We introduce and study some basic properties of rough – statistical convergent of weight g (A), where g : is a function statisying g (m, n, k) → ∞ and g (m, n, k) ↛ 0 as m, n, k → 0 of triple sequence of Bernstein
polynomials, where A represent the RH-regular matrix and also prove the Korovkin approximation theorem by using the
notion of weighted A-statistical convergence of weight g (A) limits of a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials.
The idea of rough convergence was first introduced by Phu [10-12] in finite dimensional normed spaces, showed that the set is bounded, closed, convex and introduced the notion of rough Cauchy sequence also investigated the relations between rough convergence and other convergence types and the dependence of on the roughness of degree r.
Aytar [1] studied of rough statistical convergence and defined the set of rough statistical limit points of a sequence and obtained to statistical convergence criteria associated with this set and prove that this set is closed and convex. Also, Aytar [2] studied that the r-limit set of the sequence is equal to intersection of these sets and that r-core of the sequence is equal to the union of these sets. Dündar and Cakan [9] investigated of rough ideal convergence and defined the set of rough ideal limit points of a sequence. The notion of I-convergence of a triple sequence which is based on the structure of the ideal I of subsets of , where is the set of all natural numbers, is a natural generalization of the notion of convergence and statistical convergence and also Zhan et al. [16-21] studied various rough sets.
Our primary interest in the present paper is to obtain a general Korovkin-type approximation theorem for triple sequences of positive linear operators of two variables from Hw (K) to Cw (K) via statistical A-summability.
Let A be a three dimensional summability matrix. For a given triple sequence x = (xmnk), the A-transform of x, denoted by Ax : = ((Ax) ijℓ), given by
provided the triple series converges in Pringsheim sense for every .
A three dimensional matrix A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) is said to be RH-regular it maps every bounded P-convergent sequence into a P-convergent sequence with the same P-limit. A three dimensional matrix A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) is RH-regular if and only if
for each ,
,
for each ,
for each ,
for each ,
is P-convergent for every ,
there exist finite positive integers A and B such that ∑m,n,k>B|ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k| < A holds for every .
Now let A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a non-negative RH-regular summability matrix, and . Then the A-density of K is given by
where
provided that the limit on the right-hand side exists in Pringsheim sense. A real triple sequence x = (xmnk) is said to be A-statistically convergent to a number L if, for every ∈ > 0,
In this case, we write .
Let K be a subset of the set of positive integers and let us denote the set Kikℓ ={ (m, n, k) ∈ K : m ≥ i, n ≤ j, k ≤ ℓ }. Then the natural density of K is given by
where |Kijℓ| denotes the number of elements in Kijℓ.
The Bernstein operator of order (r, s, t) is given by
where f is a continuous (real or complex valued) function defined on [0, 1].
Throughout the paper, denotes the real of three dimensional space with metric (X, d). Consider a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) such that , .
Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Brst (f, x)) is said to be statistically convergent to , written as st - limx = 0, provided that the set
has natural density zero for any ∈ > 0. In this case, 0 is called the statistical limit of the triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials. i.e., δ(K∈) = 0. That is
In this case, we write δ - lim Bmnk (f, x) = f (x) or Bmnk (f, x) → SBf (x). A subset A of is said to have asymptotic density d (A) if
A triple sequence (real or complex) can be defined as a function , where , and denote the set of natural numbers, real numbers and complex numbers respectively. The different types of notions of triple sequence was introduced and investigated at the initial by Sahiner et al. [13, 14], Esi et al. [3-6], Datta et al. [7], Subramanian et al. [15], Debnath et al. [8] and many others.
A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials is said to be triple Bernstein polynomials of analytic if
The space of all triple of Bernstein polynomials of analytic sequences are usually denoted by .
Definitions and Preliminaries
Throughout the paper denotes the real three dimensional case with the metric. Consider a triple sequence x = (xmnk) such that ; . The following definition are obtained:
Definition 2.1. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be statistically convergent to f (x) denoted by Bmnk (f, x) → st-limxf (x), if for any ∈ > 0 we have d (A (∈)) = 0, where
Definition 2.2. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be statistically convergent to f (x) denoted by Bmnk (f, x) → st-limxf (x), provided that the set
has natural density zero for every ∈ > 0.
In this case, f (x) is called the statistical limit of the sequence of Berstein polynomials.
Definition 2.3. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) in a metric space (X, | . ,. |) and r be a non-negative real number is said to be r-convergent to f (x), denoted by Bmnk (f, x) → rf (x), if for any ∈ > 0 there exists such that for all m, n, k ≥ N∈ we have
In this case Bmnk (f, x) is called an r-limit of f (x).
Remark 2.4. We consider r-limit set Bmnk (f, x) which is denoted by and is defined by
Definition 2.5. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be r-convergent if and r is called a rough convergence degree of Bmnk (f, x). If r = 0 then it is ordinary convergence of triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials.
Definition 2.6. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) in a metric space (X, | . ,. |) and r be a non-negative real number is said to be r-statistically convergent to f (x), denoted by Bmnkf (x) → r-st3f (x), if for any ∈ > 0 we have d (A (∈)) = 0, where
In this case f (x) is called r-statistical limit of Bmnkf (x). If r = 0 then it is ordinary statistical convergent of triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials.
Definition 2.7. A class I of subsets of a nonempty set X is said to be an ideal in X provided
A, B ∈ I implies A ⋃ B ∈ I.
A ∈ I, B ⊂ A implies B ∈ I.
I is called a nontrivial ideal if X ∉ I.
Definition 2.8. A nonempty class F of subsets of a nonempty set X is said to be a filter in X. Provided
φ ∈ F.
A, B ∈ F implies A ⋂ B ∈ F.
A ∈ F, A ⊂ B implies B ∈ F.
Definition 2.9.I is a non trivial ideal in X,X ≠ φ, then the class
is a filter on X, called the filter associated with I.
Definition 2.10. A non trivial ideal I in X is called admissible if {x } ∈ I for each x ∈ X.
Note 2.11. If I is an admissible ideal, then usual convergence in X implies I convergence in X.
Remark 2.12. If I is an admissible ideal, then usual rough convergence implies rough I-convergence.
Definition 2.13. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) in a metric space (X, | . ,. |) and r be a non-negative real number is said to be rough ideal convergent of weight g or rIλ-convergent to f (x), denoted by , if for any ∈ > 0 we have
In this case (Bmnk (f, x)) is called rIλ-limit of (f, x) and a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is called rough Iλ- convergent weight g to f (x) with r as roughness of degree. If r = 0 then it is ordinary Iλ-convergent of weight g.
Note 2.14. Generally, Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, y)) is not Iλ-convergent of weight g in usual sense and |Bmnk (f, x) - Bmnk (f, y) | ≤ r for all or
for some r > 0. Then the triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is rIλ- convergent of weight g.
Note 2.15. It is clear that limit of f (x) is not necessarily unique.
Definition 2.16. Consider limit set of f (x), which is denoted by
then the triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be rIλ-convergent of weight g, if and r is called a rough Iλ-convergence of weight g degree of Bmnk (f, x).
Definition 2.17. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be analytic if there exists a positive real number M such that
Definition 2.18. A point f (x) ∈ X is said to be an accumulation point and Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) in a metric space (X, d) if and only if for each ∈ > 0 the set
We denote the set of all accumulation points of (Bmnk (f, x)) by .
Definition 2.19. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) of real numbers, the notions of ideal limit superior and ideal limit inferior are defined as follows:
and
where
and
Definition 2.20. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be rough Iλ-convergent of weight g, if . It is clear that if for a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) of real numbers, then we have
Remark 2.21. Let be a non-decreasing sequence of positive numbers tending to ∞ such that
The collection of such sequences λ will be denoted by η.
We define the generalized de la Vallée-Pousin mean of weight g by
where Irst = [(pqj) - λpqj+1, pqj].
Let r = (rmnk) be a triple sequence of nonnegative numbers such that r000 > 0 and
where
.
Definition 2.22. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be [V, λ] (I) g-summable to f (x), if
i.e., for any δ > 0,
and it is denoted by [V, λ] (I) g.
Definition 2.23. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be Iλ-statistically convergent of weight g, if for every
In this case we write (Iλ) g - lim Bmnk (f, x) = f (x). Or Bmnk (f, x) → f (x) (Iλ) g.
Definition 2.24. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be Iλ-statistically convergent of weight g, if for every ∈ > 0
In this case we write . Or .
Remark 2.25. If upqj = 1 for all m, n, k, then summable is reduced to [C , 1, 1, 1] -summable or Cesáro summable and statistically convergent of weight g is reduced to statistical convergence of Bernstein polynomials of triple sequence.
A Korovkin-type approximation theorem by g(A) -statistical convergence
Let CB (K) the space of all continuous and bounded real valued functions on K = [0, ∞) × [0, ∞) × [0, ∞). This space is equipped with the supremum norm
Consider the triple space of Hw (K) of all real valued functions of Bernstein polynomials of f on K satisfying
where w be a function of the type of the modulus of continuity given by, for δ, δ1, δ2, δ3 > 0,
w is non-negative increasing function on K with respect to δ1, δ2, δ3,
w (δ, δ1 + δ2 + δ3) ≤ w (δ, δ1) + w (δ, δ2) + w (δ, δ3),
w (δ1 + δ2 + δ3, δ) ≤ w (δ1, δ) + w (δ2, δ) + w (δ3, δ),
.
The Bernstein polynomials of Bmnk (f) ∈ Hw (K) satisfies the inequality
and hence it is bounded on K. Therefore Hw (K) ⊂ CB (K).
We also use the following Bernstein polynomials of test functions
and
Definition 3.1. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1] and A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative RH-regular matrix. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be Iλ-statistically convergent of weight g, if for every ∈ > 0
In this case we write . Or .
Main results
Theorem 4.1.Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials of real numbers of (Bmnk (f,x)): [0,1] → [0,1]
if and only if
Proof. Following the proof of Theorem, we obtains
and so
Equations (4.2)-(4.10) give that
Theorem 4.2.Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials of real numbers of line break (Bmnk (f,x)): [0,1] → [0,1] which satisfies (ref4.3) to (4.10) ofTheorem4.1and the following condition holds :
Then
Proof. It follows (4.12) that |Bmnk (1, x) |≤C′, for some constant C' > 0 and for all . Hence, for f ∈ [0, 1] we obtain
In right hand side of (4.14) is constant. Hence we get .□
Statistical
A-summability
In this section we define statistical A-summability of a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials of RH-regular summability matrix and prove that it is stronger than A-Bernstein polynomials of rough statistical convergence for analytic triple sequences.
Definition 5.1. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0, 1] and A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative regular summability matrix of a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f, x)) is said to be rough statistically A summable convergent to f (x) denoted by Bmnk (f, x) → stA-limxf (x), if for every ∈ > 0 provided that the set
where Bmnk (f, x) is as in (1.1). So, if x is Bernstein polynomials of rough statistically A-summable to f (x), then for every ∈ > 0,
Thus, the triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials of Bmnk (f, x) is rough statistically A-summable to f (x) if and only if Bmnk (f, Ax) is rough statistically convergent to f (x).
Theorem 5.2.Let fbe a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f,x)) of real numbers is analytic and A-rough statistically convergent to f(x) then it is rough statistically A-summable convergent to f(x) but not conversely.
Proof. Let Bmnk (f,x) be analytic and A-rough statistically convergent to f (x), and
Then
Using the definition of triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials of A-rough statistical convergence and the conditions of RH-regularity of A, we get P-limpqj| Bmnk (f,x) -f (x) | =0 from the arbitrariness of ∈ >0. Hence . To show that the converse is not true in general, we give the following examples:
(i)A= (ai,j,l,m,n,k) be C [1,1,1, 1,1,1], the six dimensional Cesáro matrix
and let x= (xmnk) be defined
Then triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials of Bmnk (f,x) is C [1,1,1, 1,1,1] summable (and hence statistical C [1,1,1, 1,1,1] -summable) to zero but not C [1,1,1, 1,1,1] statistically convergent.
(ii) Define A= (ai,j,l,m,n,k) by
and define the triple analytic sequence of Bernstein polynomials of Bmnk (f,x)
We can easily verify that A is RH-regular, that is, conditions RH(i)-RH (vi) hold. Moreover, for the sequence defined above,
Hence it is clear that the triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials of Bmnk (f,x) is not A-summable and hence is not A-rough statistically convergent but . Hence triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials of Bmnk (f,x) is rough statistically A-summable to zero.□
Korovkin-type approximation theorem
Theorem 6.1.Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f,x)) of real numbers of CB (K) into itself. Then for all f ∈ CB (K),
if and only if
where
and
Proof. It is routine verification. Therefore the proof is omitted.□
Theorem 6.2.Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. Let A= (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative RH-regular summability matrix and a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f,x)) of real numbers of CB (K) into itself. Then for all f ∈ CB (K),
if and only if
where
and
Proof. It is routine verification. Therefore the proof is omitted.□
Theorem 6.3.Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. Let A= (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative RH-regular summability matrix and a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f,x)) of real numbers of CB (K) into itself. Then for all f ∈ CB (K),
if and only if
where
and
Proof. Condition (6.2) follows immediately from condition (6.1) since each fuvw ∈ CB (K) (u,v,w=0,1,2,3,…). Let us prove the converse. By the continuity of f on compact set K, we can write , where , for every ∈ >0, there is a number δ > 0 such that |f(u, v, w) – f(x, y, z)| < r + ∈ for all (u, v, w) ∈ K satisfying ; and . Hence we get
From (6.3) we obtain for any m,n,k ∈ ℕ3 that
where C:= max |x|, D:=max |y|, E:=max |z|. Taking supremum over (x,y,z) ∈ K we get
where
Now for given ρ > 0, choose ∈ >0 such that ∈ < ρ and define
Then and so
By considering this inequality and using (6.2) we obtain (6.1).□
Example 6.4. Now, we will show that Theorem 6.3 is stronger than its classical and statistical forms. Let A be C [1,1,1, 1,1,1] and defined x= (xmnk) by xmnk= (-1)mnk for all m,n,k. Then triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials is neither P-convergent nor A-rough statistically convergent but st3–lim Ax = 0.
The Bernstein operator of order (u,v,w) is given by
where f is a continuous (real or complex valued) function defined on [0,1], where (x,y,z) ∈ K = [0,1] × [0,1] × [0,1]; f ∈ CB (K). By using these operators, define the following positive linear operators on CB(K):
Then observe that
where
and
Since st3–lim Ax = 0, we obtain
for u,v,w=0,1,2,3. Hence by Theorem 6.3 we conclude that
for any f ∈ CB (K).
However, since P-limit and the statistical limit of the triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials of Bmnk (f,x) is not zero, then for u,v,w = 0,1,2,3, ||Bmnk (fuvw)-fuvw||CB (K) is neither P-convergent nor statistically convergent to zero. So, Theorem 6.1 and Theorem 6.2 do not work for our operators defined by (6.4).
Theorem 6.5.Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. Let A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative RH-regular summability matrix and a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f,x)) of real numbers from [0,1] into itself,
if and only if
Proof. We obtain
and so
Equations (6.6)-(6.8) give that
Definition 6.6. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1] and A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative RH-regular matrix. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk(f,x)) is said to be Iλ-weighted statistically convergent of weight g, if for every ∈ > 0
In this case we write . Or .
Theorem 6.7.Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. Let A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative RH-regular summability matrix and a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f,x)) of real numbers from [0,1] which satisfies (6.7)-(6.8) of Theorem 1 and the following condition holds:
Then,
Proof. It follows from (6.12) that
for some constant C' > 0 and for all m,n,k∈ ℕ3. Hence, for f ∈ [0,1], one obtains
Right hand side of (6.14) is constant, so umnk|| Bmnk (f,x)-f(x)|| is bounded. Since (6.12) implies (6.6), by Theorem 1 we get that
Definition 6.8. Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1] and A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative RH-regular matrix and let (upqj) be a positive nonincreasing sequence. A triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f,x)) is said to be Iλ-weighted statistically convergent of weight g, if for every ∈ > 0
where
In this case we write . Or as m,n,k → ∈.
Theorem 6.9.Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. Let A = (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative RH-regular summability matrix. Suppose that (amnk), (bmnk) and (cmnk) are three positive nonincreasing sequences. Let a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials (Bmnk (f,x)), (Bmnk (f,y)) and (Bmnk (f,z)) of real numbers from [0,1] such that
and
Then
, for any scalar α,where
Proof. (i) Suppose that
Given ∈ > 0, define
It is easy to see that
This yields that
holds for all (p,q,j) ∈ ℕ. Since dmnk = max [amnk, bmnk, cmnk], (6.19) gives that
Taking limit p,q,j → ∈ in (6.19) together with (*), we obtain
Thus, . Similarly, we can prove (ii) and (iii).
The modulus of continuity of f ∈ [0,1] is defined by
It is well known that
Theorem 6.10.Let f be a continuous function defined on the closed interval [0,1]. LetA= (ai,j,ℓ,m,n,k) be a nonnegative RH-regular summability matrix. Let a triple sequence of Bernstein polynomials Bmnk: [0,1] → [0,1] satisfies the conditions
withand , where (amnk), (bmnk) and (cmnk) are three positive nonincreasing sequences, thenwhere dmnk = max {amnk, bmnk, cmnk}.
Proof. Consider
Choosing , one obtains
where T =||f||. For a given ∈ > 0, we will define the following sets:
It follows from (6.22) that
holds for all (p,q,j) ∈ ℕ. Since dmnk = max [amnk, bmnk, cmnk], (6.23) gives that
Taking limit p,q,j → ∈ in (6.24), we obtain
Hence □
Conclusion
In this paper, we have discussed various general topological and algebraic properties of statistical convergent of weight g (A) and also have proved Korovkin approximation theorem by using the notion of weight g (A) limits of a triple sequence space of Bernstein polynomials. All the results will certainly motivate young researchers.
Competing Interests: The authors declare that there is not any conflict of interests regarding the publication of this manuscript.
Footnotes
Acknowledgement
The authors are extremely grateful to the anonymous learned referee(s) for their keen reading, valuable suggestion and constructive comments for the improvement of the manuscript. The authors are thankful to the Prof. Dr. Reza Langari, Editor-in-Chief and Prof. Dr. Jianming Zhan, Associate Editor and reviewers of Journal of Intelligent and Fuzzy Systems also Tata realty for finance support.
References
1.
AytarS., Rough statistical convergence, Numer Funct Anal Optimiz29(3-4) (2008), 291–303.
2.
AytarS., The rough limit set and the core of a real sequence, Numer Funct Anal Optimiz29(3-4) (2008), 283–290.
3.
EsiA., On some triple almost lacunary sequence spaces defined by Orlicz functions, Research and Reviews: Discrete Mathematical Structures1(2) (2014), 16–25.
4.
EsiA. and NecdetM., Catalbas, Almost convergence of triple sequences, Global Journal of Mathematical Analysis2(1) (2014), 6–10.
5.
EsiA. and SavasE., On lacunary statistically convergent triple sequences in probabilistic normed space, Appl Math and Inf Sci9(5) (2015), 2529–2534.
6.
EsiA., AraciS. and AcikgozM., Statistical convergence of bernstein operators, Appl Math and Inf Sci10(6) (2016), 2083–2086.
7.
DattaA.J., EsiA. and TripathyB.C., Statistically convergent triple sequence spaces defined by Orlicz function, Journal of Mathematical Analysis4(2) (2013), 16–22.
8.
DebnathS., SarmaB. and DasB.C., Some generalized triple sequence spaces of real numbers, Journal of nonlinear analysis and optimization6(1) (2015), 71–79.
9.
DündarE. and CakanC., Rough I–convergence, Demonstratio Mathematica47(3) (2004), 638–651.
10.
PhuH.X., Rough convergence in normed linear spaces, Numer Funct Anal Optimiz22 (2001), 199–222.
11.
PhuH.X., Rough continuity of linear operators, Numer Funct Anal Optimiz23 (2002), 139–146.
12.
PhuH.X., Rough convergence in infinite dimensional normed spaces, Numer Funct Anal Optimiz24 (2003), 285–301.
13.
SahinerA., GurdalM. and DudenF.K., Triple sequences and their statistical convergence, Selcuk J Appl Math8(2) (2007), 49–55.
14.
SahinerA. and TripathyB.C., Some I related properties of triple sequences, Selcuk J Appl Math9(2) (2008), 9–18.
15.
SubramanianN. and EsiA., The generalized tripled difference of χ3 sequence spaces, Global Journal of Mathematical Analysis3(2) (2015), 54–60.
16.
ZhanJ. and AlcantudJ.C.R., A novel type of soft rough covering and its application to multicriteria group decision making, Artificial Intelligence Review (2018). 10.1007/s10462-018-9617-3.
17.
MaX., ZhanJ., AliM.I. and MehmoodN., A survey of decision making methods based on two classes of hybrid soft set models, Artificial Intelligence Review49(4) (2018), 511–529.
18.
ZhanJ., LiuQ. and HerawanT., A novel soft rough set: Soft rough hemirings and its multicriteria group decision making, Applied Soft Computing54 (2017), 393–402.
19.
ZhanJ., AliM.I. and MehmoodN., On a novel uncertain soft set model: Z-soft fuzzy rough set model and corresponding decision making methods, Applied Soft Computing56 (2017), 446–457.
20.
MaX., LiuQ. and ZhanJ., A survey of decision making methods based on certain hybrid soft set models, Artificial Intelligence Review47 (2017), 507–530.
21.
ZhanJ. and ZhuK., A novel soft rough fuzzy set: Z-soft rough fuzzy ideals of hemirings and corresponding decision making, Soft Computing21 (2017), 1923–1936.