Are Infants with Orofacial Clefts at Risk for Insecure Mother-Child Attachments?

Abstract

Objective

Several risk factors in the early lives of children with clefts are believed to interfere with their development of secure attachments to parents; however, this possibility has rarely been studied empirically. This study compared 12- and 24-month attachment classifications of infants with cleft palate (CP), infants with cleft lip and palate (CLP), and a comparison group of unimpaired infants (COMP).

Method

Twenty-two CP infants, 24 CLP infants, and 61 matched COMP infants were assessed at 12 and 24 months of age in an urban children's hospital. At both visits, mothers and infants participated in the Strange Situation, which was videotaped and subsequently coded for patterns of attachment behavior.

Results

CP infants displayed a lower rate of 12-month attachment security than infants in the CLP or COMP groups. By 24 months, no diagnostic group differences in attachment classification were found. Stable 12- to 24-month attachment classifications were less likely in the CP group (36.3%) than in the COMP (62.3%) group. CP infants who were insecure at 12 months were more likely to become secure by 24 months than were CLP or COMP group infants.

Conclusions

In contrast to previous theory and clinical speculation, the facial appearance of infants with CLP does not appear to affect the early mother-infant relationship adversely. The infancy period is marked by attachment instability for infants with CP, who demonstrated lower-than-expected rates of security at 12 months. However, these problems resolved in nearly all cases by 24 months of age. Most infants with clefts emerged from the first 2 years of life with secure maternal attachments.

Keywords

attachment cleft lip and palate cleft palate

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ainsworth

M.D.S.

Bell

S.M.

Stayton

D.J.

. Infant-mother attachment and social development: socialization as a product of reciprocal resposiveness to signals. In: Richards

M.P.M.

, ed. The Integration of a Child Into a Social World. London: Cambridge University Press; 1974: 113–136.

Ainsworth

M.D.S.

Blehar

M.C.

Waters

Wall

. Patterns of Attachment: A Psychological Study of the Strange Situation. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum Associates; 1978.

Ainsworth

M.D.S.

Wittig

B.A.

. Attachment and exploratory behavior of one-year-olds in a strange situation. In: Foss

B.M.

, ed. Determinants of Infant Behavior IV. London: Methuen; 1969: 111–136.

Barden

R.C.

Ford

M.E.

Jensen

A.G.

Rogers-Salyer

Salyer

K.E.

. Effects of craniofacial deformity in infancy on the quality of mother-infant interactions. Child Dev. 1989; 60: 819–824.

Belsky

Campbell

S.B.

Cohn

J.F.

Moore

. Instability of infant-parent attachment security. Dev Psychol. 1996; 32: 921–924.

Belsky

Isabella

. Maternal, infant, and social-contextual determinants of attachment security. In: Belsky

Nezworski

, eds. Clinical Implications of Attachment. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 1988: 41–94.

Bretherton

. Attachment theory: retrospect and prospect. Monogr Soc Res Child Dev. 1985; 50: 3–35.

Broder

Richman

Matheson

. Learning disability, school achievement, and grade retention among children with cleft: a two-center study. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1998; 35: 127–131.

Broder

Strauss

. Self-concept of early primary school age children with visible or invisible defects. Cleft Palate J. 1989; 26: 114–117.

10.

Bus

A.S.

van IJzendoorn

M.H.

. Attachment and early reading: a longitudinal study. J Genet Psychol. 1988; 149: 199–210.

11.

Campos

J.J.

Barrett

Lamb

M.E.

Goldsmith

Stenberg

C.R.

. Socioemotional development. In: Haith

M.M.

Campos

J.J.

, eds. Handbook of Child Psychology: Vol. 2. Infancy and Developmental Psychobiology. New York: Wiley; 1983: 783–915.

12.

Crittenden

P.M.

. Social networks, quality of child rearing, and child development. Child Dev. 1985; 56: 1299–1313.

13.

Crnic

K.A.

Greenberg

M.T.

Robinson

N.M.

Ragozin

A.S.

Basham

R.B.

. Effects of stress and social support on mothers and premature and full-term infants. Child Dev. 1983; 54: 209–217.

14.

Crnic

K.A.

Greenberg

M.T.

Slough

N.M.

. Early stress and social support influence on mothers' and high-risk infants' functioning in late infancy. Infant Mental Health J. 1986; 7: 19–33.

15.

Crockenberg

S.B.

. Infant irritability, mother responsiveness, and social support influences on the security of infant-mother attachment. Child Dev. 1981; 52: 857–865.

16.

Dahllof

Ussisoo-Joandi

Idelberg

. Caries, gingivitis, and dental abnormalities in preschool children with cleft lip and/or palate. Cleft Palate J. 1989; 26: 233–237.

17.

Derijcke

Eerens

Carels

. The incidence of oral clefts: a review. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1996; 34: 488–494.

18.

Egeland

Sroufe

L.A.

. Attachment and early maltreatment. Child Dev. 1981; 52: 44–52.

19.

Eiden

R.D.

Leonard

K.E.

. Paternal alcohol use and the mother-infant relationship. Dev Psychopathol. 1996; 8: 307–323.

20.

Endriga

M.C.

Speltz

M.L.

. Face-to-face interaction between infants with orofacial clefts and their mothers. J Pediatr Psychol. 1997; 22: 439–453.

21.

Endriga

M.C.

Speltz

M.L.

Maris

C.L.

Jones

. Feeding and attachment in infants with and without orofacial clefts. Infant Behav Dev. 1998; 21: 699–712.

22.

Field

T.M.

. Early interaction of infants with craniofacial anomalies. In: Eder

R.A.

, ed. Craniofacial Anomalies: Psychological Perspectives. New York: Springer-Verlag; 1995: 99–110.

23.

Field

T.M.

Vega-Lahr

. Early interactions between infants with craniofacial anomalies and their mothers. Infant Beh Dev. 1984; 7: 527–530.

24.

Goldberg

. Risk factors in infant-mother attachment. Can J Psychol. 1988; 42: 173–188.

25.

Goldberg

Gotowiec

Simmons

R.J.

. Infant-mother attachment and behavior problems in healthy and chronically ill preschoolers. Dev Psychopathol. 1995; 7: 267–282.

26.

Goldberg

Washington

Morris

Fischer-Fay

F.A.

Simmons

R.J.

. Early diagnosed chronic illness and mother-child relationships in the first two years. Can J Psychiatry. 1990; 35: 726–733.

27.

Goossens

van IJzendoorn

Tavecchio

Kroonenberg

. Stability of attachment across time and context in a Dutch sample. Psychol Rep. 1986; 58: 23–32.

28.

Greenberg

M.T.

DeKlyen

Speltz

M.L.

Endriga

M.C.

. The role of attachment processes in externalizing psychopathology in young children. In: Atkinson

Zucker

, eds. Attachment and Psychopathology. New York: Guilford; 1997: 197–222.

29.

Greenberg

M.T.

Speltz

M.L.

. Attachment and the ontogeny of conduct problems. In: Belsky

Nezworski

, eds. Clinical Implications of Attachment. Hills-dale, NJ: Erlbaum; 1988: 177–218.

30.

Hayes

. Hearing loss in infants with craniofacial anomalies. Otolaryngology Head Neck Surg. 1994; 110: 39–45.

31.

Hollingshead

A.B.

. Four Factor Index of Social Status. New Haven, CT: Yale University; 1975.

32.

Kapp-Simon

K.A.

. Self-concept of primary-school-age children with cleft lip, cleft palate, or both. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1986; 23: 24–27.

33.

Kapp-Simon

K.A.

McGuire

D.E.

. Observed social interaction patterns in adolescents with and without craniofacial conditions. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1997; 34: 380–384.

34.

Koomen

H.M.Y.

Hoeksma

J.B.

. Development of Early Mother-Child Interaction and Attachment. Amsterdam: Pro Lingua; 1991.

35.

Lamb

M.E.

Thompson

R.A.

Gardner

Charnov

E.L.

. Infant-mother attachment: the origins and developmental significance of individual differences in Strange Situation Behavior. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum; 1985.

36.

Main

Cassidy

. Categories of response to reunion with the parent at age 6: predictable from infant attachment classifications and stable over a 1-month period. Dev Psychol. 1988; 24: 415–426.

37.

Main

Solomon

. Procedures for identifying infants as disorganized/disoriented during the Ainsworth Strange Situation. In: Greenberg

M.T.

Cicchetti

Cummings

E.M.

, eds. Attachment in the Preschool Years: Theory, Research, and Intervention. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1990: 121–160.

38.

Mangelsdorf

S.C.

Plunkett

J.W.

Dedrick

C.F.

Berlin

Meisels

S.J.

McHale

J.L.

Dichtellmiller

. Attachment security in very low birth weight infants. Dev Psychol. 1996; 32: 914–920.

39.

Marvin

R.S.

Pianta

R.C.

. Mothers' reaction to their child's diagnosis: relations with security of attachment. J Clin Child Psychol. 1996; 25: 436–445.

40.

Munro

I.R.

. A description of craniofacial anomalies: the mechanism and rationale of surgery. In: Eder

R.A.

, ed. Craniofacial Anomalies: Psychological Perspectives. New York: Springer-Verlag; 1995.

41.

Norusis

M.J.

. SPSS for Windows Base System User's Guide Release 6.0. Chicago: SPSS; 1993.

42.

Pillemer

F.G.

Cook

K.V.

. The psychosocial adjustment of pediatric craniofacial patients after surgery. Cleft Palate J. 1989; 26: 201–207.

43.

Plunkett

J.W.

Meisels

S.J.

Stiefel

G.S.

Pasick

P.L.

Roloff

D.W.

. Patterns of attachment among preterm infants of varying biological risk. J Am Acad Child Psychiatr. 1986; 25: 794–800.

44.

Pruzinsky

. Social and psychological effects of major craniofacial deformity. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1992; 29: 578–584.

45.

Richman

. Cognitive patterns and learning disabilities in cleft palate children with verbal deficits. J Speech Hear Res. 1980; 23: 447–456.

46.

Richman

L.C.

. Facial and speech relationships to behavior of children with clefts across three age levels. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1997; 34: 390–395.

47.

Richman

L.C.

Eliason

M.J.

Lindgren

S.D.

. Reading disability in children with cleft lip and/or palate. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1988; 25: 21–25.

48.

Rubin

K.H.

Lollis

S.P.

. Origins and consequences of social withdrawal. In: Belsky

Nezworski

, eds. Clinical Implications of Attachment. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum; 1988: 219–252.

49.

Rubin

K.H.

Wilkinson

. Peer rejection and social isolation in childhood: a conceptually inspired research agenda for children with craniofacial handicaps. In: Eder

R.A.

, ed. Craniofacial Anomalies: Psychological Perspectives. New York: Springer-Verlag; 1995: 158–176.

50.

Speltz

M.L.

Endriga

M.C.

Fisher

P.A.

Mason

C.A.

. Early predictors of attachment in infants with cleft lip and/or palate. Child Dev. 1997; 68: 12–25.

51.

Speltz

M.L.

Endriga

M.C.

Hill

Maris

C.L.

Jones

Omnell

M.L.

. Brief report: cognitive and psychomotor development of infants with orofacial clefts. J Pediatr Psychol. In press.

52.

Speltz

M.L.

Greenberg

M.T.

Endriga

Galbreath

. A developmental approach to the psychology of craniofacial anomalies. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1994; 31: 61–67.

53.

Speltz

M.L.

Morton

Goodell

E.W.

Clarren

S.K.

. Psychological functioning of children with craniofacial anomalies and their mothers: a follow-up from late infancy to school entry. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1993; 30: 482–489.

54.

Thompson

R.A.

Lamb

M.E.

Estes

. Harmonizing discordant notes: a reply to Waters. Child Dev. 1983; 54: 521–524.

55.

Touris

Kromelow

Harding

. Mother-firstborn attachment and the birth of a sibling. Am J Orthopsychiatry. 1995; 65: 293–297.

56.

van IJzendoorn

M.H.

Goldberg

Kroonenberg

P.M.

Frenkel

O.J.

. The relative effects of maternal and child problems on the quality of attachment: a meta-analysis of attachment in clinical samples. Child Dev. 1992; 63: 840–858.

57.

Vaughn

Egeland

Sroufe

Waters

. Individual differences in infant-mother attachment at twelve and eighteen months: stability and changes in families under stress. Child Dev. 1979; 50: 971–975.

58.

Waechter

E.H.

. Bonding problems of infants with congenital anomalies. Nurs Forum. 1977; 16: 298–319.

59.

Ward

M.J.

Kessler

D.B.

Altman

S.C.

. Infant-mother attachment in children with failure to thrive. Infant Mental Health J. 1993; 14: 208–220.

60.

Wasserman

G.A.

Allen

Solomon

C.R.

. At-risk toddlers and their mothers: the special case of physical handicaps. Child Dev. 1985; 6: 73–83.

61.

Wasserman

G.A.

Lennon

M.C.

Allen

Shilansky

. Contributors to attachment in normal and physically handicapped infants. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1987; 26: 9–15.

62.

Waters

. The reliability and stability of individual differences in infant-mother attachment. Child Dev. 1978; 49: 483–494.