The kibbutz, once lauded as an exemplar of the Utopian organization, has been criticized recently as yet another illustration that socialist arrangements are inferior to capitalist ones. In this paper, we test a number of explanations of what happened to the kibbutz, using an analysis of the founding rate of the kibbutz population. We find support for popular accounts that the kibbutz stagnated partly as a result of the development in Israel of capitalism and of alternatives for structuring community relations. We also find that a less recognized influence, the state, was a critical determinant of favorable and unfavorable kibbutz outcomes. Our analysis shows that early in the twentieth century, the kibbutz flourished as a source of the order that the states to which it was subject were unable to provide. Over time, the states of Palestine and Israel developed more capacity to govern and displaced the kibbutz from the order-provision role. We also show an active rivalry, with the State of Israel attacking the kibbutz to shore up its own autonomy and in the process delegitimizing the kibbutz movement. These results suggest revisions to the conclusions that are typically drawn from the “kibbutz experiment.” They also suggest that some organizational forms may experience symbiosis, competition, and rivalry with the state and that these factors can be key determinants of the state's actions and the forms' evolution.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AharoniY.1991The Political Economy of Israel. Tel Aviv: Am Oved (Hebrew).
2.
BaratzJ. A.1954A Village by the Jordan: Story of Dagania. London: Hawill.
3.
BarkaiH.1977Growth Patterns of the Kibbutz Economy. Amsterdam: North Holland.
4.
BarnettW. P.CarrollG. R.1993“How institutional constraints affected the organization of early American telephony.”Journal of Law, Economics, and Organizations, 9: 98–126.
5.
BarronD. N.WestE.HannanM. T.1994“A time to grow and a time to die: Growth and mortality of credit unions in New York, 1914–1990.”American Journal of Sociology, 100: 381–421.
6.
BaumJ. A. C.OliverC.1992“institutional embeddedness and the dynamics of organizational populations.”American Sociological Review, 57: 540–559.
7.
Ben ChorinT.1983Kibbutzim and Development Towns: From Paternalism to Partnership. Haifa: Haifa University (Hebrew).
8.
Ben-RafaelE.1988Status, Power, and Conflict in the Kibbutz. Aldershot, UK: Avebury/Gower.
9.
Ben-RafaelE.1996A Non-Total Revolution. Ramat Efal: Yad Tabenkin (Hebrew).
10.
Ben-RafaelE.1997Crisis and Transformation: The Kibbutz at Century's End. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
11.
Ben-ZadokE.1985“National planning—The critical neglected link: One hundred years of Jewish settlement in Israel.”International Journal of Middle East Studies, 17: 329–345.
12.
BigerG.1994An Empire in the Holy Land: Historical Geography of the British Administration in Palestine, 1917–1929. New York: St. Mark's Press.
13.
Bloomfield-RamagemS. M.1993“The moral economy of a kibbutz in a time of crisis.” Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Catholic University of America.
14.
BowdenT.1977The Breakdown of Public Security: The Case of Ireland, 1916–1921, and Palestine, 1936–1939. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
15.
CarrollG. R.GoodsteinJ.GyenesA.1988“Organizations and the state: Effects of the institutional environment on agricultural cooperatives in Hungary.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 33: 233–256.
16.
CarrollG. R.HannanM. T.2000The Demography of Corporations and Industries. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
17.
ChafetsZ.1998“On the kibbutz, dirty hands at last.”New York Times Magazine, September, 27: 40–44.
18.
CohenM.1987Zion and State. New York: Basil Blackwell.
19.
Cohen-AlmagorR.1995“Cultural pluralism and the Israeli nation-building ideology.”International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, 27: 461–484.
20.
DiMaggioP. J.PowellW. W.1983“The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields.”American Sociological Review, 48: 147–160.
21.
DobbinF.1994Forging Industrial Policy: The United States, Britain and France in the Railway Age. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
22.
DobbinF.DowdT. J.1997“How policy shapes competition: Early railroad foundings in Massachusetts.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 42: 501–529.
23.
DobbinF., and DowdT. J.2000“The market that antitrust built: Public policy, private coercion and railroad acquisitions, 1825–1922.”American Sociological Review, 66: 631–657.
24.
DobbinF.SuttonJ. R.1998“The strength of a weak state: The rights revolution and the rise of human resource management divisions.”American Journal of Sociology, 104: 441–476.
25.
DobrevS. D.1999“The dynamics of the Bulgarian newspaper industry in a period of transition: Organizational adaptation, structural inertia and political change.”Industrial and Corporate Change, 8: 573–605.
26.
DurkheimE.1951Suicide. New York: Free Press.
27.
DurkheimE.1984The Division of Labor in Society. New York: Free Press.
28.
EdelmanL. B.UggenC.ErlangerH. S.1999“The endogeneity of legal regulation: Grievance procedures as rational myth.”American Journal of Sociology, 105: 406–454.
29.
EilatG.2000“A security party—Form and image.” In TzurE. (ed.), Can't Do Without Us: Mapam's Views on Security and Foreign Policy 1948–1956: 91–174. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad Publishing (Hebrew).
30.
EtzioniA.1966“Change of the system: The decline of neo-feudalism in Israel.” In EtzioniA. (ed.), Studies in Social Change: 180–197. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
31.
FriedrichR. J.1982“In defense of multiplicative terms in multiple regression equations.”American Journal of Political Science, 26: 797–833.
32.
GambettaD.1993The Sicilian Mafia: The Business of Private Protection. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
33.
GavronD.2000The Kibbutz: Awakening from Utopia. Lanham, Maryland: Rowan & Littlefield.
34.
GerthH. H.MillsC. W. (eds.) 1946From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. New York: Oxford University Press.
35.
GordonA. D.1938Selected Essays. New York: League for Labor in Palestine.
36.
Graham BrownS.1982“The political economy of the Jabal Nablus, 1920–1948.” In OwenR. (ed.), Studies in the Economic and Social History of Palestine in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries: 88–176. London: Macmillan.
37.
GranovetterM. S.1985“Economic action and social structure: The problem of embeddedness.”American Journal of Sociology, 91: 481–510.
38.
GreifA.1994“Cultural beliefs and the organization of society: A historical and theoretical reflection on collectivist and individualist societies.”Journal of Political Economy, 102: 912–950.
39.
GrinbergL. L.1993“The crisis of statehood: A weak state and strong political institutions in Israel.”Journal of Theoretical Politics, 5: 89–107.
Haganah1954The Hagana Book. Tel Aviv: Maarachot (Hebrew).
42.
HaMeuchadHaKibbutz1967The Report to the 19th Convention of HaKibbutz HaMeuchad. Tel Aviv: HaKibbutz HaMeuchad.
43.
HamiltonG. G.SuttonJ. R.1989“The problem of control in the weak state: Domination in the United States, 1880–1920.”Theory and Society, 18: 1–46.
44.
HannanM. T.FreemanJ.1989Organizational Ecology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
45.
HausmanJ.HallB. H.GrilichesZ.1984“Econometric models for count data with an application to the patents-R&D relationship.”Econometrica, 52: 909–937.
46.
HavemanH. A.RaoH.1997“Structuring a theory of moral sentiments: Institutional and organizational coevolution in the early thrift industry.”American Journal of Sociology, 102: 1606–1651.
47.
HechterM.2000Containing Nationalism. New York: Oxford University Press.
48.
HechterM.KanazawaS.1993“Group solidarity and social order in Japan.”Journal of Theoretical Politics, 5: 455–493.
49.
HertzR.BakerW.1983“Women and men's work in an Israeli kibbutz: Gender and allocation of labor.” In PalgiM.BlasiJ. R.RosnerM.SafirM. (eds.), Sexual Equality: The Israeli Kibbutz Tests the Theories: 154–173. Norwood, PA: Norwood Editions.
50.
HorowitzD.LissakM.1978Origins of the Israeli Polity: Palestine under the Mandate. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
51.
HyamsonA. M.1950Palestine under the Mandate, 1920–1948. London: Methuen.
52.
IngramP.RaoH.2004“Store wars: The enactment and repeal of anti-chain legislation in the United States.”American Journal of Sociology, vol. 110 (in press).
53.
IngramP.SimonsT.2000“State formation, ideological competition, and the ecology of Israeli workers” cooperatives, 1920–1992.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 45: 25–53.
54.
KatzY.1995“The religious kibbutz movement and its credo, 1935–1948.”Middle Eastern Studies, 31: 253–280.
55.
KingG.1988“Statistical models for political science event counts: Bias in conventional procedures and evidence for the exponential Poisson regression model.”American Journal of Political Science, 32: 838–863.
56.
LapidotA.ApplebaumL.YehudaiM.2000From Protection to Competition. Ramat Efal: Yad Tabenkin (Hebrew).
57.
LehrmanW. G.1994“Diversity in decline: Institutional environment and organizational failure in the American life insurance industry.”Social Forces, 73: 605–635.
58.
LeviatanU.1985“Interpretations of sex differences in work centrality among kibbutz members.”Sex Roles, 13: 287–310.
OrrenE.1978Settlement Amid Struggles: The Pre-state Strategy of Settlement 1936–1947. Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi Publications (Hebrew).
73.
ParagY.1999“Organizational death? The failure of kibbutzim.” Unpublished master's thesis, Department of Labor Studies, Tel Aviv University (Hebrew).
74.
Peel Commission1937Palestine Royal Commission Report. Cmd. 5479. London: His Majesty's Stationery Office.
75.
PutnamR. D.2000Bowling Alone. New York: Simon & Schuster.
76.
RaymanP.1981The Kibbutz Community and Nation Building. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
77.
RosnerM.Ben DavidI.AvnatA.CohenN.LeviatanU.1990The Second Generation: Continuity and Change in the Kibbutz. New York: Greenwood Press.
78.
RosolioD.1999aCrises, Adjustments and Changes in the Kibbutz Movement. Tel Aviv: Am Oved (Hebrew).
79.
RosolioD.1999b“The rise and fall of the Labor State in Israel and its two pillars: The Histadruth and the Kibbutz.” No. 86, Haifa: University of Haifa, Institute for Study and Research of the Kibbutz and Cooperative Idea.
80.
RothschildJ.WhittJ. A.1986The Cooperative Workplace: Potentials and Dilemmas of Organizational Democracy and Participation. New York: Cambridge University Press.
81.
RozenmanA.1997Settling the Country: The Story of the Settlement Department before the Establishment of Israel. Jerusalem: Mosad Bialik (Hebrew).
82.
RueschemeyerD.EvansP. B.1985“The state and economic transformation: Toward an analysis of the conditions underlying effective intervention.” In EvansP. B.RueschemeyerD.SkocpolT. (eds.), Bringing the State Back In: 44–77. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
83.
RussoM. V.2001“Institutions, exchange relations, and the emergence of new fields: Regulatory policies and independent power production in America, 1978–1992.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 46: 57–86.
84.
SchlesingerY.1977“Sex roles and social change in the kibbutz.”Journal of Marriage and the Family, 39: 771–779.
85.
SchneibergM.BartleyT.2001“Regulating American industries: Markets, politics, and the institutional determinants of fire insurance regulation.”American Journal of Sociology, 107: 101–146.
86.
SchoonhovenC. B.1981“Problems with contingency theory: Testing assumptions hidden within the language of contingency ‘theory'.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 26: 349–377.
87.
SegevT.2001One Palestine Complete: Jews and Arabs under the British Mandate. New York: Owl Books.
88.
ShalevM.1992Labour and the Political Economy in Israel. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
89.
ShermanA. J.1997Mandate Days: British Lives in Palestine, 1918–1948. London: Thames and Hudson.
90.
ShermanN.1982“From government to opposition: The rural settlement movements of the Israel Labor Party in the wake of the elections of 1977.”International Journal of Middle East Studies, 14: 53–69.
91.
ShermanN.1993“Kibbutzim and Moshavim.” In Ben-ZadokE. (ed.), Local Communities and the Israeli Polity: 211–239. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
92.
SilvermanB. S.NickersonJ. A.FreemanJ.1997“Profitability, transactional alignment, and organizational mortality in the U.S. trucking industry.”Strategic Management Journal, 18(summer special issue): 31–52.
93.
SimonsT.IngramP.1997“Organization and ideology: Kibbutzim and hired labor, 1951–1965.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 42: 784–813.
94.
SkocpolT.1985“Bringing the state back in: Strategies of analysis in current research.” In EvansP. B.RueschemeyerD.SkocpolT. (eds.), Bringing the State Back In: 1–43. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
95.
SpilermanS.HabibJ.1976“Development towns in Israel: The role of community in creating ethnic disparities in labor force characteristics.”American Journal of Sociology, 81: 781–812.
96.
StarkD.BrusztL.1998Postsocialist Pathways. New York: Cambridge University Press.
97.
StrangeS.1996The Retreat of the State. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
98.
StreeckW.SchmitterP. C.1985“Community, market, state. and associations? The prospective contribution of interest governance to social order.” In StreeckW.SchmitterP. C. (eds.), Private Interest Government: Beyond Market and State: 1–29. London: Sage.
99.
SwaminathanA.1995“The proliferation of specialist organizations in the American wine industry, 1941–1990.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 40: 653–680.
100.
SwaminathanA.WadeJ. B.2001“Social movement theory and the evolution of new organizational forms.” In SchoonhovenC. B.RomanelliE. (eds.), The Entrepreneurship Dynamic: Origins of Entrepreneurship and the Evolution of Industries: 286–313. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
101.
TalmonY.1972Family and Community in the Kibbutz. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
102.
TillyC.1985“War making and state making as organized crime.” In EvansP. B.RueschemeyerD.SkocpolT. (eds.), Bringing the State Back In: 169–191. New York: Cambridge University Press.
103.
TsizlingA.1950Humiliated and Ashamed. Pamphlet in Hebrew. Ramat Efal, Israel: Yad Tabenkin's kibbutz movement archives.
104.
TzurE.1995“Mapam and the European and Oriental immigrations.” In TorenI.LucasN. (eds.), Israel: The First Decade of Independence: 543–556. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
105.
TzurZ.1984The Kibbutz Meuchad in the Settlement of Eretz-lsrael, vol. 3: 1949–1960. Ramat Efal: Yad Tabenkin (Hebrew).
106.
UzziB.1996“The sources and consequences of embeddedness for the economic performance of organizations: The network effect.”American Sociological Review, 61: 674–698.
107.
WadeJ. B.SwaminathanA.SaxonM. S.1998“Normative and resource flow consequences of local regulations in the American brewing industry, 1845–1918.”Administrative Science Quarterly, 43: 905–935.
108.
WeintraubD.LissakM.AzmonY.1969Moshava, Kibbutz, and Moshav. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
109.
WilliamsonO. E.1985The Economic Institutions of Capitalism. New York: Free Press.
110.
WholeyD. R.ChristiansonJ. B.SanchezS. M.1992“Organizational size and failure among health maintenance organizations.”American Sociological Review, 57: 829–842.
111.
YanaiN.1982Political Crises in Israel. Jerusalem: Keter Publishing House (Hebrew).
112.
YiftachelO.TzefadiaE.1999“Policy and identity in the development towns: The case of North-African immigrants 1952–1998.” Working paper, Ben Gurion University (Hebrew).
