Over the past two decades, a leading business practice has been often-repeated rounds of downsizing and restructuring (also referred to as reorganization, re-engineering, and a host of other euphemistic terms) by large private and public sector employers. Frequently associated with other practices such as outsourcing, privatization, and the increased use of temporary workers, downsizing/restructuring has increased the level of job insecurity among workers as well as leading to changes in work processes (including work intensification and multi-tasking) and management behavior. How has downsizing/restructuring and increased job insecurity affected the occupational health, safety, and well-being of workers, and what measures have employers, unions, and governments taken to address any adverse effects? The authors reviewed international studies of the occupational health and safety (OHS) effects of downsizing/restructuring and increased job insecurity undertaken over the past 20 years. After imposing quality filters, they obtained 86 studies. Analysis revealed that 73 (85%) of the studies found poorer OHS outcomes (using a range of measures). Studies were examined to see whether they provided clues as to the reasons for negative outcomes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
QuinlanM.Organisational restructuring/downsizing, OHS regulation and worker health and wellbeing. Int. J. Law Psychiatr.30:385–399, 2007.
2.
QuinlanM.MayhewC., and BohleP.The global expansion of precarious employment, work disorganization, and consequences for occupational health: A review of recent research. Int. J. Health Serv.31(2):335–414, 2001.
3.
SverkeM.HellgrenJ., and NaswallK.No security: A meta-analysis and review of job insecurity and its consequences. J. Occup. Health Psychol.7:242–264, 2002.
4.
QuinlanM., and BohleP.Under pressure, out of control, or home alone? Reviewing research and policy debates on the OHS effects of outsourcing and home-based work. Int. J. Health Serv.38(3):489–525, 2008.
5.
PlattS.PavisS., and AkramG.Changing Labour Market Conditions and Health: A Systematic Literature Review (1993–98). Report to European Foundation for the Improvement in Living and Working Conditions, Dublin, 1998.
6.
CascioW.YoungC., and MorrisJ.Financial consequences of employment-change decisions in major US corporations. Acad. Manage. J.40:1175–1189, 1997.
7.
SaidT.LouarnJ., and TremblayM.The performance effects of major workforce reductions: Longitudinal evidence from North America. Int J. Hum. Resourc. Manage.18(12):2075–2094, 2007.
8.
GilsonC.HurdF., and WagarT.Creating a concession climate: The case of serial downsizers. Int. J. Hum. Resourc. Manage.15(6):1056–1068, 2004.
9.
AmickB.Relationship of job strain and iso-strain to health status in a cohort of women in the United States. Scand. J. Work Environ. Health24(1):54–61, 1998.
10.
AmickB.Relationship between all-cause mortality and cumulative working life course psychosocial and physical exposures in the United States labour market from 1968 to 1992. Psychosom. Med.64:370–381, 2002.
11.
AriensG.BongersP., and HoogendoomW.High physical and psychological load at work and sickness absence due to neck pain. Scand. J. Work Environ. Health28(4):222–231, 2002.
12.
ArnetzB.Neuroendocrine and immunologic effects of unemployment and job insecurity. Psychother. Psychosom.55:76–80, 1991.
13.
BarlingJ., and KellowayE.Job insecurity and health: The moderating role of workplace control. Stress Med.12:253–259, 1996.
14.
BartleyM.SackerA., and ClarkeP.Employment status, employment conditions, and limiting illness: Prospective evidence from the British household panel survey 1991–2001. J. Epidemiol. Community Health58:501–506, 2004.
15.
BealeN., and NethercottS.Job-loss and family morbidity: A study of a factory closure. J. R. Coll. Gen. Pract.35:510–514, 1985.
16.
BealeN., and NethercottS.Certified sickness absence in industrial employees threatened with redundancy. BMJ296:1508–1510, 1988.
17.
BerthH.FosterP., and BrahlerE.Unemployment, job insecurity and life satisfaction: Results of a study with young adults in the new German states. Soz. Preventivmed.50:361–369, 2005.
18.
BorgV.KristensenT., and BurrH.Work environment and changes in self-rated health: A five year follow-up study. Stress Med.16:37–47, 2000.
19.
BourbonnaisR.Psychosocial work environment and certified leave among nurses during organisational changes and downsizing. Relations Industrielles60(3):483–509, 2005.
20.
BroomD.The lesser evil: Bad jobs or unemployment? A survey of middle-aged Australians. Soc. Sci. Med.63:575–586, 2006.
21.
BurkeR.Job insecurity in recent business school graduates: Antecedents and consequences. Int. J. Stress Manage.5(2):113–119, 1998.
22.
BurkeR., and GreenglassE.Work-family conflict, spouse support, and nursing staff well-being during organizational restructuring. J. Occup. Health Psychol.4(4):327–336, 1999.
23.
BussingA.Can control at work and social support moderate psychological consequences of job insecurity? Results from a quasi-experimental study in the steel industry. Eur. J. Work Org. Psychol.8(2):219–242, 1999.
24.
CatalanoR.RookK., and DooleyD.Labor markets and help-seeking: A test of the employment security hypothesis. J. Health Soc. Behav.27:277–287, 1986.
25.
CatalanoR., and SerxnerS.The effect of ambient threats to employment on low birthweight. J. Health Soc. Behav.33:363–377, 1992.
26.
ChengY.Job insecurity and its association with health among employees in the Taiwanese general population. Soc. Sci. Med.61:41–52, 2005.
27.
De WitteH.Job insecurity and psychological well-being: Review of the literature and exploration of some unresolved issues. Eur. J. Work Org. Psychol.8(2):155–177, 1999.
28.
DekkerS., and SchaufeliW.The effects of job insecurity on psychological health and withdrawal: A longitudinal study. Aust. Psychol.30(1):57–63, 1995.
29.
DomenighettiG.D'AvanzoB., and BisigB.Health effects of job insecurity among employees in the Swiss general population. Int. J. Health Serv.30(3): 477–490, 2000.
30.
DooleyD.RookK., and CatalanoR.Job and non-job stressors and their moderators. J. Occup. Psychol.60:115–132, 1987.
31.
DraganoN.VerdeP., and SiegristJ.Organisational downsizing and work stress: Testing synergistic health effects in employed men and women. J. Epidemiol. Community Health59:694–699, 2005.
32.
D'SouzaR.Work and health in a contemporary society: Demands, control and insecurity. J. Epidemiol. Community Health57:849–854, 2003.
33.
EarnshawA.AmundsonN., and BorgenW.The experience of job insecurity for professional women. J. Employ. Couns.27:2–18, 1990.
34.
FenwickR., and TausigM.The macroeconomic context of job stress. J. Health Soc. Behav.35:266–282, 1994.
35.
FerrieJ.Health effects of anticipation of job change and non-employment: Longitudinal data from the Whitehall II study. BMJ311(7015):311–320, 1995.
36.
FerrieJ.The health effects of major organisational change and job insecurity. Soc. Sci. Med.46(2):243–254, 1998.
37.
FerrieJ.An uncertain future: The health effects of threats to employment security in white collar men and women. Am. J. Public Health88(7):1030–1036, 1998.
38.
FerrieJ.Job insecurity in white collar workers: Towards an explanation of associations with health. J. Occup. Health Psychol.6(1):26–42, 2001.
39.
FerrieJ.Employment status and health after privatization in white collar civil servants: Prospective cohort study. BMJ322:1–7, 2001.
40.
FerrieJ.Effects of chronic job insecurity and changes in job security on self reported health, minor psychiatric morbidity, physiological measures, and health related behaviours in British civil servants: The Whitehall II study. J. Epidemiol. Community Health56(6):450–454, 2002.
41.
FerrieJ.Self-reported job insecurity and health in the Whitehall II study: Potential explanations of the relationship. Soc. Sci. Med.60(7):1593–1602, 2005.
42.
FerrieJ.The impact of moderate and major workplace expansion and downsizing on the psychosocial and physical work environment and income in Sweden. Scand. J. Public Health35(1):62–69, 2007.
43.
FlanneryR.Hospital downsizing and patients' assaults on staff. Psychiatr. Q.68(1):67–76, 1997.
44.
GalloW.Involuntary job loss as a risk factor for subsequent myocardial infarction and stroke: Findings from the health and retirement survey. Am. J. Ind. Med.45:408–416, 2004.
45.
GillespieN.Occupational stress in universities: Staff perceptions of the causes, consequences and moderators of stress. Work Stress15(1):53–72, 2001.
46.
GodinI.DesmarezP., and KittelF.Work stress and instability of employment: Complementary contribution of different data sources. Stress Health22(1):51–58, 2006.
47.
GrunbergL.MooreS., and GreenbergE.Differences in psychological and physical health amongst layoff survivors: The effect of layoff contact. J. Occup. Health Psychol.6(1):15–25, 2001.
48.
HamiltonV.Hard times and vulnerable people: Initial effects of plant closing on autoworkers' mental health. J. Health Soc. Behav.31:123–140, 1990.
49.
HarenstamA.Multilevel analyses of organisational change and working conditions in public and private sector. J. Work Org. Psychol.13(3):305–343, 2004.
50.
HeaneyC.IsraelB., and HouseJ.Chronic job insecurity among automobile workers: Effects on job satisfaction and health. Soc. Sci. Med.38(10):1431–1437, 1994.
51.
HellgrenJ.SverkeM., and IsakssonK.A two-dimensional approach to job insecurity: Consequences for employee attitudes and well-being. Eur. J. Work Org. Psychol.8(2):179–195, 1999.
52.
HellgrenJ., and ChirumboloA.Can union support reduce the negative effects of job insecurity on wellbeing?Econ. Ind. Democr.24(2):271–289, 2003.
53.
HellgrenJ., and SverkeM.Does job insecurity lead to impaired well-being or vice versa? Estimation of cross-lagged effects using latent variable modelling. J. Org. Behav.24(2):215–236, 2003.
54.
HerttingA.Downsizing and reorganisation: Demands, challenges and ambiguity for registered nurses. J. Adv. Nurs.45(2):145–154, 2004.
55.
IsakssonK.HellgrenJ., and PetterssonP.Repeated downsizing: Attitudes and well-being of surviving personnel in a Swedish retail company. In Health Effects of the New Labour Market, ed. IsakssonK., pp. 85–101. Kluwer/Plenum, New York, 2000.
56.
IversenL., and SabroeS.Psychological well-being among unemployed and employed people after a company closedown: A longitudinal study. J. Soc. Iss.44:141–152, 1988.
57.
JenkinsR.Minor psychiatric morbidity and the threat of redundancy in a professional group. Psychol. Med.12:799–807, 1982.
58.
KalimoR.TarisT., and SchaufeliW.The effects of past and anticipated future downsizing on survivor wellbeing: An equity perspective. J. Occup. Health Psychol.8(2):91–109, 2003.
59.
KinnunenU.Perceived job insecurity: A longitudinal study among Finnish employees. Eur. J. Work Org. Psychol.8(2):243–260, 2000.
60.
KristensenT.BorgV., and HannerzH.Socioeconomic status and psychosocial work environment: Results from a Danish national study. Scand. J. Public Health30(Suppl. 59), 41–48, 2002.
61.
KivimakiM.Psychological factors predicting employee sickness absence during economic decline. J. Appl. Psychol.82(6):858–872, 1997.
62.
KivimakiM.Response of hostile individuals to stressful changes in their working lives: Test of a psychological vulnerability model. Psychol. Med.28(4):903–913, 1998.
63.
KivimakiM.Factors underlying the effect of organisational downsizing on the health of employees: Longitudinal cohort study. BMJ320:971–975, 2000.
64.
KivimakiM.Organisational downsizing and musculoskeletal problems in employees: A prospective study. Occup. Environ. Med.58(12):811–817, 2001.
65.
KivimakiM.Downsizing, changes in work, and self-rated health of employees: A 7-year 3 wave panel study. Anxiety Stress Coping14(1):59–73, 2001.
66.
KivimakiM.Human costs of organisational downsizing: Comparing health trends between leavers and stayers. Am. J. Community Psychol.32(1–2):57–67, 2003.
67.
KivimakiM.Organisational downsizing and increased use of psychotropic drugs among employees who remain in employment. J. Epidemiol. Community Health61:154–158, 2007.
68.
LauB., and KnardahlS.Perceived job insecurity, job predictability, personality and health. J. Occup. Environ. Med.50:172–181, 2008.
69.
LaytonC.Levels of state anxiety for males facing redundancy and subsequent reporting to be employed or unemployed. Percept. Mot. Skills65:53–54, 1987.
70.
LeeS.Prospective study of job insecurity and coronary heart disease in US women. Ann. Epidemiol.14:24–30, 2003.
71.
LipscombJ.Health care system change and reported musculoskeletal disorders amongst registered nurses. Am. J. Public Health94(8):1431–1435, 2004.
72.
MakA., and MuellerJ.Job insecurity, coping resources and personality dispositions in occupational strain. Work Stress14(4):312–328, 2000.
73.
MantlerJ.Coping with employment uncertainty: A comparison of employed and unemployed workers. J. Occup. Health Psychol.10(3):200–209, 2005.
74.
MarchandA.DemersA., and DurandP.Social structures, agent personality and workers' mental health: A longitudinal analysis of the specific role of occupation and of workplace constraints-resources on psychological distress in the Canadian workforce. Hum. Relat.59(7):875–901, 2006.
75.
MattiassonI.Threat of unemployment and cardiovascular risk factors: Longitudinal study of quality of sleep and serum cholesterol concentrations in men threatened with redundancy. BMJ301:141–146, 1990.
76.
MaunoS., and KinnunenU.Job insecurity and well-being: A longitudinal study among male and female employees in Finland. Community Work Fam.2(2):147–171, 1999.
77.
MaunoS., and KinnunenU.The effects of job stressors on marital satisfaction in Finnish dual earner couples. J. Org. Behav.20:879–895, 1999.
78.
McDonoughP.Job insecurity and health. Int. J. Health Serv.30(2):453–476, 2000.
79.
McHughM.Rationalisation as a key stressor for public sector employees: An organisational case study. Occup. Med.48(2):103–112, 1998.
80.
MohrenD.Job insecurity as a risk factor for common infections and health complaints. J. Occup. Environ. Med.45(2):123–129, 2003.
81.
MuntanerC.Work organization and atherosclerosis: Findings from the ARIC study. Am. J. Prev. Med.14(1):9–18, 1998.
82.
NaswallK.SverkeM., and HellgrenJ.The moderating role of personality characteristics on the relationship between job insecurity and strain. Work Stress19(1):37–49, 2005.
83.
NiedhammerI.Psychosocial work environment and mental health: Job-strain and effort-reward imbalance models in a context of major organisational changes. Int. J. Occup. Environ. Health12(2):111–119, 2006.
84.
OrpenC.The effects of self-esteem and personal control on the relationship between job-insecurity and psychological well-being. Soc. Behav. Pers.22(1):53–55, 1994.
85.
OsthusS.For better or worse? Workplace change and the health and wellbeing of Norwegian workers. Work Employ. Soc.21(4):731–750, 2007.
86.
OwenA.Sick leave among railwaymen threatened by redundancy: A pilot study. Occup. Psychol.40:43–52, 1966.
87.
ParkY., and ButlerR.The safety costs of contingent work: Evidence from Minnesota. J. Labor Res.12(4):831–849, 2001.
88.
ParkerS.ChmielN., and WallT.Work characteristics and employee well-being within the context of strategic downsizing. J. Occup. Health Psychol.2(4):289–303, 1997.
89.
PelfreneE.Perceptions of job insecurity and the impact of world market competition as health risks: Results from BELSTRESS. J. Occup. Org. Psychol.76:411–425, 2003.
90.
PepperL.The Health Effects of Downsizing in the Nuclear Industry.National Institute of Occupational Health, Cincinnati, 2000.
91.
PepperL.Downsizing and health in the United States Department of Energy. Am. J. Ind. Med.44:481–491, 2003.
92.
CampbellR., and PepperL.Organizational downsizing: Implications for the health of survivors. New Solutions12(2):177–194, 2002.
93.
PetterssonI., and ArnetzB.Psychosocial stressors and well-being in health care workers: The impact of an intervention program. Soc. Sci. Med.47(11):1763–1772, 1998.
94.
PetterssonI.Are trends in work and health conditions interrelated? A study of Swedish hospital employees in the 1990s. J. Occup. Health Psychol.10(2): 110–120, 2005.
95.
PollardT.Changes in mental well-being, blood pressure and total cholesterol levels during workplace reorganization: The impact of uncertainty. Work Stress15(1):14–28, 2001.
96.
ProbstT.Wedded to the job: Moderating effects of job involvement on the consequences of job insecurity. J. Occup. Health Psychol.5(1):63–73, 2000.
97.
ProbstT., and BrubakerT.The effects of job insecurity on employee safety outcomes: Cross-sectional and longitudinal explorations. J. Occup. Health Psychol.6(2):139–159, 2001.
98.
ProbstT.Layoffs and tradeoffs: Production, quality and safety demands under the threat of job loss. J. Occup. Health Psychol.7(3):211–220, 2002.
99.
RosenmanK., Why most workers with occupational repetitive trauma do not file for workers' compensation. J. Occup. Environ. Med.42(1):25–34, 2000.
100.
RoskiesE., and Louis-GuerinC.Job insecurity in managers: Antecedents and consequences. J. Org. Behav.11(5):345–359, 1990.
101.
SaksvikP.Attendance pressure during organisational change. Int. J. Stress Manage.3(1):47–59, 1996.
102.
SchnallP.The impact of anticipation of job loss on psychological distress and worksite blood-pressure. Am. J. Ind. Med.21(3):417–432, 1992.
103.
SchweigerD., and DeNisiA.Communication with employees following a merger—a longitudinal field experiment. Acad. Manage. J.34(1):110–135, 1991.
104.
ShannonH.Change in general health and musculoskeletal outcomes in the workforce of a hospital undergoing rapid change: A longitudinal study. J. Occup. Health Psychol.6(1):3–14, 2001.
105.
SiegristJ.Adverse health effects of high-effort/low-reward conditions. J. Occup. Health Psychol.1(1):27–41, 1996.
106.
SnyderW.Hospital downsizing and increased frequency of assaults on staff. Hosp. Community Psychiatr.45(4):378–380, 1994.
107.
StechmillerJ., and YarandiH.Predictors of burnout in critical care nurses. Heart Lung22(6):534–541, 1993.
108.
StrazdinsL.Job strain, job insecurity, and health: Rethinking the relationship. J. Occup. Health Psychol.9(4):296–305, 2004.
109.
SwaenG.Effects of job insecurity from a workplace closure threat on fatigue and psychological distress. J. Occup. Environ. Med.46(5):443–449, 2004.
110.
SzubertZ.SobalaW., and Zyci'nskaZ.The effect of system restructuring on absenteeism due to sickness in the workplace. Medycyna Pracy48(5):543–551, 1997.
111.
TheorellT.Downsizing of staff is associated with lowered medically certified sick leave in female employees. Occup. Environ. Med.60(9), 2003. doi: 10.1136/oem.60.9.e9.
112.
TorkelsonE., and MuhonenT.Coping strategies and health symptoms among women and men in a downsizing organisation. Psychol. Rep.92:899–907, 2003.
113.
TrinkoffA.Staffing and worker injury in nursing homes. Am. J. Public Health95(7):1220–1225, 2005.
114.
TsutsumiA.Association between job stress and depression among Japanese employees threatened by job loss in a comparison of two complementary job-stress models. Scand. J. Work Environ. Health27(2):146–153, 2001.
115.
VahteraJ.KivimakiM., and PenttiJ.Effects of organisational downsizing on health of employees. Lancet350:1124–1128, 1998.
116.
VahteraJ.Effect of change in the psychosocial work environment on sickness absence: A seven year follow-up of initially healthy employees. J. Epidemiol. Community Health54:484–493, 2000.
VahteraJ.Organisational downsizing as a predictor of disability pension: The 10-town prospective cohort study. J. Epidemiol. Community Health59:238–242, 2005.
119.
VieitezJ.CaricaA., and RodriguezM.Perception of job security in a process of technological change: Its influence on psychological well-being. Behav. Inf. Technol.20(3):213–223, 2000.
120.
ViitasaraE.SverkeM., and MenckelE.Multiple risk factors for violence to seven occupational groups in the Swedish caring sector. Relations Industrielles58(2):202–231, 2003.
121.
WaltersV.McDonoughP., and StrohscheinL.The influence of work, household structure, and social, personal and material resources on gender differences in health: An analysis of the 1994 Canadian National Population Health Survey. Soc. Sci. Med.54(5):677–692, 2002.
122.
WestmanM.EtzionD., and DanonE.Job insecurity and crossover of burnout in married couples. J. Org. Behav.22:467–481, 2001.
123.
WesterlundH.Workplace expansion, long-term sickness absence and hospital admission. Lancet363:1193–1197, 2004.
124.
WesterlundH.TheorellT., and AlfredssonL.Organisational instability and cardiovascular risk factors in white collar employees. Eur. J. Public Health14(1):37–42, 2004.
125.
WoodwardC.The impact of re-engineering and other cost reduction strategies on the staff of a large teaching hospital: A longitudinal study. Med. Care37:556–569, 1999.
126.
PelfreneE.Use of benzodiazepine drugs and perceived job stress in a cohort of working men and women in Belgium: Results from the BELSTRESS study. Soc. Sci. Med.59:433–442, 2004.
127.
SikoraP.Downsizing and alcohol use: A cross-lagged longitudinal examination of the spillover hypothesis. Work Stress22(1):51–68, 2008.
128.
FolgerR., and SkarlickiD.When tough times makes tough bosses: Managerial distancing as a function of layoff blame. Acad. Manage. J.41(1):79–87, 1998.
129.
QuinlanM., and BohleP.Contingent work and occupational safety. In The Psychology of Workplace Safety, ed. BarlingJ. and FroneM., pp. 81–106. American Psychological Association, Washington, DC, 2004.
130.
KivimakiM.Job strain and ischaemic disease: Does the inclusion of older employees in the cohort dilute the association? The WOLD Stockholm Study. J. Epidemiol. Community Health62:372–374, 2008.
131.
SiegristJ.Social reciprocity and health: New scientific evidence and policy implications. Psychoneuroendocrinology30:1033–1038, 2005.
132.
ClarkeM.“This just isn't sustainable”: Precarious employment, stress and workers' health. Int. J. Law Psychiatr.30(4–5):311–326, 2007.
133.
BeckersD. G. J.Voluntary or involuntary? Control over overtime and rewards for overtime in relation to fatigue and work satisfaction. Work Stress22(1):33–50, 2008.
134.
KnudsenK.Downsizing survival: The experience of work and organizational commitment. Sociol. Inq.73(2):265–283, 2003.
135.
BrennanA., and SkarlickiD.Personality and perceived justice as predictors of survivors' reactions following downsizing. J. Appl. Soc. Psychol.34(6):1306–1328, 2004.
136.
BambraC.The psychosocial and health effects of workplace reorganization: 2. A systematic review of task restructuring interventions. J. Epidemiol. Community Health61:1028–1037, 2007.
137.
LeroyerA.Prospective evaluation of the impact of a change in the organization of work on perceived stress and health in assembly-line workers in an automobile plant. Rev. Epidemiol. Sante Publ.54:15–25, 2006.
