Randomized Prospective Study Comparing Tri-Cortical Iliac Crest Autograft to Allograft in the Lateral Column Lengthening Component for Operative Correction of Adult Acquired Flatfoot Deformity

Abstract

Background: Operative treatment of stage II posterior tibial tendon insufficiency (PTTI) is controversial. Many soft-tissue and bony procedures and various combinations of the two have been reported for treatment of stage II PTTI. Orthopaedists recognize the lateral column lengthening component of the procedure as a successful reconstructive technique. The use of cortical allograft for lateral column lengthening in the correction of pes planus in the pediatric patient population has been routine. In the adult population, however, tricortical iliac crest autograft has been the bone graft of choice. Harvest of this autograft can precipitate significant morbidity and cost. Therefore, we undertook this randomized controlled trial to compare graft incorporation and healing of allograft and autograft in the lateral column lengthening component of adult flatfoot reconstruction. Methods: Lateral column lengthening was done as a component of operative correction for stage II PTTI in adult patients (older than 18 years) by two surgeons using similar procedures. The patients were randomized to either the allograft or autograft procedures. The primary endpoint was graft incorporation and healing as assessed by radiographs. Results: The study included 33 randomized feet in 31 patients. We followed 18 feet in the allograft group and 15 in the autograft group to the point of union. There were 21 women and 10 men. There were no delayed unions, nonunions, or hardware failures. All patients in both groups achieved bony union by the 12-week followup evaluation. Two superficial foot infections were successfully treated with oral antibiotics. Two patients in the autograft group continued to have hip donor site pain at 3 months. Conclusions: This study suggests that union rates of allograft and autograft (iliac crest bone graft) are equal. The use of allograft in the lateral column lengthening component of operative correction of adult stage II PTTI appears to be a viable alternative to the use of iliac crest autograft and eliminates the morbidity and increased cost associated with autograft harvest.

Keywords

Adult Flatfoot Allograft Autograft Prospective Randomized

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

Fowler

: Anterior calcaneal osteotomy for symptomatic juvenile pes planus. Foot Ankle 4:274–283, 1984.

Andreacchio

Orellana

Miller

Bowen

: Lateral column lengthening as treatment for planovalgus foot deformity in ambulatory children with spastic cerebral palsy. J Pediatr. Orthop. 20:501–505, 2000.

Arrington

Smith

Chambers

Bucknell

Davino

: Complications of iliac crest bone graft harvesting. Clin. Orthop. 329:300–309, 1996.

Asselmeier

Caspari

Bottenfield

: A review of allograft processing and sterilization techniques and their role in transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus. Am. J. Sports Med. 21:170–175, 1993.

Banwart

Asher

Hassanein

: Iliac crest bone graft harvest donor site morbidity. A statistical evaluation. Spine 20:1055–1060, 1995.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC): Update: allograft-associated bacterial infections—United States, 2002. MMWR Morb. Mortal Wkly. Rep. 51:207–210, 2002.

Chi

Toolan

Sangeorzan

Hansen

Jr : The lateral column lengthening and medial column stabilization procedures. Clin. Orthop. 365:81–90, 1999.

Conrad

Gretch

Obermeyer

: Transmission of the hepatitis-C virus by tissue transplantation. J. Bone Joint Surg. 77-A:214–224, 1995.

Dwyer

: Osteotomy of the calcaneum for pes cavus. J. Bone Joint Surg. 41-B:80–86, 1959.

10.

Evans

: Calcaneo-valgus deformity. J. Bone Joint Surg. 57-B:270–278, 1975.

11.

Funk

Cass

Johnson

: Acquired adult flat foot secondary to posterior tibial-tendon pathology. J. Bone Joint Surg. 68-A:95–102, 1986.

12.

Gibson

McLeod

Wardlaw

Urbaniak

: Allograft versus autograft in instrumented posterolateral lumbar spinal fusion: a randomized control trial. Spine 27:1599–1603, 2002.

13.

Gleich

: Beitzag zur operativen plattsfussbehandlung. Arch. Klin. Chir. 46:358, 1893.

14.

Goulet

Senunas

DeSilva

Greenfield

: Autogenous iliac crest bone graft. Complications and functional assessment. Clin. Orthop. 339:76–81, 1997.

15.

Hintermann

Valderrabano

Kundert

: Lengthening of the lateral column and reconstruction of the medial soft tissue for treatment of acquired flatfoot deformity associated with insufficiency of the posterior tibial tendon. Foot Ankle Int. 20:622–629, 1999.

16.

Johnson

Strom

: Tibialis posterior tendon dysfunction. Clin. Orthop. 239:196–206, 1989.

17.

Koutsogiannis

: Treatment of mobile flat foot by displacement osteotomy of the calcaneus. J. Bone Joint Surg. 53-B:96–100, 1971.

18.

Kurz

Garfin

Booth

Jr : Harvesting autogenous iliac bone grafts. A review of complications and techniques. Spine 14:1324–1331, 1989.

19.

Mahan

Hillstrom

: Bone grafting in foot and ankle surgery. A review of 300 cases. J. Am. Podiatr. Med. Assoc. 88:109–118, 1998.

20.

Mann

Thompson

: Rupture of the posterior tibial tendon causing flat foot. Surgical treatment. J. Bone Joint Surg. 67-A:556–561, 1985.

21.

Mosca

: Calcaneal lengthening for valgus deformity of the hindfoot. Results in children who had severe, symptomatic flatfoot and skewfoot. J. Bone Joint Surg. 77-A:500–512, 1995.

22.

Myerson

Corrigan

: Treatment of posterior tibial tendon dysfunction with flexor digitorum longus tendon transfer and calcaneal osteotomy. Orthopedics 19:383–388, 1996.

23.

Myerson

Corrigan

Thompson

Schon

: Tendon transfer combined with calcaneal osteotomy for treatment of posterior tibial tendon insufficiency: a radiological investigation. Foot Ankle Int. 16:712–718, 1995.

24.

Myerson

Neufeld

Uribe

: Fresh-frozen structural allografts in the foot and ankle. J. Bone Joint Surg. 87-A:113–120, 2005.

25.

Pelker

Friedlaender

Markham

: Biomechanical properties of bone allografts. Clin. Orthop. 174:54–57, 1983.

26.

Phillips

: A review of elongation of os calcis for flat feet. J. Bone Joint Surg. 65-B:15–18, 1983.

27.

Pomeroy

Manoli

: A new operative approach for flatfoot secondary to posterior tibial tendon insufficiency: a preliminary report. Foot Ankle Int. 18:206–212, 1997.

28.

Sands

Early

Harrington

: Effect of variations in calcaneocuboid fusion technique on kinematics of the normal hindfoot. Foot Ankle Int. 19:19–25, 1998.

29.

Silber

Anderson

Daffner

: Donor site morbidity after anterior iliac crest bone harvest for single-level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. Spine 28:134–139, 2003.

30.

Simonds

Holmberg

Hurwitz

: Transmission of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 from a seronegative organ and tissue donor. N. Engl. J. Med. 326:726–732, 1992.

31.

Suchomel

Barsa

Buchvald

Svobodnik

Vanickova

: Autologous versus allogenic bone grafts in instrumented anterior cervical discectomy and fusion: a prospective study with respect to bone union pattern. Eur. Spine J. 13:510–515, 2004.

32.

Tien

Parks

Guyton

: Plantar pressures in the forefoot after lateral column lengthening: a cadaver study comparing the Evans osteotomy and calcaneocuboid fusion. Foot Ankle Int. 26:520–525, 2005.

33.

Thomas

Wells

Garrison

Prada

: Preliminary results comparing two methods of lateral column lengthening. Foot Ankle Int. 22:107–119, 2001.

34.

Tomford

: Transmission of disease through transplantation of musculoskeletal allografts. J. Bone Joint Surg. 77-A:1742–1754, 1995.

35.

Toolan

Sangeorzan

Hansen

Jr : Complex reconstruction for the treatment of dorsolateral peritalar subluxation of the foot. Early results after distraction arthrodesis of the calcaneocuboid joint in conjunction with stabilization of, and transfer of the flexor digitorum longus tendon to, the midfoot to treat acquired pes planovalgus in adults. J. Bone Joint Surg. 81-A:1545–1560, 1999.