The Comparative Effectiveness of Systematic Desensitization and an Integrative Approach in Treating Public Speaking Anxiety: A Literature Review and a Preliminary Investigation
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online September, 1989
The Comparative Effectiveness of Systematic Desensitization and an Integrative Approach in Treating Public Speaking Anxiety: A Literature Review and a Preliminary Investigation
An analysis of the literature related to public speaking anxiety (PSA) and various treatments of it are discussed. PSA is a state or situational type of anxiety which can have tremendous effects on those who suffer from it. Two of the major treatments–systematic desensitization (SD) and the integrative approach (IA) are reviewed and then experimentally tested to determine which is the more effective in treating PSA. The results are somewhat inclusive but there is strong evidence to suggest that both SD and IA reduce trait and state anxiety. It was, however, found that IA is more effective in decreasing the symptoms associated with PSA.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
HollingsworthH. L., The Psychology of the Audience, American Books, New York, 1935.
2.
Bruskin Associates, “What Are Americans Afraid Of?”The Bruskin Report, 53, p. 27, 1973.
3.
McCroskeyJ. C., Oral Communication Apprehension: A Summary of Recent Theory and Research, Human Communication Research, 4, pp. 78–96, 1977.
4.
MulacA.ShermanA. R., Behavioral Assessment of Speech Anxiety, Quarterly Journal of Speech, 60, p. 138, 1974.
5.
AsteritaM., The Physiology of Stress, Human Sciences Press, New York, 1985.
6.
BudzynskiT. H.StoyvaJ., Biofeedback Techniques in Behavior Therapy, reprinted in Biofeedback and Self Control: 1972, ShafiroD.BarberT. X.DiCaraL.KamiyaJ.MillerN.StoyvaJ. (eds.), Aldine, Chicago, 1973.
7.
WolpeJ., Psychotherapy by Reciprocal Inhibition, Stanford University Press, Stanford, 1958.
8.
SelyeH., The Stress of Life, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1976.
9.
MirskyI. A., Physiologic, Psychologic and Social Determinants in the Etiology of Duodenal Ulcer, American Journal of Digestive Disease, 3, pp. 285–314, 1958.
10.
EverlyJ.RosenfeldR., The Nature and Treatment of the Stress Response, Plenum Press, New York, 1981.
11.
RileyV., Mouse Mammary Tumors: Alteration of Incidence as an Apparent Function of Stress, Science, 189, pp. 465–467, 1975.
12.
McCroskeyJ. C.RichmondV. P., The Effects of Communication Apprehension on the Perception of Peers, Western Speech Communication Journal, 40, pp. 14–21, 1976.
13.
DalyJ. A.McCroskeyJ. C., Occupational Choice and Desirability as a Function of Communication Apprehension, Journal of Counseling Psychology, 22, pp. 309–313, 1975.
14.
McCroskeyJ. C.RichmondV. P., Self-Credibility as an Index of Self-Esteem, Paper presented at the Speech Communication Association Convention, Houston, Texas, 1975.
15.
BuehlerE. C.LinkugelW., Speech: A First Course, Harper & Row Publishers, New York, 1962.
16.
AllenD. R.HittM. A.CreerC. R., Occupational Stress and Perceived Organizational Effectiveness in Formal Groups: An Examination of Stress Level and Stress Type, Personnel Psychology, 35, pp. 358–369, 1982.
17.
AndersonC. R., Coping Behaviors as Intervening Mechanisms in the Inverted-U Stress-Performance Relationship, Journal of Applied Psychology, 61, pp. 3–34, 1976.
18.
BurkeR. J., Occupational Stresses and Job Satisfaction, The Journal of Social Psychology, 100, pp. 235–244, 1976.
19.
YerkesK. M.DodsonJ. D., The Relation of Strength of Stimulus to Rapidity of Habit Formation, Journal of Comparative and Neurological Psychology, 18, pp. 459–482, 1908.
20.
BeattyM. J., Situational and Predispositional Correlates of Public Speaking Anxiety, Communication Education, 37, pp. 28–39, 1988.
21.
ClevengerT.Jr.KingT. R., A Factor Analysis of the Visible Symptoms of Stagefright, Speech Monographs, 28, pp. 245–247, 1967.
22.
PhillipsG. M.MetzgerN. J., The Reticent Syndrome: Some Theoretical Considerations About Etiology and Treatment, Speech Monographs, 40, pp. 220–230, 1973.
23.
GlasserW., Reality Therapy: A New Approach to Psychiatry, Harper & Row, New York, 1965.
24.
GlaserS. R., Toward Communication Competence: Developing Interpersonal Skills, Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, New York, 1980.
25.
McFallR. M.LillelandD. B., Behavior Rehearsal with Modeling and Coaching in Assertion Training, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 77, pp. 313–323, 1971.
26.
McFallR. M.MarstonA. R., An Experimental Investigation of Behavior Rehearsal in Assertiveness Training, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 76, pp. 295–303, 1970.
27.
BorkovecT. D.WallR. L.StoneN. M., False Physiological Feedback and the Maintenance of Speech Anxiety, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 83, pp. 164–168, 1974.
28.
MotleyM. T., Stage Fright Manipulation by (False) Heart Rate Feedback, Central States Speech Journal, 27, pp. 186–191, 1976.
29.
GiffinK.BradleyK., An Exploratory Study of Group Counseling for Speech Anxiety, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 25, pp. 98–101, 1969.
30.
BarkerL. L.CegalaD. J.KiblerR. J.WahlersK. J., Hypnosis and the Reduction of Speech Anxiety, Central States Speech Journal, 23, pp. 28–35, 1973.
McCroskeyJ. C., The Implementation of a Large Scale Program of Systematic Desensitization for Communication Apprehension, Speech Teacher, 21, pp. 255–264, 1972.
33.
KondasO., Reduction of Examination Anxiety and Stage Fright by Group Desensitization and Relaxation, Behavior Research and Therapy, 5, pp. 275–280, 1967.
34.
PaulG. L.ShannonD. T., Treatment of Anxiety Through Systematic Desensitization in Therapy Groups, Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 71, pp. 124–135, 1966.
35.
LangP. J.LazovikA. D., Experimental Desensitization of a Phobia, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 66, pp. 519–525, 1963.
36.
FremouwW. J.ScottM. D., Cognitive Restructuring: An Alternative Method for the Treatment of Communication Apprehension, Communication Education, 28, pp. 129–133, 1979.
37.
MeichenbaumD. H.CameroR., The Clinical Potential of Modifying What Clients Say to Themselves, in Self-Control: Power to the Person, MahoneyM. J.ThoresenC. E. (eds.), Brooks/Cole, Monterey, California, 1974.
38.
EllisA., Reason and Emotion in Psychotherapy, Lyle-Stuart, New York, 1963.
39.
CurranJ. P., An Evolution of a Skills Training Program and a Systematic Desensitization Program in Reducing Dating Anxiety, Behavior Research and Therapy, 13, pp. 65–68, 1975.
40.
CurranJ. P.GilbertF. S., A Test of the Relative Effectiveness of a Systematic Desensitization Program with Date Anxious Subjects, Behavior Therapy, 6, pp. 510–521, 1975.
41.
KauferF. H.PhillipsJ. S., Learning Foundations of Behavior Therapy, John Wiley, New York, 1970.
42.
McCroskeyJ. C.RalphD. C.BarrickJ. E., The Effect of Systematic Desensitization on Speech Anxiety, Speech Teacher, 19, pp. 32–36, 1970.
43.
MarquisJ. N.MorganW. G.PiagetG. W., A Guidebook for Systematic Desensitization, Veterans Workshop, Palo Alto, California, 1973.
44.
JacobsonE., Progressive Relaxation, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1938.
45.
BensonH., The Relaxation Response, Morrow, New York, 1975.
46.
MurrayE. J.JacobsonL. I., The Nature of Learning in Traditional and Behavioral Psychotherapy, in Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change, BerginA. E.GarfieldS. L. (eds.), Wiley, New York, 1971.
47.
WolpeJ., The Systematic Desensitization of Neuroses, Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 132, pp. 189–203, 1961.
48.
McCroskeyJ. C., Measures of Communication-Bound Anxiety, Speech Monographs, 37, pp. 269–277, 1970.
49.
GossB.ThompsonM.OldsS., Behavioral Support Systematic Desensitization for Communication Apprehension, Human Communication Research, 4, pp. 158–163, 1978.
50.
LohrJ. W.McManusM. L., The Development of an Audiotaped Treatment for Systematic Desensitization of Speech Anxiety, Central States Speech Journal, 26, pp. 215–220, 1975.
51.
AyresJ.HopfT. S., A Means of Reducing Speech Anxiety, Communication Education, 34, pp. 318–323, 1985.
52.
GlaserS. R., Oral Communication Apprehension and Avoidance: The Current Status of Treatment Research, Communication Education, 30, pp. 321–341, 1981.
53.
WoolfolkR. L.LehrerD., Principles and Practice of Stress Management, Guilford Press, New York, 1984.
54.
PorterG.NorrisP. A., Why Me?, Stillpoint Publishing, Walpole, New Hampshire, 1985.
55.
NorrisP., Biofeedback, Voluntary Control, and Human Potential, Biofeedback and Self-Regulation, 11, pp. 1–20, 1986.
56.
GreenE. E.GreenA. M.WaltersE. D., Voluntary Control of Internal States: Psychological and Physiological, Journal of Transpersonal Psychology, 1, pp. 1–26, 1970.
57.
AyresJ.HopfT. S., Visualization, Systematic Desensitization, and Rational Emotive Therapy: A Comparative Evaluation, Communication Education, 36, pp. 236–240, 1987.
58.
McCroskeyJ. C., An Introduction to Rhetorical Communication, (4th ed.), Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 1982.
59.
McCroskeyJ. C.RichmondV. P., The Quiet Ones: Communication Apprehension and Shyness, Gorsuch Sarisbrick Publishers, Dubuque, 1980.
60.
McCroskeyJ. C.BeattyM. J., Communication Apprehension and Communication State Anxiety Experiences: A Research Note, Communication Monographs, 51, pp. 79–83, 1984.
61.
SpielbergerC. D.GorsuchR. L.LusheneR.VaggP. R.JacobsG. A., Manual for the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory, Consulting Psychologists Press, Palo Alto, California, 1983.
62.
BeattyM. J.BehnkeR. R., An Assimilation Theory Perspective of Communication Apprehension, Human Communication Research, 6, pp. 319–325, 1980.
63.
ClevengerT., Psychophysiological Research in Communication: A Review of the Literature, Paper presented at the Annual Convention of the Speech Communication Association, Chicago, 1984.
64.
StoyvaJ.BudzynskiT., Cultivated Low Arousal–An Anti-Stress Response? in Limbic and Autonomic Nervous System Research, DiCaraL. V. (ed.), Plenum, New York, 1974.
65.
BlanchardE. B.YoungL. D., Self-Control of Cardiac Functioning: A Promise as Yet Unfulfilled, Psychological Bulletin, 79, pp. 145–163, 1973.
66.
GatchelR. J., Biofeedback and the Treatment of Fear and Anxiety, in Clinical Applications of Biofeedback: Appraisal and Status, GatchelR. S.PriceK. P. (eds.), Pergamon, New York, 1979.
67.
SuinnR. M.RichardsonF., Anxiety Management Training: A Nonspecific Behavior Therapy Program for Anxiety Control, Behavior Therapy, 2, pp. 498–510, 1971.
68.
RyanE. D.SimonsJ., Efficacy of Mental Imagery in Enhancing Mental Rehearsal of Motor Skills, Journal of Sport Psychology, 4, pp. 41–51, 1982.
69.
ClarkL. V., Effect of Mental Practice on the Development of Certain Motor Skill, Research Quarterly, 31, pp. 560–569, 1960.
70.
RosenthalR.JacobsonL., Pygmalion in the Classroom, Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, New York, 1968.
71.
WatsonA. K.DoddC. H., Alleviating Communication Apprehension Through Rational Emotive Therapy: A Comparative Evaluation, Communication Education, 33, pp. 257–266, 1984.
72.
LangP. J., Fear Reduction and Fear Behavior: Problems in Treating a Construct, in Research in Psychotherapy, ShlienJ. M. (ed.), American Psychological Association, Washington, D.C., 1968.
