Unreported Collisions with Post-and-Beam Guardrails in Connecticut,Iowa,and North Carolina

Abstract

Presented are the results of an in-service performance evaluation of four guardrail systems: the G1 cable guardrail, the G2 weak-post W-beam guardrail, and the G4(1S) and G4(1W) strong-post W-beam guardrails. The study was focused particularly on estimating the number of unreported collisions and the true distribution of vehicle occupant injuries. The data were collected in portions of Connecticut, Iowa, and North Carolina during a 24-month data collection effort from 1997 to 1999. The collision performance was measured in terms of collision characteristics, occupant injury, and barrier damage. Unreported collisions were counted in all three areas by periodically inspecting guardrails in a specific control section. Because this type of data collection is both time-consuming and sensitive to methodology and human error, its use is not recommended for future in-service evaluation studies. Instead, the use of rates of injury-producing collisions per million vehicle kilometers traveled past the guardrail or other hardware, which can be determined from data on reported injury collisions, hardware inventory, and traffic volumes, is recommended.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Zweden

J. V.

, and Bryden

J. E.

In-Service Performance of Highway Barriers. Report NYSDOT-ERD-77-RR51. New York Department of Transportation, Albany, 1977.

Carlson

R. D.

, Allison

J. R.

, and Bryden

J. E.

Performance of Highway Safety Devices. Report FHWA-NY-77-RR57. New York State Department of Transportation, Albany, 1977.

Schneider

Cable Guardrail Performance Evaluation Through the Use of Accident Statistics. FHWA, Iowa Division Office, Ames, 1979.

Tyrell

A. B.

, and Bryden

J. E.

Performance of Cable Median Barrier on the Palisades Interstate Parkway. New York Department of Transportation, Albany, 1989.

Hiss

J. G. F.

Jr. , and Bryden

J. E.

Traffic Barrier Performance. Report FHWA/NY/RR92/155. New York State Department of Transportation, Albany, 1992.

Ray

M. H.

, and Weir

J. A.

In-Service Performance of the Bullnose Median Barrier in the State of Iowa. Presented at 80th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C., 2001.

Roadside Design Guide. AASHTO, Washington, D.C., 1996.

Ray

M. H.

, and McGinns

R. G.

NCHRP Synthesis 244: Guardrail and Median Barrier Crashworthiness. TRB, National Research Council, Washington, D.C., 1997.

Engstrand

Improvements to the Weak-Post W-Beam Guardrail. M.S. Thesis. Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, Mass., 2000.

10.

Design Manual. Iowa Department of Transportation, Ames, 1996.

11.

1996 Volume of Traffic on the Primary Road System of Iowa. Iowa Department of Transportation, Ames, 1997.

12.

Ray

M. H.

, and Weir

J. A.

In-Service Performance Evaluation of Post-and-Beam Guardrails in Connecticut, Iowa and North Carolina. NCHRP Project 22-13. Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, Mass., 2000.