The purpose of the study was to assess the feasibility of a psychiatric consultation intervention for somatizing patients in the family practice setting in terms of 1) patient compliance, 2) patient satisfaction, and 3) compliance and satisfaction of general practitioners (GPs).
Method:
In a period of nine months, forty-six patients were selected for psychiatric consultation in six solo family practices in a semi-urban area in the Netherlands. The consultation included an interview with the consulting psychiatrist, the patient, and the GP. A written summary of the consultation was provided to the GP and the patient. A booster session with a GP and psychiatrist was included to evaluate and reinforce the recommendations.
Results:
The majority of the selected patients agreed to participate after informed consent. An intervention was implemented containing interpersonal techniques, reattribution, clarification, and structuring. GP compliance with recommendations was 100 percent, patient compliance 75 percent.
Conclusion:
A standardized psychiatric consultation for somatizing patients in a family practice setting can be implemented. Several levels of implementation can be distinguished.
GoldbergD. The treatment of mental disorders in general medicine settings (editorial). General Hospital Psychiatry1992;14:83–85.
2.
VonKorffM. Case definitions in primary care, the need for clinical epidemiology (editorial). General Hospital Psychiatry1992;14:293–295.
3.
LevensonJLColendaCLarsonDBBaretaJ. Methodology in consultation-liaison research: A classification of biases. Psychosomatics1992;31:367–376.
4.
PincusHA. Patient-oriented models for linking primary care and mental health care. General Hospital Psychiatry1987;9:95–101.
5.
SmithGRRostKKashnerM. A trial of the effect of a standardized psychiatric consultation on health outcomes and costs in somatizing patients. Archives of General Psychiatry1995;52:238–243.
6.
SmithGRMonsonRARayDC. Patients with multiple unexplained symptoms, their characteristics, functional health, and health care utilization. Archives of Internal Medicine1986;14:69–72.
7.
EscobarJIBurhamMAKarnoMForsytheAGoldingJ. Somatization in the community. Archives of General Psychiatry1987;44:713–718.
8.
EscobarJIGoldingJMHoughRLKarnoMBurnamMAWellsKB. Somatization in the community; relationship to disability and use of services. American Journal of Public Health1987;77:837–840.
9.
BalintE. Symposium: Whither psychiatry in general practice? The Balint group approach. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine1979;72(6):469–471.
10.
BorusJF. The community mental health center and the private medical practitioner: A first step. Psychiatry1971;34:274–288.
11.
BorasJFCasserlyMK. Psychiatrists and primary care physicians: Collaborative learning experiences in delivering primary care. Hospital and Community Psychiatry1979;30:686–689.
12.
SmarrEPBerkowR. Teaching psychological medicine to family medicine residents. American Journal of Psychiatry1977;132:984–987.
13.
KoranjiIK. Physical health and illness in a psychiatric outpatient department population. Canadian Psychiatric Association Journal1972;17:109–117.
14.
StrainJJPincusHAGiseLHHouptJL. The role of psychiatry in the training of primary care physicians. General Hospital Psychiatry1986;8:372–385.
15.
FinkPJ. Psychiatry and the primary care physician. Hospital and Community Psychiatry1985;36:870–875.
16.
FinkPJ. The relationship of psychiatry to primary care. American Journal of Psychiatry1977;134:126–129.
17.
McMahonTGallagherRMLittleD. Psychiatry—family practice liaison: A collaborative approach to clinical training. General Hospital Psychiatry1983;5:1–6.
18.
StrathdeeG. Primary care—psychiatry interaction: A British perspective. General Hospital Psychiatry1987;9:102–110.
19.
BuisWMJ. Psychiatrische diagnostiek en advies ten dienste van de huisarts. (Psychiatric diagnosis and treatment recommendations for the general practitioner) (Academic Dissertation). Amsterdam, Uitgeverij Thesis, 1990.
20.
Van HemertAMHengeveldMWBolkJHRooijmansHGMVandenbrouckeJP. Psychiatric disorders in relation to medical illness among patients of a general medical outpatient clinic. Psychological Medicine1993;23:167–173.
21.
MeeuwesenLArrindellWAHuyseFJ. Psychometrische kwaliteiten van de symptom checklist (SCL-90) bij poliklinische patienten met buikpijn of lage rugklachten. (Psychometric aspects of the symptoms checklist (SCL-90) of outpatients with stomach ache or low back pain). Tijdschrift voor Sociale Gezondheidszorg1992;70:123–131.
22.
CaplanG. The theory and practice of mental health consultation. London: Tavistock Publications, 1970.
23.
CreedFMarksB. Liaison psychiatry in general practice: A comparison of the liaison-attachment scheme and shifted outpatient clinic models. Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners1989;39:514–517.
24.
TyrerPFergusonBWadsworthJ. Liaison psychiatry in general practice: The comprehensive collaborative model. Acta Pschiatrica Scandinavica1990;81:359–363.
25.
TyrerP. Psychiatric clinics in general practice: An extension of community care. British Journal of Psychiatry1984;145:9–14.
26.
EngelGL. The need for a new medical model: A challenge for biomedicine. Science1977;196:129–136.
27.
SchwartzMAWigginsOP. Systems and the structuring of meaning: Contribution to a biopsychosocial medicine. American Journal of Psychiatry1986;143:1213–1221.
28.
LeighHReiserMF. A systematic approach to psychiatric consultation. Journal of Psychosomatic Research1982;26:73–76.
29.
LeighHReiserMF. The patient: Biological, psychological and social dimensions of medical practice. New York: Plenum, 1985.
30.
HuyseFJ. Systematic interventions in consultation liaison psychiatry (academic dissertation). Amsterdam: Free University Press, 1989.
31.
HuyseFJStrainJJHammerJS. Systematic interventions in consultation/liaison psychiatry: Part II: Concordance. General Hospital Psychiatry1990;12:221–231.
32.
LikeRReebK. Clinical hypothesis testing in family practice: A biopsychosocial perspective. Journal of Family Practice1984;19:517–523.
33.
HavensL. Approaches to the mind. Movement of the psychiatric schools from sects toward science. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1987.
34.
KlermanGLWeissmanMMRounsavilleBJChevronES. Interpersonal psychotherapy of depression (a brief, focussed, specific strategy). Northvale, New York: Aronson, 1994.
35.
VerhaakPFMCollijnDWijkelD.van der Feltz-CornelisCMHuijseFJ. Psychiatrisch consult in de huisartspraktijk. Somatiserende patienten (Psychiatric consultation in the family practice setting. Somatizing patients). Medisch Contact1994;49:1319–1322.
36.
LyonsHA. Joint psychiatric consultations. Journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners1969;18:125–127.
37.
AschRPricJHawksG. Psychiatric outpatients' reactions to summary letters of their consultations. British Journal of Medical Psychology1991;64:3–9.
38.
SmithGRMonsonRARayDC. Psychiatric consultation in somatization disorder, a randomized control study. New England Journal of Medicine1986;314:1407–1413.
