This article synthesizes a cross-disciplinary literature review of 205 articles from Chinese top journals and presents a comprehensive picture of corruption and anti-corruption research in a non-Western setting. By attempting to describe how corruption negatively affects the public administration and how improved public administration can mitigate corruption, this study finds that the Chinese research is gradually shifting from qualitative analysis to quantitative research but that empirical research needs to be developed further. In addition, in the review, human greed, economic transition, institutional omissions, a weak civil society, and social and cultural traditions are found to be the main causes of corruption in China. The effect of corruption on economic development differs on the basis of the institutional situation and social environment, but the influence of corruption on social stability and public satisfaction with the government is often negative in China. In addition, the anti-corruption mechanism has changed from the campaign against corruption (1950s-1980s) to institutionalized anti-corruption (1990s) and finally to anti-corruption through new media platforms (since the 2000s). Evaluations of anti-corruption effects are still lacking in China, especially in empirical studies. The following three aspects deserve further study: (1) the corruption mechanisms, (2) the impact of the establishment of new state institutions on anti-corruption, and (3) the relationship between political factors and anti-corruption efforts in China.
BaoS. X. (1990). Legal Thinking on the Elimination of Corruption and Severe Punishment of Duty Crimes.Law Review, (1), 18–28.
2.
Central Commission for Discipline Inspection of the Communist Party of China (2017). Wunianlai chufen xiangkeji jiyixia dangyuan ganbu 134.3 wanren [China has punished 1.343 million street-level Party cadres since the last five years] (in Chinese). http://fanfu.people.com.cn/n1/2017/1008/c64371–29574649.html
3.
ChangG. M. & TangX. Q. (2007). Improve the Ruling Party ‘s Mechanism of Combating Corruption.CASS Journal of Political Science, (1), 45–52.
4.
ChenG. (2013). The Negative Role Model of Corrupt High Government Officials in the Spread of Corruption: Evidence from China.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (2), 155–164.
5.
ChenG.LiS. & YinX. G. (2008). Corruption and China's Economic Growth: From the Perspective of Positivism.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (3), 59–68.
6.
ChenG. Q. (1993), Research of Corruption Countermeasure in the Process of Economic Development of Less Developed Countries.Sociological Studies, (6), 1–5.
7.
ChenJ. J. & TongF. L. (1998). Eliminate the Hotbed of Corruption: Rent-seeking.Chinese Public Administration, (4), 63.
8.
ChengW. H. (2004). Institutional Roots of China's Corrupt Opportunities Emerging in the Reform Era.China Public Administration Review, 2, 87–97.
9.
ChenY. S. (1997). Anti-Corruption and Public Participation.CASS Journal of Political Science, (4), 14–20.
10.
CuccinielloM.PorumbescuG. A. & GrimelikhuijsenS. (2017). 25 Years of Transparency Research: Evidence and Future Directions.Public Administration Review, 77(1):32–44.
11.
DengX. J. & LiuJ. (2013). Research on the Becoming Model of Public Opinion in Anti-Corruption Microblogging: Based on Social Computing Analysis on the Subjective Relationship of the Biaoge Event on Sina Weibo, Journalism & Communication, (12), 82–94
12.
DingX. L. (1994). Corruption is the Lubricant or the Corrosive of Reform?Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 64–65.
13.
DuG. J. (2002). Perfecting the Mechanism of Power Operation and Effectively Preventing Power Abuse.China Reform, (5), 28–30.
14.
FanZ. Y. (2013). Fiscal Transfer, Infrastructure Investment and Corruption.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (2), 179–192.
15.
FangM. Y. & NieH. H. (2015). The Impact of Corruption on Contract Enforcement of Firms: Evidence from Chinese Firms.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 119–129.
16.
GeY. F. (1994). Sociological Thinking on Corruption.Management World, (3), 206–210.
17.
GongT. (2010). Auditing Accountability and Anticorruption in China: Prospects and Problems.Journal of Public Administration, 3(2):69–84.
18.
GongT. & WuM. L. (2012a). A Research Report on China's Corruption Cases during 2000–2009: Empirical Analysis of Some 2800 Corruption Cases.Sociological Studies, (4), 204–220.
19.
GongT.WuA.M. (2012b). Does increased civil service pay deter corruption? Evidence from China.Review of Public Personnel Administration, 32(2):192–204.
20.
GuoJ. M. (2009). The Construction of Public Budget Constraint Mechanism and the Improvement of China's Anti-Corruption Model.CASS Journal of Political Science, (4), 73–81.
21.
GuoJ. M. (2011). From Budget Opening to Government Clearing-up: the International Vision of Anti-corruption System Construction.CASS Journal of Political Science, (2), 57–68.
22.
GuoJ. M. & CaoS. Y. (2011). Explore the Path from Fiscal Transparency to the Government's Clearing-up.CASS Journal of Political Science, (2), 124— 125.
23.
GuoJ.YangJ. & ChengX. (2013). Regional Corrupt Governance and the Scale of Government Expenditure: Based on Provincial Panel Data and Spatial Econometric Analysis.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (1), 196–204.
24.
GuoY. (2006). Economic Transition, System and Corruption.CASS Journal of Political Science, (3), 53–60.
25.
GuoY. (2010). Suggestions on Improving China's Anti-Corruption System and Mechanism.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 110–116.
26.
GuoY. (2016). Six Tendencies of Corruption and Anti-Corruption in Contemporary China.Chinese Public Administration, (1), 60–63.
27.
GuoY. (2017). Corruption Situation in China after the 18th CPC National Congress: Evaluation from Three Dimensions.CASS Journal of Political Science, (3): 2–11.
28.
GuoY. & SongW. (2015). Research on the Present Situation, Difficulties and Reform of Discipline Inspection Agencies at the County Level in China.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 142–153.
29.
HeJ. H. (2015). Analysis of the Causes of Corruption in China.Law Review, (1), 68–76.
30.
HeZ. K. (2001). Innovative Anti-corruption System Towards Good Governance.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 54–64.
31.
HeZ. K. (2003). Research in the Issues of Corruption and Combating Corruption during Chinese Transition.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (1), 19–29.
32.
HeZ. K. (2003). Research in the Issues of Corruption and Combating Corruption during Chinese Transition.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (2), 52–60.
33.
HouJ. F. & HanL. (2006). Current Situation and Progress of Anti-Corruption Work in China.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (2), 76–80.
34.
HuA. G. & GuoY. (2001). Comprehensive Strategy and System Design of Prevention and Control of Corruption in Transition Period.Management World, (6), 44–55.
35.
HuangB. L. (2001). The Communist Party of China is the Core Force Leading the Fight Against Corruption in Contemporary China.CASS Journal of Political Science, (4), 15–19.
36.
HuH. L. (1989). Three Policies of Clean Government Building.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (2), 19–23.
37.
JiangL. Y. (2008). The Innovation of China's 30 Years’ Anti-Corruption Theory.CASS Journal of Political Science, (6), 44–51.
38.
JiangS. L. (2010). The Regulatory Officials Capture and Its Control Strategies During Transition Period.Chinese Public Administration, (11), 72–76.
39.
KimS. (2016). Public Trust in Government in China and South Korea: Implications for Building Community Resilience.Chinese Public Administration Review, (1), 35–76.
40.
LiH. J. & MaS. (2016). Governor Turnover, Government Regulation and Bribery.Journal of Public Administration, (3), 125–146.
41.
LiK. (2003). Mechanism-Related Corruption in Transition Countries: A General Equilibrium Model.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (1), 30–40.
42.
LiX. F. (2008). Non-profit Organization and Anti-Corruption: Theoretical Background and Analysis of International Experience.Chinese Public Administration, (1), 98–101.
43.
LiX. F. & LiJ. (2004). Analysis of the Current Status of the Research on Corruption in the Circle of the Studies of Administration.Journal of Public Management, (3), 27–34.
44.
LiY. L.WuS. J. & HuY. M. (2011). A Review of Anti-Corruption Studies in Recent China.Chinese Public Administration, (11), 115–119.
45.
LiuQ. J. (2013). Empirical Analysis of Corruption in China Since the Reform and Opening Up.CASS Journal of Political Science, (6), 39–51.
46.
LiuQ. J. & XuX. L. (2008). Expand the Thought of Corrupt Governance and Realize the Transformation of Anti-Corruption Strategy.Chinese Public Administration, (6), 124–125.
47.
LiuS. Z. (2005). Sectoral-Local-Economic Entity Informal Alliance: An Organizational Sociological Analysis of Local Corruption.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 99–105.
48.
LiuX. & ZhuQ. Y. (2010). The Reality Dilemma and Route Choice of China's Anti-Corruption.CASS Journal of Political Science, (2), 109–115.
49.
LiuX. Q. (2015). On Clean Government Construction Under the Background of Big Data.Chinese Public Administration, (12), 113–117.
50.
LongZ. Y. & TianY. H. (2008). Corruption and Measures for Anticorruption: A Study Based on Prospect Theory.Journal of Public Management, (4), 46–52.
51.
MaL. (2014). Information Disclosure, Accountability and Government Honesty: An Empirical Study of Chinese Cities.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 141–154.
52.
NiX. (1997). Comments on Rent-Seeking Corruption.CASS Journal of Political Science, (4), 21–29.
53.
NiX. (2011). Analysis on the Change of China's Anti-Corruption Strategy and its Effect.CASS Journal of Political Science, (5), 74–86.
54.
NiX. & ChenZ. C. (2011). Problem and Direction: Literature Evaluation of Contemporary China's Corruption and Anti-Corruption.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (3), 185–194.
55.
NiX. & SunZ. F. (2015). Economic Development, Institutional Structure and Local Anti-Corruption Efforts: A Panel Data Analysis Based on G Province.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (5), 92–103.
56.
NieH. H. & WangM. Q. (2014). The Impact of Political Cycles on Combatting Corruption: Evidence from Chinese Bureau-Level Corruption Cases during 2003–2013.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 127–140.
57.
PrasadM., da Silva, B. M. & NickowA. (2018). Approaches to Corruption: A Synthesis of the Scholarship.Studies in Comparative International Development. Published online 21 August 2018.
58.
PuX. Z. (2009). How to Block the Connection between “Public Power” and “Private Desires”.CASS Journal of Political Science, (6), 31–37.
59.
QiG. H. (2002). Management Factors of Securities System Corruption: The Dislocation of Government Function.Chinese Public Administration, (5), 21–23.
60.
RongJ. B. (1997). System Transformation and Clean Government Building.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (3), 1–7.
61.
ShenR. F. (2000). Entry into WTO and Countermeasures Against Corruption of China.Chinese Public Administration, (12), 14–16.
62.
SongW. & SheL. (2011). Discussion on Corruption and Internet Corruption in China in the New Era.CASS Journal of Political Science, (2), 84–90.
63.
SunZ. F. & YangL. T. Q. (2016). How Do Anti-Corruption Efforts Affect Public Perception of Corruption? Evidence from Guangdong Province in China.Journal of Public Administration, (3), 89–107.
64.
TangX. Y. (2000). The Key of Building Clean Government is Legislative Establishment.Chinese Public Administration, (5), 21–22.
65.
TangY. W.JingY. J. & LiuC. R. (2008). Research of Indicators Assessment System of China's Local Clean Governments Built.Sociology, 28(5), 203–223.
66.
WanG. H. & WuY. P. (2012). The System Construction and Anti-corruption Effectiveness.Management World, (4), 60–69.
67.
WangC. L. (2001). Analysis of Corruption Frequency in Chinese Society from 1900 to 1999.CASS Journal of Political Science, (1), 38–55.
68.
WangC. L. (2016). The Principles and Connotation of Systematic Methods to Struggle Against Corruption.CASS Journal of Political Science, (3), 54–64.
69.
WangH. N. (1995). China's Institutional Choice of Suppressing Corruption.CASS Journal of Political Science, (1), 7–15.
70.
WangM. G. (2006). Study on the Mechanism of Punishment of Corrupt Officials.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (5), 42–52.
71.
WangT. (1993). The Research of Public Officials’ Corruption and Malfeasance.Sociological Studies, (3), 30–41.
72.
WangX. J. & TianL. F. (2003). Ten Points of Anti-Corruption Theory Innovation.Chinese Public Administration, (8), 34–36.
73.
WangY. Z. & JiangL. Y. (2009). New China's 60 Years of Anti-Corruption: a Brief Review.CASS Journal of Political Science, (5), 53–58.
74.
WedemanA. (2012). Double Paradox: Rapid Growth and Rising Corruption in China. New York: Cornell University Press.
75.
WeiF. (2010). Empirical Study on the Corruption Neighbor Effect of Chinese Province.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 101–109.
76.
WeiS. J. (2001). Bribe in Economy: Lubricants or Sand.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (1), 33–43.
77.
WuA. M. (2014). Governing Civil Service Pay in China. Copenhagen, Denmark: NIAS Press.
78.
WuJ. J. & LiuJ. Y. (2017). Corruption and Political Trust: Based on a Multi-Level Analysis of China's Provincial Governments.China Public Administration Review, (3), 92–108.
79.
WuA. M. & LinM. (2012). Determinants of Government Size: Evidence from China.Public Choice, 151, 255–270.
80.
WuY. P. & RuiM. (2010). Regional Corruption, Marketization and China's Economic Growth.Management World, (11), 10–27.
81.
WuY. P. & ZhuJ. N. (2012). Corruption, Anti-Corruption, and Inter-County Income Disparity in China.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (2), 29–39.
82.
XiangY. B. (1989). Analysis of Corruption of Public Officials.Management World, (5), 180–185.
83.
XiaoH. Y. & GongT. (2016). Some Theoretical Issues in Corruption Studies: a Review of 526 SSCI Articles from 2009 to 2013.Comparative Economic and Social Systems, (2), 48–60.
84.
XieB. & KangJ. X. (2010). Public Opinion in Anti-Corruption Criminal Policy.Management World, (1), 173–174.
85.
XieB. & KangJ. X. (2011). The Scientific Construction of Anti-Corruption Criminal System.Management World, (3), 170–171.
86.
XieB.RenS. D. & ZhangJ. B. (2008). The New Economic Discipline and Corruption Governance in New Rural Construction.Economic Research Journal, (4), 111–118.
87.
XieG. B. (1990). Improve the Legal System - the Only Way to Build a Clean Government.Law Review, (5), 86–88.
88.
XieS. G. (2014). The Legal Difficulties and Outlet of Network Anti-corruption.Chinese Public Administration, (2), 91–94.
89.
XinC. Y. (1997). Anti-Corruption: Constrain Public Power.CASS Journal of Political Science, (4), 1–8.
90.
XueG. (2010). “Involved” and “Informed”: Two Points Separated from the Path of Community Corruption.CASS Journal of Political Science, (1), 93–105.
91.
YangK. F. (2009). A Reflection on China's Administrative Ethics Reforms: Morality, Law and Beyond.Journal of Public Administration, 2(3), 127–149.
92.
YuK. P. (1991). Discussion on Types of Political Corruption.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 45–49.
93.
ZhangG. & WuJ. J. (2014). Corruption and the Boundary of the State Power: Theory and Evidence in China.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (4), 155–169.
94.
ZhangJ. (2013). Foreign direct investment, governance, and the environment in china: Regional dimensions. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.
95.
ZhangJ. (2017). The Illusion and the Reality of Chinese Budget Reforms: Does Budgeting Influence Corruption Perception?Chinese Public Administration Review, 8(1), 1–22.
96.
ZhangP. (2011). Research on the Problem of Collective Corruption of Civil Servants in China.CASS Journal of Political Science, (5), 67–73.
97.
ZhangQ. F. & MiaoL. Y. (1999). The Effects and Mechanism of Open Government on Anti-Corruption.CASS Journal of Political Science, (3), 60–64.
98.
ZhangX. B. & RenY. (2013). Privacy Protection in Online Anti-corruption.Chinese Journal of Law, (6), 104–118.
99.
ZhangY. & KimM. (2018). Do public corruption convictions influence citizens’ trust in government? The answer might not be a simple yes or no.The American Review of Public Administration, 48(7), 685–698.
100.
ZhangZ. T. & YangH. (2013). The Hotspots and Their Progress Trends in the Domestic Research of Corruption and Anti-Corruption of China: Bibliometrics Analysis Based on the Core Journals of 1992–2011 in CNKI.Academics in China, (4), 70–83.
101.
ZhaoB. Z. (2014). Study on Some Important Practical Problems of the Criminal Rule of Law in Anti-corruption in China.Law Review, (3), 1–17.
102.
ZhaoB. Z. & YuX. X. (1990). The Construction of Clean Government and the Improvement of Criminal Legislation.Law Review, (4), 8–14.
103.
ZhengL. P. (2003). Administrative System and Corruption: Internal Mechanism and Countermeasures.Chinese Public Administration, (3), 30–34.
104.
ZhouL. A. & TaoJ. (2009). Research of Size of Government, Marketization and Regional Corruption.Economic Research Journal, (1), 57–69.
105.
ZhuJ. N. (2017). Corruption in Reform China: a Multidisciplinary Review.Sage handbook of contemporary China, 3v, Chapter: 15, Publisher: Sage, Editors: Weiping Wu, Mark W. Frazier.
106.
ZhuJ. N. & ZhangD. (2017). Does Corruption Hinder Private Business? Leadership Stability and Predictable Corruption in China.Governance: an International Journal of Policy, Administration and Institutions, 30 (3), 343–363.
107.
ZhuL. & GongF. J. (2015). On the Difference between Objective and Subjective Measurements on Corruption.Comparative Economic & Social Systems, (5), 66–80.
