In this paper, we bring structural holes theory to different cultural contexts by studying the effect of structural holes in four high-tech companies in China and assessing whether they confer the benefits to individuals occupying the brokering position in a career network that have been found in Western contexts. On the level of national culture, we propose that the typical collectivistic culture of China will dampen the effects of structural holes. On the organizational level, we propose that in organizations that foster a high-commitment culture—a culture that emphasizes mutual investment between people—the control benefits of structural holes are dissonant with the dominant spirit of cooperation, and the information benefits of structural holes cannot materialize due to the communal-sharing values in such organizations. Empirical results of network surveys confirm our hypotheses, and interview data add depth to our explanations. Brokers do not fit with the collectivistic values of China. Further, the more an organization possesses a clan-like, high-commitment culture, the more detrimental are structural holes for employees' career achievements such as salary or bonus, even after controlling for a host of other factors that may influence these career outcomes. In high commitment organizations, the “integrators” who bring people together to fill structural holes enjoy greater career benefits.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdlerP. S.KwonS.2002“Social capital: Prospects for a new concept”. Academy of Management Review, 27: 17–40.
2.
AhujaG.2000“Collaboration networks, structural holes, and innovation: A longitudinal study”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 45: 425–455.
3.
AhujaG.CoffR. W.LeeP. M.2005“Managerial foresight and attempted rent appropriation: Inside trading on knowledge of imminent breakthroughs”. Strategic Management Journal, 26: 791–808.
AppelbaumE.BaileyT.BergP.KallebergA. L.2000Manufacturing Advantage: Why High Performance Work Systems Pay Off. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
6.
ArnoldH. J.FeldmanD. C.1981“Social desirability response bias in self-report choice situations”. Academy of Management Journal, 24: 377–385.
7.
ArthurJ. B.1994“Effects of human resources systems on manufacturing performance and turnover”. Academy of Management Journal, 37: 670–687.
8.
AshforthB. E.MaelF. A.1989“Social identity theory and the organization”. Academy of Management Review, 14: 20–39.
9.
BakerG.GibbonsR.MurphyK. J.2001“Bringing the market inside the firm?”American Economic Review, 91: 212–218.
10.
BaronJ. N.KrepsD. M.1999Strategic Human Resources: Frameworks for General Managers. New York: Wiley.
11.
BeckerB. E.HuselidM. A.1998“High performance work systems and firm performance: A synthesis of research and managerial implications”. In FerrisG. R. (ed.), Research in Personnel and Human Resources Management, 16: 34–64. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
12.
BlauP.1964Exchange and Power in Social Life. New York: Free Press.
13.
BlylerM.CoffR. W.2003“Dynamic capabilities, social capital, and rent appropriation: Ties that split pies”. Strategic Management Journal, 24: 677–686.
14.
BorgattiS. P.EverettM. G.FreemanL. C.2002UCINET for Windows: Software for Social Network Analysis. Cambridge, MA: Analytic Technologies.
15.
BourdieuP.1980“Le capital social: Notes provisoires”. Actes de la Recherche en Sciences Sociales, 3: 2–3.
16.
BrassD. J.1984“Being in the right place: A structural analysis of individual influence in an organization”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 29: 518–539.
17.
BrassD. J.1995“A social network perspective on human resources management”. In FerrisG. R. (ed.), Research in Personnel and Human Resources Management, 13: 39–79. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
18.
BrassD. J.BurkhardtM. E.1993“Potential power and power use: An investigation of structure and behavior”. Academy of Management Journal, 36: 441–470.
19.
BrassD. J.ButterfieldK. D.SkaggsB. C.1998“Relationships and unethical behavior: A social network perspective”. Academy of Management Review, 23: 14–31.
20.
BurtR. S.1980“Autonomy in a social topology”. American Journal of Sociology, 85: 892–925.
21.
BurtR. S.1992Structural Holes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
22.
BurtR. S.1997“The contingency of social capital”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 42: 339–365.
23.
BurtR. S.1999“When is corporate culture a competitive asset?”Financial Times: Mastering Strategy, 1: 14–15, August 5.
24.
BurtR. S.2000“The network structure of social capital”. In SuttonR. I.StawB. M. (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, 22: 345–423. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
25.
BurtR. S.2002“Bridge decay”. Social Networks, 24: 333–363.
26.
BurtR. S.GabbayS. M.HoltG.MoranP.1994“Contingent organization as a network theory: The culture-performance contingency function”. Acta Sociologica, 37: 345–370.
27.
BurtR. S.HogarthR. M.MichaudC.2000“The social capital of French and American managers”. Organization Science, 11: 123–147.
28.
BurtR. S.JannottaJ. E.MahoneyJ. T.1998“Personality correlates of structural holes”. Social Networks, 20: 63–87.
29.
ChatmanJ. A.BarsadeS. G.1995“Personality, organizational culture, and cooperation: Evidence from a business simulation”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 40: 423–443.
30.
ChatmanJ. A.PolzerJ. T.BarsadeS. G.NealeM. A.1998“Being different yet feeling similar: The influence of demographic composition and organizational culture on work processes and outcomes”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 43: 749–780.
31.
ChenC. C.1995“New trends in rewards allocation preferences: A Sino-U.S. comparison”. Academy of Management Journal, 38: 408–428.
32.
ChenC. C.ChenX.-P.MeindlJ. R.1998“How can cooperation be fostered? The cultural effects of individualism-collectivism”. Academy of Management Review, 23: 285–304.
33.
ChenC. C.PengM.SaparitoP. A.2002“Individualism, collectivism, and opportunism: A cultural perspective on transaction cost economics”. Journal of Management, 28: 567–583.
34.
ChoiI.NisbettR. E.NorenzayanA.1999“Causal attribution across cultures: Variation and universality”. Psychological Bulletin, 125: 47–63.
35.
CoaseR. H.1937“The nature of the firm”. Economica, 4: 386–405.
36.
ColemanJ. S.1988“Social capital in the creation of human capital”. American Journal of Sociology, 94: S95–S120.
37.
ColemanJ. S.1990Foundations of Social Theory. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
38.
DeleryJ. E.DotyH. D.1996“Modes of theorizing in strategic human resources management: Tests of universalistic, contingency, and configurational performance predictions”. Academy of Management Journal, 39: 802–835.
39.
EarleyP. C.1989“Social loafing and collectivism: A comparison of the United States and the People's Republic of China”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 34: 565–581.
40.
EarleyP. C.1993“East meets West meets Mideast: Further explorations of collectivistic and individualistic work groups”. Academy of Management Journal, 36: 319–348.
41.
EarleyP. C.1994“Self or group? Cultural effects of training on self-efficacy and performance”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 39: 89–117.
42.
EtzioniA.1961A Comparative Analysis of Complex Organizations. New York: Free Press.
43.
FreemanL. C.RomneyA. K.FreemanS. C.1987“Cognitive structure and information accuracy”. American Anthropologist, 89: 310–325.
44.
FukuyamaF.1995Trust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity. New York: Free Press.
45.
GargiuloM.BenassiM.2000“Trapped in your own net: Network cohesion, structural holes, and the adaptation of social capital”. Organization Science, 11: 183–196.
46.
GerhartB.1987“The prediction of voluntary turnover using behavioral intentions, job satisfaction, and area unemployment rates”. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Academy of Management, New Orleans.
47.
GhoshalS.KorineH.SzulanskiG.1994“Interunit communication in multinational corporations”. Management Science, 40: 96–110.
48.
GhoshalS.MoranP.1996“Bad for practice: A critique of transaction cost theory”. Academy of Management Review, 21: 13–47.
49.
GuthrieD.1998“The declining significance of Guanxi in China's economic transition”. China Quarterly, no. 154: 254–282.
50.
GuthrieJ. P.2001“High-involvement work practices, turnover, and productivity: Evidence from New Zealand”. Academy of Management Journal, 44: 180–190.
51.
HansenM. T.1999“The search-transfer problem: The role of weak ties in sharing knowledge across organizational subunits”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44: 82–111.
52.
HolmstromB.MilgromP.1994“The firm as an incentive system”. American Economic Review, 84: 972–991.
53.
HuiC. H.TriandisH. C.1986“Individualism-collectivism: A study of cross-cultural researchers”. Journal of Across-culture Psychology, 17: 225–248.
54.
HuselidM. A.1995“The impact of human resource management practices on turnover, productivity, and corporate financial performance”. Academy of Management Journal, 38: 635–672.
55.
IbarraH.Smith-LovinL.1997“New directions in social network research on gender and organizational careers”. In JacksonS.CooperC. (eds.), Handbook for Future Research in Organizational Behavior: 361–383. Sussex, U.K.: Wiley.
56.
JamesL. R.1982“Aggregation bias in estimates of perceptual agreement”. Journal of Applied Psychology, 67: 219–229.
57.
JamesL. R.DemareeR. G.WolfG.1983“Estimating within-group interrater reliability with and without response bias”. Journal of Applied Psychology, 69: 85–98.
58.
KilduffM.KrackhardtD.1994“Bringing the individual back in: A structural analysis of the internal market for reputation in organizations”. Academy of Management Journal, 37: 87–108.
59.
KleinK. K.KozlowskiS. W.2000Multilevel Theory, Research, and Methods in Organizations: Foundations, Extensions, and New Directions. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
60.
KogutB.ZanderU.1992“Knowledge of the firm, combinative capability and the replication of technology”. Organization Science, 3: 383–397.
61.
KrackhardtD.1987“Cognitive social structures”. Social Networks, 9: 109–134.
62.
KrackhardtD.KilduffM.1999“Whether close or far: Social distance effects on perceived balance in friendship networks”. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76: 770–782.
63.
KrepsD. M.1990“Corporate culture and economic theory”. In AltJ.ShepsleK. (eds.), Perspectives on Positive Economics: 90–143. New York: Cambridge University Press.
64.
LawrenceP.LorschJ.1967“Differentiation and integration in complex organizations”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 121: 1–30.
65.
LepakD. P.SnellS. A.1999“The human resource architecture: Toward a theory of human capital allocation and development”. Academy of Management Review, 24: 31–48.
66.
LeungK.1987“Some determinants of reactions to procedural models for conflict resolution: A cross-national study”. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 53: 898–908.
67.
LeungK.BondM. H.1984“The impact of cultural collectivism on reward allocation”. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 47: 793–804.
68.
LeungK.WhiteS.2003The Handbook of Asian Management. Boston: Kluwer Academic.
69.
LiuL. A.FriedmanR.ChiS. C.2005“‘Ren Qing’ versus the ‘Big Five’: The role of culturally sensitive measures of individual differences in distributive negotiations”. Management and Organization Review, 1: 225–247.
70.
LuoJ.-D.2005“Particularistic trust and general trust: A network analysis in Chinese organizations”. Management and Organization Review, 1: 437–458.
71.
LuoY.2000Guanxi and Business. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing.
72.
MacDuffieJ. P.1995“Human resources bundles and manufacturing performance: Organizational logic and flexible production systems in the world auto industry”. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 48: 197–221.
73.
MarchJ. G.2005“Parochialism in the evolution of a research community: The case of organization studies”. Management and Organization Review, 1: 5–22.
74.
MarchJ. G.SimonH. A.1958Organizations. New York: Wiley.
75.
MartinJ.1992Cultures in Organizations: Three Perspectives. New York: Oxford University Press.
76.
MehraA.KilduffM.BrassD. J.2001“The social networks of high and low self-monitors: Implications for workplace performance”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 46: 121–146.
77.
MenonT.MorrisM. W.ChiuC.-Y.HongY.-Y.1999“Culture and construal of agency: Attribution to individual versus group dispositions”. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76: 701–717.
78.
MillerG. J.1992Managerial Dilemmas: The Political Economy of Hierarchy. New York: Cambridge University Press.
79.
Ministry of the Information Industry (MII)2003Statistics Report of the Information Industry in 2002. Beijing: MII.
80.
MorrisM. W.PengK.1994“Culture and cause: American and Chinese attributions for social and physical events”. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67: 949–971.
81.
NeterJ.WassermanW.KutnerM. H.1990Applied Linear Statistics Models. Homewood, IL: Irwin.
82.
ObstfeldD.2005“Social networks, the tertius iungens orientation, and involvement in innovation”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 50: 100–130.
83.
OhH.ChungM. H.LabiancaG.2004“Group social capital and group effectiveness: The role of informal socializing ties”. Academy of Management Journal, 47: 860–875.
84.
O'ReillyC. A.ChatmanJ. A.1996“Culture as social control: Corporations, cults, and commitment”. In CummingsL. L.StawB. M. (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, 18: 157–201. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
85.
OstermanP.1988Employment Futures: Reorganization, Dislocation, and Public Policy. New York: Oxford University Press.
86.
OuchiW. G.1981Theory Z. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
87.
PackardD.1995The HP Way. New York: Harper Business.
88.
PengM. W.LuY.ShenkarO.WangD. Y. L.2001“Treasure in the China house: A review of management and organizational research on Greater China”. Journal of Business Research, 52: 95–110.
89.
PfefferJ.1997New Directions for Organization Theory. New York: Oxford University Press.
90.
PodolnyJ. M.BaronJ. N.1997“Relationships and resources: Social networks and mobility in the workplace”. American Sociological Review, 62: 673–693.
91.
PodolnyJ. M.PageK. L.1998“Network forms of organization”. Annual Review of Sociology, 24: 57–76.
92.
PorterM. E.1980Competitive Strategy. New York: Free Press.
93.
PutnamR. D.1993Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
94.
ReagansR.McEvilyB.2003“Network structure and knowledge transfer: The effects of cohesion and range”. Administrative Science Quarterly, 48: 240–267.
95.
ReddingS. G.WongG.1986“The psychology of Chinese organizational behaviour”. In BondM. H. (ed.), The Psychology of the Chinese People: 267–295. London: Oxford University Press.
96.
ScarpelloV.CampbellJ. P.1983“Job satisfaction: Are all the parts there?”Personnel Psychology, 36: 577–600.
97.
ScheinE.1985Organizational Culture and Leadership. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
98.
SiebertS. E.KraimerM. L.LidenR. C.2001“A social capital theory of career success”. Academy of Management Journal, 44: 219–237.
99.
SodaG.UsaiA.ZaheerA.2004“Network memory: The influence of past and current networks on performance”. Academy of Management Journal, 47: 893–906.
100.
TrevorC. O.2001“Interactions among actual ease-of-movement determinants and job satisfaction in the prediction of voluntary turnover”. Academy of Management Journal, 44: 621–638.
101.
TriandisH. C.1989“The self and social behavior in differing cultural contexts”. Psychological Review, 96: 506–520.
102.
TriandisH. C.1995Individualism and Collectivism. Boulder, CO: West-view.
103.
TriandisH. C.GelfandM.1998“Converging measurement of horizontal and vertical individualism and collectivism”. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74: 118–128.
104.
TriceH. M.BeyerJ. M.1993The Culture of Work Organizations. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
105.
TsaiW.2001“Knowledge transfer in intra-organizational networks: Effects of network position and absorptive capacity on business unit innovation and performance”. Academy of Management Journal, 44: 996–1004.
106.
TsaiW.2002“Social structure of ‘coopetition’ within a multiunit organization: Coordination, competition, and intraorganizational knowledge sharing”. Organization Science, 13: 179–190.
107.
TsuiA. S.1997“The HR challenge in China: The importance of guanxi”. In UlrichD.LoseyM.LakeG. (eds.), Tomorrow's HR Management: 337–344. New York: Wiley.
108.
TsuiA. S.2006“Contextualization in Chinese management research”. Management and Organization Review, 2: 1–13.
109.
TsuiA. S.FarhJ. L.1997“Where guanxi matters: Relational demography and guanxi in the Chinese context”. Work and Occupations, 24: 56–79.
110.
TsuiA. S.PearceJ. L.PorterL. W.HiteJ. P.1995“Choices of employee-organization relationship: Influence of external and internal organizational factors”. In FerrisG. R. (ed.), Research in Personal and Human Resources Management, 13: 117–151. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
111.
TsuiA. S.PearceJ. L.PorterJ. W.TripoliA. M.1997“Alternative approach to the employee-organization relationship: Does investment in employees pay off?”Academy of Management Journal, 40: 1089–1121.
112.
TsuiA. S.SchoonhovenC. B.MeyerM. W.LauC. M.MilkovichG. T.2004“Organization and management in the midst of societal transformation: The People's Republic of China”. Organization Science, 15: 133–144.
113.
Van MaanenJ.KundaG.1989“Real feelings: Emotional expression and organizational culture”. In CummingsL. L.StawB. M. (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, 11: 43–103. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
114.
WalderA. G.1986Communist Neo-traditionalism: Work and Authority in Chinese Industry. Berkeley: University of California Press.
115.
WaltonR. E.1985“From control to commitment in the workplace”. Harvard Business Review, 632: 76–84.
116.
WankD. L.1996“The institutional process of market clientelism: Guanxi and private business in a south China city”. China Quarterly, no. 147: 820–838.
117.
WatsonT. J.PetreP.2000Father, Son and Co. New York: Random House.
118.
WeberE. U.AmesD. R.BlaisA.2005“‘How do I choose thee: Let me count the ways’: A textual analysis of similarities and differences in modes of decision-making in China and the United States”. Management and Organization Review, 1: 87–118.
119.
WeberE. U.HseeC. K.2000“Culture and individual judgment and decision-making”. Applied Psychology: An International Review, 49: 32–61.
120.
WilliamsonO.1975Market and Hierarchies. New York: Free Press.
121.
WilliamsonO.1985The Economic Institutions of Capitalism. New York: Free Press.
122.
WilliamsonO.1994“Transaction cost economics and organization theory”. In SmelserN. J.SwedbergR. (eds.), Handbook of Economic Sociology: 77–107. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
123.
YangM.1994Gifts, Favors, and Banquets. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
124.
YoundtM. A.SnellS. A.DeanJ. W.Jr.LepakD. V.1996“Human resource management, manufacturing strategy, and firm performance”. Academy of Management Journal, 39: 836–866.
125.
ZanderU.KogutB.1995“Knowledge and the speed of transfer and imitation of organizational capabilities: An empirical test”. Organization Science, 6: 76–92.
