Teacher Biases in the Identification of Learning Disabilities: An Application of the Logistic Multilevel Model

Abstract

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the presence of teacher biases with regard to identification of students with learning disabilities (LD). Factors related to teachers' gender, age, and experience, along with children's gender, were investigated. Results suggested that teacher gender is associated with biases with regard to identification of learning disabilities by a factor of 2:1. In other words, every child who is rated by female teachers as having an LD (who actually has LD) corresponds two children when rated by male teachers. Students' gender, on the other hand, did not differentially predict identification rates. Furthermore, teacher age and experience did not contribute significantly to student identification rates. The findings are discussed with regard to policy mandates and classification schemes.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abidin

R. R.

Robinson

L. L.

(2002). Stress, biases, or professionalism: What drives teachers' referral judgments of students with challenging behaviors? Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders, 4, 204–212.

Achenbach

T. M.

(1991). Manual for the teacher's report form and 1991 profile. Burlington: University of Vermont Department of Psychiatry.

Aiken

L. S.

West

S. G.

(1991). Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

Anderson

K. G.

(1997). Gender bias and special education referrals. Annals of Dyslexia, 47, 151–162.

Bellamy

(1994). Bias in the classroom: Are we guilty? Science Scope, 17, 60–63.

Bender

W. N.

Vail

C. O.

Scott

(1995). Teachers' attitudes toward increased mainstreaming: Implementing effective instruction for students with learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 28, 87–94.

Berry

C. A.

Shaywitz

S. E.

Shaywitz

B. A.

(1985). Girls with attention deficit disorder: A silent minority? A report on behavioral and cognitive characteristics. Pediatrics, 76, 801–809.

Boe

E. E.

Shin

Cook

L. H.

(2007). Does teacher preparation matter for beginning teachers in either special or general education? Journal of Special Education, 41, 158–170.

Boomsma

(1986). On the use of bootstrap and jackknife in covariance structure analysis models. Compstat, 7, 205–210.

10.

Borg

M. G.

Falzon

J. M.

(1998). Secondary school teachers' perception of students' undesirable behaviors. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 68, 67–79.

11.

Brennan-O'Neil

Liljequist

(2002). Strategies used by teachers to rate student behaviour. Psychology in the Schools, 39, 77–85.

12.

Bryk

A. S.

Raudenbush

S. W.

(1992). Hierarchical linear models. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

13.

Chang

D. F.

Demyan

(2007). Teachers' stereotypes of asian, black, and white students. School Psychology Quarterly, 22, 91–114.

14.

Chernick

(2007). Bootstrap methods: A guide for researchers and practitioners. New York: Wiley.

15.

Choi

(2001). Latent variable modeling in the hierarchical modeling framework in longitudinal studies: A fully Bayesian approach. Asia Pacific Education Review, 2, 44–55.

16.

Dembo

M. H.

Gibson

(1985). Teachers' sense of efficacy: An important factor in school improvement. The Elementary School Journal, 86, 173–184.

17.

Diaconis

Efron

(1983). Computer intensive methods in statistics. Scientific American, 248, 116–130.

18.

Duffy

Warren

Walsh

(2001). Classroom interactions: Gender of teacher, gender of student, and classroom subject. Sex Roles, 45, 579–593.

19.

Dupaul

G. J.

Anastopoulos

A. D.

Power

T. J.

Reid

Ikeda

McGoey

K. E.

(1998). Parent ratings of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, symptoms: factor structure and normative data. Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment, 20, 83–102.

20.

Efron

(1982). The jackknife, bootstrap, and other resampling plans. Philadelphia: SIAM.

21.

Einarsson

Granstroem

(2002). Gender-biased interaction in the classroom: The influence of gender and age in the relationship between teacher and pupil. Scandinavian Journal of Educational Research, 46, 117–127.

22.

Fierros

Bloomberg

N. A.

(2005). Restrictiveness and race in special education placements in for profit and non-profit charter schools in California. Learning Disabilities: A Contemporary Journal, 3, 1–16.

23.

Flannery

Liederman

Daly

Schultz

(2000). Male prevalence for reading disability is found in large sample of black and White children free from ascertainment bias. Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 6, 433–442.

24.

Flynn

J. M.

Rahbar

M. H.

(1994). Prevalence of reading failure in boys compared with girls. Psychology in the Schools, 31, 66–71.

25.

Fox

A. M.

Lent

(1996). Clumsy children: Primer on developmental coordination disorder. Canadian Family Physician, 42, 1965–1971.

26.

Fuchs

Deshler

(2007). What we need to know about responsiveness to intervention (and shouldn't be afraid to ask). Learning Disabilities Research & Practice, 22, 129–136.

27.

Gibson

Dembo

M. H.

(1984). Teacher efficacy: A construct validation. Journal of Educational Psychology, 76, 569–582.

28.

Gilligan

(1982). In a different voice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

29.

Gillberg

(2003). Deficits in attention, motor control, and perception: A brief review. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 88, 904–910.

30.

Goodman

Webb

M. M.

(2006). Reading disability referrals: Teacher bias and other factors that impact response to intervention. Learning Disabilities: A Contemporary Journal, 4, 59–70.

31.

Haager

(2007). Promises and cautions regarding using response to intervention with English language learners. Learning Disability Quarterly, 30, 213–218.

32.

Haager

Calhoon

M. B.

Linan-Thompson

(2007). English language learners and response to intervention: Introduction to special issue. Learning Disability Quarterly, 30, 151–153.

33.

Hammill

(1995). The Learning Disability Diagnostic Inventory (LDDI). Austin, TX: Pro-Ed.

34.

Hammill

D. D.

(1990). On defining learning disabilities: An emerging consensus. Journal of learning Disabilities, 23(2), 74–84.

35.

Hammill

D. D.

Bryant

B. R.

(1998). Learning Disabilities Diagnostic Inventory Examiner's manual. Austin, TX: Pro-Ed.

36.

Helwig

Anderson

Tindal

(2001). Influence of elementary school gender on teachers' perceptions of mathematics achievement. Journal of Educational Research, 95, 93–102.

37.

Henderson

Sugden

D. A.

(1992). Movement Assessment Battery for Children. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation.

38.

Hopf

Hatzichristou

(1999). Teacher gender-related influences in Greek schools. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 69, 1–18.

39.

Jensen

A. R.

(1980). Bias in mental testing. London: Methuen.

40.

Junaid

Harris

Fulmer

Carswell

(2000). Teachers' use of the MABC checklist to identify children with motor coordination difficulties. Pediatric Physical Therapy, 12, 158–163.

41.

Kavale

K. A.

Holdnack

J. A.

Mostert

M. P.

(2006). Responsiveness to intervention and the identification of specific learning disability: A critique and alternative proposal. Learning Disability Quarterly, 29, 113–127.

42.

Keogh

B. K.

(2005). Revisiting classification and identification. Learning Disability Quarterly, 28, 100–102.

43.

King-Sears

M. E.

(2005). Are you highly qualified? The plight of effective special educators for students with learning disabilities. Learning Disability Quarterly, 28, 187–188.

44.

Knotek

(2003). Bias in problem solving and the social process of student study teams. The Journal of Special Education, 37, 2–14.

45.

Kokkinos

C. M.

Panayiotou

Davazoglou

A. M.

(2005). Correlates of teacher appraisals of students' behaviors. Psychology in the Schools, 42, 79–89.

46.

Kreft

de Leeuw

(1998). Introducing multilevel modeling. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

47.

Leinhardt

Seewald

A. M.

Zigmond

(1982). Sex and race differences in LD classrooms. Journal of Educational Psychology, 74, 835–843.

48.

Lieberman

Kantrowitz

Flannery

(2005). Male vulnerability to reading disability is not likely to be a myth: A call for new data. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 38, 109–129.

49.

Liljequist

Renk

(2007). The relationship among teachers' perceptions of student behaviour, teachers' characteristics, and ratings of students' emotional and behavioral problems. Educational Psychology, 27, 557–571.

50.

Lorenz

F. O.

Melby

J. N.

Conger

R. D.

(2007). The effects of context on the correspondence between observational ratings and questionnaire reports of hostile behaviour: A multi-trait, multimethod approach. Journal of Family Psychology, 21, 498–509.

51.

Lovejoy

M. C.

(1996). Social inferences regarding inattentive-overactive and aggressive child behaviour and their effects on teacher reports of discipline. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 25, 33–42.

52.

MacMillan

D. L.

Siperstein

G. N.

Gresham

F. M.

(1996). A challenge to the viability of mild mental retardation as a diagnostic category. Exceptional Children, 62, 356–371.

53.

Mamlin

Harris

(1998). Elementary teachers' referral to special education in light of inclusion and pre-referral. Journal of Educational Psychology, 90, 385–396.

54.

Mashburn

A. J.

Henry

G. T.

(2004). Assessing school readiness: validity and bias in preschool and kindergarten teachers' ratings. Educational Measurement: Issues and Practice, 23, 16–30.

55.

McLeskey

Waldron

N. L.

Wornhoff

S. A.

(1990). Factors influencing the identification of black and white students with learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 362–366.

56.

Meece

J. L.

(1987). The influence of school experiences on the development of gender schemata. In Liben

L. S.

Signorella

M. L.

(Eds.), Children's gender schemata (pp. 57–73). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

57.

Merrett

Wheldall

(1993). How do teachers learn to manage classroom behaviour? A study of teachers' opinions about their initial training with special reference to classroom behaviour management. Educational Studies, 19, 91–106.

58.

Messe

L. A.

Crano

W. D.

Messe

S. R.

Rice

(1979). Evaluation of the predictive validity of tests of mental ability for classroom performance in elementary grades. Journal of Educational Psychology, 71, 233–241.

59.

Miller

L. T.

Missiuna

C. A.

Macnab

J. J.

Malloy-Miller

Polatajko

H. J.

(2001). Clinical description of children with developmental coordination disorder. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 68, 5–15.

60.

Moore

F. M.

(2008). Preparing elementary preservice teachers for urban elementary science classrooms: Challenging cultural biases toward diverse students. Journal of Science Teacher Education, 19, 85–109.

61.

Naiden

(1976). Ratio of boys to girls among disabled readers. The Reading Teacher, 439–442.

62.

No Child Left Behind Act of 2001. 20 U.S.C. 6301 et seq. (2001).

63.

Noddings

(1984). Caring. A feminine approach to ethics and moral education. Berkeley: University of California Press.

64.

Padeliadu

Sideridis

G. D.

(2008). Learning Disabilities Screening for Teachers. YPEPTH: EPEAEK.

65.

Peterson

Baindbridge

(1999). Teachers' gendered expectations and their evaluation of student writing. Reading Research and Instruction, 38, 255–271.

66.

Podell

Soodak

(1993). Teacher efficacy and bias in special education referrals. Journal of Educational Research, 86, 247–253.

67.

Proctor

Prevatt

(2003). Agreement among four models used for diagnosing learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 36, 459–466.

68.

Pugach

M. C.

Johnson

L. J.

(1995). Unlocking the expertise among classroom teachers through structured dialogue: extending research on peer collaboration. Exceptional Children, 62, 101, 110.

69.

Raudenbush

S. W.

Bryk

A. S.

(2002). Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

70.

Rescorla

L. A.

Achenbach

T. M.

Ginzburg

Ivanova

Dumenci

Almqvist

Bathiche

Bilenberg

Bird

Domuta

Erol

Fombonne

Fonseca

Frigerio

Kanbayashi

Lambert

M. C.

Liu

Leung

Minaei

Roussos

Simsek

Weintraub

Weisz

Wolanczyk

Zubrick

S. R.

Zukauskiene

Verhulst

(2007). Consistency of teacher-reported problems for students in 21 countries. School Psychology Review, 36, 91–110.

71.

Ritter

(1989). Teachers' perceptions of problem behavior in general and special education. Exceptional Children, 55, 559–564.

72.

Rivard

L. M.

Missiuna

Hanna

Wishart

(2007). Understanding teachers' perceptions of the motor difficulties of children with developmental coordination disorder (DCD). British Journal of Educational Psychology, 77, 633–648.

73.

Roberts

K. J.

(2004). An introductory primer on multilevel and hierarchical linear modeling. Learning Disabilities: A Contemporary Journal, 2, 30–38.

74.

Rosenthal

Jacobson

(1968). Pygmalion in the classroom. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.

75.

Rubovits

Maehr

M. L.

(1973). Pygmalion black and white. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 25, 210–218.

76.

D. L.

Silva

P. A.

(2003). Gender bias in IQ-discrepancy and post-discrepancy definitions of reading disability. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 36, 4–14.

77.

Schneider

Lee

(1990). A model for academic success: The school and home environment of East-Asian students. Anthropology and Education Quarterly, 21, 358–377.

78.

Shaywitz

S. E.

(1996). Dyslexia. Scientific American, 373, 607–609.

79.

Shaywitz

Fletcher

Escobar

(1990). Prevalence of reading disability in boys and girls. Journal of the American Medical Association, 264, 998–1002.

80.

Shin

Espin

C. A.

Deno

S. L.

McConnell

(2004). Use of hierarchical linear modeling and curriculum-based measurement for assessing academic growth and instructional factors for students with learning difficulties. Asia Pacific Education Review, 5, 136–148.

81.

Shinn

M. R.

Tindal

G.A.

Spira

D. A.

(1987). Special education referrals as an Index of teacher tolerance: Are teachers imperfect tests? Exceptional Children, 54, 32–40.

82.

Singer

Willet

(2003). Applied longitudinal data analysis: Modeling change and event occurrence. New York: Oxford University Press.

83.

Smart

Sanson

Prior

(1996). Connections between reading disability and behaviour problems: Testing temporal and causal hypotheses. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 24, 363–383.

84.

Soodak

L. C.

Podell

D. M.

(1993). Teacher efficacy and student problems as factors in special education referral. Journal of Special Education, 26, 66–81.

85.

Soodak

L. C.

Podell

D. M.

(1996). Teacher efficacy: Toward the understanding of a multifaceted construct. Teaching and Teacher Education, 12, 401–411.

86.

Stanovich

K. E.

(2005). The future of a mistake: Will discrepancy measurement continue to make the learning disabilities field a pseudoscience? Learning Disability Quarterly, 28, 103–106.

87.

Stevens

Quittner

A. L.

Abikoff

(1998). Factors influencing elementary school teachers' ratings of ADHD and ODD behaviors. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 27, 406–414.

88.

Stormark

K. M.

Heiervang

Heimann

Lundervold

Gillberg

(2008). Predicting nonresponse bias from teacher ratings of mental health problems in primary school children. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 36, 411–419.

89.

Svanum

Bringle

R. G.

(1982). Race, social class, and predictive bias: An evaluation using WISC, WRAT, and teacher ratings. Intelligence, 6, 275–286.

90.

Tate

R. L.

(2000). Elaboration of HLM growth modeling results. Florida Journal of Educational Research, 40, 53–75.

91.

Taylor

P. B.

Gunter

P. L.

Slate

J. R.

(2001). Teachers' predictions of inappropriate student behavior as a function of teachers' and students' gender and ethnic background. Behavioral Disorders, 26, 146–151.

92.

Temp

(1971). Validity of the SAT for blacks and whites in thirteen integrated institutions. Journal of Educational Measurement, 8, 245–251.

93.

Tenenbaum

H. R.

Ruck

M. D.

(2007). Are teachers' expectations different for racial minority than for European-American students? A meta-analysis. Journal of Educational Psychology, 99, 253–273.

94.

Tobias

Cole

Zibrin

Bodlakova

(1982). Teacher-student ethnicity and recommendations for special education referrals. Journal of Educational Psychology, 74, 72–76.

95.

Tobias

Zibrin

Menell

(1983). Special education referrals: Failure to replicate student-teacher ethnicity interaction. Journal of Education Psychology, 75, 706–707.

96.

Tournaki

Podell

D. M.

(2005). The impact of student characteristics and teacher efficacy on teachers' predictions of students' success. Teaching and Teacher Education, 21, 299–314.

97.

Vaughn

Fuchs

(2003). Redefining learning disabilities as inadequate response to instruction: The promise and potential problems. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice, 18, 137–146.

98.

Vogel

(1990). Gender differences in intelligence, language, visual-motor abilities and academic achievement in students with learning disabilities: A review of the literature. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 44–52.

99.

Wehmeyer

Schwartz

(2001). Disproportionate representation of males in special education services: Biology, behaviour or bias? Education and Treatment of Children, 24, 28–45.

100.

Wimer

J. W.

Ridenour

C. S.

Thomas

Place

A. W.

(2001). Higher order teacher questioning of boys and girls in elementary mathematics classroom. Journal of Educational Research, 95, 84–92.

101.

Wingenfeld

S. A.

Lackar

Gruber

C. P.

Kline

R. B.

(1998). Development of the teacher-informant student behavior survey. Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment, 16, 226–249.

102.

Wong

B.Y.L.

(1996). The ABCs of learning disabilities. New York: Academic Press.

103.

Wood

J. G.

Benton

S. L.

(2005). Attributional responses to students with attention-deficit-hyperactivity disorder who fail. Teacher Education and Special Education, 28, 153–162.

104.

Ysseldyke

Thurlow

Graden

Wesson

Algozzine

Deno

(1983). Generalizations from five years of research on assessment and decision making: The University of Minnesota Institute. Exceptional Children Quarterly, 4, 75–93.