Relationships Between Melodic Error Detection,Melodic Dictation,and Melodic Sightsinging

Abstract

This study investigated the competencies of undergraduate music majors in the three aural skills of melodic error detection, melodic dictation, and melodic sightsinging. Three criterion-referenced aural tasks were developed for comparative evaluation of these competencies within the single musical parameter of pitch for diatonic, chromatic, and “atonal” melodic styles. Significant relationships were obtained among nearly all task and subtask scores, although the relationships were generally higher between error detection and dictation scores than between error detection and sightsinging scores. It also was found that differing melodic styles affected task difficulty but did not have an appreciably different effect upon the relationships between tasks.

Keywords

aural discrimination music students music theory sight reading

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Costanza, Anthony Peter. “The Development and Evaluation of Programmed Instruction in Score Reading Skills.” Unpublished doctoral dissertation. University Park: Pennsylvania State University, 1968.

Fitch, John Richard. “An Instructional Design Using Selected Contemporary Compositional Practices as the Basis for a Beginning Theory Course.” Unpublis' ed doctoral dissertation. Tucson: University of Arizona, 1970.

McMullen, Patrick T. and Daniel Bauman . Music Theory Knowledge and Skills for Beginning Teachers: A Descriptive Survey Report. Teacher Education Research Center, State University College, Fredonia, New York, 1975.

Ottman, Robert W. “A Statistical Investigation of the Influence of Selected Factors on the Skill of Sight Singing.” Unpublished doctoral dissertation. Denton: North Texas State University, 1956.

Shaw, Thomas. “A Program to Improve Choral Conducting Students' Ability to Detect Rhythmic Errors in Choral Rehearsal.” Unpublished doctoral dissertation. Denton: North Texas State University, 1971.

Sherburn, Merrell L. Critique of R. W. Ottman , “A Statistical Investigation of the influence of Selected Factors on the Skill of Sight Singing.” Council for Research in Music Education Bulletin, No. V (Spring 1965).

Sherman, Robert , et al . Aural and Visual Perception of Melody in Tonal and Atonal Musical Environments. Washington, D.C.: United States Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Office of Education, Bureau of Research, 1967.

Sidnell, Robert G. The Development of Self Instructional Drill Materials to Facilitate the Growth of Score Reading Skills of Student Conductors. Washington, D.C.: United States Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Office of Education, Bureau of Research, 1968.

Thostenson, Marvin S. The Study and Evaluation of Certain Problems in Eartraining Relative to Achievement in Sight Singing and Music Dictation. Washington, D.C.: United States Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Office of Education, Bureau of Research, 1971.