Irlen Filters and Reading Strategies: Effect of Coloured Filters on Reading Achievement,Specific Reading Strategies,and Perception of Ability

Abstract

The effect of tinted nonoptical (Irlen) lenses was investigated with 29 lens-using subjects and a control group of 31 subjects. Assessment of reading four months after the initial screening showed a significant improvement in reading rate and comprehension but not in accuracy. A significant decrease in the number of pauses while reading was also noted for the lens users as well as increases in correlation between word repetition and reading rate and accuracy. The lens users also showed significantly improved scores on a scale of attitude towards school tasks.

References

Adelman

H. S.

MacDonald

V. M.

Nelson

Smith

D. S.

Taylor

(1990) Motivational readiness and the participation of children with learning and behavior problems in psychoeducational decision making. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 171–176.

Adler

Attwood

(1987) Poor readers: What do they really see on the page? A study of a major cause of dyslexia. Los Angeles, CA: Los Angeles County Office of Education.

Andrews

(1989) Psycholinguistics and reading acquisition. New South Wales Journal of Special Education, 10, 15–21.

Beimiller

(1970) The development of the use of graphic and contextual information as children learn to read. Reading Research Quarterly, 6, 75–96.

Bishop

Butterworth

(1980) Verbal performance discrepancies: Relationship to both risk and specific reading retardation. Cortex, 16, 315–389.

Blaskey

Scheiman

Parisi

Ciner

E. B.

Gallaway

Selznick

(1990) The effectiveness of Irlen filters for improved reading performance: A pilot study. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 604–612.

Boersma

F. J.

Chapman

J. W.

(1978) Comparison of Student's Perception of Ability Scale with Piers-Harris Children's Self-concept Scale. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 47, 827–832.

Bond

G. L.

Tinker

M. A.

Wasson

B. B.

(1979) Reading difficulties: Their diagnosis and correction. (4th ed.) Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Bouma

Legein

Ch. P.

(1977) Foveal and parafoveal recognition of letters and words by dyslexics and by average readers. Neuropsychologia, 15, 69–80.

10.

Bouma

Legem

Ch. P.

(1980) Dyslexia: A specific recoding deficit? An analysis of response latencies for letters and words in dyslexics and average readers. Neuropsychologia, 18, 285–298.

11.

Brannan

J. R.

Williams

M. C.

(1988) Developmental versus sensory deficit effects on perceptual processing in the reading disabled. Perception & Psychophysics, 44, 437–444.

12.

Breitmeyer

B. G.

(1989) A visually based deficit in specific reading disability. The Irish Journal of Psychology, 10, 534–541.

13.

Breznitz

(1987) Increasing first graders' reading accuracy and comprehension by accelerating their reading rates. Journal of Educational Psychology, 79, 236–242.

14.

Bruck

(1988) The word recognition and spelling of dyslexic children. Reading Research Quarterly, 23, 51–68.

15.

Bryant

P. E.

Bradley

(1985) Children's reading problems. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.

16.

Burgess

(1990) Long-term evaluation of the effect of Irlen tinted lenses on academic and related skills. Unpublished M.Ed, thesis, Univer. of Canberra, Belconnen A.C.T.

17.

Burke

(1976) A developmental study of children's reading strategies. Educational Review, 29, 30–46.

18.

Chan

L. K. S.

Robinson

G. L. W.

(1989) The effects of comprehension monitoring instruction for reading disabled students with and without tinted lenses. Australian Journal of Special Education, 13, 4–13.

19.

Chan

L. K. S.

Robinson

G. L. W.

(1990) The effects of poor readers' responsiveness to metacognition instruction in comprehension. Department of Education, Univer. of Newcastle, Australia.

20.

Chapman

J. W.

Boersma

F. J.

(1979) Academic self-concept in elementary learning-disabled children: A study with the Student's Perception of Ability Scale. Psychology in the Schools, 16, 201–206.

21.

Chapman

J. W.

Boersma

F. J.

(1982, August) The Student's Perception of Ability Scale: Cross-national validation of an instrument for measuring academic self concept. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Australian Psychological Society, Melbourne, Australia.

22.

Clay

M. M.

Imlach

R. H.

(1971) Juncture, pitch and stress as reading behavior variables. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 10, 133–139.

23.

Cohen

A. S.

(1975) Oral reading errors of first grade children taught by a code emphasis approach. Reading Research Quarterly, 10, 616–650.

24.

Cotton

M. M.

Evans

K. M.

(1990) An evaluation of Irlen lenses as a treatment for specific reading disorders. Australian Journal of Psychology, 42, 1–12.

25.

Daneman

Carpenter

P. A.

(1980) Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 19, 450–466.

26.

Eames

T. H.

(1957) The relationship of the central visual field to the speed of visual perception. American Journal of Ophthalmology, 43, 279–280.

27.

Ehri

L. C.

(1989) The development of spelling knowledge and its role in reading acquisition and reading disability. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 356–365.

28.

Ehri

L. C.

Wilce

(1985) Movement into reading: Is the first stage of printed word learning visual or phonetic? Reading Research Quarterly, 20, 163–179.

29.

Fisher

D. F.

Shebliske

W. L.

(1985) There is more that meets the eye than the eyemind assumption. In Croner

McConkie

G. W.

Menz

(Eds.), Eye movements and human information processing. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science. Pp. 149–157.

30.

Foorman

B. R.

Liberman

B. R.

(1989) Visual and phonological processing of words: A comparison of good and poor readers. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 22, 349–355.

31.

Foss

D. J.

Hakes

D. T.

(1978) Psycholinguistics. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

32.

Fricker

(1989) Do Irlen coloured glasses improve stereopsis and reading ability in children who have reading difficulties caused by visual perceptual distortion when they look at black print on white paper, and does their colour vision differ from the normal population? Unpublished Diploma of Community Child Health thesis, Flinders Univer., Adelaide, Australia.

33.

Gibson

E. J.

(1965) Learning to read. Science, 148, 1060–1072.

34.

Gole

G. A.

Dibden

S. N.

Pearson

C. R.

Pidgeon

K. J.

Hannell

Fitzgerald

B. A.

Kortman

J. Y.

McGlinchey

N. D.

(1989) Tinted lenses and dyslexics: A controlled study. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Ophthalmology, 17, 137–141.

35.

Griffin

D. C.

Walton

N. H.

Ives

(1974) Saccades as related to reading disorders. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1, 310–316.

36.

Haag

S. R.

(1984) The IDPS Children's Form: A validity study. Unpublished Master of Science thesis, California State Univer., Los Angeles.

37.

Hannell

Gole

G. A.

Dibden

S. M.

Rooney

Pidgeon

K. J.

McGlinchey

N. D.

(1989) Reading improvement with tinted lenses: A report of two cases. Clinical and Experimental Optometry, 12, 170–176.

38.

Harding

L. M.

Beech

J. R.

Sneddon

(1985) The changing pattern of reading errors and reading style from 5 to 11 years of age. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 55, 45–52.

39.

Holland

K. C.

Tyrrell

Wilkins

(1991) The effect of Irlen coloured lenses on saccadic eye movements and reading. Paper presented at the Coloured Spectacles and Reading Difficulties Seminar, London.

40.

Hood

(1976) Qualitative analysis of oral reading errors: The interjudge reliability of scores. Reading Research Quarterly, 11, 577–598.

41.

Howell

Stanley

(1988) Colour and learning disability. Clinical and Experimental Optometry, 71, 66–71.

42.

Irlen

(1983) Successful treatment of learning disabilities. Paper presented at the 91st Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, Anaheim, California.

43.

Jennings

G. D. J.

Underwood

(1984) The influence of parafoveal information on a simple reading task. In Gale

A. G.

Johnson

(Eds.), Theoretical and applied aspects of eye movement research. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science. Pp. 179–185.

44.

Juel

Griffith

Gough

(1986) Acquisitions of literacy: A longitudinal study of children in first and second grade. Journal of Educational Psychology, 78, 243–255.

45.

Just

M. A.

Carpenter

P. A.

(1980) A theory of reading: From eye fixations to comprehension. Psychological Review, 87, 329–354.

46.

Kirby

J. R.

Williams

N. H.

(1991) Learning problems: A cognitive approach. Toronto, Canada: Kagan & Woo.

47.

Kreuttner

Strum

(1990) The Irlen approach: An intervention for students with low reading achievement and symptoms of Scotopic Sensitivity Syndrome. New York City Schools, New York.

48.

Kyd

L. J. C.

Sutherland

G. F. M.

McGettrick

P. M.

(1992) A preliminary appraisal of the Irlen screening process for Scotopic Sensitivity Syndrome and the effect or Irlen coloured overlays on reading. The British Orthoptic Journal, 49, 25–30.

49.

LaBerge

Samuels

(1974) Toward a theory of automatic information processing in reading. Cognitive Psychology, 6, 293–323.

50.

Lea

A. R.

Hailey

D. M.

(1990) Tinted lenses in the treatment of the reading disabled. Canberra: Australian Institute of Health.

51.

Legein

Ch. P.

Bouma

(1982) Reading and the ophthalmologist. Documenta Ophthalmologica, 53, 123–157.

52.

Lehmkuhle

Garzia

R. P.

Turner

Hash

Baro

J. A.

(1993) A defective visual pathway in children with reading disability. New England Journal of Medicine, 328, 989–996.

53.

Liberman

I. Y.

Shankweiler

(1985) Phonology and the problem of learning to read and write. RASE, 6, 8–17.

54.

Livingstone

M. S.

Hubel

D. H.

(1987) Psychophysical evidence for separate channels for the perception of form, color, movement and depth. Journal of Neuroscience, 7, 3416–3468.

55.

Livingstone

M. S.

Rosen

G. D.

Drislane

F. W.

Galaburda

A. M.

(1991) Physiological and anatomical evidence for a magnocellular defect in developmental dyslexia. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA, 88, 7943–7947.

56.

Lovegrove

W. J.

(1984) Dyslexia and the vision factor. Education News, 19, 15–18.

57.

Lovegrove

W. J.

Martin

Slaghuis

W. A.

(1986) Theoretical and experimental case for a visual deficit in specific reading disability. Cognitive Neuropsychology, 3, 225–267.

58.

Lovegrove

W. J.

Garzia

R. P.

Nicholson

S. B.

(1990) Experimental evidence for a transient system deficit in specific reading disability. Journal of the American Optometric Association, 61, 137–146.

59.

Lovett

M. W.

(1986) Sentential structure and the perceptual spans of two samples of disabled readers. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 15, 153–175.

60.

Lovett

M. W.

(1987) A developmental approach to reading disability: Accuracy and speed criteria of normal and deficient reading skill. Child Development, 58, 234–260.

61.

Lunzer

Gardiner

(Eds.) (1979) The effective use of reading. London: Heinemann.

62.

Mazer

S. R.

McIntyre

C. W.

Murray

M. E.

Till

R. E.

Blackwell

S. L.

(1983) Visual persistence and information pick up in learning disabled children. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 16, 221–225.

63.

McIntyre

C. W.

Murray

M. E.

Cronin

C. M.

Blackwell

S. L.

(1978) Span of apprehension in learning disabled boys. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 11, 468–475.

64.

McLachlan

Yale

Wilkins

(in press) Open trial of subjective precision tinting: A follow-up of 55 patients. Ophthalmological and Physiological Optics.

65.

Meares

(1980) Figure/ground, brightness, contrast and reading disabilities. Visible Language, 14, 13–29.

66.

Miller

L. S.

(1984) Scotopic sensitivity and reading disability. Unpublished Master of Education thesis, California State Univer, Los Angeles.

67.

Neale

M. D.

(1966) Neale Analysis of Reading Ability. London: Macmillan.

68.

Neville

M. H.

Pugh

A. K.

(1977) Context in reading and listening: Variations in approach to close tasks. Reading Research Quarterly, 12, 13–31.

69.

Oakan

Weiner

Cromer

(1971) Identification, organisation and reading comprehension in good and poor readers. Journal of Educational Psychology, 62, 71–78.

70.

Oakhill

Garnham

(1988) On becoming a skilled reader. London: Blackwell.

71.

O'Connor

P. D.

Sofo

Kendall

Olsen

(1990) Reading disabilities and the effects of colored filters. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 597–603, 620.

72.

Paris

S. G.

Oka

E. R.

(1986) Self-regulated learning among exceptional children. Exceptional Children, 53, 103–108.

73.

Pavlides

C. A.

(1985) Eye movements in dyslexia: Their diagnostic significance. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 18, 42–50.

74.

Perfetti

C. A.

(1985) Reading ability. New York: Oxford Univer. Press.

75.

Prior

M. R.

(1989) Reading disability: “normative” or “pathological.” Australian Journal of Psychology, 41, 135–158.

76.

Riding

R. J.

Pugh

J. C.

(1977) Iconic memory and reading performance in nine-year-old children. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 47, 132–137.

77.

Robinson

G. L.

(1990) An evaluation of the Irlen lenses as a treatment for specific reading disorders—commentary on M. M. Cotton and K. M. Evans. Australian Journal of Psychology, 42, 13–15.

78.

Robinson

G. L.

Conway

R. N. F.

(1990) The effects of Irlen colored lenses on specific reading skills and perception of ability: A twelve month validity study. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 23, 588–597.

79.

Robinson

G. L.

Miles

(1987) The use of coloured overlays to improve visual processing: A preliminary survey. The Exceptional Child, 34, 65–70.

80.

Rourke

B. P.

(1989) Nonverbal learning disabilities: The syndrome and the model. New York: Guilford.

81.

Saint-John

L. M.

White

M. A.

(1988) The effect of coloured transparencies on the reading performance of reading disabled children. Australian Journal of Psychology, 40, 403–411.

82.

Sakitt

(1976) Iconic memory. Psychological Review, 83, 257–276.

83.

Simons

H. D.

Grisham

J. D.

(1987) Binocular anomalies and reading problems. Journal of the American Optometric Association, 58, 578–587.

84.

Solman

R. T.

Cho

Datn

S. J.

(1992) Colour-mediated grouping effects in good and disabled readers. Ophthalmological and Physiological Optics, 11, 320–327.

85.

Solman

R. T.

Datn

S. J.

Keech

S. L.

(1991) Color-mediated contrast sensitivity in disabled readers. Optometry and Vision Science, 68, 331–337.

86.

Spache

G. D.

(1976) Investigating the issues of reading disabilities. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.

87.

Spafford

Grosser

G. S.

(1991) Retinal differences in light sensitivity between dyslexic and proficient reading children: New prospects for optometric input in diagnosing dyslexia. Journal of the American Optometric Association, 62, 610–615.

88.

Stanley

(1990) Rose coloured spectacles: A cure for dyslexia? Australian Psychologist, 25, 65–76.

89.

Stanley

Hall

(1973) Short term visual processing in dyslexics. Child Development, 44, 841–844.

90.

Stanovich

K. E.

(1980) Toward an interactive-compensatory model of individual differences in development of reading fluency. Reading Research Quarterly, 16, 32–71.

91.

Stanovich

K. E.

(1981) The relationship between word decoding speed, general name retrieval ability and reading progress in first grade children. Journal of Educational Psychology, 6, 809–815.

92.

Stanovich

K. E.

(1986) Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21, 360–407.

93.

Stanovich

K. E.

(1991) Discrepancy definitions in reading disability: Has intelligence led us astray? Reading Research Quarterly, 26, 7–29.

94.

Stein

Fowler

(1985) Effect of monocular occlusion on visuomotor perception and reading in dyslexic children. The Lancet, 2, 68–73.

95.

Stolzenberg

M. E.

Ritty

J. M.

Cohen

Ltebegmann

(1989) Effects of ocular functioning and time upon reading proficiency. Journal of the American Optometric Association, 60, 122–126.

96.

Wagner

R. K.

(1988) Causal relationships between the development of phonological processing abilities and the acquisition or reading skills: A meta-analysis. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 34, 261–279.

97.

Watson

A. J.

Sinclair

K. E.

Cooney

G. H.

March

H. W.

(1988) The development of children's cognition, oral language, and reading: A five year longitudinal study. Genetic, Social and General Psychology Monographs, 114, 509–553.

98.

Weber

R. M.

(1970) A linguistic analysis of first grade reading errors. Reading Research Quarterly, 5, 427–451.

99.

Wechsler

(1974) Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children—Revised. New York: Psychological Corp.

100.

Whiting

(1985) How difficult can reading be? New insight into reading problems. Journal of the English Teachers Association, 49, 49–55.

101.

Whiting

Robinson

G. L.

(1988) Using Irlen coloured lenses for reading: A clinical study. Australian Educational and Developmental Psychologist, 5, 7–10.

102.

Wilkins

Neary

(1991) Some visual, optometric and perceptual effects of coloured glasses. Ophthalmological and Physiological Optics, 11, 163–171.

103.

Wilkins

Wilkinson

(1991) A tint to reduce eye strain from fluorescent lighting: Preliminary observations. Ophthalmological and Physiological Optics, 11, 172–175.

104.

Williams

M. C.

Bologna

N. B.

(1985) Perceptual grouping in good and poor readers. Perception & Psychophysics, 38, 367–374.

105.

Williams

M. C.

Brannan

J. R.

Latrigue

E. K.

(1987) Visual search in good and poor readers. Clinical Vision Sciences, 1, 361–371.

106.

Williams

M. C.

Lecluyse

Rock Faucheux

(1992) Effective interventions for reading disability. Journal of the American Optometric Association, 63, 411–417.

107.

Willich

Prior

Cummtng

Spanos

(1988) Are disabled readers delayed or different? An approach using an objective miscue analysis. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 58, 315–329.

108.

Winter

(1987) Irlen lenses: An appraisal. Australian Educational and Developmental Psychologist, 5, 7–10.

109.

Wong

B. Y. L.

(1986) Metacognition and special education: A review of a view. The Journal of Special Education, 20, 9–29.