Standalone Balloon Dilation versus Sinus Surgery for Chronic Rhinosinusitis: A Prospective,Multicenter,Randomized,Controlled Trial

Abstract

Background

A prospective randomized controlled study was conducted on patients with chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) to test the hypotheses that symptom improvement after balloon dilation was noninferior to functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS) and balloon dilation was superior to FESS for postoperative debridements.

Methods

Adults with uncomplicated CRS of the maxillary sinuses with or without anterior ethmoid disease who met criteria for medically necessary FESS were randomized 1:1 to office balloon dilation or FESS and followed for 6 months. A minimum of 36 patients per arm were required to test the hypotheses with 90% power. Symptom improvement using the validated 20-item Sino-Nasal Outcome Test (SNOT-20) survey, debridements, recovery outcomes, complications, and revision surgeries were compared between groups.

Results

Ninety-two patients (50 balloon dilation; 42 FESS) were treated. Mean SNOT-20 improvement was 1.67 ± 1.10 and 1.60 ± 0.96 in the balloon and FESS arms, respectively. Both groups showed clinically meaningful and statistically significant (p < 0.0001) improvement and the balloon arm was noninferior (p < 0.001) to FESS. The mean number of postprocedure debridements per patient was 0.1 ± 0.6 in the balloon arm versus 1.2 ± 1.0 in the FESS arm, with the balloon group showing superiority (p < 0.0001). Occurrence of postoperative nasal bleeding (p = 0.011), duration of prescription pain medication use (p < 0.001), recovery time (p = 0.002), and short-term symptom improvement (p = 0.014) were all significantly better for balloon dilation versus FESS. No complications occurred in either group and one revision surgery was reported in each arm.

Conclusion

Balloon dilation is noninferior to FESS for symptom improvement and superior to FESS for postoperative debridements in patients with maxillary and anterior ethmoid disease. Balloon dilation is an effective treatment in patients with uncomplicated CRS who meet the criteria for medically necessary FESS.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Schiller

J.S.

Lucas

J.W.

Ward

B.W.

and Peregoy

J.A.

Summary health statistics for U.S. adults: National Health Interview Survey, 2010. National Center for Health Statistics.

Vital Health Stat 10: 252, 2012.

Bhattacharyya

Incremental health care utilization and expenditures for chronic rhinosinusitis in the United States.

Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 120: 423–427, 2011.

Levine

H.L.

Sertich

2nd , Hoisington

D.R.

Multicenter registry of balloon catheter sinusotomy outcomes for 1,036 patients.

Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 117: 263–270, 2008.

Stankiewicz

Truitt

Atkins

Two-year results: transantral balloon dilation of the ethmoid infundibulum.

Int Forum Allergy Rhinol 2: 199–206, 2012.

Weiss

R.L.

Church

C.A.

Kuhn

F.A.

Long-term outcome analysis of balloon catheter sinusotomy: Two-year follow-up.

Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 139: S38–S46, 2008.

Albritton

4th , Casiano

R.R.

and Sillers

M.J.

Feasibility of in-office endoscopic sinus surgery with balloon sinus dilation.

Am J Rhinol Allergy 26: 243–248, 2012.

Karanfilov

Silvers

Pasha

Office-based balloon sinus dilation: A prospective, multicenter study of 203 patients.

Int Forum Allergy Rhinol 3: 404–411, 2013.

Brodner

Nachlas

Mock

Safety and outcomes following hybrid balloon and balloon-only procedures using a multifunction, multisinus balloon dilation tool.

Int Forum Allergy Rhinol doi: 10.1002/alr.21156. [Epub ahead of print Feb 19, 2013.]

Ahmed

Pal

Hopkins

and Jayaraj

Functional endoscopic balloon dilation of sinus ostia for chronic rhinosinusitis.

Cochrane Database Syst Rev 5: CD008515, 2010. (DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD008515.)

10.

Burton

M.J.

Bhattacharyya

and Rosenfeld

R.M.

Extracts from the Cochrane Library: Functional endoscopic balloon dilation of sinus ostia for chronic rhinosinusitis.

Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 145: 371–374, 2011.

11.

Altman

D.G.

Schulz

K.F.

Moher

The revised CONSORT statement for reporting randomized trials: Explanation and elaboration.

Ann Intern Med 134: 663–694, 2001.

12.

Rosenfeld

R.M.

Andes

Bhattacharyya

Clinical practice guideline: Adult sinusitis.

Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 137: S1–S31, 2007.

13.

Anthem Insurance Companies. Functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS). policy number CG-SURG-24. North Haven, CT: Anthem Insurance Companies, Inc. Available online at http://www.anthem.com/medicalpolicies/guidelines/gl_pw_a051164.htm. Last accessed August 31, 2011.

14.

BlueCross BlueShield of North Carolina. Policy number: Functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS). Chicago, IL: BlueCross BlueShield Association. Available online at http://www.bcbsnc.com/assets/services/public/pdfs/medicalpolicy/functional_endoscopic_sinus_surgery_fess.pdf. Last accessed December 31, 2011.

15.

Piccirillo

Merritt

M.G.

Jr. , and Richards

M.L.

Psychometric and clinimetric validity of the 20-Item Sino-Nasal Outcome Test (SNOT-20).

Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 126: 41–47, 2002.

16.

Hintze

(2008). PASS 2008. NCSS, LLC.

Kaysville, UT.

www.ncss.com

17.

Hochberg

and Benjamini

More powerful procedures for multiple significance testing.

Stat Med 9: 811–818, 1990.

18.

Pynnonen

M.A.

Kim

H.M.

and Terrell

J.E.

Validation of the Sino-Nasal Outcome Test 20 (SNOT-20) domains in nonsurgical patients.

Am J Rhinol Allergy 23: 40–45, 2009.

19.

Browne

J.P.

Hopkins

Slack

and Cano

S.J.

The Sino-Nasal Outcome Test (SNOT): Can we make it more clinically meaningful?

Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 136: 736–741, 2007.

20.

Chester

A.C.

and Sindwani

Symptom outcomes in endoscopic sinus surgery: A systematic review of measurement methods.

Laryngoscope 117: 2239–2243, 2007.

21.

Rudmik

and Smith

T.L.

Quality of life in patients with chronic rhinosinusitis.

Curr Allergy Asthma Rep 11: 247–252, 2011.

22.

Soler

Z.M.

and Smith

T.L.

Quality-of-life outcomes after endoscopic sinus surgery: How long is long enough?

Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 143: 621–625, 2010.

23.

Rudmik

Soler

Z.M.

Orlandi

R.R.

Early postoperative care following endoscopic sinus surgery: An evidence-based review with recommendations.

Int Forum Allergy Rhinol 1: 417–430, 2011.

24.

Tan

B.K.

and Chandra

R.K.

Postoperative prevention and treatment of complications after sinus surgery.

Otolaryngol Clin North Am 43: 769–779, 2010.

25.

Ramakrishnan

V.R.

and Suh

J.D.

How necessary are postoperative debridements after endoscopic sinus surgery?

Laryngoscope 121: 8–9, 2011.

26.

Lee

J.Y.

and Byun

J.Y.

Relationship between the frequency of postoperative debridement and patient discomfort, healing period, surgical outcomes, and compliance after endoscopic sinus surgery.

Laryngoscope 118: 1868–1872, 2008.

27.

Portela

R.A.

Hootnick

and McGinn

Perioperative care in functional endoscopic sinus surgery: A survey study.

Int Forum Allergy Rhinol 2: 27–33, 2012.

28.

Kuhn

F.A.

Church

C.A.

Goldberg

A.N.

Balloon catheter sinusotomy: One-year follow-up–outcomes and role in functional endoscopic sinus surgery.

Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 139: S27–S37, 2008.

29.

Cutler

Truitt

Atkins

First clinic experience: Patient selection and outcomes for ostial dilation for chronic rhinosinusitis.

Int Forum Allergy Rhinol 1: 460–465, 2011.

30.

Plaza

Eisenberg

Montojo

Balloon dilation of the frontal recess: A randomized clinical trial.

Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 120: 511–518, 2011.

31.

Achar

Duvvi

and Kumar

B.N.

Endoscopic dilatation sinus surgery (FEDS) versus functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS) for treatment of chronic rhinosinusitis: A pilot study.

ACTA Otorhinolaryngol Ital 32: 314–319, 2012.