Period writings about singing activity from early eighteenth-century Boston and current data on singing in the United States provide material for a comparison of sex-related differences in public singing involvement. This material shows that, in America, there has been a marked shift from male to female predominance in public singing interest. Males arrogated singing leadership to themselves in early Boston and urged women to sing. Today, adolescent and adult American males are much less publicly involved with singing than are females. A cursory analysis of this phenomenon suggests that an inversion of leadership interest in public singing by sex has taken place in America. This interpretation, however, does not explain the facts, and music educators have some cause for concern that choral singing involvement of both sexes will continue to wane.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Birge, Edward Bailey. 1939. History of public school music in the United States—new and augmented edition. Boston: Oliver Ditson Co.
2.
Bonner, John. 1722. [Map of] The town of Boston in New England. Boston: Captain John Bonner and William Price.
3.
Britton, Allen P. 1950. Theoretical introductions in American tune books to 1800. Ann Arbor, MI: University Microfilms, No. 1505.
4.
Britton, Allen P., and Irving Lowens.1953. Unlocated titles in early American sacred music. Music Library Association Notes11 (December):33–48.
5.
Burney, Charles. 1789. A general history of music. (Reprinted in 1957 by Dover Publications, New York.)
6.
Crawford, Richard, and D. W. Krummel.1983. Early American music printing and publishing. In Printing and society in early America, ed. William Leonard Joyce et al., 186–227. Worcester, MA: American Antiquarian Society.
7.
Dearnley, Christopher. 1970. English church music 1650–1750. New York and London: Oxford University Press.
8.
Finney, Theodore M. 1966. The third edition of Tufts' Introduction to the art of singing psalm-tunes. Journal of Research in Music Education14 (Fall): 163–70.
9.
Franklin, Benjamin, V, ed. 1980. Boston printers, publishers, and booksellers, 1640–1800. Boston: G. K. Hall.
10.
Gates, J. Terry.1988a. Samual Gerrish, publisher to the 'regular singing movement' in 1720s New England. Music Library Association Notes45 (September): 15–22.
11.
Gates, J. Terry.1988b. A comparison of the tune books of Tufts and Walter. Journal of Research in Music Education36 (Fall):169–93.
12.
Gates, J. Terry. 1988c. Recruiting and retention studies: Rethinking the assumptions. Research paper presented at the New York State School Music Association Annual Convention, November 29, 1988, Kiamesha Lake, New York. (Manuscript available from the author: c/o Music Department, SUNY at Buffalo, Buffalo, NY 14260.)
13.
Greer, Cynthia, and Karl Gude. 1987. Parents doing OK, national survey says. Associated Press. Naperville [Illinois] Sun, 26 November, 6C. (Nationally syndicated report of poll by The Roper Organization.)
14.
Hood, George. [1846] 1970. A history of music in New England. Reprint. New York: Johnson Reprint Corporation.
15.
Kelton, Mai Hogan. 1984. Analysis of the music curriculum of The Sacred Harp (American tune book, 1971 edition) and its continuing traditions. Ed.D. diss., University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa.
16.
Liemohn, Edwin. 1953. The chorale. Philadelphia: Muhlenberg Press.
17.
Lowens, Irving. 1954. John Tufts' Introduction to the singing of psalm-tunes (1721–1744): The first American music textbook. Journal of Research in Music Education2 (Winter):89–102.
18.
Lowens, Irving. 1964. Music and musicians in early America. New York: Norton.
19.
Mather, Cotton. 1721. The accomplished singer. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
20.
Mather, Cotton. 1741. Ornaments for the daughters of Zion. 3d ed. Boston: S. Kneeland and T. Green.
21.
Metcalf, Frank J. 1968. American psalmody. New York: Da Capo. (Originally issued in 1917 by Heartman, New York.)
22.
National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP). 1981. Music 1971–79: Results from the second national music assessment (Report No. 10-MU-01, November). Denver: Education Commission of the States.
23.
National Association of Secondary School Principals (NASSP). 1984. The mood of American youth. Washington, DC: National Association of Secondary School Principals.
24.
Ottinger, Cecilia A. (comp.). 1987. 1986–87 fact book on higher education. New York: American Council on Education and Macmillan.
25.
Reavis, William, and George E. Van Dyke.1933. Nonathletic extracurriculum activities (Bulletin 1932. No. 17: National Survey of Secondary Education; Monograph No. 26). Washington, DC: U.S. Office of Education.
26.
Rivas, Frank W. 1974. The first national assessment of musical performance (Report 03-MU-01). Denver: Education Commission of the States.
27.
Rowe, J. 1722. Singing of psalms by seven constituted sounds, opened and explained. Boston: N.p.
28.
Scholes, Percy A. 1934. The puritan and music: In England and New England. London: Oxford University Press.
29.
Steinel, Daniel V., ed. 1984. Music and music education: Data and information. Reston, VA: Music Educators National Conference.
30.
Symmes, Thomas. 1720. The reasonableness of regular singing. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
31.
Symmes, Thomas. 1723. Utile dulci. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
32.
Temperley, Nicholas. 1981. The old way of singing: Its origins and development. American Musicological Society Journal34:511–44.
33.
Thacher, Peter, John Danforth, and Samuel Danforth. 1723. Cases of conscience about singing psalms. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
34.
Tufts, John. 1721. An introduction to the art of singing psalm-tunes. Boston: Samuel Gerrish (unlocated, but see Britton and Lowens 1953).
35.
Tufts, John. 1723. An introduction to the art of singing psalm-tunes. 3d ed. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
36.
Tufts, John. 1726. An introduction to the singing of psalm-tunes. 5th ed. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
37.
Tufts, John. 1728. An introduction to the singing of psalm-tunes. 7th ed. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
38.
Walter, Thomas. 1721. The grounds and rules of musicke explained. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
39.
Walter, Thomas. 1722. Sweet psalmist of Israel. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
40.
Walter, Thomas. 1723. The grounds and rules of musicke explained. 2d ed. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
41.
Watts, Isaac. 1715. Honey out of the rock. Boston: Samuel Gerrish.
