The endurance of democracy in England from the late medieval period to the Glorious Revolution (1688) remains a puzzle. Many analysts agree that an important factor in maintaining constitutionalism in England during this pivotal period was the reliance of the English Crown on indirect taxation and suggest that this reliance occurred because taxation on trade was easy and lucrative in a commercialized economy. I show how this explanation is inadequate. The English Crown tried to institute an additional system of permanent direct taxation in England in this period but failed. In contrast, the French Crown was successful in implementing a system of regular direct taxation in the early fifteenth century, which in turn facilitated the emergence of an autocratic state in the early modern period. I discuss reasons for the national difference, with particular attention to the role of regional factors and the response of local society to state impositions in shaping outcomes in both countries.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllmandChristopher. 1989. The Hundred Years WarCambridge: Cambridge University Press.
2.
AndersonPerry. 1974. Lineages of the Absolutist State. London: New Left Books.
3.
ArdantGabriel. 1971. Histoire de l'impôt. Paris: Fayard.
4.
ArdantGabriel. 1975. “Financial Policy and Economic Infrastructure of Modern States and Nations.” In The Formation of National States in Western Europe, ed. TillyCharles, 164–242. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
5.
BatesRobert H.LienDa-Hsiang Donald. 1985. “A Note on Taxation, Development, and Representative Government.”Politics and Society14(1):53–70.
6.
BlochMarc. 1966. French Rural History. Berkeley: University of California Press.
7.
BlockmansWim P.1978. “A Typology of Representative Institutions in Late Medieval Europe.”Journal of Medieval History4:189–215.
8.
BlockmansWim P.1994. “Voracious States and Obstructing Cities: An Aspect of State Formation in Preindustrial Europe.” In Cities and the Rise of States in Europe, A.D. 1000–1800, ed. TillyCharlesBlockmansWim P., 218–50. Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press.
9.
BlockmansWim P.1996. “The Growth of Nations and States in Europe before 1800.”European Review4:241–51.
10.
BradyThomas A.Jr.ObermanHeiko A.TracyJames D., 1994. “Introduction: Renaissance and Reformation, Late Middle Ages and Early Modern Era.” In Handbook of European History, 1400–1600, ed. BradyThomas A.Jr.ObermanHeiko A.TracyJames D., 1:xiii–xxiv. Leiden: Brill.
11.
BraudelFernand. 1982. The Wheels of Commerce. New York: Harper and Row.
12.
BraudelFernand. 1984. The Perspective of the World. New York: Harper and Row.
13.
BraudelFernand. 1990. The Identity of France. Vols. 1 and 2. New York: HarperCollins.
14.
BritnellR.H.1991. “Eastern England.” In The Agrarian History of England and Wales, vol. 3: 1348–1500, ed. MillerEdward, 53–66, 194–209, 611–623. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
15.
BrownA.L.1989. The Governance of Late Medieval England 1272–1461. London: Edward Arnold.
16.
CamH.M.1970. “The Legislators of Medieval England.” In Historical Studies of the English Parliament, vol. 1: Origins to 1399, ed. FrydeE.B.MillerEdward, 168–94. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
17.
CarstenF.L.1954. The Origins of Prussia. London: Oxford University Press.
18.
CharlesworthAndrew, ed. 1983. An Atlas of Rural Protest in Britain 1548–1900. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
19.
ChirotDaniel. 1986. Social Change in the Modern EraNew York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
20.
ClarkSamuel. 1995. State and Status: The Rise of the State and Aristocratic Power in Western Europe. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.
21.
DahlgrenStellan. 1973. “Charles X and the Constitution.” In Sweden's Age of Greatness, 1632–1718, ed. RobertsMichael, 174–203. New York: St. Martin's Press.
22.
de Bertier de SauvignyG.PinkneyDavid H., 1983. History of France. Arlington Heights, Ill.: Forum Press.
23.
de SchepperHugo. 1994. “The Burgundian-Habsburg Netherlands.” In Handbook of European History, 1400–1600, ed. BradyThomas A.Jr.ObermanHeiko A.TracyJames D., 1:499–534. Leiden: Brill.
24.
DodwellBarbara. 1939. “The Free Peasantry of East Anglia.”Norfolk Archaeology27:145–57.
25.
DouglasDavid C.1927. The Social Structure of Medieval East Anglia. Oxford Studies in Social and Legal History, vol. 9. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
26.
DowningBrian M.1988. “Constitutionalism, Warfare, and Political Change in Early Modern Europe.”Theory and Society17:7–56.
27.
DowningBrian M.1989. “Medieval Origins of Constitutional Government in the West.”Theory and Society18:213–47.
28.
DowningBrian M.1992. The Military Revolution and Political Change. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
29.
Dupont-FerrierGustave. 1976. Études sur les institutions financières de la France à la fin du moyen age. I. Les élections et leur personnel. II. Les finances extraordinaires et leur mécanisme. Genève: Slatkine-Megariotis Reprints.
30.
EinzigPaul. 1959. The Power of the Purse. London: Secker and Warburg.
ErtmanThomas. 1997. Birth of the Leviathan: Building States and Regimes in Medieval and Early Modern Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
33.
FrydeE.B.1959. “The English Farmers of the Customs, 1343–51.”Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 5th ser., 9:1–17.
34.
FrydeE.B.1970a. Introduction. In Historical Studies of the English Parliament, vol. 2, 1399–1603, ed. FrydeE.B.MillerEdward, 1–30. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
35.
FrydeE.B.1970b. “Parliament and the French War, 1336–40.” In Historical Studies of the English Parliament, vol. 1, Origins to 1399, ed. FrydeE.B.MillerEdward. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
36.
FrydeE.B.1991. “Royal Fiscal Systems and State Formation in France from the 13th to the 16th Century, with Some English Comparisons.”Journal of Historical Sociology4(3):236–87.
37.
FrydeE.B.1996. Peasants and Landlords in Later Medieval England. New York: St. Martin's Press.
38.
FrydeE. B.FrydeNatalie. 1991. “Peasant Rebellion and Peasant Discontents.” In Agrarian History of England and Wales, vol. 3, 1348–1500, ed. MillerEdward, 745–819. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
39.
GladstoneW.E.1863. Financial Statements of 1856, 1860–63. London.
40.
GrayH.L.1915. English Field Systems. Cambridge, Mass.: University Press.
41.
GreengrassMark. 1991. “Conquest and Coalescence.” In Conquest and Coalescence: The Shaping of the State in Early Modern Europe, ed. GreengrassMark, 1–24. London: Edward Arnold.
42.
GustafssonHarald. 1994. Political Interaction in the Old Regime: Central Power and Local Society in the Eighteenth-Century Nordic States. Trans. CrozierAlan. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
43.
HarrisG.L.1975. King, Parliament, and Public Finance in Medieval England to 1369. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
44.
t'HartMarjolein. 1993. The Making of a Bourgeois State: War, Politics and Finance during the Dutch Revolt. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
45.
HennemanJohn Bell. 1971. Royal Taxation in Fourteenth-Century France. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
46.
HenshallNicholas. 1992. The Myth of Absolutism. London: Longman.
47.
HoffmanPhilip T.1994. “Early Modern France, 1450–1700.” In Fiscal Crises, Liberty, and Representative Government, 1450–1789, ed. HoffmanPhilip T.NorbergKathryn, 226–52. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
48.
HoffmanPhilip T.NorbergKathryn. 1994. “Conclusion.” In Fiscal Crises, Liberty, and Representative Government, 1450–1789, ed. HoffmanPhilip T.NorbergKathryn, 299–313. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
49.
HomansG.C.1987. “The Explanation of English Regional Differences.” In Certainties and Doubts: Collected Papers, 1962–1985, 169–74. New Brunswick: Transaction Books.
50.
HopcroftRosemary L.1994. “The Social Origins of Agrarian Change in Late Medieval England.”American Journal of Sociology99(6):1559–95.
51.
HopcroftRosemary L.1997. “Rural Organization and Receptivity to Protestantism in Sixteenth-Century Europe.”Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion36(2):158–81.
52.
HoyleR.W.1994. “Crown, Parliament and Taxation in Sixteenth-Century England.”English Historical Review109(434):1174–96.
53.
KiserEdgar. 1994. “Markets and Hierarchies in Early Modern Tax Systems: A Principal-Agent Analysis.”Politics and Society22(3):284–315.
54.
LeviMargaret. 1988. Of Rule and Revenue. Berkeley: University of California Press.
55.
LewisArchibald R.1984. “Patterns of Economic Development in Southern France, A.D. 1050–1271.” In Medieval Society in Southern France and Catalonia. London: Variorum Reprints.
56.
LoadesDavid M.1994. “England under the Tudors.” In Handbook of European History, 1400–1600, ed. BradyThomas A.Jr.ObermanHeiko A.TracyJames D., 1:403–36. Leiden: Brill.
57.
LotF.FawtierR., 1958. Histoire des institutions françaises au moyen age. Vol. 2. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
58.
LyonBryce. 1957. From Fief to Indenture: The Transition from Feudal to Non-Feudal Contract in Western Europe. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
59.
MaddicottJ.R.1981. “Parliament and the Constituencies, 1272–1377.” In The English Parliament in the Middle Ages, ed. DaviesR.G.DentonJ.H., 61–87. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
60.
MajorJ. Russell. 1994. From Renaissance Monarchy to Absolute Monarchy. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
61.
MannMichael. 1986. The Sources of Social Power. Vol. 1: A History of Power from the Beginning to A.D. 1760. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
62.
MannMichael. 1988. States, War and Capbookism. Oxford: Blackwell.
63.
MannMichael. 1993. The Sources of Social Power. Vol. 2: The Rise of Classes and Nation-States, 1760–1914. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
64.
ManningBrian. 1975. “The Peasantry and the English Revolution.”Journal of Peasant Studies2, no. 2 (January):133–58.
65.
MettamRoger. 1988. Power and Faction in Louis XIV's France. New York: Basil Blackwell.
66.
MillerEdward. 1970. Introduction. In Historical Studies of the English Parliament, vol. 1: Origins to 1399, ed. FrydeE. B.MillerEdward, 1–30. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
67.
MiskiminHarry A.1984. Money and Power in Fifteenth-Century France. New Haven: Yale University Press.
68.
MooreBarrington. 1966. Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy. Boston: Beacon Press.
69.
MunroJohn H. A.1972. Wool, Cloth and Gold. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
70.
NeveuxHugues. 1975. “Déclin et repris: La fluctuation biséculaire 1340–1560.” In Histoire de la France rurale, ed. DubyGeorgesWallonArmand, 2:9–156. Paris: Éditions du Seuil.
71.
NorthDouglass C.ThomasRobert Paul. 1973. The Rise of the Western World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
72.
PicotGeorges. 1888. Histoire des états généraux. Vol. 1. Paris: Hachette.
73.
PlucknettT.F.T.1970. “Parliament, 1327–36.” In Historical Studies of the English Parliament, vol. 1: Origins to 1399, ed. FrydeE.B.MillerEdward, 195–241. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
74.
PolandBurdette C.1957. French Protestantism and the French Revolution: A Study in Church and State, Thought and Religion, 1685–1815. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
75.
PostanM. M.1973. Essays on Medieval Agriculture and General Problems of the Medieval Economy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
76.
PrestwichM.1972. War, Politics and Finance under Edward I. London: Faber and Faber.
77.
Rand McNally Atlas of World History. 1984. Chicago: Rand McNally.
78.
RiddlePhyllis. 1993. “Political Authority and University Formation in Europe, 1200–1800.”Sociological Perspectives36(1):45–62.
79.
RootHilton L.1994. The Fountain of Privilege: Political Foundations of Markets in Old Regime France and England. Berkeley: University of California Press.
80.
RoskellJ.S.1970. “Perspectives in English Parliamentary History.” In Historical Studies of the English Parliament, vol. 2: 1399–1603, ed. FrydeE.B.MillerEdward, 296–323. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
81.
SayerDerek. 1992. “A Notable Administration: English State Formation and the Rise of Capitalism.”American Journal of Sociology97(5):1382–1415.
82.
SchumpeterJoseph A.1954. “The Crisis of the Tax State [1918].”International Economic Papers 4.
83.
SkocpolTheda. 1979. States and Social Revolutions. New York: Cambridge University Press.
84.
SpruytHendrik. 1994. The Sovereign State and Its Competitors. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
85.
SpuffordPeter. 1965. “Assemblies of Estates, Taxation and Control of Coinage in Medieval Europe.” In Congrès internationale des Sciences historiques, Études présentées à la Commission l'histoire des assemblées d'états. Louvain: Nauwelaerts.
86.
StoneL.1960. “Discussion of Trevor-Roper's General Crisis.”Past and Present18:31–33.
87.
StrayerJ.R.TaylorC.H., 1939. Studies in Early French Taxation. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
88.
StubbsWilliam. [1897] 1967. The Constitutional History of England, 4th ed.Vol. 2. New York: Barnes and Noble.
89.
SussmanNathan. 1993. “Debasements, Royal Revenues, and Inflation in France during the Hundred Years' War, 1415–1422.”Journal of Economic History53(1):44–70.
90.
TillyCharles. 1989. “Cities and States in Europe, 1000–1800.”Theory and Society18:563–84.
91.
TillyCharles. 1992. Coercion, Capital, and European States, A.D. 990–1992. Cambridge: Blackwell.
92.
TillyCharles. 1994. “Entanglements of European Cities and States.” In Cities and the Rise of States in Europe, A.D. 1000–1800, 1–27. Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press.
93.
Times Concise Atlas of World History. 1992. London: HarperCollins.
WallersteinImmanuel. 1974. The Modern World System. New York: Academic Press.
96.
WeberMax. [1922] 1968. Economy and Society. Ed. RothGuentherWittichClaus. Berkeley: University of California Press.
97.
WolfeMartin. 1972. The Fiscal System of Renaissance France. New Haven: Yale University Press.
98.
ZolbergAristide R.1980. “Strategic Interactions and the Formation of Modern States: France and England.”International Social Science Journal32(4):687–716.
