Who Decides? What Matters? Scottish Adolescents' Perceptions of the Importance and Influence of Media Personalities,Parents and Peers

Abstract

To provide an up-to-date description of Scottish adolescents' perceptions of influences on them, a questionnaire-based survey of 427 Secondary Year 2 pupils (13–14 year-old), spread across the country, was carried out in 2002. The results of this survey suggest that these adolescents perceive themselves to be quite autonomous and encouraged to be so by most adults. By contrast, few felt that they had much say in rule-making, beyond the context of the family. Around 90% agreed that parents, friends and teachers were influential, whereas only around 50% agreed that media personalities were an influence.

References

Allen

Donohue

W.A.

Griffin

Ryan

Turner

M.M. Mitchell

(2003) Comparing The influence of parents and peers on the choice to use drugs: A meta-analytic summary of the literature. Criminal Justice and Behavior 30 (2), 163–186.

Angus

(1986) Pupils, power and the organization of the school. Journal of Educational Administration 24 (1), 5–17.

Ainsworth

(2002) Report of an Inquiry into Summerhill School-Leiston Suffolk, <http://www.selfmanagedlearning.org/Summerhill/RepMain.htm>.

Aspinall

Cave

(2001) Lowering the flag: Democracy, authority and rights at Tokorozawa High School. Social Science Japan Journal 4 (1), 77–93.

Benporath

S.R.

(2003) Autonomy and vulnerability: On just relations between adults and children. Journal of Philosophy of Education 37 (1), 127–145.

Briggs

Cobley

(eds.) (2002) The Media: An Introduction. Harlow: Longman.

Brooks

(2003) Kid Power. The Guardian, April 26 <http://www.guardian.co.uk/weekend/story/0,3605,942479,00.html>.

Bucher

A.A.

(1998) The influence of models in forming moral identity. International Journal of Educational Research, 27 (7), 619–627.

Buerkel-Rothfuss

N.L.

Strousse

J.S.

(1993) Media exposure and perceptions of sexual behaviour. In Greenberg

B.S.

Brown

J.D.

Burekel-Rothfuss

N.L.

(eds.) Media, Sex and the Adolescent (pp. 225–247). Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.

10.

Carter

D.S.G.

Bennetts

Carter

S.M.

(2003) ‘We're not Sheep’: Illuminating the nature of the adolescent peer group in effecting lifestyle choice. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 24 (2), 225–241.

11.

Children Now (1997) Entertainment Media: Messages about Masculinity: A National Poll of Children, Focus Groups and Content Analysis of Entertainment Media. NewYork: Children Now, <http://www.childrennow.org>.

12.

Corner

(2000) Influence: The contested core of media research. In Curran

Gurevitch

Mass Media and Society (pp. 376–397). Oxford: Arnold.

13.

Cowell

Wilson

(1983) The democratic myth. Journal of Philosophy of Education 17(1), 111–117.

14.

Cumberbatch

(1998) Media effects: The continuing controversy. In Briggs

Cobley

(eds.) (2002) The Media: An Introduction (pp. 259–271). Harlow: Longman.

15.

Davis

Mares

(1998) Effects of talk show viewing on adolescents. Journal of Communication 48, 69–86.

16.

Dewey

(1899) The School and Society. University of Chicago Press, <http://www.lib.uchicago.edu/projects/centcat/centcats/fac/facch08_01.html>.

17.

Eagle

de Bruin

Bulmer

(2002) Beyond Children Directed TV Advertising: Violence, Values, and the Electronic Media Environment. Auckland: Massey University, Department of Commerce, College of Business Working Paper Series No. 00.32, <http://college-of-busmess.massey.ac.nz/commerce/research_outputs/2000032.pdf>.

18.

Galambos

Barker

E.T.

Almeida

D.M.

(2003) Parents do matter: Trajectories of change in externalizing and internalizing problems in early adolescence. Child Development 74 (2), 578–594.

19.

Gauntlett

(1995) Moving Experiences: Understanding Television's Influences and Effects. Luton: John Libbey Media.

20.

Gauntlett

(1998) Ten things wrong with the ‘effects model’. In Dickinson

Harindranath

Linné

(eds.) (1998) Approaches to Audiences - A Reader. London: Arnold.

21.

Gazelle

Ladd

G.W.

(2003) Anxious solitude and peer exclusion: A diathesis-stress model of internalizing trajectories in childhood. Child Development 74 (1), 257–278.

22.

Gordon

(1992) Citizens and others: Gender, democracy and education. International Studies in Sociology of Education 2 (1), 43–56.

23.

Greenberg

B.S.

Stanley

Heeter

Siemki

Soderman

Linsangan

(1993) Sex content on soaps and prime-time television series most viewed by adolescents. In Greenberg

B.S.

Brown

J.D.

Burekel-Rothfuss

N.L.

(eds.) Media, Sex and the Adolescent (pp. 29–44). Cresskill, NJ: Hampton Press.

24.

Irwin

Conard

M.T.

Skoble

(eds.) (2002) The Simpsons and Philosophy: The D'oh! of Homer. Peru Illinois: Carus Publishing.

25.

Kent

(1999) Blair government seeks closure of Summerhill school. World Socialist Web Site <http://www.wsws.org>.

26.

Kitzinger

(2002) Impacts and influences. In Briggs

Cobley

(eds.) The Media: An Introduction (pp. 272–281). Harlow: Longman.

27.

Learning and Teaching Scotland (2000) Education for Citizenship in Scotland. Glasgow: LTS.

28.

Levin

(1998) The educational requirement for democracy. Curriculum Inquiry 28 (1), 57–79.

29.

Lines

(2001) Villains, fools or heroes? Sports stars as role models for young people. Leisure Studies 20 (4), 285–303.

30.

Livingstone

Bovill

(1999) Young People, New Media. London: London School of Economics.

31.

McGuire

W.J.

(1986) The myth of massive media impact. In Comstock

(ed.) Public Communication and Behaviour, Vol 1. Orlando: Academic Press.

32.

Melnick

Jackson

S.J.

(2002) Globalization American-style and reference idol selection: The importance of athlete celebrity others among New Zealand youth. International Review for the Sociology of Sport 37 (4), 429–448.

33.

National Family and Parenting Institute (2002) Soaps and the family, <http://www.nfpi.org/data/research/docs/soapstoryforweb.rtfx.

34.

Pearson

Michell

(2000) Smoke rings: Social network analysis of friendship groups, smoking and drug-taking. Drugs: Education, Prevention & Policy 7 (1), 21–37.

35.

Qualifications and Curriculum Authority (1998) Education for Citizenship and the Teaching of Democracy in Schools (The Crick Report). London: QCA.

36.

Rutter

(2003) The first big test: Citizenship education and the First Gulf War. In Ross

(ed.) A Europe of Many Cultures: Proceedings of the Fifth Conference of the Children's Identity and Citizenship in Europe Thematic Network (pp. 389–395). London: CiCe.

37.

Sapolsky

B.S.

Tabarlet

J.O.

(1991) Sex in prime-time television: 1979 versus 1989. Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media 35, 505–516.

38.

Solomon

Warin

Lewis

Langford

(2002) Intimate talk between patents and their teenage children: Democratic openness or covert control? Sociology 36 (4), 965–983.

39.

Summerhill Website (2003) <http://www.summerhillschool.co.uk/pages/index.htmlx.

40.

Tingleff

(1998) The Simpsons as a Critique of Consumer Culture. Simpsons Archive <http://www.snpp.com/other/papers/st.paper.html>.

41.

Turner

(1999) Peer support and young people's health. Journal of Adolescence 22 (4), 567–572.

42.

Walters

Bowen

G.L.

(1997) Peer group acceptance and academic performance among adolescents participating in a dropout prevention program. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal 14 (6), 413–426.

43.

Wartella

O'Keiffe

Scantlin

(2000) Children and Interactive Media: A Compendium of Current Research and Directions for the Future. Austin, TX: Markle Foundation.

44.

Windle

(2000) Parental, sibling, and peer influences on adolescent substance use and alcohol problems. Applied Developmental Science 4 (2), 98–110.