Changes in the social organization of home care work due to health care restructuring have affected the job stress and job dissatisfaction of home care workers. This article reports the results of a survey of 892 employees from three nonprofit home care agencies in a medium-sized city in Ontario, Canada. Survey results are complemented by data from 16 focus groups with 99 employees. For the purposes of this study, home care workers include both office workers (managers, supervisors, coordinators, office support staff, and case managers) and visiting workers (nurses, therapists, and visiting homemakers). Focus group participants indicated that health care restructuring has resulted in organizational change, budget cuts, heavier workloads, job insecurity, loss of organizational support, loss of peer support, and loss of time to provide emotional laboring, or the “caring” aspects of home care work. Analyses of survey data show that organizational change, fear of job loss, heavy workloads, and lack of organizational and peer support lead to increased job stress and decreased levels of job satisfaction.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
GillD.G., and IngmanS. R.Eldercare, Distributive Justice, and the Welfare State: Retrenchment or Expansion.State University of New York Press, Albany, 1994.
2.
WilliamsA.The development of Ontario's home care program: A critical geographical analysis. Soc. Sci. Med.42(6): 937–948, 1996.
3.
KaneN. M., and SaltmanR. B.Comparative experience in home care and pharmaceutical policy. Health Policy41: S1–S7, 1997.
4.
LesemannF., and MartinL. (eds.). Home-Based Care: The Elderly, the Family, and the Welfare State: An International Comparison.University of Ottawa Press, Ottawa, 1993.
5.
Federal/Provincial/Territorial Working Group on Home Care. Report on Home Care.Health Services and Promotion Branch, Health and Welfare Canada, Ottawa, 1990.
6.
Canadian Association for Retired Persons (CARP). Putting a Face on Home Care: CARP's Report on Home Care in Canada 1999.Queen's Health Policy Research Unit, Queens University, Kingston, Ont., 1999.
7.
DentonM.ZeytinogluI. U.WebbS., and LianJ.Occupational health issues among employees of home care agencies. Can. J. Aging18(2): 154–181, 1999.
8.
McQuaigL.Shooting the Hippo: Death by Deficit and Other Canadian Myths.Viking, Toronto, 1995.
9.
McDanielS. A.Health care policy in an aging Canada: The Alberta ‘experiment.’J. Aging Stud.11(3): 211–227, 1997.
10.
AronsonJ., and NeysmithS.The retreat of the state and long-term care provision: Implications for frail elderly people, unpaid family carers and paid home care workers. Stud. Polit. Econ.53: 37–66, 1997.
11.
ArmstrongP., and ArmstrongH.Wasting Away: The Undermining of Canadian Health Care.Oxford University Press, Toronto, 1996.
12.
GrayC.Visions of our Medicare future: Status quo has become a dirty word in Canadian health care. CMAJ154(5): 693–696, 1996.
13.
ChappellN.Implications of shifting health care policy for caregiving in Canada. J. Aging Soc. Policy5(1/2): 39–55, 1993.
14.
AronsonJ., and NeysmithS.“You're not just in there to do the work”: Depersonalizing policies and the exploitation of home care workers' labor. Gender Society10(1): 59–77, 1996.
15.
AronsonJ., and NeysmithS.The work of visiting homemakers in the context of cost cutting in long term care. Can. J. Public Health87(6): 422–425, 1996.
16.
Canadian Home Care Association. Investing in Home Care: A Wise Priority. Briefing Document Submitted to the Standing Committee on Finance. Ottawa, 1998.
17.
McDanielS. A., and ChappellN. L.Health care in regression: Contradictions, tensions and implications for Canadian seniors. Can. Public Policy25(1): 123–132, 1999.
18.
MhatreS. L., and DeberR. B.From equal access to health care to equitable access to health: A review of Canadian provincial health commissions and reports. Int. J. Health Serv.22(4): 645–668, 1992.
19.
RafuseJ.Private-sector share of health spending hits record level. CMAJ155(6): 749–750, 1996.
20.
HavensB.Long-term care diversity within the care continuum. Can. J. Aging14(2): 245–262, 1995.
21.
DeberR. B., and WilliamsA. P.Policy, payment, and participation: Long-term care reform in Ontario. Can. J. Aging14(2): 294–318, 1995.
22.
Ontario, Ministry of Community and Social Services, Ministry of Health, Office for Senior Citizens' Affairs, Office for Disabled Persons. Strategies for Change: Comprehensive Reform of Ontario's Long-Term Care Services.Toronto, 1990.
23.
Ontario. Redirection of Long-Term Care and Support Services in Ontario—A Public Consultation Paper.Queen's Printer for Ontario, Toronto, October 1991.
24.
Ontario, Ministry of Health, Ministry of Community and Social Services, Ministry of Citizenship. Partnerships in Long-term Care: A New Way to Plan, Manage, and Deliver Community Support—A Policy Framework.Queen's Printer for Ontario, Toronto, April 1993.
25.
Ontario. Partnerships in Long-term Care: A New Way to Plan, Manage, and Deliver Services and Community Support—An Implementation Framework.Queen's Printer for Ontario, Toronto, June 1993.
26.
Ontario, Ministry of Health, Ministry of Community and Social Services, Ministry of Citizenship. Partnerships in Long-term Care: A New Way to Plan, Manage, and Deliver Services and Community Support—Guidelines of the Establishment of Multiservice Agencies.Queen's Printer for Ontario, Toronto, September 1993.
27.
Ontario Ministry of Health (Long Term Care Division). Community Care Access Centres.Board Orientation. Toronto, June 1996.
28.
HerronS. N.Tryingto heal at home. Hamilton Spectator, November 17, 1997, p. A7.
29.
GlazerN. Y.Overlooked, overworked: Women's unpaid and paid work in the health services' “cost crisis.”Int. J. Health Serv.18(1): 119–137, 1988.
30.
GlazerN. Y.Women's Paid and Unpaid Labor: The Work Transfer in Health Care and Retailing.Temple University Press, Philadelphia, 1993.
31.
O'ConnorM.Women and the Increase in Invisible Labour. Paper presented at the 6ème Congrès annuel de L'Association Latine pour l'Analyse des Systèmes de Santé, Montreal, 1995.
32.
MorrisM.The Changing Nature of Home Care and Its Impact on Women's Vulnerability to Poverty.Canadian Research Institute for the Advancement of Women, Ottawa, 1999.
33.
ArmstrongP.Voices from the Ward: A Pilot Study of the Impact of Cutbacks on Hospital Care. Occasional Paper prepared by York University Centre for Health Studies. Toronto, Ont., 1993.
34.
CameronS.HorsburghM., and Annstrong-StassenM.Effects of Downsizing on RNs and RNAs in Community Hospitals.Quality of Nursing Worklife Research Unit, Hamilton, Ont., 1994.
35.
SzaszA.The labor impacts of policy change in health care: How federal policy transformed home health organizations. J. Health Polit. Policy Law15(1): 191–210, 1990.
36.
Canadian Advisory Council on the Status of Women. What Women Prescribe: Report and Recommendations from the National Symposium Women in Partnership: Working Towards Inclusive, Gender-Sensitive Health Policies.Ottawa, 1995.
37.
DennersteinL.Mental health, work, and gender. Int. J. Health Serv.25(3): 503–509, 1995.
38.
PugliesiK.Work and well-being: Gender differences in the psychological consequences of employment. J. Health Soc. Behav.36: 57–71, March 1995.
39.
WaltersV.Paid and unpaid work roles of male and female nurses. In Issues in Women's Occupational Health: Invisible, La Sante des Travailleuses, edited by MessingK.NeisB., and DumaisL., pp. 125–149. Gynergy, Charlottetown, P.E.I., 1995.
40.
FeldmanP.SapienzaA., and KaneN.On the home front: The job of the home aide. Generations, Fall 1994, pp. 16–19.
41.
ChichinE.Home care is where the heart is: The role of interpersonal relationships in paraprofessional home care. Home Health Care Serv. Q.13(12): 161–177, 1992.
42.
NeysmithS., and NicholsM.Working conditions in home care: Comparing three groups of workers. Can. J. Aging13(2): 170–186, 1994.
43.
DentonM., and ZeytinogluI. U.Healthy Work Environments in Community Based Health and Social Service Agencies Stage One Report: Focus Group Findings. MRCPOWH Technical Report Series, No. 1. Hamilton, Ont., 1996.
44.
BartoldusB.GilleryB., and SturgesP. J.Job-related stress and coping among home-care workers with elderly people. Health Soc. Work, August 1989, pp. 204–210.
45.
NelsonD. L., and HittM. A.Employed women and stress: Implications for enhancing women's mental health in the workplace. In Stress and Well-Being at Work: Assessments and Interventions for Occupational Mental Health, edited by QuickJ. C.MurphyL. T., and HurrellJ. J.Jr., pp. 146–177. American Psychological Association, Washington, D.C., 1992.
46.
BalkaE.Technology as a factor in women's occupational stress. In Issues in Women's Occupational Health: Invisible, La Sante des Travailleuses, edited by MessingK.NeisB., and DumaisL., pp. 75–103. Gynergy, Charlottetown, P.E.I., 1995.
47.
WaltersV.Stress, anxiety and depression: Women's accounts of their health problems. Soc. Sci. Med.36: 393–402, 1993.
48.
WaltersV., and DentonM.Stress, depression and tiredness among women: The social production and social construction of health. Can. Rev. Sociol. Anthropol.31(1): 53–70, 1997.
49.
PrenticeD.Stress in visiting nursing (abstracts). First Annual Conference on the Quality of Nursing Worklife, p. 99. QNW Research Unit, March 26–27, Hamilton, Ont., 1992.
50.
Walcott-McQuiggJ.Worksite stress: Gender and cultural diversity issues. AAOHN J.42(11): 528–533, 1994.
51.
JonesF.FletcherB., and IbbetsonK.Stressors and strains amongst social workers: Demands, supports, constraints and psychological health. Br. J. Social Work21(5): 57–69, 1991.
52.
McHughM.Rationalization as a key stressor for public sector employees: An organizational case study. Occup. Med.48(2): 103–112, 1998.
53.
HallE. M.Double exposure: The combined impact of the home and work environments on psychosomatic strain in Swedish women and men. Int. J. Health Serv.22(2): 239–260, 1992.
54.
Martin MatthewsA.Homemaker Services to the Elderly: Provider Characteristics and Client Benefit. Report Prepared for the Ontario Ministry of Community and Social Services, 1989–92. Gerontology Research Centre, University of Guelph, Ont., 1992.
55.
ThomasG.Working can be harmful to your health. Canadian Nurse, June 1993, pp. 35–38.
56.
CorriganM.Burnout: How to spot it and protect yourself against it. J. Volunteer Admin.25: 24–31, 1994.
57.
MFL (MFL Occupational Health Centre). Stress at work. Focus Occup. Health Safety7(3): 13–14, 1996.
58.
DonovanR.Home care work: A legacy of slavery in U.S. health care. Affilia13(3): 33–45, 1987.
59.
DonovanR.Work stress and job satisfaction: A study of home care workers in New York City. Home Health Care Serv. Q.10(1/2): 97–114, 1989.
60.
Canadian Advisory Council on the Status of Women. Women, Paid/Unpaid Work, and Stress.Ottawa, 1989.
61.
FeldmanP.SapienzaA., and KaneN.Who Cares for Them: Workers in the Home Care Industry.Greenwood, New York, 1990.
62.
GilbertN.Home care worker resignations: A study of the major contributing factors. Home Health Care Serv. Q.12(1): 69–83, 1991.
63.
LockeE.The nature and causes of job satisfaction. In Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology, edited by DunnetteM. D., pp. 1297–1343. Wiley, New York, 1976.
64.
NeysmithS. M., and AronsonJ.Working conditions in home care: Negotiating race and class boundaries in gendered work. Int. J. Health Serv.27(3): 479–499, 1997.
65.
JudgeT. A.HanishK. A., and DrankoskiR. D.Human resource management and employee attitudes. In Handbook of Human Resource Management, edited by FerrisG. R.RosenS. D., and BarnumD. T., pp. 576–596. Blackwell, Cambridge, Mass., 1995.
66.
DonovanR.KurzmanP., and RotmanC.Improving the lives of home care workers: A partnership of social work and labor. Soc. Work38(5): 505–648, 1993.
67.
EustisN.FischerL., and KaneR.The home care worker: On the front-line of quality. Generations, Fall 1994, pp. 43–49.
68.
SuprinR.HaslangerK., and DawsonS.Quality paraprofessional home care. Caring, April 1994, pp. 12–22.
69.
CrownW.AhlburgD., and McAdamM.The demographic and employment characteristics of home care aides: A comparison with nursing home aides, hospital aides, and other workers. Gerontologist35(2): 162–170, 1995.
70.
Ontario Women's Directorate. Women in Caregiving Occupations: Executive Summary.Toronto, 1989.
71.
British Columbia Home Support/Homemaker Joint Adjustment Committee. Employment and Education in the British Columbia Home Support/Homemaker Industry.Home Support Association of British Columbia, Vancouver, 1990.
72.
WagnerJ.Job Satisfaction of Home Care Nurses from Two Western Canadian Suburban Settings. Thesis, University of Alberta, Edmonton, 1991.
73.
GreenL. W.Study of Participatory Research in Health Promotion.Royal Society of Canada, Ottawa, 1995.
74.
ZeytinogluI. U.Self-reported musculoskeletal disorders among visiting and office home care workers. Women Health31(2/3): 1–35, 2000.
75.
KarasekR. T., and TheorellT.Healthy Work: Stress, Productivity, and the Reconstruction of Working Life.Basic Books, New York, 1990.
76.
IlfeldF. W.Jr.Further validation of a psychiatric symptom index in a normal population. Psychol. Rep.39: 1215–1228, 1976.
77.
IlfeldF. W.Jr.Characteristics of current social stressors. Psychol. Rep.39: 1231–1247, 1976.
78.
IlfeldF. W.Jr.Methodological issues in relating psychiatric symptoms to social stressors. Psychol. Rep.39: 1251–1258, 1976.
79.
LeiterM. P.Burnout as a developmental process: Consideration of models. In Professional Burnout: Recent Developments in Theory and Research, edited by SchaufeliW. B.MaslachC., and MarekT., pp. 237–250. Taylor and Francis, Washington, D.C., 1993.
80.
MaslachC., and JacksonS. E.The measurement of experienced burnout. J. Occup. Behav.2: 99–113, 1981.
81.
ZeytinogluI. U. (ed.). Changing Work Relationships in Industrialized Economies. Advances in Organization Studies, No. 1. John Benjamins, Amsterdam, 1999.
82.
ZeytinogluI. U., and MuteshiJ.Gender, race/ethnicity and class dimensions of nonstandard work: A critical review of the literature and policy suggestion. Relations industrielles—Industrial Relations55(1): 133–167, 2000.
83.
ZeytinogluI. U., and MuteshiJ.A critical review of flexible labour: Gender, race and class dimensions of economic restructuring. Resources Feminist Res.27(3/4): 97–120, 1999/2000.
84.
OstermanP. (ed.). Broken Ladders: Managerial Careers in the New Economy.Oxford University Press, New York, 1996.
85.
NelsonD. L., and BurkeR. J.Lessons learned. Can. J. Admin. Sci.15(4): 372–381, 1998.
86.
Kets deVriesM. F. R., and BalazsK.The downside of downsizing. Human Relations50: 11–50, 1997.
87.
MacAdamM.Human Resource Issues in Home Care in Canada: A Policy Perspective.Canada, Minister of Public Works and Government Services, Ottawa, 1999.
88.
MorrisR.CaroF. G., and HansanJ. E.Personal Assistance: The Future of Home Care.Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1998.
