Erie Land Lighthouse: A Microcosm of Nineteenth-Century Great Lakes Maritime History

Abstract

The Erie Land Lighthouse was a visible link in the early eighteenth century western frontier trade network. Lighting the harbor entrance to Erie, Pennsylvania, from 1818 until the close of the century, the Erie Land Lighthouse contributed to the emergence of Erie as a vital shipping port connecting the Great Lakes to expanding inland markets. Constructed in 1818, the Erie Land Lighthouse (formerly, Presque Isle Lighthouse) was the first of a series of lighthouses built by the United States to aid navigation and promote shipping on the Great Lakes. As with its contemporaries, the original 1818 structure was replaced in 1858 by a taller lighthouse and a more elaborate keeper's residence. Structural flaws required the 1858 lighthouse to be replaced in 1867 by a third, which still stands today. The record of the Erie Land Lighthouse mirrors the history of similar facilities and processes across the Great Lakes. Unlike other locations, however, the Erie, Pennsylvania, site is archaeologically unique due to the presence of remnants of all phases of its construction and use history. Archaeological investigation of the first two sequent lighthouse structures on the site recovered a range of artifacts reflecting the government ownership of the lighthouse property, the site's advantageous location in a commercial hub, the effects of local and regional competition, and the day-to-day life of the lighthouse keepers. Details of the archaeological excavations at the Erie Land Lighthouse are provided and the site is placed in the larger context of lighthouse construction and use on the Great Lakes.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ball

Donald B.

1983 Approaches Toward the Dating of 19th Century Ohio Valley Flat Glass, Proceedings of the Symposium on Ohio Valley Urban and Historic Archaeology, I, pp. 129–137.

Cox

J. L.

Jr.

1986 Presque Isle Bay Underwater Archaeology Survey, submitted to the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission and the Bureau for Historic Preservation, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.

Cushion

J. P.

1980 Handbook of Pottery and Porcelain Marks, Faker and Faker Limited, London.

DeBolt

1994 DeBolt's Dictionary of American Pottery Marks, Collector Books, Division of Schroeder Publishing Co., Inc., Paducah, Kentucky.

ERIE COUNTY HISTORICAL SOCIETY 1991 Three Lights at Erie, From the Cashiers House XVI:1, Erie County Historical Society, Erie, Pennsylvania.

Grimm

J. L.

1970 Archaeological Investigation of Fort Ligonier 1960-1965. Annals of Carnegie Museum 42, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

Holland

F. R.

1994 Great American Lighthouses, Preservation Press, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York.

Huntington

1982 Archaeological Data Recovery at AZBB:9:72 (ASM), The Band Quarters Kitchen and Corral Wall at Fort Lowell, and AZBB:9:54 (ASM), a Ricon Phase Habitation Site, Craycroft Road, Tucson, Arizona, Archaeological Series 163, Arizona State Museum, Tucson.

Jensen

1971 Board and Batten Siding and the Balloon Frame: Their Incompatibility in the 19th Century, Journal of the Society for Architectural Historians, 30:1, pp. 41–50.

10.

Jordan

W. R.

and Huddleston

1999 The First Pensacola Lighthouse: Archaeology of a Keeper's Residence, submitted to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Mobile District. Copies available from Brockington and Associates, Inc., Atlanta and Charleston.

11.

Jurney

D. H.

1987 Cut and Wire Nails: Functional and Temporal Interpretations, in Historic Buildings, Material Culture, and People of the Prairie Margin, edited by Jurney

D. H.

and Moir

R. W.

, pp. 84–96, Richland Creek Technical Series Vol. V, Archaeology Research Program, Institute for the Study of Earth and Man, Southern Methodist University, Dallas.

12.

Kovel

and Kovel

1986 Kovels' New Dictionary of Marks, Crown Publishers, Inc., New York.

13.

Lees

W. B.

1977 Investigations at Tx-33, Old Hardesty, Texas County, Oklahoma, Research Report 11, Archaeological Research Associates, Tulsa, Oklahoma.

14.

MacDonald

R. J.

and Frew

1997 Home Port Erie, Erie County Historical Society, Erie, Pennsylvania.

15.

Moir

R. W.

1987 Socioeconomic and Chronometric Patterning of Window Glass, in Historic Buildings, Material Culture, and People of the Prairie Margin, edited by Jurney

D. H.

and Moir

R. W.

, pp. 73–81, Richland Creek Technical Series Vol. V, Archaeology Research Program, Institute for the Study of Earth and Man, Southern Methodist University, Dallas.

16.

Monro

W. L.

1926 Window Glass in the Making: An Art, A Craft, A Business, American Window Glass Company, Pittsburgh.

17.

Oleszewski

1998 Great Lakes Lighthouses American & Canadian, Avery Color Studios, Inc., Gwinn, Michigan.

18.

Preiss

P. J.

1970 Penny Wise, Penny Foolish: The Description of Nail Sizes, Society for Historical Archaeology Newsletter, 3:3, pp. 8–9.

19.

Reid

C. S.

1976 Clay Pipes in the Upper Great Lakes: The Ermatinger Assemblage, Northeast Historical Archaeology, 5, pp. 1–11.

20.

Roenke

K. G.

1978 Flat Glass: Its Use as a Dating Tool for Nineteenth Century Archaeological Sites in the Pacific Northwest and Elsewhere, Memoir 4, Northwest Anthropological Research Notes, University of Idaho, Moscow.

21.

Sloane

1982 Eric Sloane's America, Promontory Press, New York.

22.

South

1977 Method and Theory in Historical Archaeology, Academic Press, New York.

23.

Spencer

H. R.

1962 Erie … A History, Spencer

H. R.

, publisher, The Erie Book Store, distributor, Erie, Pennsylvania.

24.

Stone

and Frew

1993 Waters of Repose. Erie County Historical Society, Erie, Pennsylvania.

25.

Taylor

D. C.

1991 Soil Survey of Erie County, Pennsylvania, Reissued, Originally published 1960, United States Department of Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington.

26.

Thomas

1993 An Examination of Early 19th Century Settlement in the Ohio Valley as Reflected in the Kelley Historic Site, Master's thesis, Department of Anthropology, Kent State University, Kent, Ohio.

27.

Thomas

and Adovasio

J. M.

1998 Archaeological Investigation of the Erie Land Lighthouse (36ER288), Erie County, Pennsylvania, submitted by Mercyhurst Archaeological Institute, Erie, Pennsylvania, for the Pennsylvania Coastal Zone Management Program, Contract No. CZ 1:97.01 PE, ME No. 97081.

28.

Veit

1999 Navesink Twin Lights, submitted to Twin Lights State Park. Copies available Department of History and Anthropology, Monmouth University, West Long Branch, New Jersey.

29.

Walker

I. C.

1971 Nineteenth-Century Clay Tobacco Pipes in Canada, Ontario Archaeology, 16, pp. 19–35.

30.

Wellejus

1980 Erie, Chronicle of a Great Lakes City, Windsor Publication, Inc., Woodland Hills, California.