Few pediatric primary care providers routinely use mental health screening tools, in part because they may have concerns about whether screening is useful and how it will affect their practice. This study examined the extent to which screening in primary care would increase the identification of mental health problems among a diverse population of children and youth.
Methods:
Prior to the visit, the parents of 767 patients age 5 to 16 completed the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire to report their child's mental health symptoms and impairment. Without viewing the screening results, each child's provider (N = 53) completed a questionnaire to report whether the child or youth demonstrated a mental health problem.
Results:
Compared with providers, the screen identified twice as many patients with moderate symptoms and nearly 28% more patients with high symptoms. Among patients with high symptoms, providers failed to identify a problem among 78% of those who were Latino/Other and 55% of those who were African American compared with 27% of Caucasian patients (p < 0.001). Providers were not more likely to identify patients with externalizing versus internalizing symptoms but were more likely to identify patients who demonstrated symptoms across multiple domains of functioning.
Conclusions:
Screening substantially increased the number of children and youth who would be identified as possibly having a mental health problem. Screening may have the most potential to increase the identification of problems among patients who have moderate mental health symptoms and those who are African American or Latino.
LavigneJVBinnsHJChristoffelKKRosenbaumDArendRSmithK. Behavioral and emotional problems among preschool children in pediatric primary care: Prevalence and pediatricians' recognition. Pediatrics1993; 91(3): 649–655.
2.
RichardsonLAKellerAMSelby-HarringtonMLParrishR. Identification and treatment of children's mental health problems by primary care providers: A critical review of research. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing1996; 10(5): 293–303.
3.
LogsdonMC. Depression in adolescent girls: Screening and treatment strategies for primary care providers. Journal of the American Medical Womens Association2004; 59(2): 101–106.
4.
FrankenfieldDLKeylPMGielenAWissowLSWerthamerLBakerSP. Adolescent patients—Healthy or hurting? Missed opportunities to screen for suicide risk in the primary care setting. Archives of Pediatric Adolescent Medicine2000; 154(2): 162–168.
5.
BrugmanEReijneveldSAVerhulstFCVerloove-VanhorickSP. Identification and management of psychosocial problems by preventive child health care. Archives of Pediatric Adolescent Medicine2001; 155(4): 462–469.
6.
BorowskyIWMozayenySIrelandM. Brief psychosocial screening at health supervision and acute care visits. Pediatrics2003; 112(1 Pt 1): 129–133.
7.
WrenFJScholleSHHeoJComerDM. Pediatric mood and anxiety syndromes in primary care: Who gets identified. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine2003; 33(1): 1–16.
8.
GardnerWKelleherKJPajerKACampoJV. Primary care clinicians' use of standardized tools to assess child psychosocial problems. Ambulatory Pediatrics2003; 3(4): 191–195.
9.
OlsonALKelleherKJKemperKJZuckermanBSHammondCSDietrichAJ. Primary care pediatricians' roles and perceived responsibilities in the identification and management of depression in children and adolescents. Ambulatory Pediatrics2001; 1(2): 91–98.
10.
CooperSValleleyRJPolahaJBegenyJEvansJH. Running out of time: Physician management of behavioral health concerns in rural pediatric primary care. Pediatrics2006; 118(1): e132–e138.
11.
McLennanJDJansen-McWilliamsLComerDMGardnerWPKelleherKJ. The physician belief scale and psychosocial problems in children: A report from the pediatric research in office settings and the ambulatory sentinel practice network. Journal of Deviant Behavior in Pediatrics1999; 20(1): 24–30.
12.
KelleherKJMcInernyTKGardnerWPChildsGEWassermanRC. Increasing identification of psychosocial problems: 1979–1996. Pediatrics2000; 105(6): 1313–1321.
13.
CostelloEJEdelbrockCCostelloAJDulcanMKBurnsBJBrentD. Psychopathology in pediatric primary care: The new hidden morbidity. Pediatrics1988; 82(3 Pt 2): 415–424.
14.
HorwitzSMLeafPJLeventhalJMForsythBSpeechleyKN. Identification and management of psychosocial and developmental problems in community-based, primary care pediatric practices. Pediatrics1992; 89(3): 480–485.
15.
BorowskyIWMozayenySIrelandM. Brief psychosocial screening at health supervision and acute care visits. Pediatrics2003; 112(1 Pt 1): 129–133.
16.
KostaneckaAPowerTClarkeAWatkinsMHausmanCLBlumNJ. Behavioral health screening in urban primary care settings: Construct validity of the PSC-17. Journal of Deviant Behavior in Pediatrics2008; 29(2): 124–128.
17.
StoppelbeinLGreeningLJordanSSElkinTDMollGPullenJ. Factor analysis of the pediatric symptom checklist with a chronically ill pediatric population. Journal of Deviant Behavior in Pediatrics2005; 26(5): 349–355.
18.
Briggs-GowanMJCarterASIrwinJRWachtelKCicchettiDV. The brief infant-toddler social and emotional assessment: Screening for social-emotional problems and delays in competence. Journal of Pediatric Psychology2004; 29(2): 143–155.
19.
JellinekMSMurphyJMBurnsBJ. Brief psychosocial screening in outpatient pediatric practice. Journal of Pediatrics1986; 109(2): 371–378.
20.
WinterLBSteerRAJones-HicksLBeckAT. Screening for major depression disorders in adolescent medical outpatients with the beck depression inventory for primary care. Journal of Adolescent Health1999; 24(6): 389–394.
21.
JellinekMSMurphyJMLittleMPaganoMEComerDMKelleherKJ. Use of the pediatric symptom checklist to screen for psychosocial problems in pediatric primary care: A national feasibility study. Archives of Pediatric Adolescent Medicine1999; 153(3): 254–260.
22.
KelleherKJMooreCDChildsGEAngelilliMLComerDM. Patient race and ethnicity in primary care management of child behavior problems: A report from PROS and ASPN. Medical Care1999; 37(11): 1092–1104.
23.
ChaviraDASteinMBBaileyKSteinMT. Child anxiety in primary care: Prevalent but untreated. Depression and Anxiety2004; 20(4): 155–164.
24.
TarshisTPJutteDPHuffmanLC. Provider recognition of psychosocial problems in low-income Latino children. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved2006; 17(2): 342–357.
25.
CostelloEJShugartMA. Above and below the threshold: Severity of psychiatric symptoms and functional impairment in a pediatric sample. Pediatrics1992; 90(3): 359–368.
26.
LeafPJOwensPLLeventhalJMForsythBWVaden-KiernanMEpsteinLD. Pediatricians' training and identification and management of psychosocial problems. Clinical Pediatrics2004; 43(4): 355–365.
27.
WissowLSGadomskiARoterDLarsonSBrownJZacharyC. Improving child and parent mental health in primary care: A cluster-randomized trial of communication skills training. Pediatrics2008; 121(2): 266–275.
28.
KelleherKJChildsGEWassermanRCMcInernyTKNuttingPAGardnerWP. Insurance status and recognition of psychosocial problems. A report from the pediatric research in office settings and the ambulatory sentinel practice networks. Archives of Pediatric Adolescent Medicine1997; 151(11): 1109–1115.
29.
StangeKCZyzanskiSJSmithTFKellyRLangaDMFlockeSA. How valid are medical records and patient questionnaires for physician profiling and health services research? A comparison with direct observation of patients visits. Medical Care1998; 36(6): 851–867.
30.
CradockJYoungASSullivanG. The accuracy of medical record documentation in schizophrenia. Journal of Behavior in Health Service Research2001; 28(4): 456–465.
31.
GoodmanR. The extended version of the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire as a guide to child psychiatric caseness and consequent burden. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry1999; 40(5): 791–799.
32.
BourdonKHGoodmanRRaeDSSimpsonGKoretzDS. The Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire: U.S. normative data and psychometric properties. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry2005; 44(6): 557–564.
33.
GerraldaME. & BaileyD. (1986). Children with psychiatric disorders in primary care. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry1986; 27(5) 611–624.
34.
Briggs-GowanMJOwensPLSchwab-StoneMELeventhalJMLeafPJHorwitzSM. Persistence of psychiatric disorders in pediatric settings. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry2003; 42(11): 1360–1369.
35.
WissowLAnthonyBBrownJDosReisSGadomskiAGinsburgG. A common factors approach to improving the mental health capacity of pediatric primary care. Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research2008; 35(4): 305–318.
36.
AsarnowJRJaycoxLHDuanNLaBordeAPReaMMMurrayP. Effectiveness of a quality improvement intervention for adolescent depression in primary care clinics: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of the American Medical Association2005; 293(3): 311–319.
37.
LeslieLKWeckerlyJPlemmonsDLandsverkJEastmanS. Implementing the american academy of pediatrics attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder diagnostic guidelines in primary care settings. Pediatrics2004; 114(1): 129–140.
38.
BrownJDWissowLS. Discussion of sensitive health topics with youth during primary care visits: Relationship to youth perceptions of care. Journal of Adolescent Health2009; 44: 48–54.
39.
AngoldAErkanliAFarmerEMFairbankJABurnsBJKeelerG. Psychiatric disorder, impairment, and service use in rural African American and white youth. Archives of General Psychiatry2002; 59(10): 893–901.
40.
HoughRLHazenALSorianoFIWoodPMcCabeKYehM. Mental health services for Latino adolescents with psychiatric disorders. Psychiatric Services2002; 53(12): 1556–1562.
41.
SnowdenLR. Barriers to effective mental health services for African Americans. Mental Health Services Research2001; 3: 181–187.
42.
BrownJDWissowLSZacharyCCookBL. Receiving advice about child mental health from a primary care provider: African American and Hispanic parent attitudes. Medical Care2007; 45(11): 1076–1082.
43.
ArciaEFernandezMCJaquezM. Latina mothers' stances on stimulant medication: Complexity, conflict, and compromise. Journal of Deviant Behavior in Pediatrics2004; 25(5): 311–317.
44.
SomnathSKomaromyMKoepsellTDBindmanAB. Patient-physician racial concordance and the perceived quality and use of health care. Archives of Internal Medicine1999; 159: 997–1004.
45.
StreetRLO'MalleyKJCooperLAHaidetP. Understanding concordance in patient-physician relationships: Personal and ethnic dimensions of shared identity. Annals of Family Medicine2008; 6: 198–205.
46.
VegaWALopezSR. Priority issues in Latino mental health services research. Mental Health Services Research2001; 3(4)189–200.
