Should Visual Images Be Defined as Depictive Neural Patterns,or as Conscious Sensations Constructed from “Imageless” Visual Thoughts?

Abstract

Greater vividness of visual imagery correlated significantly with improved performance on a task in which 112 subjects generated and tested hypotheses about the rules of three-point perspective (3PP), but not with improvement on a similar task in which another 116 subjects applied previously known rules of two-point perspective (2PP). Given the 100-year history of research finding zero correlation between image vividness and visuospatial reasoning, the 2PP results are interpreted as support for Külpe's thesis that the imageless thinker's existing knowledge of imageless rules allows for the solution of spatial problems, without any construction of visual images. The 3PP results are interpreted as support for Kunzendorf and Reynold's thesis that the vivid imager's construction of test images from newly hypothesized rules allows for the refinement of those imageless rules, with less reliance on overt mistakes for corrective feedback.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Appalachian Mountain Club. (1979). A.M.C. White Mountain Guide (22nd ed.). Boston: Appalachian Mountain Club.

Ashton

McFarland

Walsh

White

(1978). Imagery ability and the identification of hands: A chronometric analysis. Acta Psychologica, 42, 253–262.

Barsky

B. A.

(2007). A note on the mathematics of two- and three-point perspective. Retrieved June 13, 2007, from http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/∼barsky/perspective.html

Bethel-Fox

C. E.

Lohman

D. F.

Snow

R. E.

(1984). Adaptive reasoning: Componential and eye movement analysis of geometric analogy performance. Intelligence, 8, 205–238.

Betts

G. H.

(1909). The distribution and functions of mental imagery. New York: Teachers College, Columbia University.

Bowers

(1935). The role of visual imagery in reasoning. British Journal of Psychology, 25, 436–446.

Broadbent

D. E.

(1970). In defence of empirical psychology. Bulletin of the British Psychological Society, 23, 87–96.

Bühler

(1907/1964). Thinking and the new psychology: Imageless thought. In Mandler

J. M.

Mandler

(Eds. & Trans.), Thinking: From association to Gestalt (pp. 162–164). New York: John Wiley. (Original work published 1907.)

Chen

Kato

Zhu

X. H.

Ogawa

Tank

D. W.

Ugurbil

(1998). Human primary visual cortex and lateral geniculate nucleus activation during visual imagery. Neuroreport, 9, 3669–3674.

10.

Chomsky

(1965). Aspects of the theory of syntax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

11.

Cox

(2005). The pictorial world of the child. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

12.

Cutter

L. F.

(1979). Appalachian Mountain Club Map of the Mount Washington Range. In A.M.C. White Mountain Guide (22nd ed.; map 6). Boston: Appalachian Mountain Club.

13.

Dean

Morris

P. E.

(1991). Imagery and spatial ability: When introspective reports predict performance. In Logie

R. H.

Denis

(eds.), Mental images in human cognition (pp. 331–347). Amsterdam: Elsevier.

14.

DiVesta

F. J.

Ingersoll

Sunshine

(1971). A factor analysis of imagery tests. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 10, 471–479.

15.

Dolle

J.-M.

(1980). Research on the origin of the representation of perspective in the child. Psychologie Française, 25, 3–14.

16.

Durndell

A. J.

Wetherick

N. E.

(1976). Reported imagery and two spatial tests. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 43, 1050.

17.

Farah

M. J.

Peronnet

(1989). Event-related potentials in the study of mental imagery. Journal of Psychophysiology, 3, 99–109.

18.

Finke

R. A.

Kosslyn

S. M.

(1980). Mental imagery acuity in the peripheral visual field. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 6, 126–139.

19.

Finke

R. A.

Kurtzman

H. S.

(1981). Mapping the visual field in mental imagery. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 110, 501–517.

20.

Finke

R. A.

Schmidt

M. J.

(1978). The quantitative measure of pattern representation in images following orientation-specific color aftereffects. Perception & Psychophysics, 23, 515–520.

21.

Fusella

V. J.

(1973). Blocking of an external signal through self-projected imagery: The role of inner-acceptant personality style and categories of imagery. Dissertation Abstracts International, 33(11-B), 5489–5490.

22.

Gur

R. C.

Hilgard

E. R.

(1975). Visual imagery and the discrimination of differences between altered pictures simultaneously and successively presented. British Journal of Psychology, 66, 341–345.

23.

Hatakeyama

(1981). Individual differences in imagery ability and mental rotation. Tohoku Psychologica Folia, 40(1[Suppl. 4]), 6–23.

24.

Hegarty

Waller

(2004). A dissociation between mental rotation and perspective-taking abilities. Intelligence, 32, 175–191.

25.

Howie

Markham

Kleitman

(2006). The development of imagery scales for children in three modalities. Journal of Mental Imagery, 30(1&2), 39–64.

26.

Huttenlocher

Presson

C. C.

(1973). Mental rotation and the perspective problem. Cognitive Psychology, 4, 277–299.

27.

Keenan

J. M.

Olson

R. K.

(1979). The imagery debate: A controversy over terms and cognitive styles. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2, 558–559.

28.

Kosslyn

S. M.

(1980). Image and mind. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

29.

Kosslyn

S. M.

(1994). Image and brain. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

30.

Kosslyn

S. M.

Alper

S. N.

(1977). On the pictorial properties of visual images: Effects of image size on memory for words. Canadian Journal of Psychology, 31, 32–40.

31.

Kosslyn

S. M.

Brunn

Cave

Wallach

(1984). Individual differences in mental imagery ability: A componential analysis. Cognition, 18, 195–243.

32.

Kosslyn

S. M.

Pinker

Smith

G. E.

Shwartz

S. P.

(1979). On the demystification of mental imagery. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2, 535–581.

33.

Kosslyn

S. M.

Pomerantz

J. R.

(1977). Imagery, propositions, and the form of internal representations. Cognitive Psychology, 9, 52–76.

34.

Kosslyn

S. M.

Thompson

W. L.

Ganis

(2006). The case for mental imagery. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

35.

Külpe

(1893/1895). Outlines of psychology ( Titchener

E. B.

, Trans.). London: Sonnenschein. (Originally published under the German title Grundriss der Psychologie in 1893.)

36.

Kunzendorf

R. G.

(1982). Mental images, appreciation of grammatical patterns, and creativity. Journal of Mental Imagery, 6, 183–202.

37.

Kunzendorf

R. G.

(1984). Centrifugal effects of eidetic imaging on flash electroretino-grams and autonomic responses. Journal of Mental Imagery, 8(4), 67–76.

38.

Kunzendorf

R. G.

(1989). Afterimages of eidetic images: A developmental study. Journal of Mental Imagery, 13(1), 55–62.

39.

Kunzendorf

R. G.

Hall

(2001). Electroretinographic after-effects of visual imaging: Individual differences in imagery vividness and reality testing. Journal of Mental Imagery, 25(3&4), 79–92.

40.

Kunzendorf

R. G.

Justice

Capone

(1997). Conscious images as ‘centrally excited sensations”: A developmental study of imaginal influences on the ERG. Journal of Mental Imagery, 21(1&2), 155–166.

41.

Kunzendorf

R. G.

Reynolds

(2004–2005). On the cognitive function of visual images and the development of individual differences. Imagination, Cognition and Personality, 24, 245–257.

42.

Kunzendorf

R. G.

Wallace

(2000). Individual differences in subjective experience: First-person constraints on theories of consciousness, subconsciousness, and self-consciousness. In Kunzendorf

R. G.

Wallace

(Eds.), Individual differences in conscious experience (pp. 1–14). Amsterdam: John Benjamins Publishing Company.

43.

Kunzendorf

R. G.

Young

Beecy

Beals

(2000). Is visual thinking “imageless thought”? Perceptual and Motor Skills, 91, 981–982.

44.

Laughlin

P. R.

Bonner

B. L.

Aftermatt

T. W.

(1999). Effectiveness of positive hypothesis testing in inductive and deductive rule learning. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 77, 130–146.

45.

Lindauer

M. S.

(1977). Imagery from the point of view of psychological aesthetics, the arts, and creativity. Journal of Mental Imagery, 1, 343–362.

46.

Lorenz

Neisser

(1985). Factors of imagery and event recall. Memory and Cognition, 13, 494–500.

47.

MacEvoy

(2007a). Two point perspective. Retrieved June 13, 2007, from http://www.handprint.com/HP/WCL/perspect3.html

48.

MacEvoy

(2007b). Three point perspective. Retrieved June, 13, 2007, from http://www.handprint.com/HP/WCL/perspect4.html

49.

Marcus

G. F.

Vijayan

Rao

S. B.

Vishton

P. M.

(1999). Rule learning by seven-month-old infants. Science, 283, 77–80.

50.

Marks

D. F.

(1973). Visual imagery differences in recall of pictures. British Journal of Psychology, 64, 17–24.

51.

McKelvie

S. J.

(1995). The VVIQ as a psychometric test of individual differences in visual imagery vividness: A critical quantitative review and plea for direction. Journal of Mental Imagery, 19(3&4), 1–106.

52.

McKelvie

S. J.

Rohrberg

M. M.

(1978). Individual differences in reported visual imagery and cognitive performance. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 46, 451–458.

53.

Morrison

R. G.

Wallace

(2001). Imagery vividness, creativity and the visual arts. Journal of Mental Imagery, 25(3&4), 135–152.

54.

Musso

Moro

Glauche

Rijntjes

Reichenbach

, Büchel

Weiller

(2003). Broca's area and the language instinct. Nature Neuroscience, 6, 774–781.

55.

Parrott

C. A.

(1986). Visual imagery training: Stimulating utilization of imaginal processes. Journal of Mental Imagery, 10(1), 47–64.

56.

Piaget

(1970). Genetic epistemology ( Duckworth

Trans.). New York: Columbia University Press.

57.

Pinker

(1991). Rules of language. Science, 253, 530–534.

58.

Poltrock

S. E.

Brown

(1984). Individual differences in visual imagery and spatial ability. Intelligence, 8, 93–138.

59.

Pylyshyn

Z. W.

(1973). What the mind's eye tells the mind's brain: A critique of mental imagery. Psychological Bulletin, 80, 1–24.

60.

Reisberg

Heuer

(2005). Visuospatial images. In Shah

Miyake

(Eds.), The Cambridge handbook of visuospatial thinking (pp. 35–80). New York: Cambridge University Press.

61.

Richardson

(1977). The meaning and measurement of mental imagery. British Journal of Psychology, 68, 29–43.

62.

Shepard

R. N.

Metzler

(1971). Mental rotation of three-dimensional objects. Science, 171, 701–703.

63.

Sokal

R. R.

Rohlf

F. J.

(1995). Biometry (3rd ed.). New York: W. H. Freeman & Company.

64.

Wallace

(1984a). Apparent equivalence between perception and imagery in the production of various visual illusions. Memory & Cognition, 12, 156–162.

65.

Wallace

(1984b). Creation of the horizontal-vertical illusion through imagery. Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society, 22, 9–11.

66.

Wallace

(1988). Imaging ability, visual search strategies, and the unvividness paradox. Journal of Mental Imagery, 12(3&4), 173–184.

67.

Wallace

(1991). Imaging ability and performance in a proofreading task. Journal of Mental Imagery, 15(3&4), 177–188.

68.

Watson

J. B.

(1913). Image and affection in behavior. Journal of Philosophy, Psychology, and Scientific Methods, 10, 421–428.

69.

Wexler

(1990). Innateness and maturation in language development. Developmental Psychobiology, 23, 645–660.

70.

Wood

B. D.

Bell

J. C.

(1920). Solution of problems in geometry. Journal of Educational Psychology, 11, 316–326.