R.(2006), “Power and Emotion in Negotiation: Power Moderates the Interpersonal Effects of Anger and Happiness on Concession Making,”European Journal of Social Psychology36(4), 557–81.
93.
WebsterFrederick E.(1965), “The ‘Deal-Prone’ Consumer,”Journal of Marketing Research2(May), 186–89.
94.
WernerfeltBirger(1986), “A Special Case of Dynamic Pricing Policy,”Management Science32(12), 1562–66.
95.
WernerfeltBirger(1991), “Brand Loyalty and Market Equilibrium,”Marketing Science10(3), 229–45.
96.
YamagishiToshio and YamagishiMidori(1994), “Trust and Commitment in the United States and Japan,”Motivation and Emotion18(2), 129–66.
97.
ZeithamlValarie A., BerryLeonard L., and ParasuramanA.(1996), “The Behavioral Consequences of Service Quality,”Journal of Marketing60(April), 31–46.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
