A number of studies have documented the cognitive outcomes associated with bilingualism. To gain a clear understanding of the extent and diversity of these cognitive outcomes, the authors conducted a meta-analysis of studies that examined the cognitive correlates of bilingualism. Data from 63 studies (involving 6,022 participants) were extracted and analyzed following established protocols and procedures for conducting systematic reviews and guidelines for meta-analysis. Results indicate that bilingualism is reliably associated with several cognitive outcomes, including increased attentional control, working memory, metalinguistic awareness, and abstract and symbolic representation skills. Overall mean effect sizes varied from small to large, depending on the cognitive outcomes measured, and were moderated by methodological features of the studies.
AbramiP. C.BernardR. M. (2006). Research on distance education: In defense of field experiments. Distance Education, 27, 5–26.
2.
*Abu-RabiaS.SiegelL. S. (2002). Reading, syntactic, orthographic, and working memory skills of bilingual Arabic-English speaking Canadian children. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research, 31, 661–678.
3.
BaddeleyA. D. (1996). Exploring the central executive. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 49A, 5–28.
4.
BakerK. A.de KanterA. A. (1981). Effectiveness of bilingual education: A review of the literature. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, Office of Planning, Budget and Evaluation.
5.
BamfordK. W.MizokawaD. T. (1990, April). Cognitive development of children in an additive-bilingual program: The third report. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Boston, MA.
6.
BamfordK. W.MizokawaD. T. (1991, April). Cognitive and language development in an additive-bilingual program: Report after four observations. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL.
7.
BamfordK. W.MizokawaD. T. (1992, April). Spanish-immersion children in Washington State: Fourth year of a longitudinal study. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Seattle, WA.
8.
BergunoG.BowlerD. M. (2004). Communicative interactions, knowledge of a second language, and theory of mind in young children. Journal of Genetic Psychology, 165, 293–309.
9.
BhatiaT.RitchieW. (Eds.). (2006). Handbook of bilingualism. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
10.
BialystokE. (1987). Words as things: Development of word concept by bilingual children. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 9, 133–140.
11.
BialystokE. (1988). Levels of bilingualism and levels of linguistic awareness. Developmental Psychology, 24, 560–567.
12.
*BialystokE. (1997). Effects of bilingualism and biliteracy on children’s emerging concepts of print. Developmental Psychology, 33, 429–440.
13.
*BialystokE. (1999). Cognitive complexity and attentional control in the bilingual mind. Child Development, 70, 636–644.
14.
BialystokE. (2001a). Against isolationism: Cognitive perspectives on second language research. Selected Proceedings of the Second Language Research Forum, 97–103.
15.
BialystokE. (2001b). Bilingualism in development: Language, literacy, and cognition. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
16.
BialystokE. (2002). Acquisition of literacy in bilingual children: A framework for research. Language Learning, 52, 159–199.
17.
BialystokE. (2005). Consequences of bilingualism for cognitive development. In KrollJ. F.de GrootA. M. B. (Eds.), Handbook of bilingualism: Psycholinguistic approaches (pp. 417–432). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
18.
*BialystokE. (2006). Effect of bilingualism and computer video game experience on the Simon task. Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology, 60, 68–79.
19.
BialystokE.CraikF. I. M.FreedmanM. (2007). Bilingualism as a protection against the onset of symptoms of dementia. Neuropsychologia, 45, 459–464.
20.
*BialystokE.CraikF. I. M.GradyC.ChauW.IshiiR.GunjiA.PantevC. (2005). Effect of bilingualism on cognitive control in the Simon task: Evidence from MEG. NeuroImage, 24, 40–49.
21.
*BialystokE.CraikF. I. M.KleinR.ViswanathanM. (2004). Bilingualism, aging, and cognitive control: Evidence from the Simon task. Psychology & Aging, 19, 290–303.
22.
BialystokE.CraikF. I. M.LukG. (2008). Cognitive control and lexical access in younger and older bilinguals. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition, 34, 859–873.
23.
*BialystokE.CraikF. I. M.RuoccoA. C. (2006). Dual-modality monitoring in a classification task: The effects of bilingualism and aging. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 59, 1968–1983.
24.
BialystokE.CraikF. I. M.RyanJ. (2006). Executive control in a modified anti-saccade task: Effects of aging and bilingualism. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 32, 1341–1354.
25.
*BialystokE.LukG.KwanE. (2005). Bilingualism, biliteracy, and learning to read: Interactions among languages and writing systems. Scientific Studies of Reading, 9, 43–61.
26.
*BialystokE.MajumderS. (1998). The relationship between bilingualism and the development of cognitive processes in problem solving. Applied Psycholinguistics, 19, 69–85.
27.
*BialystokE.MajumderS.MartinM. M. (2003). Developing phonological awareness: Is there a bilingual advantage?Applied Psycholinguistics, 24, 27–44.
28.
*BialystokE.MartinM. M. (2004). Attention and inhibition in bilingual children: Evidence from the dimensional change card sort task. Developmental Science, 7, 325–339.
29.
BialystokE.MartinM. M.ViswanathanM. (2005). Bilingualism across the lifespan: The rise and fall of inhibitory control. International Journal of Bilingualism, 9, 103–119.
30.
*BialystokE.McBride-ChangC.LukG. (2005). Bilingualism, language proficiency, and learning to read in two writing systems. Journal of Educational Psychology, 97, 580–590.
31.
*BialystokE.SenmanL. (2004). Executive processes in Appearance-reality tasks: The role of inhibition of attention and symbolic representation. Child Development, 75, 562–579.
32.
*BialystokE.ShaperoD. (2005). Ambiguous benefits: The effect of bilingualism on reversing ambiguous figures. Developmental Science, 8, 595–604.
33.
BochnerS. (1996). The learning strategies of bilingual versus monolingual students. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 66, 83–93.
34.
BorensteinM.HedgesL. V.HigginsJ. P. T.RothsteinH. R. (2008). Comprehensive meta-analysis (Version 2.2.048). Englewood, NJ: Biostat.
35.
BorensteinM.HedgesL. V.HigginsJ. P. T.RothsteinH. R. (2009). Introduction to meta analysis. Chichester, UK: Wiley.
36.
BracciniF.CianchiR. (1993). The influence on some linguistic and cognitive skills of the early learning of a foreign language. Rassegna Italiana Di Linguistica Applicata, 25, 53–66.
37.
*BruckM.GeneseeF. (1995). Phonological awareness in young second language learners. Journal of Child Language, 22, 307–324.
38.
*CampbellR.SaisE. (1995). Accelerated metalinguistic (phonological) awareness in bilingual children. British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 13, 61–68.
39.
CarsonK. P.SchriesheimC. A.KinickiA. J. (1990). The usefulness of the “fail-safe” statistic (N) in meta-analysis. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 50, 233–243.
40.
CazdenC. R. (1974). Play with language and metalinguistic awareness: One dimension of language experience. Urban Review, 7, 28–29.
41.
CenozJ.2003. The additive effect of bilingualism on third language acquisition: A review. International Journal of Bilingualism, 7, 71–87.
42.
ChanK. T. (2005). Chinese-English bilinguals’ theory-of-mind development. Dissertation Abstracts International, A: The Humanities and Social Sciences, 65(10-A).
43.
*ChenX.AndersonR. C.LiW.HaoM.WuX.ShuH. (2004). Phonological awareness of bilingual and monolingual Chinese children. Journal of Educational Psychology, 96, 142–151.
44.
*ClarksonP. C.GalbraithP. (1992). Bilingualism and mathematics learning—another perspective. Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 23, 34–44.
45.
CooperH. M.HedgesL. V. (1994). The handbook of research synthesis. New York, NY: Russell Sage.
46.
*CromdalJ. (1999). Childhood bilingualism and metalinguistic skills: Analysis and control in young Swedish English bilinguals. Applied Psycholinguistics, 20, 1–20.
47.
CumminsJ. (1976). The influence of bilingualism on cognitive growth: A synthesis of research findings and explanatory hypotheses. Working Papers on Bilingualism, 9, 1–43.
48.
*DavidsonD.TellD. (2005). Monolingual and bilingual children’s use of mutual exclusivity in the naming of whole objects. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 92, 25–45.
49.
*DemieF.StrandS. (2006). English language acquisition and educational attainment at the end of secondary school. Educational Studies, 32, 215–231.
50.
*DemontE. (2001). Contribution of early second language learning in the development of language awareness and learning to read. International Journal of Psychology, 36, 274–285.
51.
DensonN. (2009). Do curricular and co-curricular diversity activities influence racial bias? A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 79, 805–838.
52.
DiazR. M. (1985). The intellectual power of bilingualism. Quarterly Newsletter of the Laboratory of Comparative Human Cognition, 7, 16–22.
53.
DiazR. M.KlingerC. (1991). Towards an explanatory model of the interaction between bilingualism and cognitive development. In BialystokE. (Ed.), Language processing in bilingual children (pp. 167–192). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
54.
DuncanS. E. (2005). Child bilingualism and cognitive functioning: A study of four Hispanic groups. Dissertation Abstracts International, A: The Humanities and Social Sciences, 65(8), 2895–A.
55.
EmmoreyK.LukG.PyersJ. E.BialystokE. (2008). The source of enhanced cognitive control in bilinguals. Psychological Science, 19, 1201–1206.
56.
EngleR. W. (2002). Working memory capacity as executive attention. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 11, 19–23.
57.
EssesV. M.GardnerR. C. (1996). Multiculturalism in Canada: Context and current status. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science, 28, 145–152.
58.
*EviatarZ.IbrahimR. (2000). Bilingual is as bilingual does: Metalinguistic abilities of Arabic-speaking children. Applied Psycholinguistics, 21, 451–471.
59.
FerdmanB. M.HakutaK. (1985, April). A population perspective on bilingualism in Puerto Rican children. Paper presented at the meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Toronto, Canada.
60.
FernandesM. A.CraikF. I. M.BialystokE.KreugerS. (2007). Effects of bilingualism, aging, and semantic relatedness on memory under divided attention. Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology, 61, 128–141.
61.
FlavellJ. H. (1978). Metacognitive development. In ScanduraJ. M.BrainerdC. J. (Eds.), Structural process theories of complex human behavior (pp. 213–245). Alphen aan den Rijn, Netherlands: Sijthoff & Noordhoff.
62.
*GalambosS. J.Goldin-MeadowS. (1990). The effects of learning two languages on levels of metalinguistic awareness. Cognition, 34, 1–56.
63.
GalambosS.HakutaK. (1988). Subject-specific and task-specific characteristics of metalinguistic awareness in bilingual children. Applied Psycholinguistics, 9, 141–162.
64.
GoetzP. J. (2000). A comparison of 3- and 4-year-old English monolinguals, mandarin monolinguals, and mandarin-English bilinguals on a series of theory of mind-related tasks. Dissertation Abstracts International, B: Sciences and Engineering, 61, 1110–B.
65.
GonczL. (1988). A research study on the relation between early bilingualism and cognitive development. Psychologische Beitrage, 30, 75–91.
*Gutierrez-ClellenV. F.CalderonJ.WeismerS. E. (2004). Verbal working memory in bilingual children. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 47, 863–876.
68.
HakutaK. (1986). Mirror of language: The debate on bilingualism. New York, NY: Basic Books.
69.
HakutaK. (1990). Bilingualism and bilingual education: A research perspective (Occasional Papers in Bilingual Education No. 1). Washington, DC: National Clearinghouse for Bilingual Education.
70.
HamersJ. F.BlancM. H. A. (2000). Bilinguality and bilingualism (2nd ed.). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
71.
HedgesL. V. (1981). Distribution theory for Glass’s estimator of effect size and related estimators. Journal of Educational Statistics, 6, 107–128.
HedgesL. V.VeveaJ. L. (1998). Fixed and random-effects models in meta-analysis. Psychological Methods, 3, 486–504.
74.
HigginsJ. P. T.ThompsonS. G. (2002). Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Statistics in Medicine, 21, 1539–1558.
75.
HoD. Y. (1987). Bilingual effects on language and cognitive development: With special reference to Chinese-English bilinguals. Bulletin of the Hong Kong Psychological Society, 18, 61–69.
76.
HuberE.LasagabasterD. (2000). The cognitive effects of bilingualism. ITL, Review of Applied Linguistics, 129–130, 191–224.
77.
Huedo-MedinaT. B.Sánchez-MecaF.Marín-MartínezF.BotellaJ. (2006). Assessing heterogeneity in meta-analysis: I or Q statistic?Psychological Methods, 11, 193–206.
78.
*HumphreysG. W.MumtazS. (2001). The effects of bilingualism on learning to read English: Evidence from the contrast between Urdu-English bilingual and English monolingual children. Journal of Research in Reading, 24, 113–134.
79.
IannacconeA.FraternaliO. T.VacciaR. (1992). Cognitive flexibility and early bilingual education. Rassegna Italiana Di Linguistica Applicata, 24, 149–165.
80.
JohnsonJ. (1991). Constructive processes in bilingualism and their cognitive growth effects. In BialystokE. (Ed.), Language processing in bilingual children (pp. 193–221). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
81.
JohnsonJ. S.NewportE. L. (1989). Critical period effects in second language learning: The influence of maturational state on the acquisition of English as a second language. Cognitive Psychology, 21, 60–99.
82.
*Jordà-MariaP. S. (2003). Metapragmatic awareness and pragmatic production of third language learners of English: A focus on request acts realizations. International Journal of Bilingualism, 7, 43–68.
83.
JustM. A.CarpenterP. A. (1992). A capacity theory of comprehension: Individual differences in working memory. Psychological Review, 98, 122–149.
84.
KaneM. J.BleckleyM. K.ConwayA. R. A.EngleR. W. (2001). A controlled-attention view of working-memory capacity. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 130, 169–183.
85.
KempC. (2007). Strategic processing in grammar learning: Do multilinguals use more strategies?International Journal of Bilingualism, 4, 241–261.
86.
*KeshavarzM. H.AstanehH. (2004). The impact of bilinguality on the learning of English vocabulary as a foreign language (L3). International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 7, 295–302.
87.
KodaK.ZehlerA. (Eds.). (2008). Learning to read across languages: Cross-linguistic relationships in first- and second-language literacy development. New York, NY: Routledge.
88.
KonakaK. (1997). The relationship between degree of bilingualism and gender to divergent thinking ability among native Japanese-speaking children in the New York Area. Dissertation Abstracts International, AAT 9718715.
89.
KovacsA. M.TeglasE. (2002). Integrating two languages, theories of minds, and executive functions. Odense Working Papers in Language and Communication, 3, 1.
90.
KozulinA. (1999). Reality monitoring, psychological tools, and cognitive flexibility in bilinguals: Theoretical synthesis and pilot experimental investigation. In LloydP.FernyhoughC. (Eds.), Lev Vygotsky: Critical assessments: Future directions (Vol. 4, pp. 187–198). New York, NY: Routledge.
91.
LeeH.PlassJ. L.HomerB. D. (2006). Optimizing cognitive load for learning from computer-based science simulations. Journal of Educational Psychology, 98, 902–913.
92.
LipseyM. W.WilsonD. B. (2001). Practical meta-analysis. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
93.
*LoizouM.StuartM. (2003). Phonological awareness in monolingual and bilingual English and Greek five-year-olds. Journal of Research in Reading, 26, 3–18.
94.
*LoveT.MaasE.SwinneyD. (2003). The influence of language exposure on lexical and syntactic language processing. Experimental Psychology, 50, 204–216.
95.
MacnamaraJ. (1966). Bilingualism and primary education. Edinburgh, UK: Edinburgh University Press.
96.
McLeayH. (2003). The relationship between bilingualism and the performance of spatial tasks. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 6, 423–438.
97.
*MerrimanW. E.KutlesicV. (1993). Bilingual and monolingual children’s use of two lexical acquisition heuristics. Applied Psycholinguistics, 14, 229–249.
98.
MichaelE.GollanT. H. (2005). Being and becoming bilingual: Individual differences and consequences for language production. In KrollJ. F.de GrootA. M. B. (Eds.), The handbook of bilingualism: Psycholinguistic approaches (pp. 389–407). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
99.
National Research Council. (1992). Combining Information: Statistical issues and opportunities for research. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
100.
*OllerD. K.PearsonB. Z.Cobo-LewisA. B. (2007). Profile effects in early bilingual language and literacy. Applied Psycholinguistics, 28, 191–230.
101.
OrwinR. (1983). A fail-safe N for effect size in meta-analysis. Journal of Educational Statistics, 8, 157–159.
102.
PealE.LambertW. E. (1962). The relation of bilingualism to intelligence. Psychological Monographs, 76, 1–23.
103.
PonomarevS. Y. (1992). Bilingualism and its influence on personality development. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo Universiteta, Seriya 2: Istoriya, Yazykoznanie, Literaturovedenie, 3, 46–49.
104.
*RansdellS.BarbierM.NiitT. (2006). Metacognitions about language skill and working memory among monolingual and bilingual college students: When does multilingualism matter?International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 9, 728–741.
105.
RavitchD. (1990). Multiculturalism: E pluribus plures. American Scholar, 59, 339–340.
106.
*ReichardC.MokhtariK. (2004). Investigating the strategic reading processes of first and second language readers in two different cultural contexts. System, 32, 379–394.
107.
RicciardelliL. A. (1992). Creativity and bilingualism. Journal of Creative Behavior, 26, 242–254.
108.
RicciardelliL. A. (1993). An investigation of the cognitive development of Italian-English bilinguals and Italian monolinguals from Rome. Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development, 14, 345–346.
109.
RosenV. M.EngleR. W. (1997). The role of working memory capacity in retrieval. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 126, 211–227.
110.
RosenblumT.PinkerS. A. (1983). Word magic revisited: Monolingual and bilingual children’s understanding of the word-object relationship. Child Development, 54, 773–780.
111.
RosenthalR. (1979). The “file drawer problem” and tolerance for null results. Psychological Bulletin, 86, 638–641.
112.
RossellC. H.BakerK. (1996). The educational effectiveness of bilingual education. Research in the Teaching of English, 30, 7–69.
113.
*SanzC. (2000). Bilingual education enhances third language acquisition: Evidence from Catalonia. Applied Psycholinguistics, 21, 23–44.
114.
*ShengL.McGregorK. K.MarianV. (2006). Lexical-semantic organization in bilingual children: Evidence from a repeated word association task. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 49, 572–587.
115.
SlavinR. E.CheungA. (2005). A synthesis of research on language of reading instruction for English language learners. Review of Educational Research, 75, 247–284.
116.
SrivastavaB. (1991). Creativity and linguistic proficiency. Psycho-Lingua, 21, 105–109.
117.
StephensM. A. (1997). Bilingualism, creativity, and social problem-solving. Dissertation Abstracts International, AAT 9729615.
118.
SwellerJ.ChandlerP. (1994). Why some material is difficult to learn. Cognition & Instruction, 12, 185–233.
119.
ThomasJ.BruntonJ. (2006). EPPI-Reviewer 3.0: Analysis and management of data for research synthesis. London, UK: Social Science Research Unit, Institute of Education.
120.
TitoneR. (1997). Early second-language learning: Bilingualism and metalinguistic development. Europe Plurilingue, 12–13, 138–149.
121.
TuckerG. R. (1998). A global perspective on multilingualism and multilingual education. In CenozJ.GeneseeF. (Eds.), Beyond bilingualism: Multilingualism and multilingual education (pp. 3–15). Clevedon, UK: Multilingual Matters.
122.
van MerrienboerJ.SwellerJ. (2005). Cognitive load theory and complex learning: Recent developments and future directions. Educational Psychology Review, 17, 147–177.
123.
VorstmanE.De SwartH.CeginskasV.Van Den BerghH. (2009). Language learning experience in school context and metacognitive awareness of multilingual children. International Journal of Multilingualism, 6, 258–280.
124.
WilligA. (1985). A meta-analysis of selected studies on the effectiveness of bilingual education. Review of Educational Research, 55, 269–317.
125.
WilligA. (1987). Examining bilingual education research through meta-analysis and narrative review: A response to Baker. Review of Educational Research, 57, 363–376.
126.
YangH.YangS.CeciS.WangQ. (2005). Effects of bilinguals’ controlled-attention on working memory and recognition. In CohenJ.McAlisterKRolstadKMacSwanJ. (Eds.), Proceedings of the 4th international symposium on bilingualism. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Press.
127.
YoshidaH. (2008). The cognitive consequences of early bilingualism. Journal of Zero to Three, 29, 26–30.
