In 2007, a Filipina organization in Quebec (PINAY) sought the help of university researchers to document the workplace health and safety experiences of domestic workers. Together, they surveyed 150 domestic workers and produced a report that generated interest from community groups, policymakers, and the media. In this article, we—the university researchers—offer a case study of community-university action research. We share the story of how one project contributed to academic knowledge of domestic workers' health and safety experiences and also to a related policy campaign. We describe how Quebec workers' compensation legislation excludes domestic workers, and we analyze the occupational health literature related to domestic work. Striking data related to workplace accidents and illnesses emerged from the survey, and interesting lessons were learned about how occupational health questions should be posed. We conclude with a description of the successful policy advocacy that was possible as an outcome of this project.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CampbellC., “La conformité de l'exclusion du domestique et du gardien de la protection automatique de la Loi sur les accidents du travail et les maladies professionnelles à la Charte des droits et libertés,” (“Compliance with the exclusion of domestic workers and childcare-givers from automatic protection of the Act respecting industrial accidents and occupational diseases by the Charter of Rights and Freedoms“), Quebec Human Rights Commission, Cat. 2.120-2.68 (2008).
2.
de GrootR. and OuelletE., “Plus que parfaites. Les aides familiales a Montréal 1850–2000,” (Past perfect. Domestic helpers in Montreal 1850–2000”), (Montreal, Edition du Remue-menage, 2001).
Human Resources and Skills Development Canada (HRSDC), Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC), Ministry of Relations with Citizens and Immigrants (MRCI), Labor Standards Commission (CNT), “Programme des aides familiaux résidants: des solutions aux problèmes actuels,” (“The Live-In Caregiver Program: solutions to current problems”), Ottawa, Report from the Interdepartmental Working Group (2003).
5.
LippelK., “La protection défaillante de la santé des travailleurs autonomes et des sous-traitants en droit québécois de la santé au travail,” (“The Failing Health Protection of Autonomous and Contract Workers in Quebec Occupational Health Law”), Santé, société, Solidarité (Health, Society, Solidarity) 2 (2004): 101–110.
6.
BoivinL., “Les femmes dans l'engrenage mondialisé de la concurrence, étude de cas sur les travailleuses des services d'aide à domicile au Québec,” (“Women caught up in global competition: a case study of homecare workers in Quebec”), (Montréal: Conseil D'intervention Pour L'accès des Femmes au Travail, 2007).
7.
GubermanN. and CôtéD., “Pourquoi la Commission de la santé et de la sécurité du travail du Québec n'est pas le premier recours des enseignantes et des préposées à l'aide domestique ayant des lésions professionnelles,” (“Why is the Quebec Commission of Occupational Health and Safety not the First Recourse for Domestic Workers?”), Revue PISTES7, no. 2 (2005): http://www.pistes.uqam.ca/v7/n2/pdf/v7n2a3.pdf
8.
RollinsJ., Between Women: Domestics and their Employers (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1985).
9.
AhonenE. Q.Lopez-JacobM. J.VazquezM. L.PorthéV.Gil-GonzalezD.GarciaA. M.Ruiz-FrutosC.BenachJ., and BenavidesF. G., “Invisible Work, Unseen Hazards: The Health of Women Immigrant Household Service Workers in Spain,”American Journal of Industrial Medicine53, no. 4 (2009): 405–416.
10.
SalesE. C. and SantanaV. S., “Depressive and Anxiety Symptoms among Housemaids,”American Journal of Industrial Medicine44, no. 6 (2003): 685–691.
11.
HabibR.R.FathallahF. A.MessingK., “Full-time Homemakers: Workers who Cannot ‘Go Home and Relax’,”International Journal of Occupational Safety and Ergonomics16, no. 1 (2010): 113–128.
12.
CloutierE.LedouxE.BourdouxheM.DavidH.GagnonI., and OuelletF., “Restructuring of the Quebec Health Network and its Effects on the Profession of Home Health Aides and their Occupational Health and Safety,”New Solutions17, no. 1–2 (2007): 83–95.
13.
GucerP. W.OliverM.ParrishJ., and McDiarmidM., “Work Productivity Impairment from Musculoskeletal Disorder Pain in Long-Term Caregivers,”Journal of Occupational & Environmental Medicine51, no. 6 (2009): 672–681.
14.
Slack-SmithL. M.ReadA. W., and StanleyF. J., “Health of Caregivers in Child Care,”Child Care Health Development32, no. 1 (2006): 111–119.
15.
SharipovaM.BorgV., and HoghA., “Prevalence, Seriousness and Reporting of Work-Related Violence in the Danish Elderly Care,”Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences22, no. 4 (2008): 574–581.
16.
DelpL.WallaceS. P.Geiger-BrownJ., and MuntanerC., “Job Stress and Job Satisfaction: Home Care Workers in a Consumer-Directed Model of Care,”Health Services Research45, no. 4 (2010): 922–940.
17.
BarlingJ.RogersA. G., and KellowayE. K., “Behind Closed Doors: In-Home Workers' Experience of Sexual Harassment and Workplace Violence,”Journal of Occupational Health Psychology6, no. 3 (2001): 255–269.
18.
SwansonN. G.PiotrkowskiC. S.CurbowB.GravilleS.KushnirT., and OwenB. D., “Occupational Health and Safety Issues in Child-Care Work,”Pediatrics94, no. 6 (1994): 1079–1080.
19.
NIOSH Hazard Review, “Occupational Hazards in Home Healthcare,” NIOSH Publication No. 2010-125 (January, 2010).
20.
ScherzerT.RuguliesR., and KrauseN., “Work-related Pain and Injury and Barriers to Workers' Compensation among Las Vegas Hotel Room Cleaners,”American Journal of Public Health95, no. 3 (2005): 483–488.
21.
PremjiS.LippelK., and MessingK., “On travaille à la seconde! Rémunération à la pièce et santé et sécurité du travail dans une perspective qui tient compte de l'ethnicité et du genre,” (“We work by the second! Piecework renumeration and occuapational health and safety from an ethnicity and gender-sensitive perspective”), Revue PISTES1, no. 1 (2008) http://www.pistes.uqam.ca/v10n1/articles/v10n1a2.htm
22.
BurgelB. J.LashuayN.IsraelL., and HarrisonR., “Garment Workers in California: Health Outcomes of the Asian Immigrant Women Workers Clinic,”American Association of Occupational Health Nurses Journal52, No. 11 (2004): 465–475.
23.
LipscombH. J.EplingC. A.PompeiiL. A., and DementJ. M., “Musculoskeletal Symptoms among Poultry Processing Workers and a Community Comparison Group: Black Women in Low-wage Jobs in the Rural South,”American Journal of Industrial Medicine50, no. 5 (2007): 327–338.
24.
MessingK. and StellmanJ. M., “Sex, Gender and Women's Occupational Health: The Importance of Considering Mechanism,”Environmental Research101, no. 2 (2006): 149–162.
25.
MessingK., One-eyed Science: Occupational Health and Women Workers (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1998).
26.
ReidJ.EwanC., and LowyE., “Pilgrimage of Pain: The Illness Experiences of Women with Repetition Strain Injury and the Search for Credibility,”Social Science and Medicine32, no. 5 (1991): 601–612.
27.
LippelK., “Compensation for Musculoskeletal Disorders in Quebec: Systemic Discrimination against Women Workers?,”International Journal of Health Services33, no. 2 (2003): 253–281.
28.
CoxR. and LippelK., “Falling through the Legal Cracks: The Pitfalls of Using Workers' Compensation Data as Indicators of Work-Related Injuries and Illnesses,”Policy and Practice in Health and Safety6, no. 2 (2008): 9–30.
29.
AzaroffL. S.LevensteinC., and WegmanD. H., “Occupational Injury and Illness Surveillance: Conceptual Filters Explain Underreporting,”American Journal of Public Health92, no. 9 (2002): 1421–1429.
30.
BuchananS.VossenasP.KrauseN.MoriartyJ.FruminE.ShimekJ.A.M.MirerF.OrrisP., and PunnettL., “Occupational Injury Disparities in the U.S. Hotel Industry,”American Journal of Industrial Medicine53, no. 2 (2010): 116–125.
31.
PremjiS.DuguayP.MessingK.LippelK., “Are Immigrants, Ethnic and Linguistic Minorities Over-Represented in Jobs with a High Level of Compensated Risk? Results from a Montréal, Canada Study Using Census and Workers' Compensation Data,”American Journal of Industrial Medicine53, no. 9 (2010): 875–885.
32.
BonautoD. K.SmithC. K.AdamsD. A.FanZ. J.SilversteinB. A., and FoleyM. P., “Language Preference and Non-Traumatic Low Back Disorders in Washington State Workers' Compensation,”American Journal of Industrial Medicine53, no. 2 (2010): 204–215.
33.
GravelS.BrodeurJ. M.ChampagneF.LippelK.VissandjéeB., “Incompréhension des travailleurs immigrants victimes de lésions professionnelles de leurs difficultés d'accéder à l'indemnisation,” (“Immigrant worker victims of work-related injuries and their lack of knowledge about the difficulty of accessing compensation”), Migration et santé131, no. 2 (2007): 11–42.
