Evaluating Pay-on-Entry Versus Proof-of-Payment Ticketing in Light Rail Transit

Abstract

Pay-on-entry (POE) fare control for on-street transit allows effective revenue protection. However, the POE systems requires single door boarding and therefore increased stop dwell times compared with proof-of-payment (POP) systems. Most light rail transit (LRT) uses POP but is often criticized for poor revenue protection. This paper explores the trade-offs between the POE and POP systems through the comprehensive modeling of revenue protection, dwell time, ridership, revenue, and operational resource impacts in a case study of the conversion of the Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, POP system to a POE system; the paper uses data from LRT in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, which uses a POE system. The results show that the POE system increases journey times (+15%) and decreases ridership (−10%) and that 49 (+14%) additional light rail vehicles are required. POE conversion costs a net 29.4 million Australian dollars (A$) per annum and A$276 million for new vehicles, compared with a fare evasion reduction of A$8.1 million per annum. A 30-year discount cash flow analysis of the POE system results in a benefit–cost ratio of 0.44. The results are most sensitive to POE stop dwell time but not to fare evasion rates. Stop dwell times have a significant impact on LRT financial performance; alternative methods of revenue protection, such as increased inspection rates, are more effective than the POE system. The results justify the widespread adoption of POP systems in LRT and should provide a strong basis for defending against criticisms of the higher fare evasion rates of POP systems. The results should also act as a wake-up call to any LRT (or bus) system that still uses a POE rather than POP system and provide a basis for assessing the impacts of POP conversion for all modes.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Multisystems, Inc. TCRP Report 80: A Toolkit for Self-Service, Barrier-Free Fare Collection. TRB, National Research Council, Washington, D.C., 2002.

Larwin

T. F.

, and Koprowski

. TCRP Synthesis of Transit Practice 96: Off-Board Fare Payment Using Proof-of-Payment Verification. Transportation Research Board of the National Academies, Washington, D.C., 2012.

Dauby

, and Kovacs

. Fare Evasion in Light Rail Systems. Presented at Joint International Light Rail Conference, Saint Louis, Mo., 2006.

Currie

, Delbosc

, and Reynolds

. Modeling Dwell Time for Streetcars in Melbourne, Australia, and Toronto, Canada. In Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, No. 2275, Transportation Research Board of the National Academies, Washington, D.C., 2012, pp. 22–29.

Currie

, and Delbosc

. Understanding the Psychology of Fare Evasion: Working Paper 1: Review of Literature and Practice. Institute of Transport Studies, Monash University, Clayton, Victoria, Australia, 2012.

Victorian Official Fare Compliance Series: May 2015. Public Transport Victoria, Melbourne, Australia, 2015.

Public Transport Victoria. Timetables—Public Transport Victoria. http://ptv.vic.gov.au/timetables/. Accessed May 28, 2015.

Currie

, and Sarvi

. New Mode for the Secondary Benefits of Transit Priority. In Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, No. 2276, Transportation Research Board of the National Academies, Washington, D.C., 2012, pp. 63–71.

Tram Origin and Destination Surveys. Public Transport Victoria, Melbourne, Australia, 2007.

10.

Hamilton

B. A.

Review of Passenger Transport Demand Elasticities. Land Transport New Zealand, Wellington, 2003.

11.

National Guidelines for Transport System Management in Australia. Australian Transport Council, Canberra, 2006.

12.

Currie

, Delbosc

, Harrison

, and Sarvi

. Impact of Crowding on Streetcar Dwell Time. In Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, No. 2353, Transportation Research Board of the National Academies, Washington, D.C., 2013, pp. 100–106.