External Ring Fixation versus Screw Fixation for Ankle Arthrodesis: A Biomechanical Comparison

Abstract

Background:

The use of external ring fixation for ankle arthrodesis offers an alternative to internal screw fixation when bone quality is suboptimal, when complex ankle pathology is present, and as a salvage procedure for complicated cases. Additionally, it permits earlier weightbearing and postoperative adjustment of bone alignment and joint compression. This study was designed to determine whether there are differences in initial ankle joint fixation integrity between these two techniques.

Materials and Methods:

Ten fresh-frozen cadaveric lower extremities underwent ankle arthrodesis with a hybrid ring fixator, and the bending and torsional stiffness of each arthrodesed joint was quantified. Stiffness was calculated from angulation measured at the tibiotalar joint using electronic clinometers attached to those bones. The external fixators were then removed and ankle arthrodesis performed using 6.5-mm cannulated screws: three across the ankle joint, one fixing the fibula to the tibia, and one fixing the fibula to the talus. Stiffness testing was then repeated.

Results:

No statistically significant difference in bending stiffness, torsional stiffness, or joint rotation under torsional load was demonstrable between the two techniques.

Conclusion:

The similarity in ankle fusion site stability achieved with external ring fixation and an optimized screw fixation technique under the described testing conditions indicates that, in cases in which suboptimal bone quality or complex ankle pathology preclude the use of internal fixation, an external fixator is a viable option.

Clinical Relevance:

Establishing that the primary stability of external ring fixation is comparable to that of screw fixation provides a basis for its use in cases in which screw fixation may be problematic.

Keywords

Arthrodesis Fixator Ankle Screws

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abidi

Gruen

Conti

: Ankle arthrodesis: Indications and techniques. J. Am. Acad. Orthop. Surg. 8:200–209, 2000.

Alonso-Vazquez

Lauge-Pedersen

Lidgren

Taylor

: Finite element analysis of the initial stability of ankle arthrodesis with internal fixation: Flat cut versus intact joint contours. Clin. Biomech. 18:244–253, 2003. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/S0268-0033(02)00207-3.

Alonso-Vazquez

Lauge-Pedersen

Lidgren

Taylor

: Initial stability of ankle arthrodesis with three-screw fixation. A finite element analysis Clin. Biomech. 19:751–759, 2004. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/j.clinbiomech.2004.04.014.

Berman

Bosacco

Parks

: Compression Artrodesis of the ankle by triangular external fixation: biomechanical and clinical evaluation. Orthopaedics. 22:1129–1134, 1999.

Berman

Bosacco

Yanicko

Jr. Raisis

: Compression arthrodesis of the ankle by triangular external fixation: an improved technique. Orthopedics. 12:1327–1330, 1989.

Braly

Baker

Tullos : Athrodesis of the ankle with lateral plating. Foot Ankle. 15:649–653, 1994.

Brodsky

Bohne

Huffard

Kennedy

: An analysis of talar surface area occupied by screw fixation in ankle fusions. Foot Ankle Int. 27:53–55, 2006.

Brown

Seligson

: An optimal technique for ankle arthrodesis. J. Foot Ankle Surg. 43:64–66, 2004. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1053/j.jfas.2003.11.012.

Caja

Kim

Larsson

Chao

EYS

: Comparison of the mechanical performance of three types of external fixators: linear, circular and hybrid. Clin. Biomech. 10:401–406, 1995. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/0268-0033(95)00014-3.

10.

Calhoun

Ledbetter

Gill

: Biomechanics of the Ilizarov fixator for fracture fixation. Clin. Orthop. 280:15–22, 1992.

11.

Calif

Stein

Lerner

: The Ilizarov external fixation frame in compression arthrodesis of large, weightbearing joints. Acta Orthop Belg. 70:51–56, 2004.

12.

Catagni

Ottaviani

Combi

Elhence

: External circular fixation: A comparison of infection rates between wires and conical half-pins with threads outside or inside the skin. J. Trauma. 61:1186–1191, 2006. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1097/01.ta.0000195442.77288.ea.

13.

Charnley

: Compression arthrodesis of the ankle and shoulder. J. Bone Joint Surg. 33B:180–191, 1951.

14.

Crosby

Yee

Formanek

Fitzgibbons

: Complications following arthroscopic ankle arthrodesis. Foot Ankle Int. 17:340–342, 1996.

15.

Dennis

Clayton

Wong

Mack

Susman

: Internal fixation compression arthrodesis of the ankle. Clin. Orthop. 253:212–220, 1990.

16.

Dohm

Benjamin

Harrison

Szivek

: A biomechanical evaluation of three forms of internal fixation used in ankle arthrodesis. Foot Ankle Int. 15:297–300, 1994.

17.

Fragomen

Meyers

Davis

Shu

Wright

Rozbruch

: A biomechanical comparison of micromotion after ankle fusion using 2 fixation techniques: Intramedullary arthrodesis nail or Ilizarov external fixator. Foot Ankle Int. 29:334–341, 2008. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.3113/FAI.2008.0334.

18.

Friedman

Glisson

Nunley

: A biomechanical comparative analysis of two techniques for tibiotalar arthrodesis. Foot Ankle Int. 15:301–305, 1994.

19.

Green

Harris

Wall

Ishkanian

Marinow

: The rancho mounting technique for the ilizarov method. A preliminary method Clin. Orthop. 280:104–116, 1992.

20.

Hammerschlag

: Ankle arthrodesis using a ring external fixator. Tech. Orthop. 11:263–268, 1996. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1097/00013611-199601130-00008.

21.

Hawkins

Langerman

Anger

Calhoun

: The Ilizarov technique in ankle fusion. Clin. Orthop. 303:217–225, 1994.

22.

Holt

Hansen

Mayo

Sangeorzan

: Ankle arthrodesis using internal screw fixation. Clin. Orthop. 268:21–28, 1991.

23.

Johnson

Weltmer

Lian

Cracchiolo

III : Ilizarov ankle arthrodesis. Clin. Orthop. 280:160–169, 1992.

24.

Kennedy

Hodgkins

Brodsky

Bohne

: Outcomes after standardized screw fixation technique of ankle arthrodesis. Clin. Orthop. 447:112–118, 2006. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1097/01.blo.0000203480.04174.0e.

25.

Kollig

Esenwein

Muhr

Kutscha-Lissberg

: Fusion of the septic ankle: Experience with 15 cases using hybrid external fixation. J. Trauma. 55:685–691, 2003. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1097/01.TA.0000051933.83342.E4.

26.

Lance

Paval

Fries

Larsen

Patterson

Jr. : Arthrodesis of the ankle joint. A follow-up study Clin. Orthop. 142:146–158, 1979.

27.

Malarkey

Binsky

: Ankle arthrodesis with the Calandruccio frame and bimalleolar onlay grafting. Clin. Orthop. 268:44–48, 1991.

28.

Mann

Rongstad

: Arthrodesis of the ankle: a critical analysis. Foot Ankle Int. 19:3–8, 1998.

29.

Mann

Van Mannen

Wapner

Martin

: Ankle fusion. Clin. Orthop. 268:49–55, 1991.

30.

Moeckel

Patterson

Inglis

Sculco

: Ankle Arthrodesis: a comparison of internal and external fixation. Clin. Orthop. 268:78–83, 1991.

31.

Moore

Prince

Pochatko

Smith

Fleming

: Retrograde intramedullary nailing for ankle arthrodesis. Foot Ankle Int. 16:433–436, 1995.

32.

Morgan

Henke

Bailey

Kaufer

: Long-term results of tibiotalar arthrodesis. J. Bone Joint Surg, 67-A:546–550, 1985.

33.

Mueckley

Eichorn

Oldenburg

: Biomechanical evaluation of primary stiffness of tibiotalar arthrodesis with an intramedullary compression nail and four other fixation devices. Foot Ankle Int. 27:814–820, 2006.

34.

Myerson

Quill

: Ankle arthrodesis: a comparison of an arthroscopic and an open method treatment. Clin. Orthop. 268:84–95, 1991.

35.

Nasson

Shuff

Palmer

Owen

Wayne

Carr

Adelaar

May

: Biomechanical comparison of ankle arthrodesis techniques: Crossed screws vs. blade plate Foot Ankle Int. 22:575–580, 2001.

36.

Ogilvie-Harris

Fitsialos

Hedman

: Arthrodesis of the ankle: a comparison of two versus three screw fixation in a crossed configuration. Clin. Orthop. 304:195–199, 1994.

37.

Paley

Lamm

Katsenis

Bhave

Herzenberg

: Treatment of malunion and nonunion at the side of an ankle fusion with the Ilizarov apparatus. J. Bone Joint Surg. 88-A:119–134, 2006. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.2106/JBJS.E.00862.

38.

Podolsky

Chao

: Mechanical performance of Ilizarov circular external fixators in comparison with other external fixators. Clin. Orthop. 293:61–70, 1993.

39.

Rowan

Davey

: Ankle arthrodesis using an anterior AO T plate. J. Bone Joint Surg. 81-B:113–116, 1999. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1302/0301-620X.81B1.8999.

40.

Salem

Kinzl

Schmelz

: Ankle arthrodesis using Ilizarov ring fixators: a review of 22 cases. Foot Ankle Int. 27:764–770, 2006.

41.

Sarpel

Gulsen

Togrul

Capa

Herdem

: Comparison of mechanical performance among different frame configurations of the Ilizarov external fixator: Experimental study. J. Trauma. 58:546–552, 2005. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1097/01.TA.0000152550.48706.A7.

42.

Scranton

Brown

: Ankle arthrodesis: a comparative clinical and biomechanical evaluation. Clin Orthop. 151:234–243, 1980.

43.

Scranton

Jr. : An overview of ankle arthrodesis. Clin. Orthop. 268:96–101, 1991.

44.

Stauffer

: Salvage of painful total ankle arthroplasty. Clin. Orthop. 170:184–188, 1982.

45.

Thordarson

Markolf

Cracchiolo

3rd : Arthrodesis of the ankle with cancellous-bone screws and fibular strut graft. J. Bone Joint Surg. 72-A:1359–1363, 1990.

46.

Thordarson

Markolf

Cracchiolo

3rd : Stability of an ankle arthrodesis fixed by cancellous—bone screws compared with that fixed by an external fixator. A biomechanical study J. Bone Joint Surg. 74-A:1050–1055, 1992.

47.

Thordarson

Markolf

Cracchiolo

3rd : External fixation in arthrodesis of the ankle: a biomechanical study comparing a unilateral frame with a modified transfixion frame. J. Bone Joint Surg. 76-A:1541–1544, 1994.

48.

Wang

Shen

McLaughlin

Stamp

: Transfibular compression arthrodesis of the ankle joint. Clin. Orthop. 289:223–227, 1993.

49.

Yanuka

Krasin

Goldwirth

Cohen

Otremski

: Ankle arthrodesis using the Ilizarov apparatus: good results in 6 patients. Acta Ortho. Scand. 71:297–300, 2000. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/000164700317411915.

50.

Yilmaz

Belhan

Karakurt

Arslan

Serin

: Mechanical performance of hybrid Ilizarov external fixator in comparison with Ilizarov circular external fixator. Clin. Biomech. 18:166–172, 2003. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1016/S0268-0033(03)00073-1.