Abstract
Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) are one of most dangerous microbes that occupies the paediatric nasopharyngeal as a commensal opportunistic bacterium, which may lead to meningitis in uncontrolled infection. Colonisation of pharyngeal tissues is the starting point for most H. influenzae infections, which may develop into invasive diseases, such meningitis. The vaccination against Hib in specific, as well as against most of vaccines preventable diseases; in general, play a major role in reducing children (
Keywords
Haemophilus influenzae type b
Haemophilus influenzae solely presents in the human upper respiratory tract as an opportunistic commensal bacterium [54]. Colonisation of pharyngeal tissues is the starting point for most H. influenzae infections, which may develop into invasive diseases, such meningitis. The prevalence carriage rate of H. influenzae type b (Hib) in non-immunized individuals varies between 0.7 and 5.3%; however, these percentages increase to 48–71% in children attending day-care centres. These data suggest that many non-vaccinated toddlers and children are colonised with Hib; therefore, they could represent a focal point for the spread of bacteria. Hib spreads via Flügge droplets and nasopharyngeal secretions. Transmission is prevented 24 to 48 hours after initiating antibiotic treatment [3]. In the pre-vaccination era, most H. influenzae infections were caused by Hib [8, 68, 70, 100]. Hib infections are most commonly observed at 6–8 months of age in non-vaccinated infants [93].
Hib vaccination
In 1985 the earliest Hib CPS vaccine (polyribosylribitol phosphate – PRP vaccine) was licensed in the United States (US). It was subsequently found to provide low levels of immunogenicity in children younger than 18 months and was only effective in children above this age. The US, Canada, and Saudi Arabia were the only countries throughout the world in which PRP vaccines were licensed for public use in children aged 24 to 59 months [51, 75].
Improving the immunogenicity of polysaccharides was accomplished; many years ago in 1931, through polysaccharide-protein conjugation [59]. Such conjugates provoke PRP-specific serum antibodies, and the antibody levels could be improved by a booster dose of the conjugate [24]. PRP-protein conjugate vaccines were investigated, developed, and confirmed to be effective for use in all children, including those aged below 18 months [51].
As a result of using conjugated Hib vaccines in 1989–2000, the annual incidence of invasive Hib disease in children aged
Diphtheria toxoid conjugate (PRP-D; ProHIBiT) was the first licensed Hib conjugate vaccine, and it was shortly followed by a mutant diphtheria toxin conjugate (PRP-CRM or HbOC; HibTITER), a meningococcal outer membrane protein conjugate (PRP-OMP; PedvaxHIB), and a tetanus toxoid conjugate (PRP-T; ActHIB, OmniHIB, or Hiberix) [75]. It was clear that the initial dose of PRP-T and PRP-CRM197 were usually unsuccessful in inducing an antibody response, and that 2–3 doses were required to reach protective levels [9, 82].
Reports from the UK have shown lower anti-Hib antibodies titres post primary vaccination with a combination Hib vaccine including acellular pertussis (DTaP-Hib), rather than whole cell pertussis, and this may make vaccinated individuals more susceptible to invasive Hib infection, regardless of the existence of immune memory. Even though three doses of DTaP-Hib vaccines provoke lower anti-Hib titres than monovalent vaccines, such combinations are effectual in lowering the incidence of invasive Hib disease if a fourth dose is given as a booster [95, 96, 103]. Accordingly, the UK childhood immunization programme now includes a booster dose of the Hib vaccine [3]. The schedule for routine vaccinations in children and adults have been amended and improved many times over recent years worldwide, following the licensure of new vaccines, the outcomes of clinical trials, and evidence-supporting declining immunity [7].
The risk factors that may affect the proficiency of Hib vaccination in children include under vaccination, sickle cell anaemia, and/or immunocompromising [34]. Environmental factors and socioeconomic status have also a negative effect on non-immunized populations [76]. Moreover, a history of respiratory viral infections and acute otitis media are linked to an increased susceptibility to invasive Hib disease [36]. Vaccine failure is identified as invasive Hib disease following completion of a primary vaccination series. In 2013, the first case of a possible Hib vaccine failure in Kuwait was reported [80].
Anti-hib antibodies
Anti-Hib antibodies initiate their protective effect by initiating complement-mediated activity, including opsonisation and bacterial lysis. Such antibodies can be acquired through intrauterine placental passage, with age, or by vaccination. Physico-chemical properties of antibodies, e.g. specific determinants, molecular size, conformation, etc., can play a major role in their response to CPS antigens [109].
Hib disease rarely strikes in children less than 2 months of age, since neonates are protected by maternal antibodies. IgG antibodies, unlike immunoglobulin M (IgM) and immunoglobulin A (IgA), proficiently cross the placenta, and among IgG subclasses, with subclass IgGl crossing better than IgG2 [32]. The recognition of factors affecting the passage of antibodies across the placenta may be crucial in selecting vaccines for use in planning maternal immunization prevention strategies.
Antibodies against pathogenic bacteria, e.g. Hib, have been found in adults without a known history of previous exposure to or infection with this bacteria [91]. It is estimated that 95% of the population aged over six years are protected by naturally acquired anti-Hib antibodies [15, 56]. These protective antibodies have been found to be produced in response to cross-reactive antigens among pharyngeal and intestinal bacteria [57]. Consequently, planned intestinal colonisation with cross-reacting bacteria in adult humans and animals can stimulate the production of anti-CPS antibodies to pathogenic bacteria [39].
IgG antibodies in the presence of complement is opsonic and bactericidal, but IgM antibodies are bactericidal only, and IgA antibodies have neither activity [13]. Furthermore, antibodies of a similar isotype may have different functional activities. Anti-PRP IgG1 antibodies, for example, appear to be functionally more effective than IgG2 antibodies, although both subclasses are protective [14]. Antibody function can be estimated by a serum bactericidal antibody assay (SBA), which measures the antibody titre that binds and fixes complement onto the surface of a target strain, thereby initiating complement-mediated lysis [94].
IgA antibodies have a key role in immunity, mainly at the mucosa. Many pathogenic bacteria have developed strategies to precisely avoid or destroy the immune activity of IgA antibodies. These avoidance strategies consist of proteins that specifically attach to IgA antibodies and the secretory component, and then obstruct their activities via specialised proteases that deactivate IgA antibodies through cleavage. Bacteria that emit IgA1 proteases often inhabit or invade mucosal membranes, and frequently found in the genital tract and the oral cavity, where they are responsible for infection and also deadly meningitis [108].
A concentration of
Immunogenicity in Saudi infants was examined after three doses of the HbOC vaccine. Anti-Hib antibodies were found to be 14.4 g/ml, which is higher than the levels reported in the US (
Interesting relationships in the IgG subclass-specific immune responses to Hib infection have been noted; first, the anti-PRP specific IgG4 response is considerably higher after invasive disease than among children without known disease; second, the IgG4 response to Hib appears to be independent of age; third, levels of anti-PRP specific IgG2, total IgG4, and total anti-PRP antibodies do not differ between infected cases and non-infected healthy children; and fourth, Eskimos have slightly lower IgG4 antibody levels than expected for their ages. Therefore, IgG4 antibodies may be vital in the immune response to Hib infections in naturally weakly-immune young children [81, 87]. The response of anti-PRP specific IgG4 antibodies observed after invasive Hib infections could represent antibodies with functional activity, which facilitates protection. It is of significance that the increased IgG4 antibody levels appear to be unaffected by age or time since illness, and this suggests that anti-PRP specific IgG4 antibodies may be a possibly valuable marker of prior invasive disease [81].
Summary of Hib meningitis incidence in children younger than 5 years in pre-Hib vaccination era.
However, the positive correlation between IgG2-and IgG4-specific PRP antibodies indicates that if a subject has a high IgG2-specific PRP antibody level, then he or she typically also has a high IgG4-specific PRP antibody response, indicating some similarity in the control mechanisms regulating the production of IgG2 and IgG4 subclass antibodies within that individual. IgG4-specific PRP antibodies shows a diverse pattern of response in relation to time compared to IgG2-specific PRP or total PRP antibodies. Poor IgG2 antibody development is accompanied by repeated invasive infections caused by encapsulated bacteria [71].
For children age 24 to 35 months, a rise in total antibody levels and IgG4-specific antibody levels has been observed following infection, but no rise in anti-PRP specific IgG2 antibodies compared to non-infected children. This could show that in this age group, invasive disease favourably stimulates the production of IgG4 antibodies, whilst the production of IgG2 antibodies may be stimulated equally by invasive and non-invasive disease. However, there was a deep correlation of IgG2-specific PRP antibodies with total anti-PRP antibodies, suggesting that a high proportion of the total PRP antibodies may be of this subclass [81]. A Brazilian study proved the prevalence of IgG antibodies over IgM antibodies in response to CPS (ratio 17:1); IgG antibodies were mainly of the IgG1 subclass, and a rise in IgG avidity was seen throughout the post-vaccination era [64].
The term antibody affinity represents the strength of the binding of a single antibody type (e.g. monoclonal antibody) and a single antigen [87]. The antibody population within human serum is polyclonal (heterogeneous); therefore, it is impossible to measure antibody affinity. Nevertheless, variations in the concept of affinity have been developed, and measurements of the strength and stability of antigen-antibody contact in a mixed antibody population have been termed antibody avidity measurements [44]. Antibody avidity is used as a marker for the evaluation of memory induced antibodies following conjugate vaccination [40]. Although cellular and mucosal immunity could play a significant role in preventing H. influenzae disease, the existence of serum antibodies against Hib is strongly associated with protection [77].
In recent times Hib invasive disease mainly occurs in developing countries and some populations within developed countries [75]. The incidence of Hib differs in different regions of the world; for example, 6/100,000 in some Asian countries compared to 109/100,000 in oceanic and Western Pacific countries [79].
The worldwide incidence of Hib meningitis in children aged
Several populations remain vulnerable to Hib disease despite vaccination. For example, Native American populations are up to six times more susceptible to Hib infection and Alaskan natives continue to be affected by Hib disease [98].
Western countries
The majority of American countries, Australia, and Western Europe have a high coverage of Hib vaccine and a low incidence of Hib disease [1]. The causative organism of bacterial meningitis differs with age; however, the most widespread organisms in children aged
Although rare in the US, Hib disease does occur in children who have received the full vaccination course and booster dose. Among Hib disease-affected patients aged
American Indian children, followed by African American and Caucasian children, have the highest Hib incidence rates both before and after the introduction of the Hib vaccination to the US. In contrast, the lowest rates appear within Asian/Pacific Islander and Hispanic children [20]. Similarly in Australia, the incidence of Hib disease has been shown to vary between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal individuals [43]. These racial/ethnic variations may be associated with variances in socioeconomic conditions, population vulnerability, genetic variation, vaccine coverage, and/or excessive carriage of Hib in the respiratory tract within these populations.
High post-Hib vaccination antibody levels in the serum of children at high risk of invasive Hib disease is the main factor protecting such children, and if high levels of antibodies are not reached; then there will be the re-emergence of a high Hib incidence rate, similar to that which occurred in the UK [66] and Alaska [38].
In adults, Hib infections are elevated in those aged
In a study conducted in Finland during the pre-Hib vaccination era, most Finnish children aged 4–5 years had protective antibody levels; 79% had antibody levels greater than 0.15
Non-Western countries
According to the WHO, Hib vaccine coverage is only 18% and 27% in the Western Pacific and South-East Asia Regions, respectively, while in Brazil, nearly all children (97.56%) have been vaccinated with a Hib-combined vaccine. The actual spread of Hib in North Africa and the Middle East is difficult to evaluate, since the collection of data is irregular; surveillance techniques are weak and identification of the etiologic agent in infectious diseases is infrequent [2, 6]. In certain Asian countries, it was believed that Hib was not the main etiologic agent of childhood meningitis; however, a review by Peltola et al. has revealed that Hib is the major etiologic agent of bacterial meningitis in most Asian countries [73]. However, the incidence of bacterial meningitis ranges from 5.2 to 19.2/100,000 in Asia [29] to a much higher rate of 76/100,000 in South Africa [49].
In Thailand, Rerks-Ngram et al. reported a very low incidence of Hib meningitis at 3.8/100,000 [90], while in Bohol and Manila, the annual incidence was 17.6/100,000 and 95/100,000, respectively [58]. In Kathmandu, Nepal, only 20% of children under the age of 5 years had anti-Hib antibody levels of
In China, the second most widespread organism causing pneumonia and 30–50% of bacterial meningitis in children is H. influenzae. In Beijing, Hib conjugate vaccines are obtainable from private health facilities, but the majority of children are not vaccinated [113]. Among children in Beijing aged
In population-based studies conducted in Johannesburg during 1997–1998 and in Cape Town during 1991–1992 in the pre-Hib vaccination era, an annual invasive Hib incidence of 170/100,000 children younger than 1 year was reported [48, 62]. This rate was considerably higher than those noted in another investigation conducted in these two cities during July 1999–June 2000 [105]. In Gambia, 14 years after Hib vaccination using a 3-dose primary series without a booster was introduced, there was effective control of Hib invasive disease, including both pneumonia and meningitis [47, 69].
In the pre-vaccination era in Turkey, India, and in Burkina-Faso, West Africa, the majority of children aged 4 to 5 years had protective levels of anti-Hib antibodies. These results are similar to those reported for Finland by Kayhty et al. [50], indicating that 79% of children had antibody levels greater than 0.15
Middle East and North African countries
A Hib-conjugated vaccine became obligatory in the national immunization programme in Saudi Arabia in 2000, and since then a considerable decline in Hib cases has been observed. During the first three years after the vaccine was made compulsory (2001–2003), there were 30 cases of H. influenzae invasive disease, compared to only six cases in the following three-year period (2004–July 2007) [11]. The coverage of the pentavalent vaccine (Diphtheria, Pertussis, Tetanus, Hib, and Hepatitis B) is 97.7% [5]. During 1988–1991, Hib was responsible for 42–58% of bacterial meningitis in children, with a fatality rate of 2.8–14.3%; children aged
Bacterial meningitis in children in Saudi Arabia, between 1988 and 1991 (pre-vaccination era).
In Saudi Arabia between 1995 and 1999, the yearly incidence of Hib infections in infants younger than 1 year was 15.6–20.8/100,000, while in children less than 5 years it was 4.5–6.7/100,000. There was a clear dissimilarity within regions of the Kingdom, ranging from no cases in some regions to more than 35 in others. However, some factors may affect the accuracy of these data, including laboratory inadequacies and inaccurate reporting [10].
A study conducted in Saudi Arabia between June 1999 and May 2001 reported 208 cases of meningitis across five regions, 27.8% were recognised as being caused by Hib. The patients’ ages ranged from a few days to 5 years, and the incidence was highest for patients aged 2–6 months and the median age of the patients was 8 months. No noteworthy statistical variations in terms of mean ages were noted in relation to geographical regions [10].
Again, in Saudi Arabia, it was clear that an increase in cases occurred during two periods: from March to May and from September to November. The major period of infection coincided with the Hajj season and was mainly caused by N. meningitidis, while Hib and aseptic meningitis were noted during the other period [10]. At King Fahad National Guard Hospital (KFNGH), within Riyadh districts, Saudi Arabia, bacterial meningitis was more common among children aged
Approximate comparable chart showing the incidence of Hib meningitis in pre- and post- vaccination times in KFNGH within children aged less than 4 years. 
Our recent results showed higher levels of anti-Hib IgG (2.41
In Egypt, the number of confirmed Hib meningitis cases is 23/100,000 in children aged
Pre-HIb vaccination era, the passive immunization plays a crucial role, although it was limited, but save many life’s. In addition to vaccine failures do occur too. These Protective factors (effect limited to infants younger than 6 months of age) include breastfeeding and passively acquired transplacentally maternal IgG antibodies. In both cases the passive immunization would be needed similarly to other microbial pathogens control the invasive Hib disease affected exclusively to children [82].
Conclusions
This brief presentation of the available information is expected to serve as a useful review for public health officials and policy makers. Moreover, monitoring the levels of circulating anti-Hib antibodies and their avidity is important in order to evaluate herd immunity, the need to vaccinate elderly and immunocompromised patients, and/or to revaluate the national immunization programme.
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
The current work is a part of the Ph.D. thesis of Mr. Adi Essam Zarei (Department of Biology, Faculty of Science, King Abdulaziz University). This work was supported in part by King Abdulaziz City for Scientific Research and Technology (KACST, PGP-37-56), Saudi Arabia.
Conflict of interest
The authors confirm that this paper content has no conflict of interests.
