New Zealand has experienced radical public sector restructuring over the last decade, including the corporatization and subsequent privatization of state trading units and the reform of social services, including health. In 1991 a new government proposed and then implemented more radical health reforms, which included the corporatization of state-owned provider units (23 crown health enterprises) and the creation of an internal market with purchasers (four regional health authorities) separated from providers. Interviews with chief executives of crown health enterprises suggest that provider units are seeking a wider role than envisaged, with an interest in the health needs of their populations and undertaking some purchasing on their behalf. The purchasers see a narrower role for crown health enterprises. Both purchasers and providers report that competition between providers is not particularly helpful (and with only limited opportunities for this to occur), with collaboration being seen as more useful. Providers are critical of purchasers' ability to adopt a strategic approach. Unlike other aspects of New Zealand's restructuring, there appears to be a retreat from some of the more radical facets of the reforms, reflecting both the resistance of the health sector and a newly uncertain political climate.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
HoodC.A public management for all seasons?Public Admin. 69: 3–19, 1991
2.
Minister of Health. Your Health and the Public Health (Green and White Paper). Wellington, 1991
3.
McLeanI.Review article: Some recent work on public choice. Br. J. Polit. Sci.16: 377–394, 1986
4.
BostonJ.The theoretical underpinnings of public sector restructuring in New Zealand. In Reshaping the State: New Zealand's Bureaucratic Revolution, edited by BostonJ., pp. 1–26. Oxford University Press, Auckland, 1991
5.
JordanG.AshfordN.Public Policy and the Impact of the New Right. Pinter Publishers, London, 1993
6.
TrebilcockM. J.The Prospects for Reinventing Government. C. D. Howe Institute, Toronto, 1994
7.
AucoinP.Administrative reform in public management: Paradigms, principles, paradoxes and pendulums. Governance3(2): 115–137, 1990
8.
OECD. Public Management Developments. Paris, 1990
9.
PainterM.Public Management: Fad or fallacy?Aust. J. Public Admin. 47: 1–3, 1988
10.
FriedB. J.DeberR. B.LeattP.Corporatization and deprivatization of health services in Canada. Int. J. Health Serv. 17(4): 567–584, 1987
11.
WhiteisD.SalmonJ. W.The proprietarization of health care and the underdevelopment of the public sector. Int. J. Health Serv. 17(1): 47–64, 1987
12.
BerlinerH. S.BurlageR. K.The walk-in chains: The proprietarization of ambulatory care. Int. J. Health Serv. 17(4): 585–594, 1987
13.
MurphyL.KearnsR. A.Housing New Zealand Ltd: Privatisation by stealth. Environment and Planning A26: 623–637, 1994
14.
JacobsB. D.The New Right, housing and urban renewal in Britain and the United States. In Public Policy and the Impact of the New Right, edited by JordanG.AshfordN., Pinter Publishers, London, 1993
15.
New Zealand, The Treasury. Economic Management. Wellington, 1984
16.
DuncanI.BollardA.Corporatization and Privatization. Oxford University Press, Auckland, 1992
17.
ScottG.GorringeP.Reform of the core public sector: The New Zealand experience. Aust. J. Public Admin. 48: 81–92, 1989
18.
New Zealand, The Treasury. Government Management. Wellington, 1987
19.
MascarenhasR. C.Reform of the public service in Australia and New Zealand. Governance3(1): 75–95, 1990
20.
ScottC. D.Reform of the New Zealand health care system. Soc. Policy29: 25–40, 1994
21.
BostonJ.DalzielP.The Decent Society. Oxford University Press, Auckland, 1992
22.
ScottC.FougereG.MarwickJ.Health Benefits Review: Choices for Health Care. Government Printer, Wellington, 1986
23.
GibbsA.Unshackling the Hospitals: Report of the Task Force on Hospital and Related Services. Government Printer, Wellington, 1987
24.
MalcolmL. A.Service management—New Zealand's version of resource management. Health Policy16: 470–474, 1990
25.
DaviesS.Health sector reform. Public Sector12(1): 8–9, 1990
26.
MalcolmL. A.Trends in primary medical care related services and expenditure in New Zealand 1983–93. N. Z. Med. J.106: 470–474, 1993
27.
BellJ. D.FayM. T.The medical profession and changing attitudes to advertising and competition. N. Z. Med J. 104: 69–71, 1991
28.
KearnsR. A.BarnettJ. R.Enter the supermarket: Entrepreneurial medical practice in New Zealand. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy10: 267–281, 1992
29.
MathesonD. P.HoskinsR. S.The general practice contract scheme: Was it targeted?N. Z. Med. J.105: 35–36, 1992
30.
MalcolmL. A.BarnettP. S.New Zealand's health providers in an emerging market. Health Policy29: 85–100, 1990
31.
PetcheyR.NHS internal market 1991–92: Towards a balance sheet. Br. Med. J.306: 699–701, 1993
32.
DiederichsonF.Market reforms in Swedish health care: A threat to or salvation for the universalist welfare state?Int. J. Health Serv. 23(1): 185–188, 1993
33.
HarrisonS.WistowG.The purchaser provider split in English health care: Towards explicit rationing?Policy Politics20(2): 123–130, 1992
34.
RobinsonR.Le GrandJ.Evaluating the NHS Reforms. The King's Fund, London, 1994
35.
Campbell-HuntC. C.HarperD. A.HamiltonR. T.Islands of Excellence? A Study of Management in New Zealand. New Zealand Institute of Economic Research, Wellington, 1993
36.
MoeT.The new economics of organisation. Am. J. Polit. Sci.28: 739–775, 1984
37.
DeardonR. W.Purchasing with a vision. Health Serv. Manage., August 1991, pp. 171–173
38.
New Zealand, National Interim Provider Board. Providing Better Health Care for New Zealanders. Wellington, 1992
39.
New Zealand, Minister of Health. Policy Guidelines to Regional Health Authorities 1994/95. Wellington, 1994
40.
New Zealand, Minister of Health. Transitional Assistance for New Service Developments. Media release, August 19, 1994. Wellington, 1994
41.
Howden-ChapmanP.AshtonT.Shopping for health: Purchasing health services through contracts. Health Policy29: 61–83, 1994
42.
BarnettP.PerkinsR. J.Adapting US-style managed care to New Zealand: Another exotic species comes ashore. Health Manager1(4): 5–8, 1994
43.
MalcolmL. A.Managed care in New Zealand—making it happen. Health Manager1(4): 9–12, 1994
44.
GriffithsR.NHS Management Inquiry. Department of Health and Social Services, London, 1983
45.
MalcolmL. A.BarnettP.Decentralisation, integration and accountability: A study of New Zealand's top health services managers. Health Serv. Manage. Res., in press, 1996
46.
FeinglassJ.SalmonJ. W.Corporatization of medicine: The use of medical management information systems to increase the clinical productivity of physicians. Int. J. Health Serv. 20(2): 233–252, 1990
47.
PageC.WilsonM.KolbD.Management Competencies in New Zealand: On the Inside Looking In?Ministry of Commerce, Wellington, 1994
48.
JamesC.New Territory: The Transformation of New Zealand 1984–92. Bridget Williams Books, Wellington, 1992
