Effects of Air Traffic Geometry on Pilots' Conflict Detection With Cockpit Display of Traffic Information

Abstract

Objective: This experiment attempted to identify the features of air traffic geometry that would influence the difficulty and biases of pilots' conflict detection using a cockpit display of traffic information (CDTI). Background: There was previously no systematic study on effects of such features on conflict detection using the CDTI. Method: Twenty-four pilots viewed dynamic encounters between their own aircraft and an intruder aircraft on a simulated CDTI; difficulty was varied by the intruder aircraft's distance and time to closest point of approach (CPA), relative speed, miss distance at CPA, approach side, and conflict angle. Participants estimated the intruder's location at, and its time to, CPA. Effects on three estimation error measures were explored: intruder's miss distance at CPA, orientation at CPA, and time to CPA. Results: (a) Estimation errors increased with slower speeds, longer times to CPA, and longer distances to CPA and with longer miss distances at CPA; (b) the best performance occurred at a conflict angle of 90°; (c) there was a bias to judge conflicts to be more risky than was actually the case; and (d) there was a “distance-over-speed” bias, such that two aircraft farther apart and converging rapidly were perceived as less risky than when they were closer to each other and converging at a slower rate, despite identical time to CPA. Conclusion: Pilots' conflict detection with CDTI was subject to various errors and biases, which has important safety implications. Application: The design of procedures, displays, and decision support tools for the free flight environment needs to take these human performance limitations into account.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander, A.L. , Wickens, C.D. , & Merwin, D.H. (2005). Perspective and coplanar cockpit displays of traffic information: Implications for maneuver choice, flight safety, and mental workload . International Journal of Aviation Psychology, 15, 1-21.

Azen, R. , & Budescu, D.V. (2003). The dominance analysis approach for comparing predictors in multiple regression. Psychological Methods, 8, 129-148.

Behson, S.J. (2002). Which dominates? The relative importance of work-family organizational support and general organizational context on employee outcomes . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 61, 53-72.

Block, J. (1995). On the relation between IQ, impulsivity, and delinquency: Remarks on the Lynam, Moffitt, and Stouthamer-Loeber (1993) interpretation . Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 104, 395-398.

Boudes, N. , & Cellier, J.-M. (2000). Accuracy of estimations made by air traffic controllers. International Journal of Aviation Psychology, 10, 207-225.

Budescu, D.V. (1993). Dominance analysis: A new approach to the problem of relative importance of predictors in multiple regression. Psychological Bulletin, 114, 542-551.

Courville, T. , & Thompson, B. (2001). Use of structure coefficients in published multiple regression articles: β is not enough. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 61, 229-248.

Ellis, S.R. , & Palmer, E.A. (1982). Threat perception while viewing single intruder conflicts on a cockpit display of traffic information (NASA Tech. Memorandum 81341). Moffett Field, CA: NASA Ames Research Center.

Endsley, M.R. , Mogford, R.H. , & Stein, E.S. (1997). Controller situation awareness in free flight. In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 41st Annual Meeting (pp. 4-8). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors and Ergonomics Society .

10.

Federal Aviation Administration. (2000). Air traffic control (Order 7110.65M). Washington, DC: Author.

11.

Galster, S.M. , Duley, J.A. , Masalonis, A.J. , & Parasuraman, R. (2001). Air traffic controller performance and workload under mature free flight. International Journal of Aviation Psychology, 11, 71-93.

12.

Hancock, P.A. , & Manser, M.P. (1998). Time-to-contact. In A. Feyer & A. Williamson (Eds.), Occupational injuries: Risk, prevention and intervention (pp. 44-58). London : Taylor & Francis.

13.

Johnson, J.W. (2000). A heuristic method for estimating the relative weight of predictor variables in multiple regression. Multivariate Behavioral Research, 35, 1-19.

14.

Johnson, W.W. , Battiste, V. , & Bochow, S.H. (1999). A cockpit display designed to enable limited flight deck separation responsibility. In Proceedings of the 1999 World Aviation Conference (Paper No. 1999-01-5567). Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers.

15.

Johnson, W.W. , Battiste, V. , Delzell, S. , Holland, S. , Belcher, S. , & Jordan, K. (1997). Development and demonstration of a prototype free flight cockpit display of traffic information. In Proceedings of the 1997 World Aviation Congress (Paper No. 975554). Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers.

16.

Johnson, W.W. , Liao, M. , & Tse, S. (1999). Effect of symbology location and format on attentional deployment on a cockpit display of traffic information. In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 43rd Annual Meeting (pp. 1348-1357). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors and Ergonomics Society.

17.

Kahneman, D. (2003). A perspective on judgment and choice: Mapping bounded rationality. American Psychologist, 58, 697-720.

18.

Kimball, K.A. (1970). Estimation of intersection of two converging targets as a function of speed and angle of target movement. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 30, 303-310.

19.

Kimball, K.A. , Hofmann, M.A. , & Nossaman, R.O. (1973). Differential velocity and time prediction of motion. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 36, 935-945.

20.

Knecht, W.R. (2001). Effects of critical information saliency on task performance: Application of ecological information augmentation in a cockpit display of traffic information. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis.

21.

Kreifeldt, J.G. (1980). Cockpit displayed traffic information and distributed management in air traffic control. Human Factors, 22, 671-691.

22.

Law, D.J. , Pelegrino, J.W. , Mitchell, S.R. , Fischer, S.C. , McDonald, T.P. , & Hunt, E.B. (1993). Perceptual and cognitive factors governing performance in comparative arrival-time judgments. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 19, 1183-1199.

23.

Masalonis, A.J. , & Parasuraman, R. (2003). Fuzzy signal detection theory. Ergonomics, 46, 1045-1074.

24.

Merwin, D.H. , & Wickens, C.D. (1996). Evaluation of perspective and coplanar cockpit displays of traffic information (Institute of Aviation Tech. Rep. ARL-96-5/NASA-96-1) . Savoy: University of Illinois, Aviation Research Lab.

25.

Metzger, U. , & Parasuraman, R. (2001). The role of the air traffic control in future air traffic management. Human Factors, 43, 519-528.

26.

Metzger, U. , & Parasuraman, R. (2005). Automation in future air traffic management: Effects of decision aid reliability on controller performance and mental workload. Human Factors, 47, 35-49.

27.

Nickerson, C. , Schwartz, N. , Diener, E. , & Kahneman, D. (2003). Zeroing on the dark side of the American dream: A closer look at the negative consequences of the goal for financial success . Psychological Science, 14, 531-536.

28.

Palmer, E.A. , Jago, S.J. , Baty, D.L. , & O' Connor, S.L. (1980). Perception of horizontal aircraft separation on a cockpit display of traffic information. Human Factors, 22, 605-620.

29.

Palmer, E.A. , Jago, S.J. , & DuBord, M. (1981). Horizontal conflict resolution maneuvers with a cockpit display of traffic information. In Proceedings of the 17th Annual Conference on Manual Control (pp. 51-62). Pasadena, CA: Caltech JPL.

30.

Peterken, C. , Brown, B. , & Bowman, K. (1991). Predicting the future position of a moving target . Perception, 20, 5-16.

31.

Planzer, N. , & Jenny, M.T. (1995). Managing the evolution to free flight. Journal of Air Traffic Control, 37(1), 18-20.

32.

Radio Technical Commission for Aeronautics. ( 1995a). Free flight implementation (RTCATask Force 3 Rep.). Washington, DC: Author.

33.

Radio Technical Commission for Aeronautics. ( 1995b). Report of the RTCA Board of Director's Select Committee on Free Flight. Washington, DC: Author.

34.

Remington, R.W. , Johnston, J.C. , Ruthruff, E. , Gold, M. , & Romera, M. (2000). Visual search in complex displays. Human Factors, 42, 349-366.

35.

Scallen, S.F. , Smith, K. , & Hancock, P.A. (1996). Pilot actions during traffic situations in a free-flight airspace structure. In Proceedings of Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 40th Annual Meeting (pp. 111-115). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors and Ergonomics Society.

36.

Slater-Hammel, A.T. (1955). Estimation of movement as a function of the distance of movement perception and target distance. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 5, 201-204.

37.

Smith, J.D. , & Ellis, S.R. , & Lee, E.C. (1984). Perceived threat and avoidance maneuvers in response to cockpit traffic displays. Human Factors, 26, 33-48.

38.

Suh, E. , Diener, E. , Oishi, S. , & Triandis, H.C. (1998). The shifting basis of life satisfaction judgments across cultures: Emotions versus norms. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74, 482-493.

39.

Thomas, L.C. , & Rantanen, E.M. (2006). Human factors issues in implementation of advanced aviation technologies: A case of false alerts and cockpit displays of traffic information. Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science, 7, 501-523.

40.

Weinberger, T.E. (1995). Determining the relative importance of compensable factors: The application of dominance analysis to job evaluation. Compensation and Benefits Management, 11(2), 17-23.

41.

Wickens, C.D. , Gempler, K. , & Morphew, M.E. (2000). Workload and reliability of predictor displays in aircraft traffic avoidance. Transportation Human Factors , 2, 99-126.

42.

Wickens, C.D. , Helleberg, J.R. , & Xu, X. (2002). Pilot maneuver and workload in free flight. Human Factors, 44, 171-188.

43.

Wiener, E.L. (1980). Midair collisions: The accidents, the systems, and the realpolitik. Human Factors, 22, 521-533.

44.

Xu, X. (2003). Conflict detection with cockpit display of traffic information: What is it, what has been found, and what needs to be done? In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 47th Annual Meeting (pp. 194-198). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors and Ergonomics Society.

45.

Xu, X. , Rantanen, E.M. , & Huo, Y. (2006). Relative importance of conflict geometry variables in influencing pilots' conflict detection using cockpit displays of traffic information (Tech. Rep. HFD-06-02). Savoy University of Illinois.

46.

Xu, X. , Rantanen, E.M. , & Wickens, C.D. (2004). Estimation of conflict risk using cockpit displays of traffic information (Tech. Rep. AHFD-04-11/FAA-04-4). Savoy: University of Illinois, Aviation Human Factors Division.

47.

Xu, X. , Wickens, C.D. , & Rantanen, E.M. (2007). Effects of conflict alerting system reliability and task difficulty on pilots' conflict detection with cockpit display of traffic information. Ergonomics, 50, 112-130.