Computed Nasal Resistance Compared with Patient-Reported Symptoms in Surgically Treated Nasal Airway Passages: A Preliminary Report

Abstract

Background

Nasal airway obstruction (NAO) is a common health condition impacting mood, energy, recreation, sleep, and overall quality of life. Nasal surgery often addresses NAO but the results are sometimes unsatisfactory. Evaluating surgical treatment efficacy could be improved if objective tests were available that correlated with patient-reported measures of symptoms. The goal of this study was to develop methods for comparing nasal resistance computed by computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models with patient-reported symptoms of NAO using early data from a 4-year prospective study.

Methods

Computed tomography (CT) scans and patient-reported scores from the Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation (NOSE) scale and a visual analog scale (VAS) measuring unilateral airflow sensation were obtained pre- and postoperatively in two NAO patients showing no significant mucosal asymmetry who were successfully treated with functional nasal surgery, including septoplasty. Pre- and postsurgery CFD models were created from the CT scans. Numerical simulation of steady-state inspiratory airflow was used to calculate bilateral and unilateral CFD-derived nasal resistance (CFD-NR).

Results

In both subjects, NOSE and VAS scores improved after surgery, bilateral CFD-NR decreased, and unilateral CFD-NR decreased on the affected side. In addition, NOSE and VAS scores tracked with unilateral CFD-NR on the affected side.

Conclusion

These preliminary results suggest a possible correlation between unilateral NR and patient-reported symptoms and imply that analysis of unilateral obstruction should focus on the affected side. A formal investigation of unilateral CFD-NR and patient-reported symptoms in a series of NAO patients is needed to determine if these variables are correlated.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Rhee

J.S.

, Book

D.T.

, Burzynski

. Quality of life assessment in nasal airway obstruction. Laryngoscope 113: 1118–1122, 2003.

Manoukian

P.D.

, Wyatt

J.R.

, Leopold

D.A.

. Recent trends in utilization of procedures in otolaryngology-head and neck surgery. Laryngoscope 107: 472–477, 1997.

Singh

, Patel

, Kenyon

. Is there objective evidence that septal surgery improves nasal airflow? J Laryngol Otol 120: 916–920, 2006.

Andre

R.F.

, D'Souza

A.R.

, Kunst

H.P.

. Sub-alar batten grafts as treatment for nasal valve incompetence; description of technique and functional evaluation. Rhinology 44: 118–122, 2006.

Dinis

P.B.

, and Haider

. Septoplasty: Long-term evaluation of results. Am J Otolaryngol 23: 85–90, 2002.

Illum

. Septoplasty and compensatory inferior turbinate hypertrophy: Long-term results after randomized turbinoplasty. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 254(suppl 1): S89–S92, 1997.

Schumacher

M.J.

. Nasal congestion and airway obstruction: The validity of available objective and subjective measures. Curr Allergy Asthma Rep 2: 245–251, 2002.

Kjaergaard

, Cvancarova

, and Steinsvag

S.K.

. Does nasal obstruction mean that the nose is obstructed? Laryngoscope 118: 1476–1481, 2008.

Lam

D.J.

, James

K.T.

, and Weaver

E.M.

. Comparison of anatomic, physiological, and subjective measures of the nasal airway. Am J Rhinol 20: 463–470, 2006.

10.

Pawar

S.S.

, Garcia

G.J.

, Kimbell

J.S.

. Objective measures in aesthetic and functional nasal surgery: Perspectives on nasal form and function. Facial Plast Surg 26: 320–327, 2010.

11.

Andre

R.F.

, Vuyk

H.D.

, Ahmed

. Correlation between subjective and objective evaluation of the nasal airway. A systematic review of the highest level of evidence. Clin Otolaryngol 34: 518–525, 2009.

12.

Leong

S.C.

, Chen

X.B.

, Lee

H.P.

. A review of the implications of computational fluid dynamic studies on nasal airflow and physiology. Rhinology 48: 139–145, 2010.

13.

Chen

X.B.

, Lee

H.P.

, Chong

V.F.

. Numerical simulation of the effects of inferior turbinate surgery on nasal airway heating capacity. Am J Rhinol Allergy 24: e118–e122, 2010.

14.

Chen

X.B.

, Lee

H.P.

, Chong

V.F.

. Assessments of nasal bone fracture effects on nasal airflow: A computational fluid dynamics study. Am J Rhinol Allergy 25: e39–e43, 2011.

15.

Chen

X.B.

, Lee

H.P.

, Chong

V.F.

. A computational fluid dynamics model for drug delivery in a nasal cavity with inferior turbinate hypertrophy. J Aerosol Med Pulm Drug Deliv 23: 329–338, 2010.

16.

Garcia

G.J.

, Bailie

, Martins

D.A.

. Atrophic rhinitis: A CFD study of air conditioning in the nasal cavity. J Appl Physiol 103: 1082–1092, 2007.

17.

Garcia

G.J.

, Rhee

J.S.

, Senior

B.A.

. Septal deviation and nasal resistance: An investigation using virtual surgery and computational fluid dynamics. Am J Rhinol Allergy 24: e46–e53, 2010.

18.

Xiong

, Zhan

, Zuo

. Numerical flow simulation in the post-endoscopic sinus surgery nasal cavity. Med Biol Eng Comput 46: 1161–1167, 2008.

19.

C.C.

, Hsiao

H.D.

, Lee

L.C.

. Computational fluid dynamic study on obstructive sleep apnea syndrome treated with maxillomandibular advancement. J Craniofac Surg 20: 426–430, 2009.

20.

Chung

S.K.

, and Kim

S.K.

. Digital particle image velocimetry studies of nasal airflow. Respir Physiol Neurobiol 163: 111–120, 2008.

21.

Ozlugedik

, Nakiboglu

, Sert

. Numerical study of the aerodynamic effects of septoplasty and partial lateral turbinectomy. Laryngoscope 118: 330–334, 2008.

22.

Wexler

, Segal

, and Kimbell

. Aerodynamic effects of inferior turbinate reduction: Computational fluid dynamics simulation. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 131: 1102–1107, 2005.

23.

Garlapati

R.R.

, Lee

H.P.

, Chong

F.H.

. Indicators for the correct usage of intranasal medications: A computational fluid dynamics study. Laryngoscope 119: 1975–1982, 2009.

24.

Lee

H.P.

, Poh

H.J.

, Chong

F.H.

. Changes of airflow pattern in inferior turbinate hypertrophy: A computational fluid dynamics model. Am J Rhinol Allergy 23: 153–158, 2009.

25.

Lee

H.P.

, Garlapati

R.R.

, Chong

V.F.

. Effects of septal perforation on nasal airflow: Computer simulation study. J Laryngol Otol 124: 48–54, 2010.

26.

Roithmann

, Cole

, Chapnik

. Acoustic rhinometry, rhinomanometry, and the sensation of nasal patency: A correlative study. J Otolaryngol 23: 454–458, 1994.

27.

Naito

, Cole

, and Fraschetti

. Nasal patency: Subjective and objective. Am J Rhinol 3: 93–97, 1989.

28.

Stewart

M.G.

, Witsell

D.L.

, Smith

T.L.

. Development and validation of the Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation (NOSE) scale. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 130: 157–163, 2004.

29.

Stewart

M.G.

, Smith

T.L.

, Weaver

E.M.

. Outcomes after nasal septoplasty: Results from the Nasal Obstruction Septoplasty Effectiveness (NOSE) study. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 130: 283–290, 2004.

30.

Rhee

J.S.

, Poetker

D.M.

, Smith

T.L.

. Nasal valve surgery improves disease-specific quality of life. Laryngoscope 115: 437–440, 2005.

31.

Most

S.P.

. Analysis of outcomes after functional rhinoplasty using a disease-specific quality-of-life instrument. Arch Facial Plast Surg 8: 306–309, 2006.

32.

Tomkinson

, and Eccles

. Comparison of the relative abilities of acoustic rhinometry, rhinomanometry and the visual analog scale in detecting change in the nasal cavity in a healthy adult population. Am J Rhinol 10: 161–165, 1996.

33.

Garcia

G.J.

, Schroeter

J.D.

, Segal

R.A.

. Dosimetry of nasal uptake of water-soluble and reactive gases: A first study of interhuman variability. Inhal Toxicol 21: 607–618, 2009.

34.

Guyton

A.C.

. Physiology of the Human Body. Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Saunders Company. 233–248, 1979.

35.

Kimbell

J.S.

, Segal

R.A.

, Asgharian

. Characterization of deposition from nasal spray devices using a computational fluid dynamics model of the human nasal passages. J Aerosol Med 20: 59–74, 2007.

36.

Subramaniam

R.P.

, Richardson

R.B.

, Morgan

K.T.

. Computational fluid dynamics simulations of inspiratory airflow in the human nose and nasopharynx. Inhal Toxicol 10: 91–120, 1998.

37.

Hinds

W.C.

. Aerosol Technology: Properties, Behavior, and Measurement of Airborne Particles. New York, NY: Wiley, 452, 1999.

38.

Naftali

, Schroter

R.C.

, Shiner

R.J.

. Transport phenomena in the human nasal cavity: A computational model. Ann Biomed Eng 26: 831–839, 1998.

39.

Naito

, Cole

, Chaban

. Nasal resistance, sensation of obstruction, and rhinoscopic findings compared. Am J Rhinol 2: 65–69, 1988.

40.

Cole

. Nasal airflow resistance: A survey of 2500 assessments. Am J Rhinol 11: 415–420, 1997.

41.

Moore

E.J.

, and Kern

E.B.

. Atrophic rhinitis: A review of 242 cases. Am J Rhinol 15: 355–361, 2001.

42.

Canakcioglu

, Tahamiler

, Saritzali

. Nasal patency by rhinomanometry in patients with sensation of nasal obstruction. Am J Rhinol Allergy 23: 300–302, 2009.

43.

Calhoun

K.H.

, House

, Hokanson

J.A.

. Normal nasal airway-resistance in noses of different sizes and shapes. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 103: 605–609, 1990.

44.

Gleeson

M.J.

, Youlten

L.J.

, Shelton

D.M.

. Assessment of nasal airway patency: A comparison of four methods. Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci 11: 99–107, 1986.

45.

Schreck

, Sullivan

K.J.

, Ho

C.M.

. Correlations between flow resistance and geometry in a model of the human nose. J Appl Physiol 75: 1767–1775, 1993.

46.

Keyhani

, Scherer

P.W.

, and Mozell

M.M.

. Numerical simulation of airflow in the human nasal cavity. J Biomech Eng 117: 429–441, 1995.

47.

Chung

S.K.

, Son

Y.R.

, Shin

S.J.

. Nasal airflow during respiratory cycle. Am J Rhinol 20: 379–384, 2006.

48.

Hahn

, Scherer

P.W.

, and Mozell

M.M.

. Velocity profiles measured for airflow through a large-scale model of the human nasal cavity. J Appl Physiol 75: 2273–2287, 1993.

49.

Kelly

J.T.

, Prasad

A.K.

, and Wexler

A.S.

. Detailed flow patterns in the nasal cavity. J Appl Physiol 89: 323–337, 2000.

50.

Rhee

J.S.

. Measuring outcomes in nasal surgery: Realities and possibilities. Arch Facial Plast Surg 11: 416–419, 2009.