The correspondence between trends in the mass media and trends in public opinion has important practical, theoretical, and methodological implications—even if we cannot untangle the causal relationships involved. The present study attempts to clarify empirically the aggregate-level mass media—public opinion connection for one major political issue, the Arab-Israeli conflict. Mass media data came from a content analysis of 867 elite newspaper editorials on the dispute (1972–1982); public opinion data came from the frequently asked Middle East “sympathy” question. Favorability measures for editorials, mass public opinion, and college-educated public opinion were highly intercorrelated, in part as a result of a common time trend. When this time trend was partialled out, significant relationships remained between editorial opinion and public opinion. In addition, events heavily covered in mass media tended to crystallize opinion among the college educated but not among the mass public.
References
1.
AdamsW. (1982a) Blaming Israel for Begin. Public Opinion, 5(2), 51–55.
2.
AdamsW. (1982b) Middle East meets West: surveying American attitudes. Public Opinion, 5(5), 51–55.
3.
AdamsW. C. (Ed.) (1981) Television coverage of the Middle East. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
4.
AdamsW. C.HeylP. (1981) From Cairo to Kabul with the networks, 1972–1980. In AdamsW. (Ed.), Television coverage of the Middle East. Norwood, NJ: Ablex. Pp. 1–39.
5.
AlmondG. (1950) The American people and foreign policy. New York: Harcourt-Brace.
6.
AsiM. O. (1981a) Arabs, Israelis, and TV news: a time-series content analysis. In AdamsW. (Ed.), Television coverage of the Middle East. Norwood, NJ: Ablex. Pp. 67–75.
7.
AsiM. O. (1981b) Arabs, Israelis and U.S. television networks: a content analysis of how ABC, CBS, and NBC reported the news between 1970 and 1979. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Ohio Univer., Athens, OH.
8.
BagniedM.SchneiderS. (1981) Sadat goes to Jerusalem: televised images, themes and agendas. In AdamsW. (Ed.), Television coverage of the Middle East. Norwood, NJ: Ablex. Pp. 53–66.
9.
BardM. (1985) Israel's standing in American public opinion. Commentary, 80(4), 58–60.
10.
BelkaouiJ. M. (1978) Images of Arabs and Israelis in the prestige press. Journalism Quarterly, 55, 732–799.
11.
BerelsonB. (1960) Communications and public opinion. In SchrammW. (Ed.), Mass communications. Urbana, IL: Univer. of Illinois Press. Pp. 527–543.
12.
CohenB. (1963) The press and foreign policy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univer. Press.
13.
CohenB. (1973) The public's impact upon foreign policy. Boston, MA: Little-Brown.
14.
CooperA. M. (1982) Review of AdamsW. C. (Ed.), Television coverage of the Middle East.’ Journalism Quarterly, 59, 494–495.
15.
CurtissR. (1982) A changing image: American perceptions of the Arab-Israeli conflict. Washington, DC: American Educational Trust.
16.
EpsteinB. R. (1978) U.S. Opinion and the Middle East. Unpublished B'nai B'rith Anti-defamation League memorandum, New York.
17.
GilboaE. (1985) Effects of the war in Lebanon on American attitudes toward Israel and the Arab-Israeli conflict. Middle East Review, 18(1), 30–43.
18.
IyengarS.SuleimanM. (1980) Trends in American public support for Israel and Egypt 1956–1978. American Politics Quarterly, 8, 34–60.
19.
KrausS.DavisD. (1976) The effects of mass communication upon political behavior. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State Univer. Press.
20.
KresselN. J. (1983) American public opinion and mass media coverage of the Arab-Israeli conflict 1948–1982. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Psychology and Social Relations, Harvard Univer., Cambridge, MA.
21.
KresselN. J. (1987) Biased judgements of media bias: a case study of the Arab-Israeli dispute. Political Psychology, 8, 211–227.
22.
LeeJ. (1972) Editorial support and campaign news. Journalism Quarterly, 49, 710–716.
23.
LipsetS. M.SchneiderW. (1977) Carter vs. Israel: what the polls reveal. Commentary, 64(5), 21–29.
24.
QuantW. B. (1977) Decade of decisions. Los Angeles, CA: Univer. of California Press.
25.
RepassD. E.ChaffeeS. (1968) Administrative vs. campaign coverage of two presidents in eight partisan dailies. Journalism Quarterly, 45, 528–531.
26.
RogersE. M. (1983) Diffusion of innovations. (3rd ed.) New York: Free Press.
SchneiderW. (1979) Is Israel losing popular support: the evidence of the polls. Politics Today (March/April), 14–16.
29.
StemberC. H.RingerB. (1966) The impact of Israel on American attitudes. In StemberC. H. (Ed.), Jews in the mind of America. New York: Basic Books. Pp. 171–196.
30.
SuleimanM. W. (1975) Perceptions of the Middle East in American magazines. In Abu-LughodB.ZeadeyF. T. (Eds.), Arabs in America: myths and realities. Wilmette, IL: Medina Univer. Press International. Pp. 35–55.
31.
TerryJ. (1971) A content analysis of American newspapers. In JabaraA.TerryJ. (Eds.), The Arab world from nationalism to revolution. Wilmette, IL: Medina Univer. Press International. Pp. 94–113.
32.
TriceR. H. (1979) The American elite press and the Arab-Israeli conflict. The Middle East Journal, 33, 304–325.
33.
ZuckerH. G. (1978) The variable nature of news media influence. Communication Yearbook, 2, 225–242.
