Part and Whole Practice for a Tracking Task: Effects of Task Variables and Amount of Practice

Abstract

Whole and part methods were compared to test Naylor's hypothesis that, in a task of high organization, whole methods should become more efficient with increased complexity. Task complexity was varied by having two levels of display-control relationship. The part versus whole comparisons were made in two conditions, one requiring early changeover, the other later changeover to whole task practice. In the early changeover condition no significant differences were found between part and whole methods at either level of complexity. With later changeover, on the other hand, pure part training was inferior to whole training in the high complexity task. This result was present only in the first block of whole practice. No differences were found with the low complexity task. The experiment offers limited support for Naylor's hypothesis. The predicted superiority of the whole method in the high complexity task was only short lived and disappeared with further practice. Furthermore, this prediction was upheld only with later changeover to whole task performance.

References

Anderson

R. C.

Part-task versus whole task procedures for teaching a problem-solving skill to first graders. Journal of Educational Psychology, 1968, 59, 207–214.

Baker

K. E.

Wylie

R. C.

Gagné

R. M.

The effects of an interfering task on the learning of a complex motor skill. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1951, 41, 1–9.

Briggs

G. E.

Tracking behavior: Comments on Dr. Poulton's paper. In Bilodeau

E. A.

(Ed.), Acquisition of skill. New York: Academic Press, 1966. Pp. 411–424.

Briggs

G. E.

Naylor

J. C.

The relative efficiency of several training methods as a function of transfer task complexity. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1962, 64, 505–512.

Briggs

G. E.

Waters

L. K.

Transfer and training as a function of component interaction. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1958, 56, 492–500.

Dick

R. A.

Independence of component tasks in a multi-dimensional tracking task. (Doctoral dissertation, Univer. of Minnesota) Ann Arbor, Mich.: University Microfilms, 1970. (71–8140)

Gladis

Abbey

Relationship between whole and part methods of learning and degree of meaningfulness of serial lists. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1969, 81, 194–196.

Goggin

Stokes

Whole and part learning as a function of approximation to English. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1969, 81, 67–71.

Kirk

R. E.

Experimental design: Procedures for the behavioral sciences. Belmont: Brooks/Cole, 1968.

10.

Naylor

J. C.

Briggs

G. E.

Effects of task complexity and task organization on the relative efficiency of part and whole training methods. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1963, 65, 217–224.

11.

Noble

Trumbo

The organization of skilled response. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1967, 2, 1–25.