This study sought to describe patterns of mental health care for depressed and suicidal geriatric patients by primary care physicians (MDs) and nurse practitioners (NPs).
Methods:
A probability sample of 300 Illinois MDs from the AMA Physician Masterfile and a national sample of 595 NPs from the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners were surveyed. Sixty-three percent of MDs and 61 percent of NPs responded regarding their approaches to assessing, treating, and referring older adult patients who were depressed or suicidal. Respondents rated their confidence in assessing and treating depression and suicidality and identified barriers to mental health treatment in a primary care setting.
Results:
Both similarities and differences were found among MDs and NPs in their patterns of managing depressed and suicidal older adults. NPs used more varied approaches in assessing, treating, and referring their geriatric patients with mental health problems. MDs relied more heavily on psychotropic medications for the treatment of depression and on psychiatrists when referring suicidal older patients. NPs were more likely than MDs to note lack of training and referral resources as barriers to treating depression of older patients. NPs rated their training in geriatric mental health more favorably than MDs.
Conclusions:
In terms of assessment of depression, preferred treatment approaches, the use of referral resources, and perceived barriers to mental health care, there appears to be a greater orientation towards a psychosocial approach among NPs. Primary care MDs and NPs often have different perspectives that in combination could enhance the mental health care of geriatric patients.
Centers for Disease Control: Suicide among older persons—United States, 1980–1992. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report1996; 45: 3–6.
2.
FriersonRL. Suicide attempts by the old and the very old. Archives of Internal Medicine1991; 151: 141–144.
3.
BharuchaAJSatlinA. Late life suicide: A review. Harvard Review of Psychiatry1997; 5: 55–65.
4.
De ShahAT. Suicide in the elderly. International Journal of Psychiatry in Clinical Practice1998; 2: 3–17.
5.
AchteK. Suicidal tendencies in the elderly. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior1988; 18: 55–65.
6.
BlazerD. Depression in the elderly. The New England Journal of Medicine1989; 320: 164–166.
7.
CapriottiT. Unrecognized depression in the elderly: A nursing assessment challenge. Medsurg Nursing1995; 4: 47–54.
8.
ConwellYDobersteinPRLynessJMMcCoyLM. Suicide and suicide prevention in primary care practices. Washington, DC, American Public Health Association, 1998.
9.
WaernMBeskowJ. Suicidal feelings in the last year of life in elderly people who commit suicide. Lancet1999; 354: 917–918.
10.
KurlowiczLH. Nursing standard of practice protocol: Depression in elderly patients. NICHE Faculty. Geriatric Nursing1997; 18: 192–200.
11.
ReynoldsCFIII. Depression in the elderly. Geriatrics1995; 50: (Suppl 1); 4–5.
12.
GarrardJRolnickSJNitzNM. Clinical detection of depression among community-based elderly people with self-reported symptoms of depression. Journal of Gerontology: Medical Sciences1998; 53A; M92–M101.
13.
GlasserMGraudalJA. Assessment and treatment of geriatric depression in primary care settings. Archives of Family Medicine1997; 6: 433–438.
14.
NCHS.Healthy People 2000 Review, PHS 98–1256, Hyattsville, MD, 1997.
15.
ShamanskySLSt. GermainL. The elderly market for nurse practitioner services. Western Journal of Nursing Research1987; 9: 87–106.
16.
MeadNBowerPGaskL. Emotional problems in primary care: What is the potential for increasing the role of nurses?Journal of Advanced Nursing1997; 26: 879–890.
17.
CallahanCMNienaberNAHendrieHCTierneyWM. Depression of elderly outpatients: Primary care physicians' attitudes and practice patterns. Journal of General Internal Medicine1992; 7: 26–31.
18.
CrawfordMJPrinceMMenezesPMannAH. The recognition and treatment of depression in older people in primary care. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry1998; 13: 172–176.
19.
JacksonRBaldwinB. Detecting depression in elderly medically ill patients: The use of the Geriatric Depression Scale compared with medical and nursing observations. Age and Ageing1993; 22: 349–353.
20.
van MarwijkHde BockGHde JongJM. Management of depression in elderly general practice patients. Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care1994; 12: 162–168.
21.
MannD. “Elderly often suffer untreated depression,”Medical Tribune, 37, p. 6, June 6, 1996.
22.
MahoneyDF. Appropriateness of geriatric prescribing decisions made by nurse practitioners and physicians. IMAGE: Journal of Nursing Scholarship1994; 22: 41–46.
23.
McDowellBJMartinDCSnustadDG. Comparison of the clinical practice of a geriatric nurse practitioner and two internists. Public Health Nursing1996; 3: 140–146.
24.
Office of Technology Assessment.Nurse practitioners, physician assistants, and certified nurse mid-wives: A policy analysis. Washington DC, 1986.
25.
RamsayJMcKenzieJFishD. Physicians and nurse practitioners: Do they provide equivalent health care?American Journal of Public Health1982; 72: 55–57.
26.
SalkeverDSSkinnerEASteinwachsDM. Episode-based efficiency comparisons for physicians and nurse practitioners. Medical Care1982; 20: 143–153.
27.
SemlaTPSchwartzAKochH. Patterns of drug prescribing. In: Van NostrandJFFurnerSESuzmanR, editors. Health data on older Americans: United States, 1992. Washington, DC, DHHS Publication PHS93–1411, 1993.
28.
American Medical Association.Physician characteristics and distribution in the US, 1996/97 Ed. Chicago, AMA, 1997.
29.
KovnerCRosenfeldP. Practice and employment trends among nurse practitioners in New York State. Journal of the New York State Nurses' Association1997; 28: 4–8.
30.
BanazakDA. Late life depression in primary care: How are we doing?General Internal Medicine1996; 11: 163–167.
31.
PearsonJLConwellYLynessJM. Late life suicide and depression in the primary care setting. New Directions in Mental Health Services1997; 76: 13–38.
32.
RoutURoutJK. Diagnosis and treatment of depression by general practitioners in England. Psychological Reports1996; 78: 516–518.
33.
Depression Guideline Panel.Depression in primary care: Detection, diagnosis, and treatment. Quick Reference Guide for Clinicians, Number 5. Rockville, MD: U.S. DHHS, Public Health Service, Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, AHCPR Publication No. 93-0552, 1993.
34.
GerberPDBarrettJBarrettJ. Recognition of depression by internists in primary care: A comparison of internists and “gold standard” psychiatric assessments. Journal of General Internal Medicine1989; 4: 7–13.
35.
CourtneyRRiceC. Investigation of nurse practitioner-patient interactions: Using the Nurse Practitioner Rating Form. Nurse Practitioner1997; 22: 46–65.
36.
ReynoldsCFIIIFrankEPerelJM. Nortriptyline and interpersonal psychotherapy as maintenance therapies for recurrent major depression: A randomized controlled trial in patients older than 59 years. JAMA1999; 281: 39–45.
37.
JesteDAlexopoulosGBartelsS. Concensus statement on the upcoming crisis in geriatric mental health. Archives of General Psychiatry1999; 56: 848–853.
38.
BadgerLW. A Case for integration of social work psychosocial services into rural primary care practice. Health and Social Work1997; 22: 20–29.
39.
AdamekMKaplanM. Firearm suicide among older men. Psychiatric Services1996; 47: 304–306.
40.
AdamekMKaplanM. The growing use of firearms by suicidal older women, 1979–1992: A research note. Suicide & Life-Threatening Behavior1996; 26: 71–78.
41.
ShahSHarrisM. A survey of general practitioners' confidence in their management of elderly patients. Australian Family Physician, 1996; 26: (Suppl. 1): S12–17.
42.
GalloJRyanSFordD. Attitudes, knowledge, and behavior of family physicians regarding depression in late life. Archives of Family Medicine1999; 8: 249–256.
43.
WeissmanMMBroadheadWEOlfsonM. A diagnostic aid for detection of DSM-IV mental disorders in primary care. General Hospital Psychiatry1998; 20: 1–11.
44.
SmithPMastersonASmithSL. Health promotion versus disease and care: Failure to establish “blissful clarity,” in British nurse education and practice, Social Science and Medicine1999; 48: 22–239.
45.
FisherS. Nursing wounds: Nurse practitioners, doctors, women patients, and the negotiation of meaning. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1995.
46.
GordonS. Life support: Three nurses on the front lines. Boston: Little, Brown, 1997.
47.
RabinowitzSKushnirTRibakJ. Developing psychosocialmindedness and sensitivity to mental health issues among primary care nurses using the Balint Group Method. Israel Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences1994; 31: 280–286.
48.
DouchertyJP. Barriers to the diagnosis of depression in primary care. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry1997; (Suppl. 1): 5–10.
49.
MillarTGoldbergDP. Link between the ability to detect and manage emotional disorders: A study of general practitioner trainees. British Journal of General Practice1991; 41: 357–359.
50.
ShaoWAWilliamsJWJrLeeS. Knowledge and attitudes about depression among non-generalists and generalists. Journal of Family Practice, 1997; 44: 145–146.
51.
US Public Health Service.The Surgeon General's call to action to prevent suicide. Washington, DC, 1999.
