Boundary Networks and Rochester's “Smart” Lead Law: The Use of Multidisciplinary Information in a Collaborative Policy Process

Abstract

The Rochester, New York, Coalition to Prevent Lead Poisoning formed in 2001 with the goal of eliminating childhood lead poisoning by 2010. The Coalition recruited diverse community stakeholders into a collaborative process committed to using the best available science. The Coalition successfully infused the debate about a new lead poisoning law with local data, national analyses, and the latest medical research. We argue that this was facilitated by a boundary network of individuals who provided technical input throughout the process. As a result of the Coalition's advocacy, in 2005 the Rochester City Council unanimously passed an ordinance that has been hailed as one of the nation's “smartest” lead laws. Many communities are looking to Rochester's new lead ordinance as a model. Both the process and outcome of this case provide valuable lessons for collaborative efforts to promote scientifically sound local environmental health policy.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Koontz

T. M.

. Collaborative environmental management: what roles for government? Washington, DC: Resources for the Future; 2004.

Cowling

E. B.

. The performance and legacy of NAPAP. Ecological Applications 1992; 2(2): 111–116.

Jasanoff

. The fifth branch: science advisers as policymakers. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press; 1990.

Busenberg

G. J.

. Citizen participation and collaborative environmental management in the marine oil trade of coastal Alaska. Coastal Management 2007; 35(2): 239–253.

Coburn

. Community knowledge in environmental health science: co-producing policy expertise. Environ. Sci. & Policy 2007 4;10(2): 150–161.

González

E. R.

Lejano

R. P.

Vidales

, and Conner

R. F.

. Participatory Action Research for Environmental Health: Encountering Freire in the Urban Barrio. Journal of Urban Affairs 2007; 29(1): 77.

Vasquez

V. B.

Minkler

, and Shepard

. Promoting environmental health policy through community based participatory research: a case study from Harlem, New York. J. Urban Health 2006 Jan;83(1): 101–110.

Srinivasan

, and Collman

G. W.

. Evolving partnerships in community. Environ. Health Perspect. 2005 Dec;113(12): 1814–1816.

Tickner

J. A.

. Democratic participation: a critical element of precautionary public health decision-making. New Solutions 2001; 11(2): 93–111.

10.

Wondolleck

J. M.

, and Yaffee

S. L.

. Making collaboration work: lessons from innovation in natural resource management. Washington, D.C.: Island Press; 2000.

11.

O'Fallon

L. R.

, and Dearry

. Community-based participatory research as a tool to advance environmental health sciences. Environ. Health Perspect. 2002 Apr; 110(Suppl 2): 155–159.

12.

Brunner

R. D.

. Adaptive governance: integrating science, policy, and decision making. New York: Columbia University Press; 2005.

13.

Rahm

. Toxic waste and environmental policy in the 21st century United States. Jefferson, N.C.: McFarland & Co.; 2002.

14.

Feldman

M. S.

Khademian

A. M.

Ingram

, and Schneider

A. S.

. Ways of knowing and inclusive management practices. Public Adm. Rev. 2006 Dec;66: 89.

15.

Guston

D. H.

. Boundary organizations in environmental policy and science: An introduction. Science, Technology & Human Values 2001 Autumn;26(4): 399.

16.

Moore

J. E.

. Community aspects of childhood lead poisoning. Am. J. Public Health Nations Health 1970 Aug;60(8): 1430–1434.

17.

Rosner

Markowitz

Lanphear

, and Lockhart

. Gibson and the discovery of the impact of lead pigments on children's health: a review of a century of knowledge. Public Health Rep. 2005 May-Jun;120(3): 296–300.

18.

Levin

Brown

M. J.

Kashtock

M. E.

Jacobs

D. E.

Whelan

E. A.

Rodman

. Lead exposures in U.S. Children, 2008: implications for prevention. Environ. Health Perspect. 2008 Oct;(10): 1285–1293.

19.

National Center for Healthy Housing. Available at: http://www.nchh.org/. Accessed 2/8/2010, 2010.

20.

Breysse

Anderson

Galke

W. A.

, and Wilson

. Immediate and one-year post-intervention effectiveness of Maryland's lead law treatments. Environ. Res. 2007 Oct;105(2): 267–275.

21.

Brown

M. J.

Gardner

Sargent

J. D.

Swartz

, and Timperi

. The effectiveness of housing policies in reducing children's lead exposure. Am. J. Public Health 2001 Apr;91(4): 621–624.

22.

Freudenberg

, and Golub

. Health education, public policy and disease prevention: a case history of the New York City Coalition to End Lead Poisoning. Health Educ. Q. 1987; 14(4): 387–401.

23.

Rothman

N. L.

Lourie

R. J.

, and Gaughan

. Lead Awareness: North Philly Style Grant Team. Lead awareness: North Philly Style. Am. J. Public Health 2002 May; 92(5): 739–741.

24.

Schlenker

T. L.

Baxmann

McAvoy

Bartkowski

, and Murphy

. Primary prevention of childhood lead poisoning through community outreach. WMJ 2001; 100(8): 48–54.

25.

City of Rochester | Lead Paint—Essential Links and Documents Available at: http://www.cityofrochester.gov/lead/. Accessed 2/8/2010, 2010.

26.

Korfmacher

K. S.

. Collaborating for primary prevention: Rochester's new lead law. J. Public Health Manag. Pract. 2008 Jul-Aug;14(4): 400–406.

27.

Stoss

F. W.

. Building lead-free communities. Reference and User Services Quarterly 2005; 44(4): 289–295.

28.

Monroe County Department of Public Health blood lead screening data. Available at: http://www.monroecounty.gov/eh-leadpoisoning.php. Accessed 1/13/10.

29.

Coalition to Prevent Lead Poisoning. Available at: http://www.leadsafeby2010.org/. Accessed 2/8/2010, 2010.

30.

Korfmacher

K. S.

. Rochester moves to make lead history. Lead and Environmental Health Solutions 2006;March:1.

31.

Lead Home | Lead in Paint, Dust, and Soil | US EPA Available at: http://www.epa.gov/lead/. Accessed 2/8/2010, 2010.

32.

Gibson

J. L.

. A plea for painted railings and painted walls of rooms as the source of lead poisoning amongst Queensland children. Australian Medical Gazette 1904; 23: 149–153.

33.

Charney

Kessler

Farfel

, and Jackson

. Childhood lead poisoning. A controlled trial of the effect of dust-control measures on blood lead levels. N. Engl. J. Med. 1983 Nov 3;309(18): 1089–1093.

34.

Lanphear

B. P.

Matte

T. D.

Rogers

Clickner

R. P.

Dietz

Bornschein

R. L.

. The contribution of lead-contaminated house dust and residential soil to children's blood lead levels. A pooled analysis of 12 epidemiologic studies. Environ. Res. 1998 Oct;79(1): 51–68.

35.

Lanphear

B. P.

, and Roghmann

K. J.

. Pathways of lead exposure in urban children. Environ. Res. 1997; 74(1): 67–73.

36.

Lanphear

B. P.

Burgoon

D. A.

Rust

S. W.

Eberly

, and Galke

W. A.

. Environmental exposures to lead and urban children's blood lead levels. Environ. Res. 1998 Feb; 76(2): 120–130.

37.

Meyer

P. A.

Staley

Curtis

Blanton

, and Brown

M. J.

. Improving strategies to prevent childhood lead poisoning using local data. Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health 2005; 208(1–2): 15–20.

38.

Boyce

, and Hood

. Lead poisoning among young children in Monroe County, NY: A needs assessment, projection model, and next steps. 2002; Available at: http://www.monroecounty.gove/p/eh-leadpoisoningamongyoung.pdf. Accessed 3/27, 2007.

39.

Lanphear

B. P.

Weitzman

Winter

N. L.

Eberly

Yakir

Tanner

. Lead-contaminated house dust and urban children's blood lead levels. Am. J. Public Health 1996 Oct;86(10): 1416–1421.

40.

Lanphear

B. P.

Dietrich

Auinger

, and Cox

. Cognitive deficits associated with blood lead concentrations <10 microg/dL in US children and adolescents. Public Health Rep. 2000 Nov-Dec;115(6): 521–529.

41.

Canfield

R. L.

Henderson

C. R.

Jr. Cory-Slechta

D. A.

Cox

Jusko

T. A.

, and Lanphear

B. P.

. Intellectual impairment in children with blood lead concentrations below 10 microg per deciliter. N. Engl. J. Med. 2003 Apr 17;348(16): 1517–1526.

42.

Lutter

. Getting the lead out cheaply: a review of the EPA's proposed residential lead hazard standards. Environ. Sci. & Policy 2001 2;4(1): 13–23.

43.

Wakefield

. The lead effect? Environ. Health Perspect. 2002 Oct;110(10): A574–80.

44.

Haley

V. B.

, and Talbot

T. O.

. Geographic analysis of blood lead levels in New York State children born 1994–1997. Environ. Health Perspect. 2004 Nov;112(15): 1577–1582.

45.

Bailey

A. J.

Sargent

J. D.

, and Blake

M. K.

. A Tale of Two Counties: Childhood Lead Poisoning, Industrialization, and Abatement in New England. Economic Geography 1998; 74(S1): 96–111.

46.

Sargent

J. D.

Bailey

Simon

Blake

, and Dalton

M. A.

. Census tract analysis of lead exposure in Rhode Island children. Environ. Res. 1997; 74(2): 159–168.

47.

Jacobs

D. E.

Clickner

R. P.

Zhou

J. Y.

Viet

S. M.

Marker

D. A.

Rogers

J. W.

. The prevalence of lead-based paint hazards in U.S. housing. Environ. Health Perspect. 2002 Oct;110(10): A599–606.

48.

Lanphear

B. P.

Byrd

R. S.

Auinger

, and Schaffer

S. J.

. Community characteristics associated with elevated blood lead levels in children. Pediatrics 1998 Feb; 101(2): 264–271.

49.

Dixon

S. L.

Wilson

J. W.

Scott

C. C.

Galke

W. A.

Succop

P. A.

, and Chen

. Effectiveness of lead-hazard control interventions on dust lead loadings: findings from the evaluation of the HUD Lead-Based Paint Hazard Control Grant Program. Environ. Res. 2005 Jul;98(3): 303–314.

50.

Landrigan

P. J.

Schechter

C. B.

Lipton

J. M.

Fahs

M. C.

, and Schwartz

. Environmental pollutants and disease in American children: estimates of morbidity, mortality, and costs for lead poisoning, asthma, cancer, and developmental disabilities. Environ. Health Perspect. 2002 Jul;110(7): 721–728.

51.

Grosse

S. D.

Matte

T. D.

Schwartz

, and Jackson

R. J.

. Economic gains resulting from the reduction in children's exposure to lead in the United States. Environ. Health Perspect. 2002 Jun;110(6): 563–569.

52.

Stefanak

Diorio

, and Frisch

. Cost of child lead poisoning to taxpayers in Mahoning County, Ohio. Public Health Rep. 2005 May-Jun;120(3): 311–315.

53.

Alliance for Healthy Homes. Available at: http://www.afhh.org/. Accessed 2/8/2010, 2010.

54.

Lanphear

B. P.

Howard

Eberly

Auinger

Kolassa

Weitzman

. Primary prevention of childhood lead exposure: A randomized trial of dust control. Pediatrics 1999 Apr;103(4 Pt 1): 772–777.

55.

Kwong

K. T.

Friello

, and Semba

R. D.

. Interactions between iron deficiency and lead poisoning: epidemiology and pathogenesis. Sci. Total Environ. 2004 Sep 1; 330(1–3): 21–37.

56.

Bruening

Kemp

F. W.

Simone

Holding

Louria

D. B.

, and Bogden

J. D.

. Dietary calcium intakes of urban children at risk of lead poisoning. Environ. Health Perspect. 1999 Jun;107(6): 431–435.

57.

Lanphear

B. P.

. 2005. Personal communication.

58.

Wilson

Pivetz

Ashley

Jacobs

Strauss

Menkedick

. Evaluation of HUD-funded lead hazard control treatments at 6 years post-intervention. Environ. Res. 2006 Oct;102(2): 237–248.

59.

Weitzman

Aschengrau

Bellinger

Jones

Hamlin

J. S.

, and Beiser

. Lead-contaminated soil abatement and urban children's blood lead levels. JAMA 1993 Apr 7;269(13): 1647–1654.

60.

Caravanos

Weiss

A. L.

Blaise

M. J.

, and Jaeger

R. J.

. A survey of spatially distributed exterior dust lead loadings in New York City. Environ. Res. 2006 Feb;100(2): 165–172.

61.

Lee

K. N.

. Compass and gyroscope: integrating science and politics for the environment. Washington, DC: Island Press; 1993.

62.

Haas

P. M.

. Saving the Mediterranean: the politics of international environmental cooperation. New York: Columbia University Press; 1990.